z

Young Writers Society


The End of Time Chapter Two (Part A)



User avatar
157 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 4198
Reviews: 157
Wed Jun 10, 2009 12:52 am
Bickazer says...



This chapter introduces the science fiction aspect of the story.

Anyway, I'm incredibly displeased with the first part of the chapter. Actually, the first three quarters at least until Darian shows up. Luanna's introduction feels completely random, my chronology is screwed up, I go overboard with descriptions when it comes to Darian's manor, etcetera et al. Very dissatisfied, I am. The only good part of this chapter is that it moves the plot forward, and Darian. Oh, Darian, how I love you. Writing his interactions with Masudo was the only thing that really kept me going on this chapter.

Sooo....without further ado, here comes the first part of the second chapter of The End of Time, in which Darian is unfortunately absent and Luanna suddenly gets dumped on the reader.

The End of Time

Part One: The City

Chapter Two: Two Arrivals

Luanna Cole stepped into the Aetan spaceport, shifting her bag to the other shoulder.

Her lip curled with disapproval as she swept her blue eyes around the port, taking in the faded gray upholstery, the dust-choked windows, the dim light-strips on the low ceiling casting a weak and flickering light. Barely anyone was in sight: the only people she could see was a tired-looking security guard in blue uniform, lolling against a pillar; and a family hurrying past, all wearing the loose, colorful tunics that the natives of the planet preferred.

Luanna tugged at the collar of her own jacket—streamlined, simple, pale blue, with no visible closures. The style of clothing fashionable in most of the Coalition. At least, the civilized parts of the Coalition that had large, airy and bustling spaceports equipped with serving automatons and moving floors, like the spaceport on Earth.

Earth, Luanna’s home world. She had left it behind barely twelve hours ago, and already a choked knot of homesickness was rising in her stomach. What she wouldn’t give to back on the planet, sitting in Professor Benson’s afternoon civics class instead of…

Instead of standing in a dingy little spaceport light-years away from Earth, all because she’d had the misfortune of winning an essay contest.

Luanna’s parents had seen her off with huge smiles and even tears (at least from her mother), and Professor Benson had wrung her hand and rained congratulations on her head. All seemed to think that Luanna had won a great honor. No doubt, it was a great honor to have won the Young Diplomats of the Coalition competition, but she felt no pride; only a raw gnawing edge of disappointment. Part of the prize, after all, was a two-month trip to one of the recently-admitted edge planets to the Coalition: Luanna had thought she’d perhaps be going to the exciting frontier world of Ora, perhaps to help negotiate the six-months-in-the-making cease-fire between the warring families on the world—

But instead, she’d been sent to tiny, out-of-the-way, uncivilized Aeta, for two months of mind-numbing “cultural activities” in Aeta’s capital of Theratolia. Not much of an assignment, Luanna thought bitterly, for an ambitious young diplomat-in-training.

Luanna took a reluctant step forward, swinging her shoulder bag behind her. Her strides were long and steady, and her long white-blonde hair trailed after her as she walked. She’d been told a porter would come greet her after she arrived and show her to a hotel. Already, just looking at the spaceport, Luanna knew not to expect a luxury hotel like the space hotels dotting the atmospheres of Earth and most other Coalition planets; probably, she’d be taken to a little, dusty, mud-brick structure indistinguishable from the other tiny dwellings in Theratolia.

She quashed a sigh and continued walking on the stubbornly stationary floor—then again, had she really been expecting this dumpy little spaceport to have moving floors? A part of her was disturbed by how few people she saw—except the lounging guards and a few tired-looking clerks behind desks (goodness, they didn’t even have holographic screens—they were clacking on keyboards!), there didn’t seem to be anyone else around. Luanna had been expecting the dearth of people, though: She doubted that the primitive Aetans would have much use for the spaceport.

A male voice behind her jerked her out of her musings. “Miss Cole?”

Luanna turned around, already knowing who she’d see. A young man in a shabby purple porter’s uniform was bounding across the gray carpet, pushing a two-wheeled cart made of rusted metal in front of him. He could only be the porter.

When her travel coordinator had told her to expect a human porter pushing a cart, Luanna had laughed. Why would any human push another’s bags, not when automatons could do the job much more quickly and safely? Now that she was on Aeta, though, Luanna saw that a human porter only made sense: She hadn’t seen a single automaton in the spaceport.

“Miss Luanna Cole, there you are,” said the porter, stopping in front of her with a grin on his face, the white of his teeth in contrast to the bronze of his skin. “Did you have a safe journey?”

“Yes,” said Luanna, with a brief nod. A nasty part of her reflected that the porter probably had never before traveled in space.

“May I take your bags—oh, is that all?” he said, blinking owlishly at the single bag slung over Luanna’s shoulders. “That can hold all of your things?”

“It’s a compact bag,” said Luanna, casting a glance at the sleek silver fabric of the bag. It had been a present from her mother.

“A what now?” said the porter, still grinning.

Luanna suppressed the urge to snap at him in irritation—diplomats weren’t rude—and said, “Everything folds to a very small size inside the bag. A property of its fabric; something to do with nanobots. They were only invented a few years ago…”

So I doubt you’ve heard of anything like that on this backwater planet, though she didn’t say the rude words out loud.

