The words didn't register right away. It seemed to slowly sink in, and her body seemed to hear and register it first than her brain, because even without blinking, her eyes were gushing out tears that streamed down her face.
Evaline lifted his hand up to her chest and leaned in to prop her forehead on his shoulder to use as support, hoping he didn't mind that she was wetting his shirt with tears and snot. James embraced her with his one arm, pulling her close.
She didn't even know what to say. She was at a loss of words.
But one thing did come to mind.
"I love you too," she whispered as she cried in his arms.
James hugged her a little tighter as he let her cry in peace, comforting her as her sniffs and cries filled the silence.
She didn't know what came over her. She wasn't sad; these weren't happy tears. It couldn't be, hearing what James just said.
She couldn't even name the emotion that swirled and ballooned in her chest, filling her entire body with warmth as it pushed away her insecurities.
Was this what love was?
There were worries at the back of her head. Worries that she'd let her time powers control her emotions better than she would be able to control it, and worries that it would affect her future. Their future. She knew it would; it was just a matter of when.
She was always thinking of the future. But for now, with James, she just wanted to live and appreciate the present moment.
"So much," she finished with a heavy breath after a long silence, squeezing his hand again and then gripping his shirt with her shaky free hand to steady herself.
James rubbed her back with his hand gently and rhythmically.
"You okay?" he asked softly.
"Yes," Evaline said with a sniff, perching her chin on his shoulder as she leaned close to him. "More than okay. Thank you."
"You are most welcome," he said, still patting her back.
James seemed to give her a few long moments to collect herself as he held her, letting her sniffs and tears subside as they sat in silence together by the fire. After her breathing had steadied, he finally broke the silence.
"So..." he started, slightly pulling away. "I got a little sidetracked from what happened in Nye, before we parted. But I'm glad that went the direction it did. Do you want to continue talking about it?"
After a hesitation, Evaline also pulled away and wiped her face as she looked up at him. It seemed that whatever they were about to talk about next wasn't going to be as heavy as she thought it'd be after what just happened. She nodded for a few seconds.
"Okay," she simply said.
James nodded, and there was another small pause before he continued.
"When we regrouped," he said. "After Butch and Reed were no longer a threat. That was where I left off."
He looked up at her, like he was making sure she was following. She was, but she wanted to wait to hear what he had to say first. He nodded, as if to himself, and looked down.
"I noticed something was off with you," James said. "I asked you how many times you went back, and you never answered. Instead, you said that you wanted to go back to earth. I was insistent that we waited until you'd recovered from going back so many times before we talked about you going back. I wanted to be sure you were in your right mind and that it was really what you wanted. I wanted to wait until you could feel again."
He paused, and took a deep breath.
"When I told you no... you resorted to threats," he said slowly, and solemnly. "You shot at Elliot, spooking him, and he stumbled, falling down into the river. When you pointed the gun back at me... I broke my promise. And I wished you home."
With every passing word, Evaline gripped his hand and shirt a little tighter, feeling smaller and smaller. She knew she wasn't proud of what she did, but hearing it from James's perspective hurt, because the entire situation hurt.
"I'm sorry," she said quietly despite him already saying that he forgave her. "I'm sorry."
"I know," James said quietly. "You were trying to protect both of us in the only way you knew how. By pushing me away. But you don't have to keep pushing me away anymore. I'm here, and I don't want to leave you."
"But what if it happens again?" she asked desperately. "What if I threaten you again? And push you away?"
"I will just have to push back," James said. "And be patient again."
"But what if I hurt you again?" she persisted. "What if all of this happens again?"
"Evaline, I do not believe that we are doomed to repeat the patterns of our past," James said. "You keep talking about it like it's inevitable. But maybe you only believe it to be so because you have yet to discover a different path."
Evaline was quiet for a moment as she closed her eyes and held him tighter again, like the tension was symbolizing her rising anxiety, and she didn't want to let go of him in fear of losing him.
