Was I really doing this? Was I actually breaking out of Martin's Peak? The day my captors tossed me in here like a dog, I was assured I would never breathe the same air as the general public again. Nobody left Martin's Peak. As far as the world was concerned, I could be dead. Yet, here I was crawling through a wet, dark tunnel, attempting my escape via the sewer system underneath the hundred-year-old building. I had been planning this escape from day one.
Another snob in a white coat told me that I was going crazy. I had lost it. I had made up every detail of what happened to me over the last two weeks. I was really going to lose it. They'd have an absolute nutcase on their hands. If it was even remotely possible that I had imagined everything that had happened to me, I ended up with this gunshot wound in my left shoulder, which wasn't bleeding anymore, thank God, but was still sending arrows of pain down into my chest and
Why did I remember all of these things that had happened to me? How do you explain Sarah - Sarah, Oh Sarah, what has become of you? I hope you're OK.
If she wasn't an actual living human being with flesh and bones, how did I have her cellphone in my pocket - I wonder if I still have it?
I slipped my hand into my back pocket and bumped my fingers onto its smooth plastic surface. Yeah, it was real, and so was Sarah! As real as the nose on my face. As real as this dirty, smelly, wet tunnel.
She dropped it in the alley of a bowling ring as we fought off two masked bandits armed with guns. By some miracle, we both got away. If you consider a bullet in the shoulder as getting away. Sarah only sustained a few cuts on her arms, but only because she used me as her personal human shield.
Could I have imagined all of it? The searing pain shooting down my arm begged to differ. These people were the crazy ones for thinking they could blot out my memories and make me discount everything that's happened to me over the past week. It all started after an FBI agent gave me a small black box. About as big as a matchbox. She told me to guard it with my life and warned that it would spell the end of the world if it fell into the wrong hands.
Wrong hands?
The end of what?
Well, that's what I've tried to do only to have everything and everyone I cherish put in utter harm's way. Maybe I should have been a little bit bolder and told her to bugger off as I had intended to. Still, she sounded so convincing and urgent, and I felt a surge of patriotism sweep over my bones, so at that moment, I stupidly believed that I could make a difference.
Crawling through a tight, dark, smelly, wet tunnel with rats nipping at your heels is as horrible as it sounds. Still, at this point, I was desperate enough to do anything to get out of this place.
I was sitting quietly in front of a giant metal valve now, wet from head to toe and shaking like a leaf. Just beyond it was my liberation. The way out of this hellhole.
I'd just wait here till 10 a.m. until the valve opens and be flushed out with the sewage onto the grassy field on the other side of the high fence surrounding the mental hospital. That was a far better deal than spending one more minute in this hell hole.
End of chapter
Continue to next chapter Fantasticas: The Boy And His StaffPoints:
Time spent:
IP address:
Canary word: Present
Possible AI signals:
Original Text:
Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This cannot be undone.
Mark this comment as a review? Points will be awarded to the poster.
Your comment was posted, but it wasn’t long enough to count as a review. Reviews need about four complete sentences (at least 250 characters). Try writing another review that explains your thoughts in more detail — the author will appreciate it, and you’ll earn points for it.
I had just escaped from the mad house where disgustingly patronizing snobs in white gowns assured me that I was going crazy that I had lost it, that I had contrived every single thing that had happened to me over the last two week, but if that was even remotely true how did I end up with this gunshot wound in my left shoulder, which wasn't bleeding anymore, thank God, but still sending arrows of pain down into my chest and back.
Why was I remembering all of these things that had happened to me. How do you explain Sarah - Sarah, Oh Sarah, what has become of you? I hope you're OK.
If she wasn't a real person with flesh and bones how did I have her cellphone - did I still have it? I slipped my hand into my back pocket and bumped my fingers onto its smooth plastic surface, yeah it was real, and so was Sarah! As real as the nose on my face, as real as the dirty smelly wet tunnel I was crawling through right now. She dropped it in the back alley of a bowling ring as we fought off two masked bandits weilding knives and a gun, by some miracle of God we both managed to get away but barely. I got off with a bullet in my shoulder only because I fought the hardest, while Sarah only sustained a few cuts on her arms, but only because she used me as her personal human shield.
