z

Young Writers Society


Deleted



User avatar
532 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 27927
Reviews: 532
Sat Nov 20, 2010 9:09 am
ArcticMonkey says...



Deleted
Last edited by ArcticMonkey on Tue Dec 21, 2010 11:42 am, edited 4 times in total.
Someone told me there's a girl out there, with love in her eyes and flowers, in her hair.
  





User avatar
36 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1131
Reviews: 36
Sat Nov 20, 2010 3:06 pm
aweqs says...



Hello :D
Im just gonna do a quick review,
wring in bold is corrections and writing in red is suggestions :D
Ill also cross out a few unnessecary bits :D
Here I go :)

Chapter One

October 2nd 2005

Claire

I looked across the table nervously, glancing at my three siblings with a nervous smile. What was so scary about having dinner with my family? The ones I care about the most. It was out first proper meal together since... my parents accident. Amber, so suddenly, claimed that she could cook so made us this chicken roast dinner there is something about this sentence which doenst flow... maybve try "Suddely, Amber decided that she could cook, so she rustled up this roats dinner" just a suggestion :D. Maybe that’s why I was so nervous- to say that her food tasted horrible.

However, I couldn’t do that. Amber is my only sister,;and the one I look up to. She doesn’t know it, but I really envy the way she is. The way she isn’t too cocky about anything, or the way she forgives you and gives you a warm hug. It’s not like I’m one of those siblings who picks fights with her to hide the fact I want to be like her. No. We get along great.

I watched Bruce and Harvey as they slowly cut up their food and eyed it very carefully, before swallowing quickly and fake smiling. Funnily enough, Amber didn’t realise that they were being fake. She actually offered them more, which, unfortunately, they couldn’t refuse. Amber offering food was the only talkingsound at the table. Harvey noticed this, and being the eldest he asked how my day went.

How my day went? Terribly! All of my friends treated me like I was a four year old who had lost a toy. When I told them they don’t have to treat me differently, they were worse. My tutor, Mrs.Wolf, seemed like she knew what I was going through. Of course, she treaeted watch out for those typos! me a little different, but not much. Whereas, in German, my teacher kept on asking if I wanted to go home because apparently I wasn’t concentrating properly. Then those kids who didn’t know about my loss cried,

“You tell me off or give me a detention for not concentrating, you never send me home!”

Then others yelled,

“Miss, I haven’t been concentrating at all this lesson. Can I go home?”

Of course, both answers would get you a fat old detention. So, I couldmn’t tell Harvey and the others how my day really went. They would only hear the part on me not concentrating in lesson, then we would have a big discussion about it. No. I would not let that happen.

“School... is school. I did my English assessment today, but I’m not sure whether I did well enough to get my desired level.” I calmly replied.

“You obviously going to get a good mark, you always do. And what’s with the poshness? Desired? Seriously?” Bruce said, grinning. Then I told him that he’s only making fun of me because he really just ewants to be posh. Then we got in this huge argument which Amber and Harvey had to stop.

Bruce and I always had arguments. Mostly about silly little things, like being posh. Seriously, I don’t know what her meant there. I’m not posh at all, I’ve heard the way I talk. Nothing compared to this girl called Anna in my tutor group. She owns seven real life ponies and three horses. Her house is a mansion, and has a library, a tennis court and a swimming pool. That’s what she’s told us anyway, who knows if she’s telling the truth or lying dont need to mention that last bit- we get the idea form 'telling the truth ":). This kind of stuff is what she brags on about everyday, and we have to sit and listen, thinking about outour two bedroom houses.

Everyone thinks that I’m really rich because I live in a big house. The thing is I have threee other siblings about and previously two parents. We can’t have a two bedroom flat. Although, I don’t share with anyone, and neither do the others. My mum and dad shared, of course. My bedroom is a tiny box room. Everything is so cramped, and my bed is a loft bed. Meaning, it’s like a bunk bed but without the bottom bunk. Instead, I put a desk there. This means that after a long day, I can’t fall on my bed and sleep. I have to climb up a ladder. Then, getting down that ladder on cold Wwinter mornings was a nightmare.

I completely forgot about dinner. The other three were talking while I was engrossed in my own thoughts. Apparently I do this a lot, and everyone thinks I’m aa writer as I have those qualities. But I couldn’tcan't dont change tense here :) write to save my life, which is why I’m not going to do well in this English assessment.

The others were talking about how everyone’s day went. I didn’t need to know what happened, as I could just guess. Bruce would take ten seconds to figure out something to say, then it would be something like,

“ I played football with my mates,”

How more obvious could can you make it that you were hiding something?

Amber would talk about sixth form. She also mentioned her new boyfriend, Drake, and how she’ll bring him to meet us soon. Oh god, Amber’s past boyfriends were had not been very nice my corrections make it flow better I think :). All lazy, immature and uncivilised. I hope Drake won’t be like this.

