This sentence had some beauty, but it just seemed long to me. Even if I ignore the length, it seems awkwardly phrased to me.It seemed that time did not exist in that forest, or if it did, it went so slowly that if one waited a hundred years within it one would not have grown a minute older by the time one left it.
The Opening Paragraph:No doubt it was well executed, and I liked reading it very much. The way you switched on the speakers or the thoughts was commendable and it would be my bad if I forget to mention the novelty this idea had. It was a good job done, and thumbs for it!
Prologue:The prologue introduces us to your exuberant vocabulary and I really liked reading some words that you used. I liked how you blend them into simple sentences, and used them appropriately. I am really not very fond of a lot of action, but it somehow looked good. But on the other thoughts, I think that this part looked sometimes repetitive and till the end I was almost like-"Okay, I get it. She's gonna die." I do understand that you needed to elaborate on every details, on every action, but don't you think that sometimes many readers don't like reading too much. I think it's just your writing style and if somebody doesn't like reading so into-depth, then they can not read it. Simple as that. But I must commend you on your beautiful vocabulary. It was really splendid.
Chapter-1: The first part was nice, Ignis! The thing where the father forces the girl to come down was nice, and actually a bit sweet. But my main problem here was that some of the dialog here were quite humorous and the father didn't attempt to make them to really or actually scare the girl, but he was joking and being a stern one at the same side. But I didn't get this from the expressions they had. What I mean by this is that you should have told us more how they react by their facial expressions. I want to know what's more to them. In the beginning the father looked too stern and at a point I felt that he was not her well-wiser but someone really cruel. That might be because he was very brutal in his words as I may say. I know I have confused a lot but that was my take on it so far. You can ask me through PMs what I really meant, I maybe able to express myself better than.
Other than this my other critique would be that when her mother(Morgan's) scolds her in this chapter at first, I know she is very worried and very angry at her daughter. But what I don't come to know here is that what character she is. Of course if she is a mother, she can't be brutal to her own kid, but I wanted to know more in detail how her voice sounded or how she stood. I would really like to know except for her words, how she actually sounded. How she behaved physically.
Although there were many beautiful phrases, words and descriptions I liked, I was particulry overwhelmed by this one. You deserve a kudo!She loved the feeling – it was like warm water seeping through her skin, into her very core, and soaking her in its soft presence.
Now this was something weird. Even if the family is dying of hunger, I don't suspect there would be a child with only one pair of clothes. At least make it two. Something she might be wearing to church or special events. And doesn't the clothes get a wash? So what does she wear then? Or is it that you want to tell that this dress is for going out or playing and stuff? If so, just mention it. It seems awkward otherwise.No matter what she might be wearing – although she had only one piece of clothing – she could not be seen when up a tree.
I am liking how you're putting the parts of the poem in the lines here and there, as if she is connecting the dots. But it would look better if you could just italicize it.“Morgan, are you all right?” His voice seemed to be fading. “Morgan, what is wrong?” Fading into the distance …
To be honest, many of them didn't like the beginning of the chapter with a dialog but for me, simple and sweet dialog are the sweetest openers to any story. And here, it was very much needed. Although many of the people don't read prologues, but if they do, a start from the dialog would be a relief from the long, action-filled prologue you had. So most of the beginning with the dialog really did to ease down my mind a bit and get ready for a thorough review.
Her mother?Honestly speaking, her mother sometimes puzzled me. She was sometimes too strict, but then I guess some of them are. What I saw of her in the start was that she was a strict lady with a bit of short temper. Nothing weird about that, I swear. But I was confused when she told everything to her daughter about her woods' strange visit without any hesitation. The impression of the lady I had in mind didn't seem to be someone who would tell something so strange so instantly. Some scoldings and some resistance from her daughter should have made her open her mouth. Moreover so, because parents don't seem to be too pleasant about the thought of introducing their children to things which can't be explained or are strange. Don't you think? That is my take, honestly.
Other thing which is not a nitpick exactly is that you should be very careful with the dialog. I am not saying this because I have found some fault here, but because I believe that this isn't what you might be using in your daily life, and it's a particular accent her mother uses, so you should be thorough with your research in it. Something weird would be that why is it that only her mother speaks this accent and other two have a perfect English English accent? Other thing is what others have definitely told you a lot about: MCs' age. In the beginning and until her second visit on the tree she did seem to me like a seven or eight year old. But from the way she deciphered the meaning of the coded messages strangers were talking of, she seemed quite mature, obviously until she is not a prodigy child. While inquiring her mother and connecting the dots, she seemed very mature again. So the whole confusion is about the age. Her passion for trees and the way she seemed cheerful on it made me think she was a kid. So I am confused.
All nit-picks apart, I really think this has huge potential and it would be a very good piece after you've taken in consideration all the points we had to give. I really x10 liked the phrases you used, the words you took in, etc. They were really enchanting and honestly telling, I did learn some new words, so thanks to you, Ignis!
PM me for any queries. And happy time writing. ^-^
~Shubhi
Gender:
Points: 58538
Reviews: 553