z

Young Writers Society


Summer at Grandmas 1



User avatar
270 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1373
Reviews: 270
Sun Jan 13, 2008 9:56 pm
Alice says...



This is the first part to my five or six part novella, I really would like some advice on how well I did Riley's thoughts and how I did to explain how he's feeling, and then general comments would be really helpful.

* * *

Riley laid back on his bed staring up at the ceiling. Like they did every day, his thoughts drifted back to her. Was she happy now? Was she with somebody better? Did she know that he still loved her? An image of her sitting on her coffee table-a place they so often liked to sit-eating pizza with Connor.

Connor. He shuddered at the name; he knew if she was gonna be with anyone, it would be him.

“Riley James!” his mother shrieked. “Stop sulking and get down here!”

He groaned and rolled out of bed slowly meandering down the stairs to the kitchen the source of his mother’s shriek. “Yeah Ma?” he asked, pretending to be tired.

“You’ve got to stop sulking,” she ordered.

“Not like I can help it,” he retorted.

“You’re just not trying. But that’s why I brought you down here.”

He groaned and walked into the living-room.

“Riley! Get back here!”

He ignored her. Sadly, she followed him in her high-heeled cow-boy boots and blue dress. Couldn't she act more like somebody from New York? No, not his mom with her curly brown hair and intense green eyes.

“Riley, your grandmother called.”

Oh god no! He thought scornfully I hate going to her house! He knew the only reason his grandmother would call would be to insist that one of them visited her on her huge hill two hundred somethin miles away. “I’m not going up there.” He flopped down on the couch and rolled away from her, staring intently into the green of the sofa that made a strange contrast to his own blue ones.

“Yes you are. your cousin Amanda will be there and she’s bringing one of her friends.”

“I’m definitely not going up there!” Not that he wouldn't mind seeing Amanda though, she just always had an awful taste in friends. His mother grabbed his ear and painfully yanked. Witch! he thought ruefully to his mother as she pulled him into a sitting position.

“That was mean,” he said, rubbing his sore ear.

“You’re going up there,” she handed him a train ticket. “You’re meeting your cousin and her friend at the station in three hours.”

He groaned and dropped the ticket on the floor. “Mom!” he pleaded. “Don’t make me go!” He laid back again and put the pillow over his face. She ripped it off and threw it over to the chair.

"Riley James!" she scolded. "Get your ass up and go pack your bags!"

Grumbling, he stood up and stormed off to his room. Grabbing his duffel bag he shoved in a layer of clothes, his lap-top, another layer of clothes, his music junk-his gutiar music, his Ipod, his USB cords and his CDS- another layer of clothes, and then finally, his books.

“Why are you bringing your books? It’s the middle of summer. You’re not going to have time to do any reading,” his mother stated.

“Gives me a reason to avoid people.”

“You can drive now. Not like you’re going to be spending the whole time cooped up in that house. Ma’s got a truck that she never uses.”

He slung the bag over his shoulder and started down the stairs, “How long are you condemning me to that hell?”

“Riley watch your mouth!” He rolled his eyes and repeated his question. “For six weeks…”

His eyes widened in horror. “Six weeks? Why six weeks?”

“That’s how long ma’ wanted you to come.”

He leaned against the wall and banged his head against it a few times, No, no, no, this could [i]not be happening! First I lose my girlfriend and then I lose my summer vacation?[/i] Without saying another word he went outside, threw his bag in the back seat and got in the front passenger seat. He immediately turned the radio all the way up to drown out the rest of the world. He closed his eyes and pictured Claire’s face in his mind. Her beautiful lucious brown hair swaying in the wind as they sat on top of the bridge, their feet hanging over the edge, and her beautiful brown eyes the same shade as her hair. Claire he thought. I will always love you. He only wished that she loved him too.

The only bright spot on this trip was being able to see his cousin, Amanda, again-the tomboy of a girl-he spent most of his childhood with. He’d bet anything that they’d still have a thousand things to talk about and do. And the car. The car offered him some excape.
Last edited by Alice on Thu Jan 17, 2008 1:33 am, edited 5 times in total.
I just lost the game.
  





User avatar
44 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 1040
Reviews: 44
Sun Jan 13, 2008 10:21 pm
MADD94 says...



wow really nice, i love it i can totally feel the build up of a great story, pm me when you have part two
Some people call me the space cowboy
  





User avatar
1464 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Female
Points: 83957
Reviews: 1464
Sun Jan 13, 2008 11:56 pm
JabberHut says...