Harvey would probably talk about how he hasn’t illustrated anything for over a month, but today he got inspired. He says this everyday, ;a semicolon would be nice here he’s a fantastic artist. We all ask him why he didn’t sign up for art college, but apparently he doesn’tdidnt changing tense again have the money. Lies. Probably doesn’t think it’s manly enough, which sounds more like Bruce than Harvey. He would also talk about his job at Waterstones. Twenty and still working like a sixth form student. I’m not saying it’s bad to be working somehwhere typos! like that at twenty, I just couldn’t didnt expect it from him. He always seemed the type who would quit even if it meant less money for the family.

Maybe that’s why he didn’t quit. After outr parents cleared off,wait? did they die, or run away? you should use clearer phrases. the phrase 'accident' makes it seem like they didnt want to go, but then 'cleared opff' makes it seem like they decided to leave? we would be needing to make some more money. Amber has a job at Next which is for the weekends, but Harvey works six days a week. I still think that with that his experience he could get a job somewhere else.



Amber

Ever since my mum and dad cleared off dont use the same phrase twice so near each other! maybe try 'departed' :) , I’ve been thinking about about all the responsibilities I’m going to get. Even though I’m not the oldest, I’m a girl, and girls are in charge of all the house work. I don’t think that Harvey would be up to it. I didn’t want to be one of those people who fed theretheir family frozen food every night and just didn’t cook. That’s why I attempted a roast dinner. It tastes disguisting, but everyone else seems to be enjoying it.

I offered Harvey and Bruce more, I didn’t bother with Claire because she never ate. At all. Only junk food, which I find extremely unhealthy. I was just about to ask everyone about there day but Harvey beat me to it. We went to Claire first, and she seemed so engrossed in thoughts, as usual try rephrasing this - a suggestiopn "He asked Claire first, but she was engrossed in her own thoughts, as usual" thats seems to work better :). But after about ten seconds she looked up and replied,

“School... is school. I did my English assessment today, but I’m not sure whether I did well enough to get my desired level.”

What was I going to do with her? I know it’s good to be posh and ennounciate every word, but I don’t want her to be one of those cocky losers who boasts about her grades. She probably knows what level she’s going to get but she just plays up the crowd. I knew I had to have a word with her. We then[/s]Then we moved onto Bruce, whose eyes widened as we[s] said itasked how his day passed seems to work better :D. He put his head down then ten seconds later, answered,

“I scored a hatrick playing football,- it was amazing!”

I sighed. Once again with the stupid football. I don’t know how he’s going to get a job when he’s older. Also, he takes so long to answer. I bet he didn’t score a hatrick, probably just a cover story for what he really did.

We then came to me, I didn’t want to tell everyone about my boring school work. I also didn’t want to get Harvey too concerned, but I think my grades are dropping. Not drastically, of course, but I don’t think I’ll be able to get the results at the end of the year. I just talked about my new boyfriend again, Drake. I stopped as soon as I realised I was boring Claire and Bruce out. I don’t eventhink Harvey was even listening.

When we got to Harvey, he started talking about how he got another inspiration. I’m all for his art work but he always says he’s got an idea when he hasn’t. Then he complains about it, same routine every single day. Well, that’s just life, I suppose.

Bruce

Dinner time. I’dve never had a more awkward experience in my life. My sisters and brother were being really quiet, and usually they talk, leaving me out, so I can stay with my thoughts. Whenever they talk to me or bring me up in conversation, I get really nervous.

Like today, they asked how my day went. I told them I scored a hatrick in football. It wasn’t entirely a lie because I scored two goals then the last one should’ve been counted as a goal but the stupid referee said it wasn’t. If I told them about school, however, I’d be knee-deep in trouble. My teachers told me off constantly, even when I didn’t do anything. I’d built up a bad rep already, and the year had bearlybarely begun.

Claire. Claire, my little sister. My little smart little sister, I really hate the way she goes on about things when she does well. She Oobviously didn’t take after Amber. Amber is graceful and certainly not aarrogant. It annoys me that all of my friends fancy her. It’s a bit unconfortable knowing that your friends talk about your sister behind your back.

My friends aren’t all guys, of course. I have this one friend, called Amelia Lindsay. All of my friends want to go out with her but apparently she really likes me. However, it’s probably just a lie, and my mates a fooling around. They don’t know if I like her, and I’m not sure if I do. She seems like she tries too hard to look pretty, which doesn’t look very nice work when her face is caked with make-up.

Back to dinner- which wasn’t nice at all. The roast dinner that Amber poorly attepmpted to make actually made me sick. I knew I couldn’t say anything because she worked so hard on it. I’dll rather just have something heated up and eaten that makes it sound likes its already been eaten :S if I have to put up with this everyday.

