The Twins

6 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 47
This is my first piece in YWS! Critique needed urgently!
Love, berrylique.
Thanks kitty15, misty and chocoholic for the critque and comments. :D

Chapter 1
Snow began falling from the night sky. It was the first snowfall in the year, and Doctor Rees was sitting behind his office table, looking out of the polished window. Heaps of snow piled up on the windowpanes of cars parked at the car park, and angry owners wiped them away. Children were out, on the field with their family, playing with the snow and running on the grounds, grinning widely.
Seeing that made Doctor Rees think about his own son, Samuel, and beautiful wife, Tammie, who were at home, waiting for him to come back home. Samuel was three this year, and he was very obedient-unusual for a boy. When they walked through the streets, people would say that Samuel was a handsome little child, and they always commented on how much he resembled his father but those eyes, those were his mother's oval shaped, deep blue eyes.
Doctor Rees pulled open his drawer and rummaged through it for a picture of the family at the park last month.
When he felt something like a Polaroid, he pulled it out carefully, and instead, it showed his wife, heavily pregnant three years before, in 1967. She was wearing a deep blue cashmere sweater that was the same shade as her striking eyes. Doctor Rees began recalling memories of that night, and he remembered that his wife gave birth to their children on that fateful night…

*-*-*-*-*
Doctor Rees was holding his wife gingerly, and Tammie was smiling at his care. They were walking along the street down their house, and it was a cold December night. The stars were twinkling overhead, and it was a gorgeous night.
Tammie was supporting herself by placing her hand on her waist. As she did so, her hand brushed against the soft deep blue material of her sweater.
“Darling?” She began, looking at her husband. “Do you remember the day we first met?”

“Of course, dear,” replied Doctor Rees, as that day’s memories came flooding back to him.
It was only last October. Doctor Rees was at the mall looking for a nice watch to present to his mother for her birthday. As he walked through the department store, he caught sight of this woman in a pretty, little flowery dress.
She had her back facing to him, and she was quite far away, but Doctor Rees was able to see that she was tall and slender, with a coat of copper brown hair tumbling to her waist. She was at the woman’s section, picking out some blouses. He hurriedly grabbed an ocean blue cashmere sweater and followed her to the cashier.
Doctor Rees stepped abruptly into her path and the cashier glanced at him impatiently.
“I am afraid that Miss McCarthy arrived first,” the cashier, who had a piercing look in her eyes, glared at him.
“Oh, it’s OK, Jane, you can serve him first,” the woman replied.
“I am so sorry, Tamara. It should be your turn,” the cashier insisted.
Doctor Rees cleared his throat. “Sorry, but I am a doctor, and I have to rush back to the hospital,” he lied.
“Oh dear, really, Jane, do take him first,” Tamara turned to him. “Is that sweater for your wife?”
“Erm, no, I am not married yet. It is for my sister,” he said hastily, hoping that he did not give Tamara the wrong impression.
Four months after that little meeting, they got married-she was only twenty-two, while he was twenty-nine.