“I see—fascinating!” said the porter, rubbing his hands together with a dry crackling sound that made Luanna wince. “So I take we won’t be needing this?” He gave the rusted cart a wide kick that sent it careening across the natty gray carpet, where it teetered to a tentative stop in front of a grime-coated window.

Luanna just shrugged wordlessly, hoping to convey to the porter that she didn’t want to converse with him. He didn’t seem to want a conversation, though—as he walked slightly ahead of her, showing her the way out of the spaceport, he went on and on in a rambling monologue.

“So I take everyone in the Coalition has got something like that? The compact bag?” Luanna nodded. “Fascinating! They haven’t got anything like that, here. As a matter of fact, they haven’t got much of anything, here. Just sand! And burdenbeasts. Is this your first time space-traveling, Miss Cole? No? Fascinating! Where’ve you been before? Say, say, how long does it take to get a visa, Miss Cole? Been meaning to for some time, I’ve always felt my destiny was on other worlds!”

It took all of Luanna’s diplomatic training to suppress the tart retorts rising in her throat. She’d never met anyone so pushy before—although a tiny part of her sympathized with the porter’s desire to leave behind his primitive planet.

Most of her, though, just wanted him to shut up and leave Luanna alone with her thoughts.

They exited the spaceport—which didn’t even have automatic doors; the porter had to push them open—and stepped into a wide, sun-drenched street. Luanna blinked the sudden onslaught of brilliant light out of her eyes, choking on the smell of dust and a dry, hot smell that must be sand.

The next second, Luanna became aware of the heat—a heat that she felt as intensely as a blow to the head. She could almost see the heat, in the shimmering outlines of the mud-brick buildings lined up in front of her, and to either side. A square, she realized. This must be the city’s main square.

She stepped forward, following the porter and trying to ignore the spreading dark stains under his uniform armpits. She was sure she wasn’t doing much better in the heat, if the way her suddenly too-tight, too-choking, jacket clung to her skin from a new sheen of sweat was any indication.

Despite herself, Luanna took in the scene before her in studious fascination. The square was a wide pavilion, paved with the same mud bricks from which the buildings were made. In the center of the square was a wide circular fountain, about the size of a large round tub. In the center of the fountain was a statue made of sand-colored stone, of a tall, majestic man in flowing robes, one hand outstretched to the sky and the other clenched around a staff a head taller than him. Everything about him—his pose, his sculpted features—exuded power and control.

“Who’s that?” said Luanna, taking a step closer to the fountain, close enough to feel a faint cool spray from the water tinkling from the tip of the man’s staff. It wasn’t enough to completely relieve the heat, but it was something, at least.

“That—that would be the Protector,” said the porter, coming up beside her. “Ugly statue, isn’t it?”

Luanna couldn’t agree less. Whoever had sculpted the fountain had put all of his craftsmanship in the statue of this “Protector”: Even minute details like the folds of his robe were captured in perfect detail. “And the Protector is…?”

“Ahh…well, according to our mythology,” said the porter, in a tone implying not that I believe in it, “the Protector is one of the four Founders of Aeta. He’s the guardian of, well, battle magic. Really, this statue isn’t so special; the one in the Noble Quarter is better or so I’ve heard. Not that I’ve ever been there.”

“Battle magic?” said Luanna, her curiosity piqued. But the porter had already begun striding away form the fountain. Sucking in one last breath of the cool, moist air surrounding it, Luanna turned and started following the porter across the square.

The pavilion was surprisingly empty, for being a city square. Luanna couldn’t see anyone moving about save herself and the porter. There were signs that the square normally saw greater activity, such as the clusters of tiny wooden stalls with colorful silk awnings in front of every building, and the high watchtowers placed strategically around the square, beside even taller trees with stiff green leaves. But there was no one behind the stalls and the blue-uniformed guards in the watchtowers were, as far as Luanna could tell, fast asleep.

“Why isn’t there anyone here?” said Luanna, falling behind the porter as he led her to one of the buildings. “I was told Theratolia was usually a busy city…” Unless the standards of “busy” on this world are different than they are in the actual Coalition…

“Ah,” said the porter, somewhat distractedly. “Well, it’s midday, Miss Cole. Most everyone is taking a nap. They’ve got sense to do so.” He laughed darkly, and tugged at the front of his sweat-stained uniform. Luanna turned away from the acrid smell of sweat.

“Here’s your hotel.” The porter had stopped in front of the doorway to the building in front of him, an open arch in the sand-scoured wall. He swept an arm towards it. “The Blue Kaza Hotel. One of the best in the Normal Quarter. Hope you enjoy your stay, Miss Cole.”

I hope so too, thought Luanna, stepping into the archway. She paused before entering, casting the porter one last glance. Perhaps he wanted to be tipped…? She didn’t know, seeing as she’d never worked with a human porter before.

But he was just standing there, beaming like always. “Enjoy your stay, Miss Cole,” he said again, and then added, sounding more excited, “and if you ever want to drop by the spaceport and help me with all that paperwork—for the visa, you now—you’re very welcome.”