I couldn't have dreamed all that up, no ways! I wasn't crazy, these people were the crazy ones for thinking they could blot out my memories and make me discount everything I've had to endure eversince that FBI agent (or whatever she was) dropped a big black box on my doorstep and warned me to guard it with me life. "If it falls into the wrong hands it would spell the end if the world!" She told me and then without as much Goodluck ran off down the street like someone fleeing a pursuer and vanished around the corner. Well that's what I've tried to do only to have everything and everyone I cherish put in utter harms way. Maybe I should have been a little bolder and told her to bugger off as I had intended to, but she sounded so convincing, so genuine, so urgent that I felt a sudden urge of patriotism sweep over my bones, so that in that moment I stupidly believed that I could make a difference.
Crawling through a tight, dark, smelly, wet tunnel with rats nipping at you from everywhere was exactly as horrible as it sounded, but at this point I was desperate enough to do anything tp get out of this place.
I was sitting quietly in front of a big metal valve now, wet from head to toe and shaking like a leaf, not far beyond it was my liberation, the mouth of the tunnel.
I'd just wait here till 10 a.m. until the valve opens and be flushed out with the sewage onto the grassy field on the other side of the high fence surrounding the metal hospital, that was a far better deal than spending one more minute in this hell hole. Getting pricked with a thousand needles and injected with poisonous cocktails that make you vomit and shit out your insides, and getting your brain fried over and and over til you couldn't even remember your own freaking name.
"You're mind is trying to compensate by creating false memories", yeah right, tell that to a fool because I was no fool, I didn't dream up almost getting killed in the back alley like like a cheap 2 dollar hooked
This was an extremely riveting piece to read indeed! With every section, I was enthralled and your story lines are just fabulous. Great job, keep it up!
-CFG
Hey Roundsquare, Sis here to review,
Alright, so overall I think this was a really good idea. I think I know what you were trying to get across but the way you portrayed it was a bit confusing to me. I think all the reviews below mine told you grammatical errors and punctuation and stuff, but I'm to lazy to go through and read all of them. Also, you say that this is The Fading, Chapter One. However, there turns out to be 3 chapters inside of chapter 1. So, are they parts of chapter one? Or is it separate chapters? Another thing is that I think you tried to cram so much imagery into some of your sentences that it got to be a bit overwhelming.
Overall, this was a really cool idea. Maybe in your next chapters, you could explain a little more about what's going on. Like, why didn't Gloria call James back if she'd missed eleven calls? She just went to work without telling him anything. That seemed a bit out of place. Well, keep writing and keep smiling!
See ya,
Sis
Hello, Roundsquare.
I am here to review as you requested c:
Well, first off, love the story so far. I think it was a very interesting story to read.
Second off, for the readers, it is better to post your stories as chapters, instead of posting all of the chapter into one.
There was an error at the beginning of the first chapter.
You have a spelling error, it's 'a bit'.
Other than that, it was an amazing story. I can't wait to read more of it.
Keep up the good work!
-K
albeit is a word
It means although
Hey there, Roundsquare, here to review as requested.
I will review this separately with every chapter.
Chapter One
There aren't many mistakes here, but there are a few things that you could improve with punctuation, mostly commas.
Here you are missing a couple of commas that I marked. Secondly, you usually also put a comma before linking words such as "and", "but", "so", "therefore", etc... Then, countless requires no a before it.
I especially like this part, because it serves as foreshadowing, in a way. The dark alley looming next to him can represent nothing else than a dark future, or a dark conflict.
Here the sentence you wrote is a question, so there must be a question mark at the end of the sentence.
This whole part seems a bit unnecessary to me, at least for the moment. This is your first chapter, and first chapters usually serve more as an introduction. What you wrote here is, of course, not wrong, but I feel that this kind of history from the character could come later in the story.