"What would that path be?" she asked softly.
"I can't say for sure, since this is new territory for both of us," James said softly. "But maybe... it has to do with what we were talking about earlier. Learning to grieve. To love, to lose, to heal. And doing it together."
He paused, sticking his chin on her shoulder in return as he whispered softly in her ear.
"Maybe that's all the notes have ever been trying to say. That we don't have to go in it alone."
Warmth fluttered in her chest again at his words, and Evaline chose to believe it.
"Maybe you're right," she said. "Maybe that's all there is to it. But if there ever becomes a fate I cannot change with you -- should I do this all again? I can't bear to lose you, James."
James hugged her a little tighter, and then started to pull away. He kissed her gently on the cheek before he leaned back so that they could meet each others' eyes.
"My whole life has been full of fates that I couldn't change," he said softly. "But I've made it this far, with you. I think maybe that's a sign I'm supposed to be here."
He shifted his position so that they were holding hands again.
"As for you, my hope is that for whatever losses in life that inevitably come - because nothing lasts forever, as much as it hurts to say - is that you would draw on the strength of the ones you love who are around you to help you through it. So yes. You would have to do it all again. I think we have to do it all over again whenever we are in the face of a great loss. But today, I'm simply going to enjoy this moment with you."
Evaline watched him and noted the utmost sincerity behind his eyes and words. Choosing, again, to believe every word he was saying. Choosing, again, to give herself to him. Holding her heart out for him to take as he offered hers to return.
She only hoped that he wouldn't walk away with it, but she knew, deep down, despite only being partners again for days, he wouldn't leave her. Not now, or anytime soon. Not unless her intentions were tainted, and she knew it wouldn't be. Not for him.
"You always know what to say," she said quietly as she gazed at him with an aching longing. "I don't know how you do it."
James laughed weakly, and looked off to the side.
"I don't consider it too impressive," he said softly. "I think it's more important to be able to follow through with things we say than to just have the right words. That's always the hard part -- doing what you say you'll do."
"And you do both," Evaline said confidently. "It's impressive you do both. That's what I like about you."
James still kept his eyes on the ground, but she could see him flick his gaze over to her just for a second, as his face flushed just a little bit.
"...Thanks," he said softly.
"That hasn't changed," she continued offering a small, soft smile. "You were always like this to me. Always patient and kind, always knew what to say, always true to your word. I admire that of you."
"That's... a lot of things," James said with a quiet laugh that sounded a little nervous.
"Maybe," she said. "But I expect the list to grow the longer as time goes on, because I know you're not perfect either. You've somehow learned to love my flaws, and I want to learn to love yours. I already have, but I want to love it more."
James still wasn't looking up at her, avoiding eye contact as he seemed to shrink a little in discomfort.
"I've... always thought that no one would really want to love someone who can't even seem to love theirself," he said, barely audible.
Evaline arched her brows in empathy, rubbing the top of his hands with both her thumbs as she began to pour her full attention to him instead. She knew that he said all he expected of her was to just be there, but she wanted to do more than that. She wanted to comfort him too.
"It's a common phrase to hear that you can't love others unless you love yourself," she said gently. "But we know that's not true. You have so much love to give, James. And I don't want it all. I want to give some of it back to you, because you deserve it, too."
James dropped his chin down towards his chest and squeezed her hands just a little.
"I just... keep waiting for myself to actually believe that," James said quietly. "It's like I know it in my head, but my heart disagrees."
"You said the journey to healing involves other people," Evaline continued, squeezing back. "Maybe this isn't something you can believe by yourself. Maybe you need someone to help you believe it. You say that I don't need to do anything to earn your love, but I want to take the steps for you so that you can earn your own love. Would you let me do that?"
James let out a faint laugh, huffing air through his nose.
"I'm not even sure what that means or what that looks like," he said. "But... yes."
