z

Young Writers Society


An Absence of Rose



User avatar
537 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 60568
Reviews: 537
Wed May 27, 2009 11:23 pm
Evi says...



[Already Gone—Kelly Clarkson: 022. Exodus]
The sky is an overenthusiastic shade of Pepto Bismol, as if Mother Nature thinks she can smother my woes with a large dose of bubblegum pink. I force my eyes off of the road and glance at the huddled figure in the backseat, the anger building up inside of me until I pound my fists against the steering wheel. The horn shrieks in protest, and I am glad to know that I’m not the only one who needs to scream.
Just drive, I remind myself. There’s no such thing as too far away.
From the back, I hear Rose murmur something in her sleep as she falls sideways out of her seat buckle. I hadn’t had time to grab her car-seat, and it’s in Leslie’s minivan anyway—who knew where the keys were? I had buckled her slight figure down as best as I could, wrapping my jacket around her to try and dry her off.
“Emmy?” Her voice is small, but not weak. Not traumatized. Not at all like she’s just endured a near-death experience. For a moment I have room for only one emotion—relief. She’s awake. She’s okay. I’m okay. We’re headed the only direction that matters right now.
Away.
“Emmy, it hurts. I'm hot,” she says sleepily, taking a little fist and running it across her wet face. Wispy blond locks, immaculately curled by our mother every morning; now they’re plastered against her freckled forehead. I won’t lie—it hurts me, even now, to see those curls. Leslie never bothered with my hair when I was little. She never bothered with anything.
Rosie’s yawn is so careless and innocent; it reverberates around the car until all I can hear is its blissful, naive tone. “Don't wanna go home."
I bite my lip, clenching the wheel. "Don't worry. We're not going back."
She considers this for a moment, and decides it's acceptable. "Sing me a song, Emmy. I want one with the froggy,” she declares.
“Rosie, let me think for a minute. Alright? I’ll sing later.”
I hear shuffling and throat-clearing in the back, and it’s the beginning of tears. She’s working up to them, I know. Preparing for denial, so that, if the need arises, she can just whimper a bit and have it done with. “Sing it now, Emmy,” she insists.
“No, sweetie. Not now.” So tired. Can she tell? Is it possible that the complete and total exhaustion I’m fighting through is coming over in my voice?
“I'm gonna tell Mommy you won't sing!” She sits up and defiantly rubs her eyes.
So blue. Just like mine. Just like our mother’s.
There is really no way to respond to this. There’s no chance she’s ever going to tell Mommy anything again, not if I have any say in the matter—she’s going to be as far away from that woman as I can get her.
My hands shake, and I blink away terror.
I hear the chirping of birds through the open window, and their shrillness reminds me vaguely of our mother’s laugh.
*
The woman stands over the bathtub, grabbing the little girl with the beautiful curls and holding her under until she stops thrashing. There are bottles and glass in the bathroom—some of it shattered, most of it deposited randomly behind the sink or on top of the bath mat. The room is dark, except for the flicker of light from the hallway coming through from under the crack of the door.
Steam floats up from behind the half-drawn shower curtain in wisps like cigarette smoke, and the tendrils wrap around the mother and daughter possessively. Pulling them closer, pulling them farther under. The child’s feet, which are now the only thing above the water, are covered in cuts where the glass has embedded deep into her skin. Just as the after-taste of alcohol has saturated the oxygen she breathes.
The older sister bangs on the locked door, cautiously. There is something wrong in the atmosphere. It seeps through the closed door and into the hallway, it envelops the house until she’s suffocating in it. She hears the laughter and the water.
And the silence. The silence does it. The silence that means an absence of Rose.
“Leslie? Do you have Rose?” The sister’s voice is always like that: tired, suspicious, calm. Her words are stretched tight like a balloon in a room of spikes , trying to keep afloat, trying to keep everything safe and balanced. Trying not to pop.
She repeats, louder: “Leslie?” And then, hesitantly-- the forbidden word. The one that hasn't applied since the drinking began. “Mom?”
Giggling. Water. Silence.
“Oh my God, Leslie, what the hell are you doing?” The words are disjointed through the faucet’s song—they sound submerged, distant. The mother looks up briefly at the sound of her name, but all that matters is washing her baby.
Her sweet, darling baby.
“I’m giving Rose a bath.”
There are giggles, and they rise like champagne bubbles, popping gently as they reach the surface of her volatility.
There is a moment of frantic banging. “Rose! Rosie, can you hear me? Leslie, let her go! Turn off the water!”
Screaming and banging. The door—locked, of course. Another key somewhere. There are keys to everything in the godforsaken world, thinks the woman. Keys to someone’s heart, keys to the future, keys to the bathroom door—what’s the difference?
“Rose, my baby,” whispers the mother. The water is hot and steamy. Didn’t she read somewhere that steam is good for the skin? She wants her lovely baby’s skin to be perfect.
And then—
The door.
For a moment it looks as if it has splintered, fracturing into a million pieces and giving into the force on the other side—the sister. She falls through and crawls over the bathtub, gasping as the steam tightens.
The woman has let go of the girl; she sits in the water, awake, crying.
And then—
Gone.
The sister swoops up the wet angel, rubbing her and shrieking softly. Stumbles to the door, falls out into the hallway. She must have accidentally hit the light switch for the hallway, because they flicker for a moment until it’s dark again.
The mother sits next to the tub, motionless. She screams. “No, no! My baby! Bring her back! Come back here with my Rose!”
But the only response is the purr of an engine, and even that fades into the distance until all that keeps the woman company is the water.
It rises.