He was still grinning after her as Luanna ducked inside the arch and entered a small courtyard, looking for all the world like a lost puppy seeking approval. Luanna sighed mentally, kneading her fingers into her forehead.

Her first day on Aeta, and already, she’d had enough of the planet.

--------------------------------

Luanna found her room after inquiring at the receptionist’s desk, which was located in a small alcove to the south side of the courtyard. At least, she thought, the hotels on Aeta seemed to work just like the hotels on Earth, though admittedly on a more low-tech scale.

The hotel management had been tripping all over each other in their eagerness to help her—probably, they’d never hosted a foreign customer before. It was all Luanna could do to shake off the over-eager hands of a serving boy who’d wanted to lead her to her room. She could find it herself, she assured all of them. By that point, she was heartily sick of overly pushy employees.

There was no moving floor to take Luanna to her room, of course; she had to climb several flights of steep, mud-brick stairs until she reached the fifth and highest floor of the hotel. Her room was medium-sized by Earth standards, walls painted white to reflect the desert heat. A queen-sized bed was pushed against a wall, and a small, highly polished, wooden table held a wicker basket containing an assortment of strange fruits—round reddish-purple ones reminding Luanna of balloons, hard little green fruits, long orange stick-shaped ones. She didn’t touch any of them. Beside the door was a clothes-tree hung with a simple white tunic and trousers, the kind most Aetan citizens wore. Luanna left the clothes deliberately untouched, even though the sweat beneath her form-fitting jacket was beginning to itch.

She currently sat in a hard wooden chair beneath the open window, a glass of greenish juice clutched in her hand. She didn’t know what the juice was—there was just a pitcher of the stuff beside the fruit basket—but it had a nice, sour astringency to it that Luanna liked. Plus, in the desert heat, it was refreshingly cool. The heat was already dying down, now that the sun was beginning to set, coloring the sky in deep red and orange tones.

With the sunset came people. To Luanna, it seemed quite sudden: One moment, the square had been empty, dozing under the oppressing heat; the next, the sun was setting and people were spilling across the pavilion, their bright tunics dots of color against the sand-colored ground, laughing, chatting, hawking wares…

The activity entranced Luanna. High in the hotel’s fifth floor, she felt like a giant observing an anthill from a distance. People—the same people who had been dozing only minutes before—filled the square, jostling shoulders with one another, bending over vendors’ stalls, tossing shiny silvery coins into the Protector’s Fountain. A mother in a long red tunic tugged a laughing boy closer to her; two boys clashed sticks together in a mock sword fight while a small crowd egged them on; a peddler pushed a cart wafting smells of frying dough and warm fruit to Luanna’s nostrils, calling to potential customers in a high, keening voice.

Luanna leaned further out of the window, relaxing in the rapidly-cooling evening air. Perhaps, she thought vaguely, it wasn’t so bad here. Much more primitive than Earth, true; but Aeta had its own charm. Not that she’d ever want to stay longer than the two months she had to.

A tiny part of Luanna urged her to file a report about the happenings of the day, just as her travel coordinator had told her to do—but most of her waved the voice back. Her limbs felt too leaden, her head too weary, for her to move, let alone file a formal report. Despite her attempts at staying strong, the fatigue of twelve hours of space transit was beginning to catch up to her.

The peddler was shouting, his high voice reaching Luanna’s ears even from her position five stories above him. “Get your fresh, hot bobel sticks! Fresh, hot bobel sticks! Only a half pend each! With every flavor under the sun—”

“That sounds marvelous,” said a rich, deep, and shockingly familiar voice. “I’ll take two.”

Luanna almost fell out of the window from shock—only by grabbing the sill just in time was she able to keep herself from pitching forward and landing with an unpleasant splat in the square beneath her. She swayed, feeling as if someone had reached in her stomach and twisted, and then forced a dose of frozen water down her throat.

She recognized that voice. It was a voice that floated across years, across fading memories, across parsecs of space. A voice she knew as belonging to a tall, powerfully-built, dark-skinned, silver-eyed man…

The man in the long brown cloak stepped away from the peddler, holding two sticks with four round things each impaled on them. He turned around, striding towards a stall pushed up beside the hotel.
She saw a fine down of silver hair on his head, skin almost as black as ebony, a familiar crooked nose. There was no doubt about it. With a cold, settling feeling in her gut, Luanna realized this man could be none other than him.

Mr. Marsh.

Luanna didn’t know Mr. Marsh’s first name, but then again, she had never known much about him. He was just a friend of her father’s, a man who Marcus Cole had met on a gala brunch on Mars six years ago. Apparently, that one encounter had brought them close enough for Mr. Cole to suggest that Mr. Marsh move into the Cole house for a month, while Mr. Marsh’s home was apparently “undergoing renovation”.

At first, the strange, strongly built, silver-eyed man had intimidated ten-year-old Luanna…but his friendly manner began to win her over. He was kind to her and her younger sisters, and he would often take Luanna to the roof of the Cole house, where the miniature observatory was, and show her the planets and the stars. When her parents were too busy to take care of her, he’d give Luanna lessons in Centauri-style aerobic martial arts, something that he’d apparently picked up in years of traveling the Coalition.