"Maybe it starts small," she suggested. "By talking about your positive traits that make you, you. The ones that I and others admire. Do you like that side of you? Would you like me to list them out for you?"
James let out another nervous laugh as he shook his head.
"I-- you don't have to do that," he said quickly.
Evaline did it anyways.
"I've already said that you're patient and kind," she said. "But that's an overused expression to describe someone. Everyone is patient and kind to some degree, but you, James..."
She paused, waiting for him to meet her eyes, even though he quickly looked away afterwards.
"You are ridiculous," she said in a playful voice instead when she noticed that he seemed to already have a hard time taking the compliments. "You are ridiculously patient. How many times have you prevented me from being angry or annoyed? How many times have you chosen to wait and provide space instead of lashing out too? Just a few weeks ago, I was being annoyed for no reason, and I'd take it out on you, but you patiently waited anyways. And you were kind. Despite me being mean. You've done this for so long. I don't know how you do it. It's so admirable, and two of your most defining traits."
James's face seemed to flush to a deeper red, and he continued to look to the side, at the ground.
"I... didn't know you noticed," he said quietly.
Evaline scoffed, but she smiled. "I noticed the first day we met each other," she said. "I figured you were always like this. You have prevented so many needless tantrums from me without even knowing it, because I kept it to myself when you somehow defused me."
James finally looked back up at her, meeting her eyes.
"Is that a good thing?" he asked, looking amused.
"Yes," she said with a soft, sincere smile. "Of course it is. Can you imagine a relationship where we yell at each other because neither of us were patient?"
"That sounds miserable," James said.
"But you're not like that," she continued. "And neither of us are miserable."
James smiled softly, and he was quiet for a moment as he met her eyes.
"You can be patient too, you know," he said with a small grin. "But... sometimes you've given me the push when I need it."
"And maybe that's just what you need," Evaline said. "Someone to push you to love yourself. Even if I have to literally push you into it."
"Maybe don't push me too hard, though," he said with a small smirk. "I'm still bruised all over."
Evaline pursed her lips as she glanced down at his chest, trying not to let the flashbacks of the torturous memory take up space in her mind and ruin this moment.
"Dark," she said at first as she tried to rally her own thoughts. "Although, I've noticed that you often use humor to deflect trauma."
James's smirk disappeared, but he cleared his throat and briefly met her eyes.
"Thank you," he said, sounding like he was still trying to do just that. Deflect with humor.
"I didn't say that was a good thing," she said with the same tone.
"But what I'm hearing is that you think I'm funny," James said.
Evaline slightly narrowed her eyes at him, noting that James was repressing a smirk.
"I, too, think torture is hilarious," she dead-panned.
Any signs of a smirk disappeared on his face, and James looked back to the ground.
"Does it really bother you that much?" he asked quietly.
"No," Evaline said quickly. "No. No, it doesn't bother me. I'm only pointing it out because... well, you say it's healthy to talk things out, right? We didn't really talk about... that. And I'd rather listen to your thoughts about it first than hear it from a joke."
James was quiet for a moment, and she noticed his eyes had drifted down to his journal. It'd shifted and closed with all of the hugging, but it still sat in his lap.
"I guess..." he started. "It's just easier to make flippant jokes about it, instead of reliving it again."
"I understand," she said gently. "It's hard. But you also once told me: 'how can we ever move on if we don't talk about it?' And I do want you to move on from this, someday."
She could feel James's hands fidgeting a little in her grip, like he was getting antsy to let go, but Evaline only held him more firmly.
"I don't know how to talk about it," he said suddenly, pressing his lips into a small pout.
"It's okay if you're not ready," Evaline said. "But whenever you are, we don't have to talk about it all at once. We can take it scar by scar. There's no rush. I don't want you to rush this. I know it hurts."
She could feel his tension in his hands, and she could see it in the way he held his shoulders stiffly. He nodded slightly in agreement.
"Okay," he said quietly.