This is one of my favorite paragraphs from the chapter. You described it perfectly and you are introducing us to what may be the conflict of your story. I also like it because this is the point where we know that the story is no longer real, but fictitious, and it was very well done.
Overall, this chapter is a great beginning to your story (especially in the end).
Chapter Two
All right, I take back what I said about the story being fictitious. At this point I'm not sure whether it is or not, because your character's blackout seemed stranger than something that would have happened normally, right? Or it may just be me. Anyway, if the first chapter was fictitious (will we find out?) I like how this chapter brings you back to reality, and let's you think about whether you imagined the "fiction" of it or not. However, if the story is real, this chapter is still nice because it makes us think that the character's life is going back to normal, however, in almost every story, we know that events like these happen with a reason, so I would like to discover the reason why you chose to write about an earthquake.
There are no visible mistakes here, but something does catch my attention.
This sentence is not wrong. However, it doesn't really happen like that in real life, according to me. Your body is wider at the shoulders than at the elbows, so if James could pass his shoulders through, he shouldn't really have any difficulty passing the rest of his body through.
I don't have much else to say about this chapter, but it was still good. Continuing with chapter three.
Chapter Three
Okay. By the end of this chapter, I'm guessing the city not only got hit by an earthquake, but also by a meteorite. Or it was maybe just the meteorite that caused the earth to shake?
I must say, out of the three chapters, this is my least favorite, but don't take me wrong, it isn't bad. I just think it goes a little too slowly for what happened in the last two chapters. Also, I find that the timing and the chronology of the story are a little off here. In the first chapter, you said that James had been waiting in the rain, calling Gloria several times. Then he didn't want to get so wet so he decided to get into the restaurant by the back door. James gets in, takes a quick look around, sees everything messed up, and then the earthquake occurs. That is what happens in chapter one, in brief. I am saying this because that time doesn't seem to match the time in chapter three, because all that James did surely didn't take him an hour and a half, right?
Also, coming back to chapter one quickly, the earthquake occurs after. However, James got in and everything was messed up, and now we see that Gloria hadn't been inside the restaurant at all. So what was it that had really happened in the restaurant? This probably will confirm my theory that it is not just a simple earthquake, but something with a purpose.
Returning to Chapter Three now. There aren't many mistakes that I saw, but there are a couple of them that I will point out.
And and yet are both linking words, so they cannot be together. You could either take out and or yet. If you take out and, yet stays the same, but if you take off yet, and must be after the comma.
Also, I think you repeat a lot that Gloria is going late and she can't lose her job, and that Gloria's boss is strict but surely won't get too mad at her. I think you wrote those things a little too much.
That is all I have to say about this chapter.
Overall
This is a good start, and I want to know what will happen next in the rest of the story. Hope this helped a lot, and as always, keep writing.
-Alfonso
Hey there Roundsquare! How are you doing this fine day? As I told you I would be earlier, I'm here to review this work of yours. I thank you again for letting me preview the passages from later on in the story and happy to have helped you by reading it.
Now, let's get started:
I really enjoyed this work of yours. I think you did a good job and that it's very well written. I like the way you write and the words you use. I liked how it was easy to picture the story as it played out in my mind and I didn't have to go back and re-read anything. I think you have great talent and potential as a writer, and don't let anyone ever tell you otherwise.
In this sentence I feel as though you used the word deadly a bit too much. You can easily fix this by changing one of the two words to another synonym of the word.
I don't really want to spend time pointing out what few spelling errors you might have because they can easily be fixed by simply reading over it, but I thought I'd at least point one out that I noticed while I read. You can easily fix it by adding an A between the words 'like' and 'fool'. It's an easy error and we all make mistakes so don't let it bother you. And besides, I didn't notice but a couple of mistakes anyway.
I feel like the wording in this sentence is slightly strange when I read it. I think it's the word 'gone' that causes this feeling. I think that maybe if you change the second word 'gone' to another word like 'become' or something else similar.