Luanna had never asked where Mr. Marsh was from and she’d never cared. All that mattered to her was that he was like a second father to her, a parent when both her parents’ busy schedules prevented them from caring for their daughter. It was Mr. Marsh she had to thank for instilling in her the enthusiasm for the Coalition and space travel that had led Luanna to pursue her parents’ path of diplomacy. As a ten-year-old girl, small for her age and rebellious, Luanna had been determined not to follow in her parents’ footsteps.

I don’t wanna be a diplomat,” she had snapped at Mr. Marsh, once when they’d been viewing the planets of the Solar System together in the observatory.

Why not, Luanna?” Mr. Marsh replied, his tone serene. “I think it would be fun to be a diplomat, don’t you?”
Not really. Mom and Dad are diplomats and they never have any fun,” Luanna said with a scowl. Unless constant gala brunches counted as “fun”, but to Luanna they weren’t.

Ah,” said Mr. Marsh in a knowing tone, as he adjusted his telescope. “So you don’t want to be a diplomat just because your parents are.”

Luanna blushed and stared at the ground, realizing that she didn’t have a concrete reason besides that.

You know, diplomacy isn’t all gala brunches,” said Mr. Marsh with a low chuckle. He was peering intently into his telescope but it was clear that all his attention was focused on Luanna. “There’s real excitement…and danger…to being a diplomat.”

Really,” said Luanna, sticking her chin up petulantly. Her ten-year-old self believed that there was no job more exciting and dangerous than being a secret agent.

Of course!” said Mr. Marsh, his animated tone surprising Luanna. “Diplomats get to travel to every planet in the Coalition—yes, Ora included. If they’re particularly good, they get to travel for free. And first-class.”

This perked Luanna’s attention. She’d ridden spaceships before, but always in economy class. Sometimes, though, she’d glimpsed the comfortable leather seats and holographic entertainment systems of the first-class chambers.

Not to mention, in many cases—especially at the frontier worlds—diplomats encounter danger,” said Mr. Marsh, making a show of adjusting his telescope sights again. “Such as Ora. Just three months ago, a group of Coalition diplomats was held captive by the Talon family. They barely escaped with their lives.”
Really?” Luanna stared wide-eyed at Mr. Marsh, drinking in his every word. She’d long believed the sort of excitement he was talking about belonged only to spy dramas, but he was talking about things that happened in real life, and to diplomats like her parents, to boot.

Would I ever lie?” said Mr. Marsh, playfully. Then, straightening up, he turned to her and cast his paternal silver-eyed gaze on her. “Think about it, Luanna. About becoming a Coalition diplomat. You won’t regret it.”
That conversation hadn’t magically convinced Luanna to follow a diplomat’s path; but it had set her on the road. Mr. Marsh had opened her eyes to a diplomacy that existed outside her parents’ world of starched suits, social events, and tedious small talk. He had shown her that there was nothing wrong in pursuing diplomacy for its own sake, not because her parents had done the same thing.

If it wasn’t for Mr. Marsh, Luanna would never have entered the Young Diplomats contest, let alone won it. If it wasn’t for Mr. Marsh, she wouldn’t be here in Aeta today…

And apparently, for some reason, he was here too.

Luanna glanced out of the window again, once she trusted the shaking in her arms to lessen. She scanned the crowd for a glimpse of silver hair, powerful shoulders, brown cloak, but saw nothing. He was gone.

Yet he’d been there—she was sure of it. She hadn’t imagined seeing Mr. Marsh, here, on Aeta, dressed like a local and speaking on friendly terms with the locals. Mr. Marsh, who Luanna hadn’t seen in six years…

Was he a native to Aeta? Or was he here on a diplomatic mission? Or for his own unfathomable reasons? Luanna’s grip tightened against the windowsill, her knuckles turning white. Either way, Mr. Marsh was here.

And Luanna finally had something to do. She didn’t just have to waste her time while her brain turned to mush as she attended dull cultural activity after cultural activity. She could find him. She could find Mr. Marsh.

As she stood up, trembling in excitement, Luanna realized she was no longer tired.

----------------------------------

The more I read this, the more I hate it...it's such a sudden shift from the first chapter. >_> I feel maybe I should move the Nendo meeting Darian scene to the front of this chapter and have this one come later, I don't know...

I'm somewhat dissatisfied with Luanna's characterization; I actually feel she's not mean enough. Yeah, I know, she already is kind of a jerk, but she's already begin to enjoy Aeta somewhat and I don't want that; I want her to be a bastard about it and whine and bitch about Aeta for quite a bit before slowly coming to concede it isn't all bad. But I was afraid that making Luanna too big a jerk would alienate readers to her, and I don't want the readers to start hating one of the protagonists by the second chapter. >_> So I don't know how to fix Luanna's characterization. Please, suggestions!

