A Walk in the Park

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 9
Not that long ago, not very far from here, there was a man, walking through a city park. He wasa very business-like man, despite his youth. His chestnut hair was well-combed, and a tie held tight about his neck. He wore a smart gray suit and in one hand held a leather briefcase. In the other, was a piping hot cup of coffee.
This man was hurrying along in his life. The park was a short-cut to the office to him, nothing more. Consequentially, he did not see the child playing happily on a blanket with her mother. Nor did he see the elderly couple, sitting close together on a bench , celebrating fifty long years of their love. None of these things had anything to do with him and his busy life, so what reason did he have to see them?
The man turned a corner, and suddenly found himself quite alone. It was odd that one part of the park should be so crowded with people, and yet around the corner there should be no one. Well, almost no one. There was an older woman, seated behind a table on which strange odds and ends were scattered. She was watching the man closely, her eyes following him as he approached. Of course, he noticed none of this.
"You." She said as the man passed. He stopped and looked at her, judging her quickly. To him, she appeared like any other ex-hippie trying to make a living without actually getting a job. "Come here." The woman gestured to him with her finger.
"I'm in a hurry, I can't." The young man said stiffly. "I've got an important meeting in an hour. I can't miss it." He began to move, but was stopped when the mysterious old woman began to laugh. It was a high, slow sort of laugh, not intimidating, but not all that comforting, either.
"Believe me, my boy, to the rest of your life, it is not important. Now, come. I am sure you will find something among my many wares that you lack. But remember, nothing upon my table is as it seems." She said to him, her eyes dancing with mirth. The young man was unsure as to how he felt about being called 'boy,' but he approached the woman's table nonetheless. There was a certain air about her that made him want to hear what she had to say. Her silver-gray hair was held back by a dark purple cloth, and a large amount of beaded necklaces and bracelets obscured her clothing.
Upon the table was an odd assortment of miscellany. The strangest thing, the man thought, was that everything was individual. There was no more than one of each item. There was a beautiful pure-white flower, a pink crystal heart, a picture in a frame, a gold pocket-watch, a little book, a strange coin, and many such things.
"So tell me, boy, is there anything that you need?" She pierced him with her gaze, an odd knowing look that said she already knew the answer to her own question. A smile still played upon her lips.
"Anything I need?" The man said, looking down at the table. It was just a bunch of junk the old woman collected and was then pawning off, he thought. Why would he have any need of it? "Nope. Can't say I do." He finished.
The woman laughed again, more so than before. The man began to feel angry; he felt like a child in her presence. "Can't say you do, eh?" She said through her laughter. She looked quickly at all the items that were displayed before her, and picked up the picture, presenting it to the man.
"Do you have this?" She once again looked at him, like a teacher guiding a struggling student towards the right answer. It was a strange picture. Not because of its subject, no, that was quite ordinary, but how it made the young man feel. In the foreground of the picture was a pretty, young blonde, giving the man a sunny smile. She held in her arms a happy, laughing child, waving towards the camera. Behind them was a group of people, all smiling, goofing around, and having fun. The man felt as though he should know these people, but his head told him that it was impossible. They were strangers. And yet…
"Of course not. Why would I have a picture of a bunch of people I don't know?" The man said, trying not to appear as irritated as he felt.
"You do not know these people yet, my boy, but you could. You only have to choose it. With this, you would never have to spend your weekends at home petting your cat, watching TV, and eating instant noodles." The young man was struck by her words. That was exactly what he had done the day before. How could she have known? Feeling a slight bit uneasy, the man tightened his tie, a nervous habit of his. He did not say anything. The woman waited a moment, then set the picture back down with a sigh and a small smile. "Well, alright, if that does not suit you, how about… ah!" The woman picked up a little book, handing it to the man. He set the coffee on the old woman's table and accepted it. It looked more promising than the picture, at least.
"A joke book?" He said, looking at the cover. It seemed old for a joke book, and well-worn. "Jokes don't go very far at the office." The man set the book back down on the table, shaking his head.
"This may not get you very far in your career or anywhere else, but it makes you happy, you know. All the studies say so. It even burns calories." The woman said with a wink. The man felt very confused. It was almost as if the woman was talking about something else entirely. He once again remained silent as the woman returned the little joke book to its place. The man opened his mouth to bid the woman good-bye, hoping that now might be his moment to get away, but it seemed she was not giving up. Before he could say anything, the woman was offering him something else.
Gingerly held in the palms of her hands was a delicate pink-crystal heart. "Look at this, my boy, look closely. I'll tell you from experience that everyone needs this. It is fragile, true, and breaks easily, but it is quickly mended and will bring you great joy throughout your entire life. Take it, my boy, you won't regret it."
The man scowled. Why would a cheap, crystal heart make him happy throughout his life? This woman was crazy! "No, I'm sorry, I really don't need anything like that. I got to go now." The woman's expression changed with unsettling speed from joyful and teasing to grave.
She took a deep steadying breath and said in a firm, but not unkind voice. "Listen to me, young man. I am the Crone, and I have appeared to you today offering gifts. All of them were things needed by you. However, I will trust you. If you do not need family and friends, or laughter, or even love, that is your decision. I will not force my advice upon you." And then, she winked at him, again filling with mirth. "I told you nothing was as it seems." And then she was gone.
There were no theatrics, no bright light, no mist, no noise. The man just blinked, and she was gone. Feeling confused and disoriented, the man began to once again walk towards his office. Although he would have much rather have been thinking about the presentation he was going to listen to in twenty minutes' time, he could not help but think about the odd encounter he just had. Who was that woman? He thought and thought, brooding upon it as he walked.
Once again lost in his own thoughts, he did not notice those around him. As a result, he did not see the young blonde woman walking towards him until he knocked her down completely. He dropped his briefcase, paper scattering on the dirt path. His coffee fell to the ground and spilled everywhere.
"Oh, my gosh, I'm so sorry!" The blonde said, bending down to help him with his papers. The young man joined her on the ground.
"It's fine, it was my fault anyways. I wasn't watching where I was going." He stood up, and the woman handed him the papers, which he added to his own pile. She smiled at him, a bright, sunny smile that the young man recognized from somewhere. The man couldn't help but laugh at the blunder. "My mother did always tell me to get my head out of the clouds."
"Oh, and I ruined your coffee, too!" She said with a smile and a laugh as she spied the paper cup, surrounded by spilled coffee, looking rather like a war victim. "Let me buy you another one." She smiled at him again, a playful glint in her eye that the young man liked.
The man's mind spun. Had she just asked him out? But that meeting he had been hurrying all morning to get to… And then the young man realized something. It wasn't important. He didn't even need to be there. Why did he ever think it was so important? And so the man consented to coffee. He reorganized his briefcase, and as he and the woman walked, smiling and laughing, he could have sworn he heard that old woman, the Crone, laughing along with them.







