I think the former is better.
You are just random smithy guy coming along with the knights because you want to escape whatever you wanted to and one day, you saw a big interesting poster on a wall and that was some kind of what scarlett wrote here and you just thought the poster offer is really nice and joined our party because you are short on money and need to do some good-paid job that exactly like that poster is offering.
Or you just got transferred in my party because of no reason, (your former knight kicked you out maybe?).
Spoiler! :
Gender:
Points: 3187
Reviews: 173