The second part of the chapter is scads better; well, at least it starts becoming better when Darian shows up. Meanwhile, read and review, and if you manage to stick it through the entirety of the chapter, I promise a review to anyone who asks for one. :)
Ah, it is an empty movement. That is an empty movement. It is.
  





User avatar
1272 Reviews



Gender: Other
Points: 89625
Reviews: 1272
Sun Jun 14, 2009 12:14 am
Rosendorn says...



Hiya!

Luanna Cole stepped into the Aetan spaceport, shifting her bag to the other shoulder.

Her lip curled with disapproval as she swept her blue eyes around the port, taking in the faded gray upholstery, the dust-choked windows, the dim light-strips on the low ceiling casting a weak and flickering light. Barely anyone was in sight: the only people she could see was a tired-looking security guard in blue uniform, lolling against a pillar; and a family hurrying past, all wearing the loose, colorful tunics that the natives of the planet preferred.


~ I'd connect these two paragraphs, since they pretty much continue the same idea.

~ Watch the number of colours and details you hit us with at once here. Lists, especially, are prone to having too many details in them. Try spreading this out into more paragraphs so we don't get info-overload. (Keep the details, though. ^_^ The way they're written now, and in other paragraphs, are the details that make us hate the world as much as Luanna does)

Luanna tugged at the collar of her own jacket—streamlined, simple, pale blue, with no visible closures.


I'm having a hard time picturing this. Mostly, it's the "with no visible closures" bit that I don't get. It's a pretty unusual description of clothing; make us see it.

At least, the civilized parts of the Coalition that had large, airy and bustling spaceports equipped with serving automatons and moving floors, like the spaceport on Earth.


Very nice description by omission! By saying what the "civilized" parts have, you put in what this place doesn't have.

Earth, Luanna’s home world. She had left it behind barely twelve hours ago, and already a choked knot of homesickness was rising in her stomach. What she wouldn’t give to back on the planet, sitting in Professor Benson’s afternoon civics class instead of…

Instead of standing in a dingy little spaceport light-years away from Earth, all because she’d had the misfortune of winning an essay contest.


I laughed out loud at this. The trailing off was used to the best affect.

Part of the prize, after all, was a two-month trip to one of the recently-admitted edge planets to the Coalition


Hm, the term "edge planets" is clear enough, but I'd spend a bit more time explaining it later on.

Not much of an assignment, Luanna thought bitterly, for an ambitious young diplomat-in-training.


Thoughts should go in italics.

(goodness, they didn’t even have holographic screens—they were clacking on keyboards!)


Another part I laughed at.

A young man in a shabby purple porter’s uniform was bounding across the gray carpet,


"Purple porter's" is some alliteration you probably want to avoid. It made me laugh, which I doubt is what you want. ;)

He could only be the porter.


Since you just said "porter's uniform" before, this line is a bit redundant (But since "porter's" can be easily deleted from the line above, it's a quick fix)

not when automatons could do the job much more quickly and safely?


"Safely" leaves me hanging. Is it safer for the luggage or safer for the humans who would be carrying the bags?

though she didn’t say the rude words out loud.


You're beginning to use "rude" a lot when describing her actions. A bit repetitive in the long-run.

rubbing his hands together with a dry crackling sound that made Luanna wince.


Why is his skin cracking like that? And, usually if "rubbing hands" are mentioned, I always think of the classic bad-guy cliche unless there's some more description to the movement.

across the natty gray carpet,


Luanna must really dislike the colour gray, since she uses it to describe the carpet so much. (So far, every time you've mentioned the carpet you've mentioned it's gray. That's not so bad, but I'm just pointing it out to say there should be a reason behind that mention of gray carpet)

It took all of Luanna’s diplomatic training to suppress the tart retorts rising in her throat.


The way this is worded, I think she's twenty-something, not sixteen. How much training has she gotten?

A square, she realized. This must be the city’s main square.


With the tone here, these almost sound like thoughts.

following the porter and trying to ignore the spreading dark stains under his uniform armpits


That sounds really, really hot. Can a body even sweat that much in the implied thirty-seconds they were outside?

if the way her suddenly too-tight, too-choking, jacket clung to her skin from a new sheen of sweat was any indication.


I found the second part of this sentence really hard to read.I don't think "sheen" is the right word here. It doesn't make me think of sweat, even in this context. Maybe replace with "film"?

cool spray from the water tinkling from the tip of the man’s staff.


Not sure if "tinkling" is the best word here. Maybe replace it with "flowing"?

such as the clusters of tiny wooden stalls with colorful silk awnings in front of every building,


Silk is usually a luxury good, I find. Is the Normal quarter that rich?

and the high watchtowers placed strategically around the square, beside even taller trees with stiff green leaves.


I'd nix this comma.

He laughed darkly, and tugged at the front of his sweat-stained uniform.


~ Another comma that's nix-able.

~ I think you switched viewpoints here. If she's behind him, how can she see him tug on the front of his uniform?

Luanna turned away from the acrid smell of sweat.


How can she turn away without changing direction?

The porter had stopped in front of the doorway to the building in front of him


I find this sentence a bit awkward, mostly because "in front" is used twice. Rework this so that doesn't happen. ^_^

I hope so too, thought Luanna,


I mentioned thoughts in italics, right? Proofread for that in the future.