“Darling, there’s something I cannot understand,” Tammie began, and Doctor Rees looked at her questioningly.
“You said you bought this sweater for your sister, but didn’t your sister pass away before we met?” Tammie asked.
“Sorry, dear, but I had to find a way to get your name,” he replied, looking apologetic.
“Oh, darling, you are so sweet,” Tammie smiled, but her expression changed drastically as she clutched her swollen belly.
“Dear? What’s wrong?” Doctor Rees asked his wife worriedly, and clutched her more tightly. “The baby isn’t due until Christmas, right?”
“I-I don’t know. It’s hurting so-so much-h,” Tammie said, and bent over a little.
“Can you walk? I have to bring you back to the car to send you to the hospital,” Doctor Rees said, and Tammie nodded slightly.
Doctor Rees held his wife as they entered the hospital he worked in. His nurse, Marilyn, came rushing over.
“Marilyn, go and request Doctor Smith to come immediately,” Doctor Rees said. Marilyn nodded and scurried off.
Doctor Rees laid his wife down on the bed in one of the delivery rooms. He held his wife’s hand tightly, and gazed into her deep blue eyes. She was on the verge of crying, and her mouth was twisted in an odd way.
The door swung open, and Marilyn came in. “I can’t find Doctor Smith. I called him repeatedly, but he did not answer the phone,” she licked her lips, looking very worried.
“Marilyn, go and get the gas. We have to deliver the baby,” Doctor Rees ordered Marilyn, and she pushed a trolley in.
“P-Peter,” Tammie said, almost inaudible. She was clutching to Doctor Rees’ arm tightly. “Remember, S-Samuel for a-a b-boy, and S-Serena f-for a g-girl.” She then was given the gas, and soon passed out.
Marilyn set Tammie the delivering position, when prepared to hold the baby and he or she came out. Tammie woke up sometime later, and when she had enough strength, Doctor Rees and Marilyn encouraged her to push. When it was too painful for her to continue, Doctor Rees gave her the gas, and she passed out, leaving the baby to come out on its own. This was repeated a few times, when finally, Marilyn took the baby from the bed, and Doctor Rees cut the baby’s umbilical cord. Marilyn started cleaning the baby.
“It’s a boy!” Marilyn announced.
“My little Samuel!” exclaimed Doctor Rees, and he took the baby from Marilyn, and showed him to Tammie, now conscious.
Tammie smiled and reached out for the baby, but her expression stiffened, and she lay down on the bed again.
“My stomach is hurting again,” she moaned, and she was given the gas again.
“I think it is post-labor contractions,” Marilyn assured Doctor Rees, and headed towards the baby room with Samuel.
Doctor Rees walked over to his wife, and Marilyn came back in.
“Marilyn,” Doctor Rees began when he walked towards the end of the bed. “I think she is having another one.”
“Really! Excuse me, Peter, I have to get the baby out,” she replied.
This baby was much easier to deliver. The baby came out quickly, and this time, it was Doctor Rees who held it first.
“This is Serene!” He said, holding the baby cautiously. He smiled widely, but when he looked at the baby carefully, he smile faded.
The baby had an extra toe on the left foot, and there were white spots on the irises of her hazel, almond-shaped eyes. She had short limbs, unlike her brother. Doctor Rees knew what it was. It was Down syndrome. Marilyn took the baby, sensing something was wrong, and hurried off to the baby room.
He remembered his younger sister, who was out in the garden, playing with her toys. She was clutching the right side of her chest, and she breathed in short, quick breaths. His mother would look out of the kitchen window, and then turn away to cry silently.
When he was ten, he remembered his sister was sent to the hospital. His mother was crying in loud sobs, following the paramedics, while his father placed his hand on his mother’s shoulders.
He would never let Tammie go through what his late mother had gone through. Never. He loved his wife dearly, and he loved her too much to hurt her. He wouldn’t want to see Tammie crying every time. He did not want to be reminded of his sister.
He reached a decision, and stood up, walking towards the baby room. Marilyn was sitting on a chair, feeding the baby with milk from a bottle. She looked up, and gazed at him sadly.
Doctor Rees had once been asleep in his office, because of exhaustion and stress. Marilyn had been standing in the doorway, looking at him, with sweetness in her eyes. When he woke up, she smiled at him, and Marilyn just fell in love with him. Marilyn was devastated when she knew Doctor Rees was engaged. She tried to avoid Doctor Rees during work, but her efforts were in vain. She cried whenever she was alone at home, unable to believe herself for thinking she had a chance with him.
Now, Marilyn was looking at him again, this time with pure sadness. Doctor Rees mustered his courage, but not looking Marilyn in the eye, he spoke.
“Take the baby away.”
Last edited by berrylique on Wed Sep 05, 2007 6:14 am, edited 1 time in total.
'follow the notes upon a journey,
at first sight marks one's destiny.
when the voyage comes to an end,
return lies within hasty keys.'




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6235
Reviews 2631
Hi there! Just wanted to let you know that we really appreciate all the critiques you have given to other members of YWS.

Here are a few suggestions -

Children were out, on the field with their family [Perhaps families? Or are the children all related?], playing with the snow and running on the grounds, grinning widely.

Seeing that makes Doctor Rees think about his own son, Samuel, and wife, Tammie, now still at home, waiting for him to come back home. [You started off in past tense so you probably shouldn't switch to present and this could be smoother. Perhaps something like 'This recalled Doctor Rees' thoughts to his own family - his son, Samuel, and his beautiful wife, Tammie, who were at home, waiting for him to return.']

When they walked [s]on[/s] through the streets, people [s]always[/s] would say that Samuel [s]is[/s] was a handsome little child, and they always commented on how much he resembled his father but those eyes, those were his mother's oval shaped, deep blue eyes.[s]looks about the same as Doctor Rees, except he has the oval-shaped, deep blue eyes like his mother’s. [/s]

The stars were twinkling overhead, and it [s]is[/s] was a gorgeous night.

She had her back [s]facing[/s] to him, and she was quite far away, but Doctor Rees was able to see that she was tall and slender, with a coat of copper brown hair tumbling to her waist.

“Erm, no, I am not married yet. It is for my sister,” he said hastily, hoping that he [s]does not[/s] didn't give Tamara the wrong impression.

Four months after that little meeting, they got married-she was only twenty-two, while he was twenty-nine.
*-*-*-*-* [You should only end the italics here. The *-*-*-* started the first flash back, not the second.]

“You said you bought this sweater for your sister. Hasn’t your sister passed away for a long time?” Tammie asked. [I think the section in bold needs re-phrasing. Maybe something like 'But didn't your sister pass away before we met?']

“Sorry, dear, but I [s]have[/s] had to find a way to get your name,”

Tammie smiled, [s]and[/s] but her expression changed drastically as she clutched her swollen belly.

“The baby isn't due until Christmas, right?”

It’s hurting so-so much-h,” Tammie said, and [s]bended[/s] bent over a little.

She [s]is[/s] was clutching to Doctor Rees’ arm tightly.

