The Secret

9 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 7
Ok. This is my first bit of writing in a long time and i hope it is up to standards for here so enjoy it and don't worry about beign to rough on critiquing.

It was coming. Just like it always did. It always came on the same day at the same time of the day.
I shrank back into a corner of my little cell. Having the knowledge that it was coming and not being able to do anything about it was mind numbing.

It was coming and there was nothing I could do about it.

In the distance I heard a door close. They were getting closer. I had two men assigned to me. Once a week they were to do anything they could to me in order to get me to give them what their boss wanted. They didn’t even know what they were torturing me for. All they knew was when I told them I was ready to give in I was to be brought to their master immediately.

The door to my cell was suddenly opened. After a week of the single sickly torch lit confines of my cell the sunlight streaming through the window by the door blinded me. As I regained my sight I saw I had a new visitor. He was tall and wore a long robe with a hood.

“Rise.”

The order came from one of the regular men. His voice was flat and authoritative. I was on my feet before I realized.

“Do not move unless told to.”

This came from the other regular. His voice always had a hint of a laugh in it as if he found it amusing to torture me. It is likely that he did. The stranger pulled a candle out of his robe and lit it from the small torch in the wall.

“Leave us. I need to speak to him.”

His voice was light, which surprised me. Most men of this area had deeper voices. When he spoke he did not look up. He kept his hood on and as had his head slightly bent forward so one could see the upper part of his face. The men obeyed without question and quickly shut the door behind them. I was alone in my cell with this strange man. My mind swam with questions. Who was he? What did he want to talk to me about? I did not have to wait long to find out.

“What is your name boy?”

“Tharin sir.”

“After the first of your kind. It is a good name.”

I was shocked. Few outside of my race knew our tales and history. This man would have had to travel to my people’s lands to learn such tales and that was nearly impossible for any human to do.

“Tell me. How long have you been held captive?”

“Five years sir.”

His body stiffened and he almost looked up at me, but stayed himself before he did. He had still not shown his upper face.

“Five years?! You have truly lived up to the standards of your kind. I a impressed by your physical strength, but do you have the mental strength to back it up? How close are you to telling them your secret?”

My previous shock turned to fear. As few humans there were that knew our history was a great number compared to those that knew about our secrets. Every one of my people had one. No one ever asked or told their secret. Keeping it to yourself was the best way to stay alive. If another knew your secret then you would no longer be necessary to the people. It took all the secrets combined to lead the way to the Savior. The Savior, the one thing that once saved all the races from annihilation. That was many years ago though, so no one knows who or what the Savior is. My people all realize the danger it could possibly be, but the few humans who don’t think it is just a myth believe it can be used as a way to make them more powerful. They look for anyone that has the shining eyes, one of the more prominent features of my people. Our eyes shine as if they have a light behind them. It heightens our sight but also marks us out from humans. It is a curse and a blessing.

“How do you know about the secret?”

The stranger smirked and looked up. His eyes were shining and he said what I had dreamed of hearing ever since my captivity began.

“Because I am one of your people, the Elves. I am here to rescue you.”




Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 1990
Reviews 254
It was coming. Just like it always did. It always came on the same day at the same time of the day.
I shrank back into a corner of my little cell. Having the knowledge that it was coming and not being able to do anything about it was mind numbing.

It was coming and there was nothing I could do about it.

The repetition of "coming" daunts the effectiveness of this opening paragraph. Try to use it less.

Now, when I look at this opening, I see a good opening that was wasted. "It was coming" is a great way to begin your story. The thing is, to truly make it hit home, you need it to stand out, to really strike that note. I'd suggest getting rid of the entire first paragraph, only keeping "it was coming." So it would be something like.

It was coming.
I shrank back into a corner of my little cell. Having the knowledge that it was almost here and not being able to do anything about it was mind numbing.

See how more powerful it is when "it was coming" stands alone? Also, I'd personally change "mind numbing" to something else. Maybe "terrifying" or something.
After a week of the single sickly torch lit confines of my cell the sunlight streaming through the window by the door blinded me.

This sentence feels a little clumsy. Try messing around with it to find what works.

He kept his hood on and as had his head slightly bent forward so one could see

Get rid of "as".

What is your name boy?”

Comma after "name".

“Tharin sir.”

Comma after "Tharin". I think two examples of this will be enough. I'll let you find the rest.

“Tell me. How long have you been held captive?”

“Five years sir.”

How did he know how long it's been? Most prisoners loose track. If he kept track on the wall with scratch marks, then you should show it.