Once again, I think this is a very well written story and it piques my interest. I like your choice of words and it really is quite an interesting story. I can't wait to read the next section whenever you put it up and I'd love it if you could notify me when the next part of the story has been put up. I think your a talented writer. Keep it up!
I hope this review helps you and I also hope that you have a good day today!
~Dakushau
Thank you so much for your extremely kind words. I am working on the next chapter. I want it to be close to perfect (I doubt it will be though) by the time I have it up. Thanks for reading and for showing interest.
Hi Roundsquare! Here to review as requested
I'll start off my review with what I liked about this. I think that the ending is good because it leaves the story at a cliffhanger which is intriguing and makes me want to read more. I also think generally the whole idea of this is pretty cool. Although the background information to this is a bit confusing, I'm assuming he's a chef? An angry chef, and you showed that really well through his character so well done!
My first critique is that every sentence starts with either 'he' or 'James'! You really need to vary the way you sentences start because I feel like I was reading the same thing over and over again and it started to get boring. Perhaps next time try and start with adverbs to make it more interesting because right now it's a bit boring. I used to do this all the time too without even realising it, but just try and mix it up a bit because you've got a good story coming along so it'd be a shame to mess it up with your sentence structures.
Secondly, there were a few points where I could see that you were showing, not telling. For example,
So what I mean by this is instead of just simply saying it made him very angry, try and show it. Maybe you could talk about him sighing or feeling like wanting to punch something- just anything to express this emotion rather than just stating this fact.
Typo!
Lastly, more about the background stuff to this story, I think it just needs to be explained more clearly. I'm not sure whether he's a chef, or what. Obviously you don't need to go into great detail about this, and more can be told later, but some basic things need to be said so that the rest of the story isn't as confusing.
Overall, I think this is really good! You've left it at a really cool cliffhanger which leaves me wanting to read more. As for improvements, try and vary the way you start your sentences so it's not 'he did this' 'he felt that' all the time. Also, think about the details you're leaving out, like where James is on his way to in this pouring rain. I hope this review helped, feel free to PM me with any questions you have or if you'd like another review on anything.
Keep writing,
~ArcticMonkey x
It's awesome!! So worth my time!! I can't wait to read the next chapter!!!
You have captured my attention, and there are little to no mistakes apart from the ones I've pointed out already. Also it is full of suspense and had my heart rate going in anticipation!!
Well done and keep it up!!
Basil
Hey Unds!
~ This is...off. Maybe "Finally exhausted, he knelt next to the woman who still laid on the pavement, unconscious. He watched her dust covered back rise and fall with each breath, and attribute to the beautiful life still within her."Shady here to review Chapter Three and Four, as requested. Sorry it took a bit. I got sick. >.>
I suggest you post any subsequent chapters separately. It'll help keep it straight-- which reviews go with which chapter. It also encourages reviewers. I, and many reviewers, focus mostly on the works that don't have many reviews-- and, well, how this is, Ch. 4 might not have any reviews, but reviewers might not notice that.
Alright! On to the review!
Chapter Three
~ I don't like this. I don't know why...I guess it just feels immature. Like a...I can't explain why. I say nix it.
~ Figures of speech are great...but...don't feel right in this sentence.
~ Eeh... Not loving it. "Gloria couldn't take her mind off the events of the previous night. It was constantly on her mind, gnawing at her subconscious, keeping any chance of sleep at bay."
~ 'Raided' is a strange word to choose. I mean, saying 'raided' makes me think of plundering and burning a town-- maybe 'attacked' would be better?
Chapter Four
~ Hobos and miners look nothing alike. -.- And there's nothing wrong with being a miner, either.
~ Um...earthquakes affect miles and miles and miles around. She'd have felt it too, unless it wasn't real-- but, in that case, James wouldn't know that it wasn't real, no? He'd think she should know.
~ Seriously. Punctuation, dude. "She, however, was insistent that he join her for the dinner that she was just about to have. Having no serious objections, and fancying that he was near starvation, James quickly found himself sitting at Dorothy's kitchen table."
~ My mind's eye conjured up a serious messed up image just now. xD Maybe rephrase?