So this is a short story I wrote as a part of a submission for a $30000 scholarship. So I'm trusting you all to help me make this $30000 good! So tear it to shreds! Go mad! You are the Kraken and this is the maiden sacrifice! Devour it like rabid, starving wolves! Oh, and I'm still questionable about the title, I'm always terrible at them, so if anyone has a better suggestion that would be greatly appreciated.
Don't put me underground, I was meant for a life somewhere else.
Please, love, give me the wheel, before both of our hearts you
will steal tonight

-The Approaching Curve, Rise Against




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1656
Reviews 122
Not that long ago, not very far from here, there was a man, walking through a city park.


I think you can omit the third comma. It seems like a comma overload in this sentence.

He was a very business-like man, despite his youth.


Small typo there.

, and a tie held tight about his neck.


Strange phrasing. Maybe you could use 'tight around his neck'.

In the other, was a piping hot cup of coffee.


You can get rid of the comma there. Or, if you want to keep the comma, delete was.

This man was hurrying along in his life.


This sentence seems a little bland. Maybe you could word it differently?

so what reason did he have to see them?


Awkward phrasing here as well. Perhaps 'so why did he have to notice them?'

"You." She said


There should be a comma instead of a period, and de-capitalize 'she'. You have this same problem in a few other places too. You should change it.

Overall, I liked it. The Crone was an interesting character. The man really was stuck up at the beginning and I didn't like him much. The plot was okay, but the hook was a little... not strong enough. Anyway, good luck with your scholarship!
There once was a cat.
He wasn’t particularly fat.
Fuzzy was his favorite mat.
And really, that was that.

Oh, but did you really think so?
Keep reading, it’s just the start of the show!
And as for how far this tale will go…
Well, even the cat doesn’t know.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6403
Reviews 312
RAWR. It's story-ripping time.
Grammar and Wording.
First of all, there were a few little mistakes that could easily be fixed if you read this over again. I'm not going to point them all out because that would take too much time and I'm sure you'll find them. But for example, in your second sentence, it should be was a and not wasa. So just watch out for things like that. One thing, though, I noticed you do over and over:

"You." She said as the man passed.
..should be:
"You," she said as the man passed.