Her first day on Aeta, and already, she’d had enough of the planet.


Hm, I don't really see this. You haven't made us hate the place enough in your description. The past few paragraphs about the town square aren't that emotion-filled. If anything, they give a good view of the place. Don't be afraid to have Luanna hate the place. Just word your descriptions so we hate it too.

At least, she thought, the hotels on Aeta seemed to work just like the hotels on Earth, though admittedly on a more low-tech scale.


These lines don't seem to be thoughts. They could easily fit in the prose if you drop the "she thought" tag.

By that point, she was heartily sick of overly pushy employees.


Yet she's just seen one in the day? It doesn't seem to fit.

She currently sat in a hard wooden chair beneath the open window


I don't like "currently" in this sentence. It implies the description was a flash-back, when the paragraph itself didn't read as a flash-back, if that makes sense. What's really making it stand out for me is there is no summery of what she's done after walking into the room for there to be a "currently."

Perhaps, she thought vaguely, it wasn’t so bad here. Much more primitive than Earth, true; but Aeta had its own charm. Not that she’d ever want to stay longer than the two months she had to.


I will mention her change in mood in my over part of this review.

Her limbs felt too leaden, her head too weary, for her to move


I would nix the comma after "weary."

Despite her attempts at staying strong, the fatigue of twelve hours of space transit was beginning to catch up to her.


I'm not really seeing this fatigue in her thoughts and actions. With the sharp descriptions and her actually moving, it's hard to picture her being tired.

She swayed, feeling as if someone had reached in her stomach and twisted, and then forced a dose of frozen water down her throat.


It's not so much this line I'm quoting, more the affect it has on the scene bellow. This seems like an unpleasant reaction, while the scene below seems to be positive. I find it doesn't add up.

The man in the long brown cloak stepped away from the peddler


"The long brown cloak" or "a long brown cloak"? Surely there are other long brown cloaks in the market. (While "the" implies that there is only one. And it gets a bit repetitive since you've used "the" twice in three words)

four round things each impaled on them.


You used "impaled" to describe those balls of dough in Nendo's viewpoint. If you want to give each character a more individual voice, use different words to describe things.

With a cold, settling feeling in her gut, Luanna realized this man could be none other than him.


This line, also, colours the scene below. It seems to set him as as an antagonist, which I think he is, but no validity is given to those assumptions/feelings when the flash-back occurs.

*

Gah, so sorry for cutting this short (Especially after being late...), but my hand has been hurting all day and typing is just making it worse (No, it wasn't doing this review. I've been writing a lot lately)

I shall be back tomorrow for the rest of the nit-picks and the overall portion!

~Rosey
A writer is a world trapped in a person— Victor Hugo

Ink is blood. Paper is bandages. The wounded press books to their heart to know they're not alone.
  





Random avatar


Gender: Female
Points: 12900
Reviews: 110
Sun Jun 14, 2009 2:14 pm
Karsten says...



Hi Bickazer,

Continuing on from the first chapter.

Holy abrupt genre change, Batman! Where'd the spaceport come from? The previous chapter was 100% medieval, accept no substitutes. I'm floundering here - are these different novels? Different dimensions? Different planets? Different eras in history? How can the human race have advanced to interplanetary spaceflight, but people are still getting beaten with the flats of swords in markets?

Okay, I just checked back on the other chapter, and apparently both chapters are set in the city of Theratolia. This is even more confusing. I'm breaking my mind trying to figure out this works. I'm going to just tell myself that chapter one was set in Medieval Theratolia and chapter two is set in Space Era Theratolia.

Luanna needs to develop a character trait beyond superiority.

Sinister whistling guy is back! Awesome. I like him. (At least, I assume there aren't two guys with the exact same physical description wandering around the same city pestering people near bobel carts, whatever name they use.) Two unfortunate consequences of sinister whistling guy's reappearance:

1. He's just exploded my Medieval Theratolia and Space Era Theratolia theory. This leaves me back at total confusion. Apparently there is a spaceport in Medieval Theratolia, and/or the guards are armed with swords in Space Era Theratolia. The sense of temporal dislocation is increased by the fact that Luanna hasn't noticed any signs of an explosion, past or present. I'm just totally lost.

2. My coincidence bell is ringing very loudly. It seems bizarre that Luanna just happens to be in a hotel which just happens to be near a bobel cart that just happens to be the one that someone Luanna knows just happens to visit at the exact moment that Luanna is leaning out of the window. The odds of people spontaneously bumping into each other, on another planet, after six years are astronomically low. I'm not sure whether there's an ulterior motive, or you couldn't figure out a way for them to meet that did make sense.

Still reading on.

Karsten
  





User avatar
1272 Reviews



Gender: Other
Points: 89625
Reviews: 1272
Sun Jun 14, 2009 4:22 pm
Rosendorn says...



So, I'm back.

