Young Writers Society

Those books are awesome! Lol! I give them 9 out of 10 because some of the parts got boring.

I've never read them, but the fact someone told me part of the dialogue went like this -- "Sorry," [character] apologised, has put me off forever.

That's just ridiculous.

You're my new best friend Macky!!!

I've read Eragon and Eldest and I share the same opinion!! Can't, really, wait for the third and last book.

I Just Read ERAGON and ELDEST!

You poor soul. I can only imagine what effect the most cliched books in history can have on a person's psyche.

Prokaryote

WARNING the movie Eragon is totally different from the book.

If you don't count the fact that they are total rip-offs of LOTR, Star Wars, and a buch of other books they really aren't all that bad. They are very simply written and easy to read, which some people like. In my opinion, they lack character development and depth in general. Eldest is a bit better in those subjects, but it is far too long and quite boring towards the middle. Honestly I prefered Eragon because it was a lot less boring. How well they sold just goes to show you what a big difference good marketing makes. They're not terrible books, but i'm not a fan.

These books are mostly crap. While they can be interesting, I can't believe he was allowed to publish them when they are totally plagiarizing Tolkien and Terry Brooks and the like!

Macky wrote:Those books are awesome! Lol! I give them 9 out of 10 because some of the parts got boring.

I'm so sorry for you. We've lost you to the literary scourge that is: Inheritance.

Maybe you should read the other Eragon thread. I think it's five pages of bashing posts, it should give you some things to think about.

Firestarter wrote:I've never read them, but the fact someone told me part of the dialogue went like this -- "Sorry," [character] apologised, has put me off forever.

Don't forget:

"The young man was young."
~Eldest

"The young man was young."

Hah hah, is that an actual line? XD

Also, I seem to recall someone quoting something along the lines of, "You're name is unique. Only a few people in the world have it." Not exactly unique then, is it?

BrokenSword wrote:

Firestarter wrote:I've never read them, but the fact someone told me part of the dialogue went like this -- "Sorry," [character] apologised, has put me off forever.

Don't forget:

"The young man was young."
~Eldest

:face/palm:

For the love of....

La, if you want some decent fiction, look around here plenty too be found.

But Inheritance is just hideous.

The young man was young. Lol. Too funny.

Underneath all the ripping-off is an okay book. I'm not a big fan of Inheritance, but the first book was okay. The second book, not so much. Way too boring, and predictable, apart from the end.