Proctor - Chapter 2 (completed)

6 posts
User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 42
Reviews 368
Chapter 1



The March


I sniff. Me throat tightens and I feel it ache. I realize tears are on the brink of consuming the already melancholy state I am in. Gyle… Me friend. He was a good one. The best any person shall know in a place of such despair.
I simply cannot divert me attention and knowingly cast it to the bayonet strapped to me right hip. The tip of the black, leather scabbard is half buried in the snow, or as Gyle would have said, “Snaw.” Such a cruel instrument indeed. I continue to stare at the socket of the bayonet. So long too, that I stare at it until me vision goes blank.
“If only,” is all I manage before I shiver.
Through thee death of him, to honor Gyle, for months I attempted to speak as he but his tongue was, how shall I say, not akin to me own? He frequently said, “me,” when Gyle meant, “my.” The alteration of such a simplistic word was accepted and so he partially remains in me mind, spirit and prayers by the memory of his speech.
“Gyle,” I sob, and then tare my attention from the bayonet. “I am, I did not want… Why could ye… Why did not you put it… Why was is still in the open?”
With the sleeve of me navy blue coat, I brush away the tears but the motion proved to be fruitless. New ones were born immediately afterward so I let them have thee way.
Over yonder, the Gen’ls still make their way, examining the sitting bodies, like me, one after the other. I sigh as Gen’l Washington points and two men make haste and drag him off, I suppose to be rested in some God forsaken, frozen tomb. The other Gen’l, I say with little doubt, I quite like this Greene. Respectfully, with that gimp leg of his, I must admit he did appear rather unusual when he limps, but I further say, I feel good about him. I cannot express fully the reasoning but the men talk and we hear that if we lose Gen’l Washington, Gen’l Greene shall assume his position of the Army. He must be, I reason, a decent fellow and a good standing character for Gen’l Washington putting faith into him.
I still weep. I suppose if I am alone, another shall not mortify me if he witnesses me crying so openly.


*

Moments ago, I glanced at me right hand, just a peek, as the rest of it still tucked tightly in the coat. I was rather curious and as I hoped would not be, was. I saw me thumb, which resembled the toe poking through me shoe. Of course it bothered me so but such an assortment of colors were wretched – but accepted. On the march, the men and I witnessed thee pale blue hue, which appeared almost as light purples. Had it been one year prior, May of ’76,’ when I was a fool to enlist, I say with absolute honesty, such extremes of limbs needing to be removed respectfully from thy body where were birthed too, the screams are more than enough to remind a simple man from Virginia – like me – that cutting off me own… They call it a Fort, but tis more of a wintery ‘ell. Valley of the Shadow of Death; I would accept wholeheartedly that term than the Fort’s former name. Forge indeed! Yes! We forage for food, but alas none is available!
I wonder how the fallen are fairing? I ask me self suddenly, allowing me thoughts to travel freely. I think of them often, the deceased folk who perished before we reached… Here. Once, I felt proud and much obliged to serve in the ranks of the esteemed, Gen’l Washington. I heard marvelous stories of his Virginian Blues during the First War [1]. I once called them soldiers, and so help me, we were! But, I know, we are not, just pawns to be moved and trifled with at any presumable way they see fit. I dare say if I shall commit a sin now by slandering Washington, it is he that has deceived us. We die, bleed our last drip of blood and breathe or last bit of air, but the cost is intangible.