*
“No, Rosie, sweetie. You’re not going to tell Mommy. Mommy will be on vacation for a long time, okay?”
I’m still shaking, still barely breathing. My hands are wet and hot from the water. They slip on the steering wheel, and I can only imagine the irony if I saved my little sister from being drowned by our mother only to drive us into a telephone pole.
I pull over after a moment and reach, shaking, for my cell phone.
From the backseat, Rose yawns again. “You sing later, okay, Emmy? Promise?”
“I promise.”
By the time the lady at the police station answers the phone after the sixth ring, Rose is asleep again.
I try to breathe.

[Thanks for reading! ^^ I'd love opinions of the dialogue, especially Rose's (I was having difficulty trying to make her sound young but not infantile) and whether the flashback flowed well enough with the regular narration. Any and all critiques are greatly appreciated!]
Last edited by Evi on Tue Jun 02, 2009 2:51 am, edited 3 times in total.
"Let's eat, Grandma!" as opposed to "Let's eat Grandma!": punctuation saves lives.
  





User avatar
247 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 247
Thu May 28, 2009 3:14 am
Fangala the Flying Feline says...



Oh. My. God. This is possibly the most darkly beautiful thing I have ever read on this site. You had me hooked from the first sentence and you didn't let go. The first paragraph in particular is brilliant, especially the line about the MC/steering wheel screaming connection.

I mean, WOW. Sorry, I'll stop gushing. But seriously, if this isn't published, it should be. Promise me you'll try?

As for your questions, Rose's dialogue is--I admit it--a little stilted. Have you read Breaking Dawn? (Bleh. How I hate to bring vampires into this gorgeous piece of literature.) Anyway, Rose reminds me a lot of Renesmee, the perfect angel child. What do you expect with a name like Rose? If you haven't read Breaking Dawn, don't. It's stupid. But we're not here to talk about stupid books, are we? We're here to talk about this breathtaking story!

“Where are we going, Emmy? It hurts. It’s hot,”


When my little sister wakes up, the first thing she says is: "I'm HUNGRY!" Little kids are generally defiant and obnoxious. Then again, that kind of defeats the point of the story. Anyway, if she's in pain, she's in pain. Younger people seem to express whatever is on their mind.

“I’m going to tell Mommy that you won’t sing for me!”


More like: "I'm going to tell Mommy that you didn't bring my car seat!" (All children are self-appointed lawyers.)

Also, Rose might try to engage in "trivial" conversation. I don't really know her personality, though. Angel children exist. And if Rose is an angel child, she'd probably be looking after Emmy's well-being. "Are you okay?" "Why are you crying?" and the like.

The flashback was seamless, by the way. Maybe too many fragments, but otherwise perfect.

This is truly amazing. You are a fantastic writer.
"Hey look! A black shooting star!"

"That's no star...that's Fangala!"
  





User avatar
228 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1203
Reviews: 228
Thu May 28, 2009 4:45 am
Linx says...



Hi Evi! I think I'm going to end up reviewing all your stories for Cal's contest, aren't I? :D But you are an epic writer and I just love reading your stawries.


Just drive, I remind myself.

Italics for thoughts, plz? :D

From the back, I hear Rose murmur something in her sleep as she falls sideways along the seat.

Along the seat? That's a weird word to use there. I understand how it could be a car seat and it could be long, but it just doesn't sound right there. Down would be a perfectly fine word to replace it there.


