Young Writers Society

I was thinking about the proficie. What if Neville has to die?

"Neather can live while the other survives."

What if the "Neather" is Harry and Voldmort and "The Other" is Neville?
I think Dumbledoor (gah! I forgot how to spell it!) said I was wrong but what if he's wrong? He's only human.....

Because the prophecy was only between two people, as shown on the label in the Hall of Prophecy. From the minute Voldy decided to kill Harry, Neville was discounted from the Prophecy. It has nothing to do with Neville anymore.

Although, having said that, I don't think for a minute that Neville won't have some sort of a major part to play in the book. We'll just have to wait and see.

KazSmurf wrote:Because the prophecy was only between two people, as shown on the label in the Hall of Prophecy. From the minute Voldy decided to kill Harry, Neville was discounted from the Prophecy. It has nothing to do with Neville anymore.

Although, having said that, I don't think for a minute that Neville won't have some sort of a major part to play in the book. We'll just have to wait and see.

But what if there was some sort of loop hole? Uhhhh..I dunno....I was up till' 3 in the morning when I came up w/ it....