~~
Alright!
You've got me hooked. I'm intrigued what's going on, and where you're going to take this. You can slow it down in places, add more description. You use words like 'hobo', instead of describing his torn pants, the gashes in his shoes, the rock dust ground into his shirt-- you see? There are lots of ways to describe him, to give us a better chance to imagine it.
Hurry up and write chapter five.
Let me know when you do, and feel free to ask if you have any questions.
Keep writing!
~Shady
Let me start off by saying, this is a very, very interesting concept. So, you have gotten point number one right by getting my attention, keeping it, and making me want to read more. That is by far the most important thing in a story.
Of course, like any writing piece, there are the basic grammatical errors, spelling errors, word choice problems, etc. Mainly, there are words used that work, but don't seem to be the best fit for the sentence. Some simple revisions should fix this, just read back over it.
Now, my main complaint is that the flow is awkward. It is not that the story doesn't flow at all, but the flow is difficult to follow. I found myself second guessing who was speaking, who a speaker was talking about, and/or when the point of view had switched. In sections, the point of view switched and the speaker changed, perhaps an extra space or a line break between these two paragraphs would be useful to tell the reader, "Hey, I'm changing now. Pay attention."
The flow is difficult to follow, also, because the story seems to skip from event one to event two to event three etc. Instead, try a bit of connection between events where you still have a lot of storyline and action, but the reader can follow the thought process of the narrator from one action moment to the next. Your story seems to say (such as chapter one) the ceiling fell, I am outside, Gloria fell, I'm a ghost. Perhaps connect the thoughts to make the reader flow with the storyline because I felt as though I was trying to catch up to where you were in your thoughts in writing this.
Overall, excellent. I am excited to see what you do with this story because, with a little bit of work, this could be wonderful. I think the plotline can go very far with the right work. Keep writing!
Okay so I only seen like one or two mistakes it mainly had to do with wrong words.
Like: ' the young paramedic raided the bruise on her forward with something that stung.'
'the young paramedic raided the bruise on her forehead with something that stung.'
see better
There was another one but i'll have to read it again in order to find it and as much as I enjoyed it reading things twice is killer. I don't like that unless like I read it a couple of weeks from now.
Okay so not to be mean or anything but I feel that the second chapter should be longer. One because the third is way too long and it doesn't really balance out well.
I like how you went from James to Gloria. Wish it had more about her. You also had described the characters more. Like how they look I don't know what James looks like but I was with him through the whole story and I can see and understand where his head is at but I cant really see him. Nor Gloria. I can kind of picture the person with the hat but i'm guessing he isn't all that important, but something tells me my guess might be wrong. If it is I'd like for you to describe him too.
I like how you described all the things he was seeing. Not that many people do that, but you did. Oh and they language that you use is perfect. It goes with the story that you're telling.
It kind of reminds me of this movie but way better. I'd like to see what happens with James and if Gloria finds him or not okay?
Hey Roundsquare!
I'm just going to open with this: I am glad that you asked me to read this. I sure as hell don't regret it. It's a superbly written piece which kept me interested from start to finish.
Your writing style is wonderful. In the first chapter alone, you've characterised James so well. I think most of this has been achieved through your use of subtle mannerisms, such as the twitch of James's mouth at the state of the kitchen - little things such as this go so far to making your characters seem human. I wish writers did this more often.
Your vocabulary is fantastic. Too often, in the writing of both others and myself, do I see people using the same words over and over again, but your writing is free of this, which is refreshing.
Honestly, as has been said below, the best thing you could do for this piece is to proofread it. There are a few grammatical errors which could be picked up on which, whilst they didn't bother me at all, may stand out to some readers.
Keep writing, and keep me posted on the status of this novel!
Thanks,
Sandvich
Hey, Roundsquare! Here as requested. Allow me to drive straight in!

Overall, I liked it - I like where you're going with the story and the description here. It's intriguing and I'm interested to see where you take this next!
