z

Young Writers Society


Give a Boy a Gun (MAY OFFEND)



User avatar
665 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 6165
Reviews: 665
Thu Feb 03, 2005 3:23 pm
Chevy says...



There's no place to start,
Excepting the ending maybe,
Where you're sure to feel the impact.

There's no one to talk to,
Except the tombstone maybe,
But you wouldn't get an answer.

And it was a Christmas present.

His father had left;
His mother, gone to work;
His brother, who knows where or how;
He had no idea,
Why they had left him alone.

And it was from his grandfather.

School was no refuge,
He was tortured and beat down,
Physically and emotionally

Standing five feet tall,
He was a "lame."
Barely over one hundred pounds.
Ridiculed because he was "ugly."
Nothing about him was right.

He was just a young boy,
Maybe fifteen years old,
He felt the pressure,
And the desire to die.

But he wasn't going alone.
He was taking them with him,
After all, it had been their fault.

And he knew he had it in his closet.

No fear inside,
No tears outside.
The chance to die,
Was all that mattered.

He held it in his hand,
It was just in those three shots.
That he accomplished everything he had ever wanted.

Now you see what happens,
When you give the boy a gun.

NOTE:The only reason why I said "MAY OFFEND" was because some people get really sensitive when it comes to the subject of guns.
when there's nowhere to go, it's time to grow up.
  





User avatar
915 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 890
Reviews: 915
Thu Feb 03, 2005 5:33 pm
Incandescence says...



Oh Morgan...I liked the concept of the poem, or the impression the title left on my imagination. However, you're poems are always too literal. Not overtly literal, but just a little too much for me to consider it poetry but more along the lines of story. If that makes any sense.

Anyway, onto the poem and some specific complaints:

"There's no place to start,
Excepting the ending maybe,
Where you're sure to feel the impact."

I think you should use "except," not "excepting."

"There's no one to talk to,
Except the tombstone maybe,
But you wouldn't get an answer."

Don't use "maybe" again at the end of the second line. It doesn't flow well, as you used it second verse in the first stanza.

And it was a Christmas present.

"His father had left;
His mother, gone to work;
His brother, who knows where or how;
He had no idea,
Why they had left him alone."

Too much description of nothing. Also, punctuation all over the place does not appeal to the structural feel of the poem for your readers.

"And it was from his grandfather.

School was no refuge,
He was tortured and beat down,
Physically and emotionally"

Nothing's great about this stanza, but it isn't a bad stanza. You refrain from being meticulous in your description of the environment, which contributes to a better read.

"Standing five feet tall,
He was a "lame."
Barely over one hundred pounds.
Ridiculed because he was "ugly."
Nothing about him was right."

Do I get the feeling this is more about you than the boy in your poem? For the most part, in real life, it's just you telling yourself those things. For the poem, there was again too much description of nothing. What about how he feels?

"He was just a young boy,
Maybe fifteen years old,
He felt the pressure,
And the desire to die."

One of your better stanzas.

"But he wasn't going alone.
He was taking them with him,
After all, it had been their fault."

Kind of out of place. I want to say cliche, but it isn't quite the right word for this stanza. I think you could have described this better, or even integrated it into the feel of the poem.

"And he knew he had it in his closet.

No fear inside,
No tears outside.
The chance to die,
Was all that mattered."

Nice flow here. Really nice.

"He held it in his hand,
It was just in those three shots.
That he accomplished everything he had ever wanted."

Again, way too much description. For instance, where else would he have held the gun? His nose? His leg?

"Now you see what happens,
When you give the boy a gun."

A bizarre and ineffective end to this poem. You need an image at the end to capture your reader. We want to be captured. Just lay the web.
"If I have not seen as far as others, it is because giants were standing on my shoulders." -Hal Abelson
  





User avatar
481 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 6194
Reviews: 481
Thu Feb 03, 2005 7:19 pm
Bobo says...



Well, since Brad has picked it apart so well, I'll just settle for saying that the poem was really good.
  





User avatar
1259 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Male
Points: 18178
Reviews: 1259
Thu Feb 03, 2005 8:08 pm
Firestarter says...



Yeh Brad pretty much summarised the problems. I'd like to add the sentiment that you're a little literal, I'd rather see more abstraction. But to each their own.
Nate wrote:And if YWS ever does become a company, Jack will be the President of European Operations. In fact, I'm just going to call him that anyways.
  





User avatar
73 Reviews



Gender: None specified
Points: 890
Reviews: 73
Thu Feb 03, 2005 10:38 pm
convintojm says...



even i (one who tends to be quite literal and foward in my poetry) think it was a little too straightfoward. but i love the one line stanzas. i think they worked really well.
  





User avatar
323 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 323
Thu Feb 03, 2005 11:41 pm
hekategirl says...



Oh, very nice! I really like how you put the italic lines inbeetween the stanzas.
I love this stanza the most.

"No fear inside,
No tears outside.
The chance to die,
Was all that mattered. "

Bravo.
***Honorary 11-Year-Old***

Heh-COT-ee-GUR-el

Got YWS?
  





User avatar
9 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 890
Reviews: 9
Tue Feb 15, 2005 3:47 pm
Shawn Mitchell says...



You're only 15? Wow, very impressive. You have a mature yet very straightforward style. Very nice. I really liked the concept too. These days, it's hard to find an original idea for poetry, but you grasped it well.
[center]
A bitter soul is still sweet

www.shawnmitchell.com
www.writing.com/authors/prodigymytch
[/center]
  








The moral of Snow White is never eat apples.
— Lemony Snicket