Harvey

I’ve been scared ever since my parents went. I always thought being the eldest would give me advantages, like being able to tell Claire, Bruce and Amber what to do without any fuss. After a while, I realised that they weren’t willing to do that at all. You could forget about even asking Bruce, Claire would do it occasionally and Amber would do it most times. AnotherHowever, one advantage of being the eldest was that I got treated differently from the others. Everyone acted like I was a mature gentleman, which, I kind of was.

Anyway, now I keep on getting these responsibilities. Without Amber, I’d have to cook and do other housework. At the end of the day, I am responsible for Claire and Bruce and how they get on. In and out of school. Which is rather worrying, as I’m not sure what Bruce gets up to in school. He never talks, only about his football. He’s not that good and he never talks about the academic side of things. He’s afraid to admit that he’s gifted and talented in maths, which is a subject I think he should focus on. With the others,he could probably scrape a few C’s and D’s.

However,with Amber taking control of meals I’m a bit worried. try rephrasing " im a bit worried about amber talking control over meals" I wasn’t sure if it was just me and I was being a totalmy inner food critic but it tasted horrible. Everything mixed together and did noot taste nice. Maybe it’s just for a dish like roast dinner. I’ve never had a proper meal from Amber, my dad and sometimes my mum did most of the cooking.





October 8th, 2004

Dear Rose,

Sometimes, I just feel like growling so loud that tigers become afraid of me. My husband, Eric is being really kind to me. After a bit of an on and off relationship, I think we’ve finally settled down and are deeply in love. If we didn’t have kids we would probably be split up forever.
This whole paragraph is weirdly set up, the second sentence is a weird follow up to the first. First your saying how you're deeply in love, then sayinh how you would split up forever? It doesnt make sense. Try rewriting/phrasing :)
sorry that was harsh :S

Speaking of the kids... I don’t think I can do itthis anymore. Four children, what was I thinking? NowClaire has entered the years where she pretendsshe’snot to be interested in boys or other teen stuff, but she is. That year was huorrendous with Amber. Boys are different, they hide their emotions. Which is the way it should be for everyone, unless, of course, you’re Eric.

This whole situation is literally driving me up the wall. In the morning I have to iron everyones school uniform/clothes and have a shower, then go downstairs and make breakfast. After that, I go to workat school dont need to say that- we learn in the next sentence shes a teaching assistant :). Being an assissteant teacher really isn’t good pay. I go home at around three so I have to make a meal for Eric. The kids come home a bit later, apart from Claire. She never goes out, I don’t know where that girls social life is.

I have to go and make dinner. I wish I could talkwrite more as I have a LOT to whine onabout. Sending you these letters over the years has been really interesting, and I want to thank you for listening so well. Something that nobody does for me. You are a great friend!

Yours truly,

Julia Rose Marshal


This is a really good piece!
You have go the balance of love, annoyance and worry for the siblings,
and you have developed the characters well.
I am very interested in this story and I think you should continue writing!

HOWEVER, there are ALOT of typos, grammatic mistakes and punctuation problems.
A good piece of advive which I am constantly given is to READ YOUR WORK ALOUD... or atleast in your head :)
It really helps you pick up phrases which need altering, and your brain picks out typos or you.

I can see you have great potential to be a great writer,
so please keep writing!
I hope I havent been too harsh, and please feel free to PM if you want to explain anything to me etc etc :)

-Ava

/Isha:/= To be honest, we are talking about mostly nothing which in its own essence is something. But somethingness can't be nothing if there isn't nothing in the first place. So really, we're talking about meaningly somethingness that's technically caused by nothingness.


The Smiley Spammer
  





User avatar
532 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 27927
Reviews: 532
Sat Nov 20, 2010 3:58 pm
ArcticMonkey says...



Thank you for the review. I'm very sorry about all the typo's, and I've fixed quite a few of them, but I need to fix some more. So, everyone else who reviews, try and ignore the typo's until I sort them out! (by the way, I almost wrote our there, another typo! :P)
Someone told me there's a girl out there, with love in her eyes and flowers, in her hair.
  





Random avatar


Gender: None specified
Points: 300
Reviews: 0
Wed Nov 24, 2010 12:12 pm
Shreya says...



I liked it, just work a bit on your characters. :)
  





User avatar
553 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 58538
Reviews: 553
Wed Nov 24, 2010 12:48 pm
MiaParamore says...



Hey Tams! Here I am to review you. I hope I don't disappoint you.

October 2nd 2005
When you're giving the whole date, you include a comma after the date and before the year. Not a very big thing but small things like these can make a huge impact on your reader, so be careful.

It was out(our) first proper meal together since... my parents' accident.
I am not sure if you know this probably but I'd like to tell you that when we are talking of possession of plural form then we put a apostrophe after the 's'. Like: dogs' bones.