Wording-wise, some of the sentences were awkward especially in the beginning. Again, this is something that could easily be fixed by re-reading your piece. And, also, WaterVyper pointed out a lot. :)

Descriptions.
One of the hardest things about describing is finding the balance between too much and too little. In this case, it's not quite as important because it is a short story, but I think you could tell us more. How, exactly, did the Crone look like a hippie? What color were the blonde woman's eyes? What was she wearing? Maybe the young man has wrinkles in his forehead from frowning all the time or expensive Italian loafers, a rare impulse buy.

As she bent down to help him pick up his papers, he couldn't help but notice her piercing jade-colored eyes. ...or something. ;-)

The other hardest thing about describing is integrating your descriptions into the story. For example...

Annie walked into the classroom and sat down. She had red hair, brown eyes and chubby fingers.

...this is what's called an info dump. Info dumps are, fairly obviously, when the writer dumps the description, without making any effort to weave it into the story. A better, integrated description could be something like...

Annie's long, red hair made a swishing sound as she walked into the classroom. Her velvet brown eyes swept the classroom, looking for an empty seat. Finally, she sat down, and gripped her pencil with her chubby fingers.

Eh. That's still not great. :? But do you see how I intertwined Annie's description with her actions?
This happened a bit in your first paragraph when describing Mr. Young Businessman. With a little bit of revision, it could be fixed. Like, he ran his fingers through his well-combed chestnut hair. Et cetera.

Characters.
I like the Crone (she sounds like my granny :D). I like the way your MC develops from a stuck up workoholic into a less stuck up cool dude. I also liked the way you didn't use names-this is really hard, especially when you have more than two characters, because you have to rely almost completely on pronouns. So! No complaints here. :) Good job.

The beginning.
The beginning...was uninteresting. It was awkward, a bit tedious, and it was hard to keep reading. As I got further in it got better, but the beginning is very important as that's what will hook your reader. This is a very helpful article by Caligula's Launderette and I suggest reading the whole section entitled "How to sell me at the beginning." Basically, the beginning needs to catch your reader's attention; since your story begins with your main character, you need to give us a reason to care to about him.

The end.
The ending was cute! I really liked it. Especially the part about the old woman laughing along with them. Except, one teeny tiny edit on that last sentence.

He reorganized his briefcase, and as he and the woman walked, smiling and laughing, he could have sworn he heard [s]that old woman,[/s] the Crone, laughing along with them.

Since there's only one old woman and one Crone you don't need both in there.

Overall.
I liked this, but it needs a little work. Do some revising and editing, read it over a few times, and then I think it would be fully able to win a scholarship. And don't hesitate to PM me if you need more elaboration, or another review, or whatever.
Good luck! :)
'life tastes sweeter when it's wrapped in poetry'
-the wombats


critiques // nano




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 9
Thanks, guys! Awesome criticism! Yeah, I knew that there would be a lot of work to do with it. The concept is solid, but all the words need some serious rearranging. Awesome reviews, thank you all!
Don't put me underground, I was meant for a life somewhere else.
Please, love, give me the wheel, before both of our hearts you
will steal tonight

-The Approaching Curve, Rise Against




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 158
I liked this. It was fun to read, lightweight of course but that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Sometimes we need to read this sort of thing to make us happy.
As far as nit-picks go, I see very little to mention. It's mainly down to, as kissthewitch said, you writing "blahblahblah." He said , instead of "blahblahblah," he said. And that's about it. I did pick up on two things that I feel haven't been mentioned, do with them what you will.

1.
"Oh, my gosh, I'm so sorry!" The blonde said, bending down to help him with his papers. The young man joined her on the ground.
This seemed a bit off, wording-wise. You say she bends down to help him, which implies that he is already gathering the papers up. However, you then note that joins her in collecting them up. Hmm? Also, that 'joined her on the ground' bit didn't sound right. Bugged me a bit. :)
2.
She smiled at him, a bright, sunny smile that the young man recognized from somewhere. The man couldn't help but laugh at the blunder.
You say the young man, and immediately in the next lines it's the man. Maybe 'he' for the second sentence? You don't want it to verge on repetitive.

Well, that's about it. My only advice would be watch your punctuation, try to vary your sentences a bit to make it more interesting, and the blonde girl - well, that says it all. Make her something more than the blonde girl. That surely can't be her identity? Maybe have her tell him her name? Or maybe that wouldn't work, seeing as how the MC is nameless. Ah, maybe scrap that idea.

Good luck with winning. :)



In any free society, the conflict between social conformity and individual liberty is permanent, unresolvable, and necessary.
— Kathleen Norris