M'kay, m'kay. :D


Characters :arrow: I thought Rosie was put out very well really young. And the MC was very good too. I just feel, in that middle part, that Leslie could seem a bit more crazy like I imagine her too. She was drunk, but she didn't seem drunk enough. There wasn't enough description or emotion there, I guess. If there was more, it would definitely strengthen that middle part.
Also! Why does the MC keep calling her mom by her real name. Are they just not that close? Or is there a story behind that? And going inbetween calling her Leslie and mom gets a bit confusing too.


Middle Part :arrow: I felt like the middle part was weaker than the other part. You described it pretty well, but maybe there wasn't enough emotion in it. Yes, it is re-telling the story. But there does need to be some emotion in there. At least, what they might look like that shows their emotion.
It just needs some more building up there, I think. It didn't really grab me.


Other stuffs :arrow: Their ages are also a big part in this. We have no idea how old the MC is. Rose is a little girl and of course, Leslie is their mom. But how old is Emmy? She can drive, obviously. But, having such a young girl as a sister, it's kinda confusing.


They slip on the steering wheel, and I can only imagine the irony if I saved my little sister from being drowned by our mother only to drive us into a telephone pole.

I love that line, by the way. I loved most of the story anyway. ^_^


Feel free to PM me if you have any questions or comments.

*Lin
"A journey of a thousand miles must begin with a single step." ~ Lao-tzu

Attack, IM, or PM me at any time. I will respond. ;)
  





User avatar
158 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 158
Thu May 28, 2009 10:07 am
Lauren says...



Evi, this is amazing! It had me on tenterhooks, wanting to know what had happened, any everything--the little details, the sensations--added to the tension, the wanting to know what had happened. A peak, for me, was about the mother meticulously curling Rosie's hair -- very cleverly done, it gave a little insight into the character of the mother and strangely shows her as sinister.
The best part was the middle section, in third-person. The first-person parts were brilliant and also necessary, but the middle section was exceptional: floaty, dreamlike, shifting, dark. Every little detail was rife with meaning and suspenseful intention.

Evi, you're definitely one of the best writers on this site & I hope you do more of this kind of thing. Definitely your forté.
  





User avatar
1464 Reviews

Supporter


Gender: Female
Points: 83957
Reviews: 1464
Fri May 29, 2009 2:22 am
JabberHut says...



Hyello, Evi dearie! :D

To answer your question in your request, your style seemed just fine!

You had me hooked, you had me read more and more, you had me interested. (If you read through this, you'd notice brief punctuation mishaps that are easy to fix. ^^) You had an eerie air about this piece that was very appropriate for your plot. It was fantastic, and I wouldn't change anything in the style.

When it comes to Rose, I'm a tad concerned. I pictured her as a baby, not a toddler/preschooler as you seem to want to have. I saw a baby because Leslie calls her a baby, for one, and two, when you say pigtails, I think of big bushy ponytails. Perhaps if you said something about thin/young hair or if you try to work with the accent. Young children don't say every word so perfectly, and they don't have the best grammar in the world. If you play a bit with that, then it may turn out better. The demanding part was good though, how she wanted Emmy to sing 'right now'. ^_^

Seeing as my time is short, I'll have to stop there. Though there isn't much else to say anyway. Out of what you wanted us/me to look at, I found Rose was a bigger issue. Hopefully I made some sense and you can mull it over. You can find me somewhere of course if you need assistance. I hope I gave some good advice to help yourself out with the kid. ^^

Keep writing!

Jabber, the One and Only!
I make my own policies.
  





User avatar



Gender: Female
Points: 890
Reviews: 4
Sat Jun 06, 2009 7:30 pm
LightOfTheDawn says...



Whoa!!! That. Was. AMAZING. How are you not a best-selling authour yet?! Brilliant style very intense, had me on the edge of my seat and wanting more right up to the very end!! The text in italics was very sinister and effective- I had shivers going down my spine!!
Excellent work- gold star for you x200000000000000000!
xoxo
* Catch a Falling Star
* Put It in Your Pocket
* Never Let It Fade Away...
~~ SAVEITFORARAINYDAY...~~
  





User avatar
28 Reviews



Gender: None specified
Points: 1876
Reviews: 28
Wed Jun 10, 2009 12:40 am
82manycookies says...



Nice Work! your story was great. i couldn't find antthing too bad about it, it's just hard to critisize someone with more experience...bye
~Livi
"My Mama used to tell me, 'lifes like a box of chocolates... you never know what your gonna get.'" -Forrest Gump
  








If we choose, we can live in a world of comforting illusion.
— Noam Chomsky