I watched Bruce and Harvey as they slowly cut up their food and eyed it very carefully, before swallowing quickly and fake- smiling.


When I told them they don’t(didn't) have to treat me differently, they were worse.


Apparently I do this a lot, and everyone thinks I’m as writer as I have those qualities.
That pink part seemed to be missing some word or didn't have proper phrasing. I would let you correct that one on your own.

Oh god, Amber’s past boyfriends had not been.
Had not been what?

However, it’s probably just a lie, and my mates are fooling around.


Claire:So, now to be serious, I am not sure what exactly or who exactly she is. You might make or develop her in the upcoming chapters but I don't know how she exactly feels and what's her life been after her parents left them. She is flat as a paper, I don't know much about her interests but writing. Also, the whole thing was more of telling rather than telling which was the next awkward thing. Generally in a story you could have a mixture, or completely showing, if you want to impress the readers. But if you're telling them only so at one point they would feel like studying some biography or essay, so you should be careful about doing that. What I want to say next is that you really don't need to add that Annie bit here right now when you're just starting off with your novel. You should try to make us more familiar with the characters before jumping onto charries who are not that important to the story(I am assuming it right now). Once you've set the foundation, you have ample time to make and bring in variety of characters-but not the first shot. Honestly to say from what Claire said, I liked others better than her. She was hopeless, there was nothing gravity about her to pull us towards us. Sorry, if I am demoralizing this character more than necessary, but that's what I actually felt. I hope you make her more nice. Secondly, what is her age? Can we get some info on that? Coz' I would love to. Also, the conversation at the dining table, you could have brought in more of that to us. What exactly the kids were talking of? I am asking this because even a small thing like this can reveal a lot about their character/personality(and yeah, that's where showing can come). Sorry, if I have given a log lecture.

Amber:I don't have much to say for her mainly because her part here was short and I think there was no big need to have her part here until of course you think that she too needs to be introduced. But I think there's not much difference because whatever Claire had in her entry was the same as what Amber had to say. I also didn't get to know a lot about her, but only what Claire had already told. So this one was pointless. But it's good you've kept it short since there's nothing major to talk about.

Bruce and Harley:So they were better than the girls and I really liked reading about Harley as he is going to be over-burdened as he has to take care of so many kids. I feel sorry for him. Other than that, you are mostly repeating the same things which is kinda annoying. I know Amber cooked horrible dinner, how everyone is by now. I think it is necessary for us to know what each person thinks, but you don't need to go on with it at once. Like maybe one of them can think about the horrible dinner later somewhere in the novel when they're in a situation where you can fit that or something.

Characters: Fine, so your characters are typical. They are like what you can find in many books or stories. There is no new spark to them, also the family looks like every person is poles apart. I don't say it isn't possible but just unbelievable at times. You could maybe bring something new to them later on. Or maybe you can keep them like this-whatever suits you fine. Also, I'd like to see more of their conversations since dialog also reveal a lot about a character. So you should bring more of that. And the whole chapter seemed like a repetition to me-we were being told they same points over and over again, also this is understood that the food is that bad everybody is going to hate it, so you can skip telling us that.

Showing vs. Telling:Gosh, this was one info dump. I was so much bored by the end after listening all of them repeat the same things and moreover in a similar fashion. There was no description, I had no idea what was exactly happening on this table. If you want to have this telling thing for this chapter, it is okay, but if your whole story is in this format then it's goin' to be difficult to manage reading. You just needed to be more in detail and ramble less. As a starter, you could have told us how the chicken or the bacon(whatever was cooked) looked. That could also make us understand in how bad condition it was. So that would have been excellent. Just more descriptions, more dialog and less of information would make this go a long way.

Good Points: This story was actually quite intriguing, but there's one confusion: did the parents die or they've disappeared? Just wanted to know that. Also, I liked the story in itself. It is interesting to know how the children are going to combat with such tough situations. It is really going to be. Also, for a twelve years old you are a very great writer and I just wonder what you'd become to be when you grow more. :) Just don't stop writing. There were some mistakes, but nothing very great. I have not corrected all the mistakes, so you have to read this it again and fix some errors for self.

Overall:

This was a good read, you have to bring in the showing element and you'd be set on track. I really liked the little cliff-hanger you left us in. The letter, I mean. I am quite thrilled to find who the person is except for being their mom's friend. It would be great. :) There's a lot you have to work on but once you know the mistakes you can. Just post whatever you've written on YWS, let us review it and then you could maybe go on for re-writing, but don't leave it. :)

Have a great day and sorry if I was harsh.
~Shubhi
"Next time you point a finger
I might have to bend it back
Or break it, break it off
Next time you point a finger
I'll point you to the mirror"

— Paramore
  








The roots of education are bitter, but the fruit is sweet.
— Aristotle