He was just a friend of her father’s


She uses "just" to describe him and he acted like her father? I find that doesn't add up.

lessons in Centauri-style aerobic martial arts,


I don't know much about Star Trek, but this sounds like something you'd hear there. It also feels like a little too much for one style of martial arts. Usually, it's aerobic on it's own.

something that he’d apparently picked up in years of traveling the Coalition.


In this sentence, you have used "apparently" to describe something about Mr. Marsh when you've just used it in the above paragraph to describe what's happening to his house.

Luanna had never asked where Mr. Marsh was from and she’d never cared.


This might come from the fact I was a curious kid, but I'd like to see more explanation on why she never cared.

All that mattered to her was that he was like a second father to her


"To her" is a bit repetitive here. I'd nix the first one.

she had snapped at Mr. Marsh, once when they’d been viewing the planets of the Solar System together in the observatory.


If you're going to put a comma at all here, I'd put it after "once."

Luanna blushed and stared at the ground, realizing that she didn’t have a concrete reason besides that.


This doesn't ring as "rebellious" to me. I would have told him all the times I'd been dragged to boring gala lunches and how if that's all a diplomat did I wanted no part of it. Along with explaining the glamour of a spy's life, or at least what she thinks a spy's life is. ^_^

“There’s real excitement…and danger…to being a diplomat.”


You mention that diplomacy is dangerous again a little farther down. I'd nix this mention so it doesn't look repetitive.

He had shown her that there was nothing wrong in pursuing diplomacy for its own sake, not because her parents had done the same thing.


I'd replace this line with something less perfectly presented. Instead of telling us what he did, have her find things out on her own, remember him, and imply that he was the one that sparked her interest.

And apparently, for some reason, he was here too.


Now I'm confused. Is this before or after Mr Marsh stops time? Because the way things are, chronologically, the whole market should be in ruin. And since this is sunset, it would make sense for the reader to think that this happened after.

dressed like a local and speaking on friendly terms with the locals.


I'd replace "the locals" at the end with "them" so things aren't as repetitive.

Luanna realized she was no longer tired.


I'd rework this line, or delete it entirely. If she's trembling with excitement, it's implied that she's no longer tired. Have her make preparations to find him instead. ;)

~

Now I'm going to quote some of you comments and give you my suggestions on them.

The more I read this, the more I hate it...it's such a sudden shift from the first chapter. >_> I feel maybe I should move the Nendo meeting Darian scene to the front of this chapter and have this one come later, I don't know...


I find the sudden shift is from not knowing where we are until mid-way through this chapter. When doing such a sudden shift, make sure you tie things in as quickly as possible.

But I was afraid that making Luanna too big a jerk would alienate readers to her, and I don't want the readers to start hating one of the protagonists by the second chapter. >_> So I don't know how to fix Luanna's characterization. Please, suggestions!


The trick to making a completely nasty character is have us hate the place as much as they do. Check out this article on describing things to get emotion. If you describe things to show them as ugly/unpleasant then your character will seem justified in her opinion of the place.

*

General comments:

Characters/viewpoint: As I pointed out before, she really doesn't feel nasty enough. with her total hatred at the beginning, the sudden shift at the end leaves readers wondering what happened to her; Luanna's characterization proceeds to not feel complete.

As for having a chapter in her viewpoint, she's not being nasty enough in her descriptions. I mentioned that in my nit-picks, and my suggestions for making her sound like more of a jerk (I actually didn't find her to be a jerk here. Just tired. Yet that tiredness wasn't really well explained...) The tone is also rather close to Nendo's, which isn't good if you want her voice o be original.

Confusion: The first thing I want to point out here is: You set us up at the beginning to have her tired, but that never really shows up. Make Luanna snappy, cynical, whatever it takes to make it look like she's really at her limits. Be sure to explain why she's doing it, too!

Second: I find it a bit strange why she's in the Normal Quarter. If this is part of her prize, why isn't she somewhere more luxurious? Is this so she can be closer to the cultural center? If so, or if not, explain that to us.

Third: Just about everything here feels a bit under-explained, actually. The mystery around Mr. Marsh and where he picked things up was nice, since we know he's not the "cleanest" of guys (From the last chapter, he sounds like an antagonist), but a lot of the other reactions leave us hanging a bit.

Overall: Not as crisp as Nendo's chapter. It really felt like you were forcing niceness onto Luanna, so the tone feels a bit off. It also feels a bit weird how she doesn't follow Mr. Marsh with her eyes.

I will say I was a bit displeased myself.

(Side note- Because of your comments at the beginning, I almost had to force myself to read this. Put all comments, if you must make them, at the end of the chapter so we don't have an opinion as we read. ^_^)

~Rosey
A writer is a world trapped in a person— Victor Hugo

Ink is blood. Paper is bandages. The wounded press books to their heart to know they're not alone.
  





User avatar
537 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 60568
Reviews: 537
Mon Jun 15, 2009 7:29 pm
Evi says...