Hey, Alice! Thanks for tearing up my horrible chapter 1. :wink: It sooo needed and I will post the rewrite very soon. However, in return for that never-ending critique, I shall look at yours. :twisted:

Btw, like you, I crit grammar and shtuff as I read the first time through. ^^

Riley [s]sat[/s] laid on his bed, staring up at the ceiling. Like they did every day, his thoughts drifted back to her. Was she happy now? Was she with somebody better [maybe?]? Did she know that he still loved her? An image of her sitting on her coffee table--a place they so often liked to sit--eating pizza with Connor.


Connor . [s]he[/s] He shuddered at the name, but he knew if she was gonna be there with anybody, it would be him [s]of all people[/s] [You already said if "she would be there with anybody"].


He groaned and rolled out of bed, slowly [s]going[/s] walking [or another word?] down the stairs to the kitchen, the source of his mother’s shriek. “Yeah ma?” he asked, pretending to be tired.


“You’ve got to stop sulking,” she ordered.

“Not like I can help it,” he retorted.

“You’re just not trying. But that’s why I brought you down here.”

He groaned and walked into the living-room.

“Riley! Get back here!”

[s]He ignored her, sadly, she followed him.[/s] He ignored her. Sadly, she followed him.

“Riley, your grandmother called.”


This whole part is pure dialogue with simple tags at the end. This is a wonderful chance to tell us what the mom looks like, if the kitchen is messy....earlier, you could've stated if Riley's hair was standing on end from laying on his bed or whatever. Novella's get appearance descriptions for their characters too. :wink:

[s]oh[/s] Oh god no! [s]He[/s] he thought scornfully, [This should be a period, not a comma. I hate going to her house! He knew the only reason his grandmother would call would be to insist that one of them [s]went up there[/s] visited her. “I’m not going up there.” He flopped down on the couch and rolled away from her


“Yes, you are, [This should be a period, not a comma] [s]your[/s] Your cousin, Amanda, will be there and she’s bringing one of her friends.”


“I’m [s]defiantly[/s] definitely not going up there!” She grabbed his ear and yanked. Witch! he thought ruefully to his mother as she painfully pulled him into a sitting position [s]by the most painful thing she could think to do[/s].


“That was mean,” he said, rubbing his sore ear.


“Mom!” he pleaded, “don’t make me go!”


Either:

1. "Mom," he pleaded, "don't make me go!"

2. "Mom!" he pleaded. "Don't make me go!"

The first one preferably. :wink:

“Riley James!” she scolded, “get your ass up and go pack your bags!”


Again, either:

1. "Riley James!" she scolded. "Get your ass up and go pack your bags!"

2. "Riley James," she scolded, "get your ass up and go pack your bags!"

The first one preferably...again. :wink: Such a horrible mother, btw. :shock:

Grumbling, he stood up and stormed off to his room.


Grabbing his duffel bag, he shoved in a layer of clothes, his [s]lap-top[/s] laptop, another layer of clothes, his music stuff [what kind of music stuff? A guitar? Piano music? Harmonica?], another layer of clothes, and [s]then[/s] ['Finally' or nothing at all. ^^] his books.


“Why are you bringing your books? It’s the middle of summer, [This should be a period] [s]you’re[/s] You're not going to have [s]any[/s] time to do any reading,” his mother stated.


“You can drive now, not like you’re going to be spending the whole time cooped up in that house, ma’s got a truck that she never uses.”


Replace both commas with periods. ^^

He slung the bag over his shoulder and started down the stairs in front of her [Er...him?], [Period, not a comma. ^^] “[s]how[/s] How long are you condemning me to that hell?”


“Riley, watch your mouth!” He rolled his eyes and repeated his question. “For six weeks…”


His eyes widened in horror, [Period, not a comma.] “[s]six[/s] Six weeks?! [Sounded more dramatic to me. :lol:] Why six weeks?”


“That’s how long ma’ wanted you to come.”


Have you been putting the apostrophe after 'ma' the entire time? I don't think that belongs there.

He leaned against the wall and banged his head against it a couple [Keep in mind that 'couple' means only twice] times, [Period, not a comma] [s]no[/s] No, no, no, no, no, [Only three no's will do the trick. Excess no's gets annoying.] this could not be happening! First I lose my girlfriend and then I [s]loses[/s] lose my summer vacation?


Without saying another word, he went outside, threw his bag in the back seat, and got in the [s]front[/s] driver's seat [maybe?].


What kind of car does he drive? Good time to show his vehicle. Cars tell a lot about character. :D

He Immediately [s]turning[/s] turned the radio all the way up to drown out the rest of the world.


He closed his eyes and pictured Claire’s face in his mind, [Period, not a comma] Claire, he thought. I will always love you.


The only bright spot on this trip was being able to see his cousin, Amanda, again, [Use a double dash (--)] the tomboy of a girl who he spent most of his childhood with. He’d bet anything that they’d still have a thousand things to talk about and do. And the car.