Marilyn set Tammie in the delivering position, and prepared to hold the baby [s]and[/s] when he or she came out. Tammie woke up sometime later, and when she had enough strength, Doctor Rees and Marilyn [s]will[/s] encouraged her to push. When it was too painful for her to continue, Doctor Rees gave her the gas, and she passed out, leaving the baby to come out on its own. This was repeated a few times, when finally, Marilyn [s]held[/s] took the baby from the bed, and Doctor Rees cut the baby’s umbilical cord.

The baby had an extra toe on the left foot, and there [s]are[/s] were white spots on [s]her[/s] the irises of her hazel, almond-shaped eyes.

She was clutching [s]her[/s] the right side of [s]the[/s] her chest, and she breathed in short, quick breaths.

His mother would look out of the kitchen window, and [s]turned her body[/s] then turn away to cry silently.

_____________________________
In general, I think you have an interesting plot here and I like how you've done your flash backs but you need to be careful not to change tense and some more description of setting and characters might be nice. It's a good start though and I hope some of this is helpful.
Writing Gooder

~Previously KittyKatSparklesExplosion15~

The light shines brightest in the darkest places.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 493
Hi, Berry! You're doing a great job here. It's really impressive that out of thirty four posts, 21 are reviews. I'm really proud of you and welcome to the site! First and foremost, YWS is about helping young authors improve their writing. That is to say, by the time you're my age, if you actually *listen* to the advice given to you, I'm confident that you'll be a better writer. Let me tell you what, I've improved one hundred percent since I got here.

I had a few problems with your story--while I found it to be an interesting concept (deformed twin, Doctor for a husband, and so on), you had a lot of grammatical errors, which kitty pointed out. You slipped in and out of past and present tense. This is never a good thing. Make sure you're realy careful with that. The only way you're ever going to be a really great writer is to emulate great writers, especially at your age. Read the classics, the books that are beloved. Read them and study them because the authors are doing something right in them. Can you see your book someday being leatherbound in somebody's bookcase? I can see that. I want that. I know you do too. So study what you've got--your resources are infinite.

The second issue I had with this is--why? Why did you want to write a story about a doctor, about evasive "gas," about pregnancy and death, about shopping lines and sweaters. Why was this story important to you?

I'm also writing a story about twins...(it's in the Other Fiction somewhere). It's cool that we have the same idea, isn't it? My twins are named Manizha (after a friend of a friend) and Gabby. One's a cokehead who's been raped, one is mad OCD and in love with her German teacher. You see how I have definite agendas for them? I have a reason for their existance, I have ideas that I'm trying to (albeit, subtly) get across. I'm being stealth about it, but I'm making a point. What point are you trying to make?

To whom are you speaking?

And why should I care? You have yet to give me a really good reason to care. Believe me--I think you're a doll, and I'm looking for one. :D

Post more. What I want to see is purpose, clarity, focus. I don't want to see the shifts in time or the grammar issues. :) What I want to see is you, expanding on your ideas. I want to see you writing with purpose.

I have the utmost of confidence in you. So far, you're doing everything right, as far as this website goes. I'm glad that you're here and looking forward to more.

--Misty




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 516
Hey.

I loved the story. The plot was very interesting, but there are a few mistakes I can point out.

You change tenses a lot. It makes the story confusing when it goes from past to present back to past, quickly to future and back to past. Also, I got a little mixed up with the flashbacks. Perphaps when you begin you should have it in italics, when they met in bold and normal for the babies being born. I don't know, they're just some suggestions.

I liked the bit with Marylin loving the Doctor, but you should extend it a little. Tell us more about how she felt when she found out he was getting married. How emotinally crushing it must have been for her.

You never said exactly what was wrong with the little girl. Perphaps it's just my lack of medical knowledge, but I really didn't understand why she was so frail. People are born with extra fingers and toes all the time, why is this one so bad?

Apart from those things, it was good. Mistakes are all part of life, and this site will do wonders for your writing. Trust me, mine's improved drammatically in the few months I've been on the site.
*Don't expect to see me around much in the next couple of weeks. School has started again, and it'll be a couple of weeks before I've settled in. If you've asked me for a critique, you will get it, but not for a little while. Sorry*




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 47
thanks kitty, misty and chocoholic for the crtique and comments, they are greatly appreciated. :D
and chocoholic, i didn't want to elaborate on the baby's illness as I didn't want to give away the plot. but since you asked... the little girl had Down Syndrome.
gosh, looking at it now, it really seems that i made a lot of mistakes.
i will correct them and post it again.
thanks for everything!
'follow the notes upon a journey,
at first sight marks one's destiny.
when the voyage comes to an end,
return lies within hasty keys.'




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7715
Reviews 522
I liked this, but found it very confusing. You keep switching back and forth from samuel, to dr. rees, to other characters. The actual story line was good, I liked the ending. :)
I would suggest spacing it out more, but other than that I don't have any comments other than the ones already pointed out.



i don't want to pass up an opportunity to be authentic for the opportunity to be profound
— soundofmind