My previous shock turned to fear. As few humans there were that knew our history was a great number compared to those that knew about our secrets. Every one of my people had one. No one ever asked or told their secret. Keeping it to yourself was the best way to stay alive. If another knew your secret then you would no longer be necessary to the people. It took all the secrets combined to lead the way to the Savior. The Savior, the one thing that once saved all the races from annihilation. That was many years ago though, so no one knows who or what the Savior is. My people all realize the danger it could possibly be, but the few humans who don’t think it is just a myth believe it can be used as a way to make them more powerful. They look for anyone that has the shining eyes, one of the more prominent features of my people. Our eyes shine as if they have a light behind them. It heightens our sight but also marks us out from humans. It is a curse and a blessing.

This is a big info dump. You should introduce this to us slowly later in dialogue and such. I mean this could be a very interesting thing for the reader to learn later on. There's no curiosity built up yet. You've just told us they have a secret, and then you go and tell us right away what it's for. Whey not make us wonder? It would make us too curious to stop reading.

Very interesting concept, though. I like it.

“How do you know about the secret?”

You just said that humans hunted them down to find out their secrets. So wouldn't it be normal for the human to know about the secrets?

Overall this was pretty good. I really like this concept of each person having their own secret. Other than what I've said, there's not much else other than I'd suggest creating your own race as opposed to using elves. Personally, elves are a turn off for me. When you said they were elves, all my assumptions of them return, a boiling pot of what I've read from Eragon, Lord of the Rings, and even Santa's work shop. The Elf thing has just been done so much before that it looses it's originality.

This may simply be a personal preference, but I think this story could greatly benefit if you took it upon yourself to create your own race with their own distinctive features rather than use the elves.

Oh, and just as a side note, I think you need to try and make your character have a bit more personality. I'm not saying your character isn't great, I'm just saying he's a little bit unrealistic for a five year prisoner. Sure, he's fearful, but at the same time, shouldn't there be a rage slowly building up inside him? Shouldn't he be hardened and angry? Maybe you could even have the elves be a race that always keeps their emotions, such as anger, in check, and he can be considered different, or an outcast, because he hates. Or whatever you want. These are just suggestions.

Well, that's everything. Good luck with this. I really enjoyed it.
Trying to get to heaven without Jesus is like climbing to the summit of Mount Everest naked. You die before it happens.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4209
Reviews 389
I agree with mike; the fact that you're using elves is a turn off; people use them so much, it's.. kind of sad. I think you can create your own race. Are these creatures beautiful, are they rugged- used to living in mountains, or terrible cold? Are they inventive, or do they stick to the old ways? Is the term "elf" a nickname from the humans, or is it short for something else? If you want to keep the elf idea, try putting a twist on it; the Savior idea is a good start, and the light/secret ideas as well. Hold off on telling us he's an elf until like... the middle of the story; that way we'll know your character and not the stereotype.

I also suggest that you lengthen this out; add more suspense. What is your character thinking? Why is he a prisoner? Why is this elf willing to help him? Details. :)

If you need anything, PM me. :)


*Seraph*
:smt051
"How grateful we are that the heavens are indeed open, that the gospel of Jesus Christ has been restored, and that the Church is founded on the rock of revelation. We are a blessed people, with apostles and prophets upon the earth today."~ Thomas S. Monson




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6337
Reviews 39
Hello... Katie here~



Alright, first things first:


In the distance I heard a door close. They were getting closer. I had two men assigned to me.




Redundancy is unsightly. Try, "They were closing in" or "They were coming near", etcetera, etcetera. In this case, you have many choices. Why go for the plain choice? Pimp up the suspense. ;)



The door to my cell was suddenly opened. After a week of the single sickly torch lit confines of my cell the sunlight streaming through the window by the door blinded me. As I regained my sight I saw I had a new visitor. He was tall and wore a long robe with a hood.






The second sentence, mind you. I didn't understand. Try to prevent yourself from giving us vague facts. It's like a thread of nonsense, that sentence. Revise, please~




And like I always say, please, please pleaaaase give us details. "He was tall and he wore a long robe" isn't satisfying at all. What did he look like, aside from that? Does he have antennas, protruding teeth, and alien eyes? Don't leave it ALL to our imagination. Give us something to imagine, perhaps: "The tall man wore a long, winding robe with its hood partly hiding his sober patrician features; his deep, dark eyes staring right through my very being..." Or something like that. Details, please. Or else I'll bite you. Rawr. :P






“Do not move unless told to.”





Umm... "Do not move unless you are told to do so" sounds better for me... :|






His body stiffened and he almost looked up at me, but stayed himself before he did. He had still not shown his upper face.





