Young Writers Society

Harry Potter ANY day!!
I haven't read the twilight books so this might'nt be so... apt coming from me. But I have seen the movie and comparing the twilight movie to the Harry Potter one's( Which I don't think are nearly as good as the books), the Harry Potter movies would have to score. Harry Potter is funny, about friendship, love, loss, courage, hope and so much more! I started reading the books only after I watched the first movie, and I haven't stopped since. No offence to the twilight fans around here, but the Twilight movie wasn't compelling enough for me to go pick up the books and read. Plus, Twilight is relatively unknown where I live. I doubt that even one out of ten people can tell you what it is.

I believe the only reason the two are compared is because the fandoms are the same. Most of the people who loved (and still love) Harry Potter, love Twilight, also.
And some Christians HAVE banned the book. My friends aren't allowed to read it.

I adore both, and I do not think I could choose. Maybe Harry Potter, because I remember my dad reading it to me when I was little and doing the "Hagrid" voice perfectly. I think its *Ehum Swear Word* that christians shouldn't have read Harry Potter. I am not religious, so it doesn't matter. Maybe the reason it isn't any trouble with Twilight is because people don't really give a damn about religious cultures when people are talking about books. Because, come on, people don't really think that books are aimed spec at THEIR culture because they want to inflicked pain on it.

Most definitely Twilight.
Harry Potter was dragged out for far too long...
I mean, seven books?
The Twilight series is definitely better.
Plus, Twilight etc have so many hot boys!!!
And Edward is SO gentlemanly.
Really wanna see the film!!!!!!
Grrrr.

Pgsgirl7 wrote:Harry Potter was dragged out for far too long...
I mean, seven books?

Seven books really isn't that long. Many other series go on for longer.