The first thing I noticed were the grammatical errors in the first chapter, but other reviewers have already commented on that... one thing I did notice, however, is that at first, we don't know who Gloria is until Chapter 2. I mean, we have an idea that he means a lot to her but it's quite ambiguous at the moment so we don't understand that much. Is she his lover? Crush? Partner? He cares a lot about her - more than one'd expect for a typical co worker I'd say.
Also, I would advise combining Chapter 1 and 2. It'd make a lot more sense to the reader as it seems like they're almost in the same scene.
Another thing - right at the beginning of chapter 3, why isn't James more surprised? I wouldn't have expected him to have been more relaxed after the ordeal. Wouldn't his mind be spinning with questions, feeling disorientated or whatnot? He seemed a bit too relaxed for what I'd have expected.
Finally, I feel like the story was lacking something... and that thing was plot. So far, he's found himself in what seems like heaven after seeing his restaurant in a mess. That made it quite confusing because I expected there to have been a problem, but it just seems too much like an event. I wanted to see him *do* something but there isn't much of that, just him standing there experiencing things. A bit more plot, more story, would really really help.
That's all from me! Hope I helped and if you've got any questions, you know where to go.
- Blues.
Thanks you for the well thought out review. I will work on the areas you pointed out.
Hey there!
Little punctuation flub here, darling. The commas in the bolded part are unnecessary.
We don't know Gloria. This is our first introduction of her existence, and this line confuses me-- is an umbrella unmistakable? Or is it Gloria? I think saying "beside the red and purple striped umbrella that was unmistakably Gloria's" or something more fluid like that would do better, dear. Here would also be a good place to tell us who Gloria is. :3
I don’t like this line because in comparison to your gorgeous writing style prior to, it pales. The metaphor is boringly extreme, too. I’d change it to spice it up!
Exchange.
I don’t think the K in kitchen should be capitalized in the middle of a sentence! Further, avoid using extremes to describe things such as “the loudest ever” or “had never pounded so hard”. They disinterest the reader because they give off the impression that this character is either very exaggerative or clearly hasn’t experienced much excitement!
,
Should be looked!
Where in the first line should be were.
Also, I’m not sure that foam is an adjective that applied well to tears! It sounds scary.
Onward,
My first impression of your story was a good one. I like the way your words spun an exciting web together, which is a beautiful, beautiful talent to have on your side. You have a great way of storytelling for certain and I think just paying a little bit of attention to certain details would only take you further.
• Proofread - Honestly, the best thing you can do for your audience is to proofread aggressively. Read your story aloud to yourself and emphasize the punctuation to see what works where and what doesn’t. Spell check vigorously and make sure that your sentence flow into one another.
• Metaphor - You’ll notice that I pointed out in a couple places a note about it, and I think you should pay attention to such. Your metaphor is what brings your story to life, so you want to ensure that the images you use relate in a way that evokes a suitable interpretation. For instance, for a collapsing building, you wouldn’t want to use a metaphor like “cascading like a waterfall” because that implies a degree of grace and beauty about the event. Instead, you might use something like, “crashing down like an avalanche” because that’s a lot more believable in the scheme of things.
• Description - You do a good job here with this one, dear, but I think it could be improved. Avoid using adverbs (words ending with ly) to describe your characters emotion. Use stronger, certain words instead. Saying he charged into the kitchen bravely sounds less exciting than saying that he tossed his inhibitions aside and marched into the kitchen, chest high, leaving his fear in the dust. Clean description is a way for you to expand your audience’s perception of the situation at hand, and also provides a unique voice to your method of storytelling through your word choice.
• Character - I like the main character here. He was relatable and we could feel his emotions, his panic, confusion, and his desperation, through your great choice of words. You managed to develop him well without describing him to us in blatant language (and for that I applaud you!). However, I think his internal repertoire of thoughts became a little repetitious at some points, and I would recommend cutting back on the parts that repeat a similar thought with the same words.
• Story - Don’t get me wrong, I enjoyed reading this because I was intrigued by the events unwrapping, but I don’t really feel like there was much story here. I was a little lost about what exactly happened because while the build up of the story was actually very enjoyable, there was no conclusive resolution, nothing that summarized the story together and that was a little bit disappointing!