"But just so you know, James," she continued, rubbing her thumbs over his hands again. "You are more than a person who has gone through so much pain, and have the scars to prove it. I like you for you, but being you includes your past experiences too. I like all of you, the good and the bad."
James closed his eyes for a moment, and she watched as he took in a very slow deep breath and let it out with a sigh.
"You are also worthy of love," she said. "My love, and from yourself too."
James looked down at their hands, and she could see the mix of emotions swirling in his eyes. Weariness and gratitude. Like he was really trying to let her words sink in, even if it was hard.
"You say you don't believe it," Evaline continued gently. "But I believe it. And maybe, for now, that's enough. I'll keep reminding you every day if I have to."
James looked up to meet her eyes, and though he was starting to look a little tired, he still seemed present, and genuine.
"Thank you, Eve," he said softly.
Evaline leaned in to quickly kiss him on the lips.
"You're welcome, James," she said with a warm smile. "I mean every word."
James was quiet for a moment as his gaze lingered on her face and he wore a small smile of his own.
"Well... we ended up talking about a lot more than dreams," he said with a small laugh.
"That's okay," she said as she lingered her own gaze on him for a moment before glancing back at the fire, and at Elliot. "We'll have a lot of time to talk. But... maybe for now, we can take a pause on it."
She looked back at him, noting that he looked more weary and tired than he usually did, and deciding to take initiative on it.
"We should rest. Do you want to sleep first?" she asked.
"If you feel like you can stay up," James said. "I am getting pretty tired, so yes."
"I can stay up," she said.
After a brief hesitation, she let go of his hands to get up on her feet and walked to the saddlebag on Elliot, pulling out both blankets before returning to him and offering both.
"It's a chilly night," she said. "Being warm and comfortable may help you sleep."
James looked up at her with a small smile.
"Aren't you cold, too?" he asked as he took one.
"It's okay," she said as she dropped the other blanket on top of him anyways. "I have a fire to sit in front of."
"If you get too cold, though," James said. "Let me know. Okay?"
"Okay," she said with a small smile and then sat in front of the fire as James got comfortable, bundling the blankets over him as he laid down next to her, curling up by the fire. She could hear Sleepy chirp somewhere under the blankets. The chicken was often in his pocket.
They both shared their good nights - a habit she wanted to keep pursuing with him - and Evaline was left by herself under the night sky. She was a little tired, but it was always hard for her to sleep after heavy conversations. There was a lot to unpack with what they both shared, and she needed some time to absorb it all.
An hour or two passed and Evaline noticed that it started to get windy. It wasn't enough to blow the fire out, but it did make the night chillier. She glanced at Elliot and almost got up to take out more clothes for layers, but James's words kept repeating in her head: "If you get too cold, let me know."
She didn't want to interrupt his sleep when he was sleeping so soundly this time, but at the same time...
Evaline quietly crawled up to him, taking slow steps to not make any noise, but it was still difficult being completely silent. She knew he was a light sleeper.
She saw his head move, and he hummed lowly.
"Everything okay?" he mumbled.
For a second she kneeled in front of him, but then wordlessly lifted the edges of the blankets and wormed her way in so they would both be sharing it. Facing the same way, she snuggled close to James since they had limited room, and she was relieved when he wrapped his arm around her, bringing her closer.
"Yeah," she said quietly as she felt his warm breath behind her neck. "Everything's okay."
"Cold?" he asked quietly. He sounded half awake.
"Not anymore," she said. "I can still stay up. I'm sorry I woke you."
"It's okay," he said in a whisper. "Just wake me when... you know."
His sentence seemed to drop into a mutter, like he was drifting off.
"I will," Evaline whispered back, clutching the blankets they shared a little tighter.
She waited a few long minutes, and she could hear and feel James's breathing steady back to sleep.
Even though they were in the ungoverned lands, and she was vulnerable in his arms while he slept, this was the safest she had felt in a long time.
Gender:
Points: 10085
Reviews: 147