Wait, wait, wait...Why didn't he want to go with Amanda earlier? He seemed to especially not want to go when his mom mentioned Amanda. Was it her friend? Explain this.

The last part was confusing. ...talk about and do. And the car.[/b] Er...huh? Was something going on between the two? Lol, that may sound ridiculous, but this sounds really awkward. Maybe it will all make sense later, but...I'm not too sure what to think about this.

Overall, that's an evil family, lol. I wanted to punch the mom. [i]Give him a break, lady!
Lol.

You did well with Riley's thoughts and feelings. It's obvious he's depressed about losing his girlfriend and I felt even worse when his mom made him go to his grandma's. Good job with that.

However, I have no idea what either of them look like. Maybe an image of Claire could appear in his mind to? That would hurt if you can tie that in as well. My characters in my head were pretty much in a blank area. Are they city dwellers (I'm assuming because of the train) or are they country folk? (That's what I pictured in my head)

Besides clearing up the ending sentence and the grammar, pretty good. :D You got something going here, I'll say. I would be honored if you PMed me the next part. :wink: Of course, if you don't want me to crit it, that's understandable, lol. If you want to complain about this long crit, then you can PM me. If you want to punch me for it...I prefer PM. :P

Keep writing!

Jabber, the One and Only!
I make my own policies.
  





User avatar
7 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 7
Mon Jan 14, 2008 5:15 pm
Rory Lewis says...



Hey Nice start. Although I really can't picture what Riley, his mom and Claire look like.
Its a great start and I think you have potential for a great story.

~Rory~
LOVEISLIKEWAR
E A S Y TO BEGIN
H A R D TO END
IMPOSSIBLE TO F O R G E T
- - - >> [ ♥ ] << - - -
  





User avatar
270 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1373
Reviews: 270
Tue Jan 15, 2008 2:14 am
Alice says...



Edited!
I just lost the game.
  





User avatar
29 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 890
Reviews: 29
Tue Jan 15, 2008 2:59 am
DoctorClicky says...



“Yes you are. your cousin Amanda will be there and she’s bringing one of her friends.”

“I’m definitely not going up there!” Not that he wouldn't mind seeing Amanda though, she just always had a awful taste in friends.


* "Your" should be capatilized.

* I don't quite understand this sentence. I think there should be a comma between Amanda and though and "an" instead of "a" before awful.

“Riley watch your mouth!” He rolled his eyes and repeated his question. “For six weeks…”


* I don't find it too believable that a mother would be mad at her son for saying "hell" when she herself just said "fuck"... ?

Her beautiful lucious brown hair swaying in the wind as they sat on top of the bridge(,) their feet hanging over the edge


* There should be a comma where I put one in ().

The only bright spot on this trip was being able to see his cousin, Amanda, again-the tomboy of a girl who he spent most of his childhood with. He’d bet anything that they’d still have a thousand things to talk about and do. And the car.


* You say "again-the tombay" when you hadn't told us before any of what you tell us now.

* "And the car." ... ??? I don't understand that sentence. To talk about the car? To use the car?


Overall, very good. Keep it up. I'll be happy to edit the other parts for you!! ^_^
  





User avatar
713 Reviews



Gender: Male
Points: 7740
Reviews: 713
Thu Jan 17, 2008 1:21 am
BigBadBear says...



I haven't looked at the other critiques yet so sorry for repeating anything.

Like they did every day, his thoughts drifted back to her.


Comma between day and his.

Connor . He shuddered


Period after Conner.

He shuddered at the name but he knew if she was gonna be there with anybody it would be him.


This is extremely awkward and hard to read. I had to read it three times to understand what it said. Consider:
He shuddered at the name; he knew if she was gonna be with anyone, it would be him.

Yeah ma?” he asked, pretending to be tired.


ma should be capitalized. Ma.

I hate going to her house!


Hate doesn't have to be bolded. In fact, nothing should ever be bolded in regular books. So don't bold.

“how long are you condemning me


How should be capitalized.

“Riley watch your mouth!”


What a hypocrite! She just cussed at him a few lines up. Either change that or leave it, unless it's the mom's personality.

No, no, no, this could not be


Again with the bolding. If you want to emphisize something in italics, unitalicized it. Like this:

No, no, no, this could not be...

This was good. The dialogue wasn't half bad, but it was really rushed. Slow down. Make us feel for Riley. Right now we don't really care about him.

Continue please!

BBB
Just write -- the rest of life will follow.

Would love help on this.
  





User avatar
7 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 7
Thu Jan 17, 2008 9:41 pm
Kick_the_sky504 says...



Wow! I love it. But I do agree with Rory. I can't really tell what the carries look like. But I really do like it and I think a nice story will come out of it. Please pm me when you post the next one.
  








"Be yourself" is not advice. It's an existential crisis waiting to happen.
— Hank Green