As I read the kitchen scene, I couldn’t help but imagine the kitchen as the kitchen from the animated film Ratatouille! Made me smile.
Two thumbs up,
June
Thank you so much for this thorough and well thought out review. I will definitely try to improve on the areas you mentioned.
Hey Roundsquare! I'm here to review at your request. You'll notice marking throughout your story of corrections, and comments as well.
Nice start, a little bland though. Maybe oomph the action? Make me feel what the MC feels.
This paragraph is very shifty to say. You might want to keep one topic in one paragraph, not five billion.
Hello. I edited the first part of the story. The rest has the same mistakes so I just didn't mark them. When you re-read and look at the corrections I had made, you'll notice what to fix. Same mistakes, mean easier to find even if I only showed so little.
They'll be easy to catch. There is too much detail. Commas are thrown everywhere and I'm sort of lost when I read this.
I like the plot though. Very interesting. Just elaborate more and detail less. It'll make your story shine. I see you have potential, and it's big, so work on that. Great work!
PM me for anything!
Keep Writing!
- Nike
Hey there! Just finished reading your work, here's my review:

~ You have a knack for building up an atmosphere, and your description of the wrecked kitchen was exquisite
~ There were a few grammatical errors, but other reviewers have highlighted them so I won't run the risk of repetition!
~ I really like how we get a sense of the character's personality. He's relatable. We've all jumped to crazy conclusions and the way you executed these was humorous without detracting from the mysterious tone of the piece.
~ I'm really intrigued by these characters and want to know more about them. Some physical descriptors would really help me visualise them.
~ I think the flow of the piece could perhaps be improved upon. And the more philosophical quotes can seem forced, i.e. "he was full of beautiful life" and "was anything unthinkable in this crazy world?"
~ Remember, less is more. Let the readers make their own inferences, for example, you wrote "He scratched the back of his head, wondering about what was going on." I don't think the second part of this sentence is really needed as the first is enough to demonstrate his confusion.
Overall, a great piece! Just make a few refinements and it'll be excellent!
thanks you for the well thought out review
Hey.
What I really like about your writing is that you have used a large range of vocabulary, the parts where you have described those intimate objects are just perfect. You have no grammitical mistakes as far as I am concerned and this is a pretty nice peice of work. Though, long for lazy people like me. :3
Your description however, is the best part. It helps me to build up an image of those objects and surrounding.
-Will be hoping to see more work soon.
Thanks a million for the encouraging words
Hey there Roundsquare!
First off, I commend you on your nearly perfect grammar. I say nearly because the flow of the piece is sometimes jarred by your improper use of commas, for example here:
see, there isn't any need for a comma after room. Try reading your chapters to yourself aloud, and when you stumble over a sentence that doesn't please your ears, edit.
That's all I have to say on the grammatical aspect. There are, however, other instances (and here I nit-pick) where your flow is disturbed, not by commas, but by the placement of your words. For example:
That question your character asks himself is the first instance where warning bells should go off in the minds of some genre-savvy readers. Something is amiss. Tension starts to build... and evaporates, in my opinion, as you mention the chandelier going on. On that note, after life, there shouldn't be a full-stop.
One thing which struck me is that James seems to be enthralled by his work-place. He describes it like an 'eighteenth-century ballroom'. If he works here every day, then that enthusiasm would probably wear off, and his tone would be rather dull. Unless, of course, he's the kind of person that NEVER grows bored of ANYTHING, which is possible.
Back to my point of ruining flow:
went pale like a man who'd just witnessed his own death is a very strong sentence. I feel there's no need to detract from that strength with the needlessly long sentence that follows. I understand you wanted to work in a description of his hair, but I'm sure you can find a more opportune and less cliche way and moment. Rather, I think you should do away with it entirely and move along these lines:
He suddenly went pale like a man who'd just witnessed his own death. The room was completely destroyed, as if a garbage truck or tornado had gone through it. James' jaw dropped.