Hey Bickazer! Can I call you Azzy? I quite like that...*muses*

I hope so too, thought Luanna, stepping into the archway. She paused before entering, casting the porter one last glance. Perhaps he wanted to be tipped…? She didn’t know, seeing as she’d never worked with a human porter before.


a.) Italics for thoughts. Just standard protocol, I believe, and the formatting makes it easier for the reader to tell.

b.) I've always disliked ellipses (...) in prose, unless it's within dialogue. I wound advise just leaving that with the question mark and eliminating the dot dot dots. They just seem unprofessional to me, although others may disagree. I've found other ellipses throughout this piece, so I suggest you consider scratching those out.

To Luanna, it seemed quite sudden: One moment, the square had been empty, dozing under the oppressing heat; the next, the sun was setting and people were spilling across the pavilion, their bright tunics dots of color against the sand-colored ground, laughing, chatting, hawking wares…


I find the structure of this a bit odd, with the colon and the semi-colon and then the list with commas, and then the ellipses. I'd suggest breaking this up somehow with a period. Maybe replace that first colon with a double-dash, the way you have previously? Here it's just too much of a grammatical muddle, I'm afraid.

:arrow: Luanna

I agree with the part where she's not quite mean enough. You start her off wonderfully woe-is-me, but she's enjoying Aeta far too quickly. Perhaps have her grudingly accept it's kind-of-sort-of nice, in a quaint way, but point out more of the place's imperfections. Maybe the tasty green drink isn't quite as good as one back home. Maybe her bed doesn't have a personal massage option. If you make more negative connections between Earth she's used to and this foreign land, we'll be able to see the side of her that's comparing the two and having Aeta always come up flat.

However, my main problem is that I don't understand her reaction to Mr. Marsh's voice. So cold, so alarmed-- whereas nothing in the description you gave us mentions anything but a positive relationship between the two. I think you need to mention why she's a bit resigned towards the man, otherwise her response to his presence there doesn't make sense. What did he do to make her feel that way about him? Give us a small hint now.

:arrow: Overall

I did enjoy this just as well, actually! You have wonderful descriptions (perhaps a tad too numerous or long-winded, and a bit over-enthusiastically thorough, if you understand what I mean) and Luanna will develop nicely, I think. I was half-hoping you'd end this segment with the same fire catastrophe in the first chapter, but I suppose fro that I'll have to travel to the next part, which I shall try to do-- later, though.

Again, with the notes in the beginning telling us everything that's wrong with this! :wink: Be careful, or we might just start believing you. Wonderful job (I'll go back and gold star this and the first, now that I think about it) and good luck continuing! You have a wonderful writing style.

~Evi
"Let's eat, Grandma!" as opposed to "Let's eat Grandma!": punctuation saves lives.
  





User avatar
260 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 13389
Reviews: 260
Thu Jun 18, 2009 11:29 pm
zankoku_na_tenshi says...



OKAY.

This time, at least, I have a legit excuse—I’m at a five week summer program at U of A. I only just got my computer back, and the dumb ones in the university library wouldn’t let me log on to YWS. XD

Okay, chapter two. Yay!

Well, I’ll admit the shift in genre seems pretty abrupt. I think it would be best if you had made some mention or reference, to spaceports or the Coalition, or what-have-you, back in chapter one, so that this would seem a bit less random. You don’t have to go on about it, but I think a passing mention would help a lot. Like saying “Tey and Nendo ran in the direction of the spaceport” or…. I dunno, something like that.

As for whether you should switch this with the next part of the chapter… well, I won’t know until I’ve read it.

As for Luanna’s meanness and lack thereof… on one hand, I want to say not to worry too much about alienating readers. After all, as you know, I wrote a character with the specific intention of making the readers despise her, and… she kinda turned out as my favorite. XD Still… I didn’t ever write from her perspective until the readers had gotten good and used to her. XD Well, I think it’ll be okay, because even if the readers grow to dislike her, they have Nendo to like and root for. In that vein, I think her bit about sinking into a bit of fondness for Aeta does seem kind of sudden.

In any case, I think her arrogance and general rudeness were very well-written, and I’m fond of her already for all her flaws. She’s not exactly a likable person yet, but she’s a fascinating character, and I really want to hear more about her.

I also really liked your introduction of Aeta in this chapter, all Luanna’s description helped to build the setting from a completely different perspective, and that was a great way to develop it without getting info-dumpy. That’s a good way to develop a setting and culture, I think—with the other character’s editorials behind it, we end up learning about her indirectly while we learn about the setting directly.

A couple random rephrasing things:

Really, this statue isn’t so special; the one in the Noble Quarter is better or so I’ve heard.

Comma after better.

She swayed, feeling as if someone had reached in her stomach and twisted, and then forced a dose of frozen water down her throat.


This sentence lost me a little—for a second I thought she was drinking water or something. XD You might want to mess around with the phrasing so it’s clear who is hypothetically doing what. XD

Okay! That’s about all I have to say, and it’s probably a bit redundant because of the better writers who’ve gotten to it first. XD But in any case, great chapter, and I’ll proceed to the next one ASAP.
"The world is not beautiful, therefore, it is." --Kino's Journey

Hey, how about a free review?
  








"Beneath this mask, there is more than flesh. Beneath this mask, there is an idea, Mr. Creedy, and ideas are bulletproof."
— V for Vendetta