"...but stayed himself before he did." Hmmm.... Don't you mean 'steadied'? Or, if you will, try: "His body stiffened, and he almost revealed the rest of his face to me. He steadied himself." And oh, why would the tall man look up? Is the main character taller than him, or is he aloft? Detaiiiils~




My people all realize the danger it could possibly be, but the few humans who don’t think it is just a myth believe it can be used as a way to make them more powerful.






Refrain from using 'don't'. Use 'didn't', instead. Haha, I was also reminded of that when my own work was reviewed... I didn't think I could return the remark so immediately. :wink:







The stranger smirked and looked up. His eyes were shining and he said what I had dreamed of hearing ever since my captivity began.







Not 'smirked'. Give emphasis. Give me more than that. Tell me in more than one word how he had shown his insolent smile to the character. And then: "His eyes shone as he told me what I had longed to hear ever since I was held captive."




Better, no?





Aside from a few misplaced (and missing) commas, it's a nice installment. Keep it up, kiddo. :wink:
"A fish bit my hand this morning, and everything became trippy. Now with this coke and this cherry, I can beautifully rule the world!"

-Dino, @ Dino and Cake's Adventures in La-La Land (Coming Soon)

PS: "Alice in Wonderland" obsessed? You bet.




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 5973
Reviews 23




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1449
Reviews 11
Hey I don’t know what to say it seems they pretty much covered it. But, I disagree with one thing that has been said.
I know elves are a very, very, over-used species; still what you could do to make them your own is limitless. You might even have people thinking of your elves when they think of elves. Much easier than making a whole new race. With a new race you have to do so much more than just give them a name, and a look. To make them believable to me they have to have history, leaders, everything that makes up a race. But, if this is what you would like to do it seems you have a very good start, very original thinking. I am just saying, people like reading about stuff that they have heard about, or I do think that anyhow. I mean, can you think of one book that’s made it to the best sellers on a completely fabricated race? I can’t. I think it’s because in the back of people’s minds, they want to believe the legends of the things, and it’s much easier when they have heard about it before. I think, I don’t know if this makes since, sometimes it does in my head but doesn’t when I write it down. Anyway, great start, keep it up.
Keira




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1449
Reviews 11
Hey I don’t know what to say it seems they pretty much covered it. But, I disagree with one thing that has been said.
I know elves are a very, very, over-used species; still what you could do to make them your own is limitless. You might even have people thinking of your elves when they think of elves. Much easier than making a whole new race. With a new race you have to do so much more than just give them a name, and a look. To make them believable to me they have to have history, leaders, everything that makes up a race. But, if this is what you would like to do it seems you have a very good start, very original thinking. I am just saying, people like reading about stuff that they have heard about, or I do think that anyhow. I mean, can you think of one book that’s made it to the best sellers on a completely fabricated race? I can’t. I think it’s because in the back of people’s minds, they want to believe the legends of the things, and it’s much easier when they have heard about it before. I think, I don’t know if this makes since, sometimes it does in my head but doesn’t when I write it down. Anyway, great start, keep it up.
Keira




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4233
Reviews 35
Hi Corey!!! :D

You really have potential. This piece is very good. I only found a couple of things.

At the beginning of the passage, your writing is a bit repetitive.
It was coming. Just like it always did. It always came on the same day at the same time of the day.

and
It was coming and there was nothing I could do about it.

You could write something like:
"There was nothing I could do to prevent it." :D

[/quote]After a week of the single sickly torch lit confines of my cell the sunlight streaming through the window by the door blinded me.
That was a good sentence. :) Just place a comma after 'cell' and before 'the'.

"Tharin sir.”

There should be a comma after Tharin. I was thinking about this. If they have kept him prisoner, then why is he being so polite? :?

And the thing about the Elves, i agree that they have been used for a lot of stories. But I'm pretty sure you can make them stand out above what the other elves are like.
I really liked this story. I hope to see more of this in the future.
diaNe :D
The two most engaging powers of an author are to make new things familiar, and familiar things new.
Samuel Johnson

I'm not sarcastic, I'm simply verbally ironic.
Me




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 5
I like the lack of formal words. Somehow it sounds more genuin and makes it seem more realistic. keep it up. i dissagree i think elves are just fine. i read alot and i haven't read any good elfe books latley mainly vampire and faries. i know my i's aren't capital i'm just too lazy. lol. i probably spelled a lot of words wrong too but oh well.
"Straight as a circle."~Tyler Nelson
don't worry if you've never heard this before, he's not famous. He's one of my buddies.



cron
You can't fool me! I listen to public radio!
— Squidward Tentacles