See what I mean? I think that how I phrased it above is slightly more efficient in terms of shock value.
I found it funny, even amid all the mess, he's still thinking about work. Maybe he is that kind of person after all.
I think it'd more like: "Gloria? Gloria?!" he called/shouted/exclaimed. One does not simply, twitch their lips, in a situation like this (<-- improper use of commas, but hey, I'm paraphrasing a quote. Totes legit).
Now, here's a trick you could consider. Work in more emotions/feelings into your first part of the chapter. For example, when he's wet, is he cold? How cold? Is he shivering? Could you add a cool simile there? And when he sees the room as a wreck. Is he frightened? Confused? Angry? Perhaps a mix of all of the above, or maybe something entirely different! Then, have these emotions climax when he tries to raise gloria. Despair, furor (at himself maybe?), amp those emotions right to eleven... then have them ebb down, until he feels... nothing. He's a ghost, see what I mean? It may be cool, it may be silly, but perhaps, if in your third (third? I thought it was the second) chapter, you can tone down on sensory and emotive impact, and if you pull it off just right, it can be pretty awesome, and rather unique, if I do say so myself.
I felt your third chapter, however, was boring. Like, it was nothing but James getting from point A to point B, without any relevant information that may come in handy later. And even if there is something subtle that I've missed, you could still add it to the first chapter, that way the getting from point A to point B is irrelevant.
Overall, however, this is a good chapter. I'd just like to see more emotion in it, and definitely (in the future chapters) his thoughts on what he'll do next.
Thank you so much for the comment. Your tips were very useful. Will definitely consider them seriously.
Hey Unds!
Shady here with your review, as promised.
I tend to start my reviews with specific points, whether they be complaints or compliments, and wrap them up with a general overview.
Alright. The first thing that stands out is that you need punctuation. For example...
I like your description. It's very nice. It keeps things at a nice pace-- not going too fast.
~ Repetition. Nix.
~ Don't tell me, show me. Did he blanch? Start sweating? Did his eyes go wide? Details.
~ Dude. Major run-on sentence. "It looked like a tornado, or maybe a garbage truck, made a detour into the kitchen. The place was a wreck. Even worse, no one seemed to be doing anything about it."-- Three sentences. c:
~ I had to read this a few times before I understood what it meant. Maybe rephrase?
~ *racking his mind
~ Maybe restructure so that the loud noise comes first? Because the first two sentences of this bit seem really random, until you read further.
~ c: I like it.
O.o He's dead. Wow. That...wasn't expected.
~
Okay!
Sorry if that came off a bit too harsh.
//isaGrammarNazi
I did really enjoy your story-- clean up the technical difficulties in it, and it'll be great. c:
If you need any more help, or have any questions, don't hesitate to ask! I want to read your next chapter, when you get it posted!
Keep writing!
~Shady
You did a great job here, Roundsquare. This seems to promise more of the same, and that means more improvement and more good writing, so good luck with it.
Varied sentence structure and diction, fluent sentences, and proportional description contribute to the success of the piece.
One possible thing to improve on is being a little less flighty and cryptic with stuff, especially in the beginning, but hey, if that's the style you're going for, more power to ya.
Good Job
Thank you
Great story
Thank you! I'm glad you liked it.
Hi!
Firstly, welcome to YWS, I hope this brilliant site helps you as much as it's helped me!
Now, on to your story. For a first chapter I didn't find it as engaging as I was expecting. I assume you wanted to slowly build this story up, but I do think you still need to make sure you're adding enough to your paragraphs that excite your readers and make them want to read more.
Saying that, I really enjoyed the flow of your writing. Aside from a few grammar mistakes here and there, it was good for a first story. I also enjoyed your description a lot. There was just enough to create a nice vivid image of your characters surroundings, which is something I enjoyed whilst I was reading it. I also liked the way you showed the readers your main character's personality. He clearly loves his job and is very dedicated to it, which you put across nicely.
A short review, I know, but I hope it helps!
*coco