*


“Is he?” a youngin’ of no more than eighteen, asked softly. He, himself, was on the verge. Had I… I dismissed the memory quickly.
“Yes,” I said in the most soothing voice I could muster.
The lad nodded in response and without warning, he damn near knocked me over with that embrace of his. It was a rather unusual gesture, as gentlemen do not hug in the open but his own kin, his father, lied contorted on thy belly a few miles back there.
A horse whinnies, and me ears hear the familiar sloshing sound of hooves in snow. I remember I paid no attention but merely let the boy have his merry way with me. In doing so, I sort of cradled or the very least held on tight to the lad.
“You there. Move on – and take the boy. There are miles yet to uncover still,” and then the familiar voice of Gen’l Greene left. He trotted away from us.
I pulled myself to me feet and the lad occupied the gesture. We snatched our Besses from the ground, and filed into the line. Trailing our muskets in our right hand, we trudged through the ankle-deep snow.
“Are ye cold, Zack?” I asked as we marched along the trail set before us.
The question of course was ludicrous but became a common one amongst the men.
“Aye,” he answered.
I remembered I had smiled. Gyle said, “Aye,” too when he meant, “Yes.” But Zack was not Scottish or remotely akin to the Highlands. He, I assumed fancied the tales of Gyle when I found a quiet moment and spoke of him. Zack was the only person I wished to speak too concerning Gyle. Since then, I have often pondered why is it that I chose Zack.
“I have not but a crumb to feed thee.”
“You keep it,” Zack muttered.
“How are ye fairing?” I asked by changing the subject.
No answer.
“Zack?” I probed.
No answer.
I gritted me teeth and quickened me pace to inspect him. Side by side, we walked, not engaging in any sort of conversation.
“Tell me about, Gyle, Alex,” he said after a few minutes.
I hesitated. “Perhaps when we reach the Fort.”
“My chest hurts.” And then, an eruption of coughing.
I lightly slapped his back.
Zack dropped to his knees instead. He doubled over and coughed ever loudly. I moved the musket into me left shoulder, bent down, lifted him and allowed his body to drape over me right shoulder. It was a costly decision, I knew. Energy was precious and steadying Zack’s body, though as light as he was from the lack of a solid meal, proved to be concerning.
“I can,” he coughed, “walk.”
“I have ye,” I said.
“But you will die,” he coughed, “carrying me.”
His tone was weak, I remember. Frail.
“I am old,” I retorted.
“Nay,” he said.
“I am.”
“Put me down, please.”
“Nay,” I repeated.
“Why is it that you hold onto me when you are hurting yourself?”
“I will not repeat past mistakes.”
“You are not responsible for Gyle’s death.” He coughed again afterwards.
I did not respond.
I held onto him for as long I was able, but I had to release in just ten minutes.
“I do not think I can continue,” he said.
“You must,” I said gently to Zack.
“I think I should like to die here,” and then another wave of a coughing fit began.
Off in the distance, I heard a horse gallop. It did not take long for the beast to reach us.
“You both are prohibiting the line from proceeding. Every man has sidestepped your bodies.”
“He is ill, sir,” I said, referencing to Zack.
I heard Gen’l Greene sigh. “I apologize, but there is nothing I can do for him.”
“Go. I will catch up. I will rest a bit and then follow the tracks to the Fort. Be safe, Alex.”
I remember me eyes twitched. Likely, I was ready to weep, but I do not know for certain. I looked up to Gen’l Greene for support. A great weight settled upon me whole body. It hurt mostly inside.
“The boy will pay his visit soon,” Gen’l Greene said. “He gave his word.”
I looked at Zack.
“Go,” he coughed and gagged.
I placed me hand on his shoulder for a few moments and then never turned back again.

[1] - The term, First War, was referenced to the French and Indian War.



(Next Chapter, entitled, "Into the Valley of the Shadow of Death, will be posted soon).
Last edited by Fishr on Sun Feb 22, 2009 9:59 pm, edited 2 times in total.
The sadness drains through me rather than skating over my skin. It travels through every cell to reach the ground. I filter it yet strangely enough, I keep what was pure and it is the dirt that leaves.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 233
Me again :D I like how you switch between the past and present, this was very well written too- I love how he's taken on his friends speech although I am very curious to know what happened to him!!

The tip of the black, leather scabbard is half buried in the snow, or as Gyle would have said, “Snaw.”


I'd change the comma after snow to a dash.

I continue to stare at the socket of the bayonet. So long too, that I stare at it until me vision goes blank.


I'm not sure about the second sentence, I'd rephrase it a bit to something like this- 'For so long too, that after a while, me vision goes blank.'

Through thee death of him, to honor Gyle, for months I attempted to speak as he but his tongue was, how shall I say, not akin to me own?


I'd add a dash or a full stop between 'speak as he' and 'but his tongue was'.

The alteration of such a simplistic word was accepted and so he partially remains in me mind, spirit and prayers by the memory of his speech.


I think you need to add in something after accepted- either 'by me mouth/brain/body'.

With the sleeve of me navy blue coat, I brush away the tears but the motion proved to be fruitless.


I think you either need to change brush to brushed or proved to proves.

The other Gen’l, I say with little doubt, I quite like this Greene. Respectfully, with that gimp leg of his, I must admit he did appear rather unusual when he limps, but I further say, I feel good about him.


I'm not that keen on the first sentence- I think 'this Greene' doesn't quite fit on the end. Perhaps you could add it in somewhere else? For instance on the end of the last sentence instead of 'feel good about him' could be 'feel good about Gen'l Greene.' I think you should break up the last sentence as well, perhaps putting a full stop after limps and I'd add 'do' between I and feel. I think did needs to be does after 'I must admit he'. So overall something like this- 'The other Geny'l, I say with little doubt, I quite like. Respectfully, with that gimp leg of his, I must admit he does appear rather unusual when he limps. But I further say, I do feel good about Geny'l Greene.'

I cannot express fully the reasoning but the men talk and we hear that if we lose Gen’l Washington, Gen’l Greene shall assume his position of the Army.


I think you need a comma after reasoning.

Overall comments: Its hard to review this as the writing is so different with the character speaking unusually so I'm sorry If I've corrected things that were intentional! Something I might like to hear a bit more on is how the character feels where he is but that's the only change I could really find to the actual story that I think could improve it overall.

I'm sorry you've entered writers block- that annoying beast that jumps on unsuspecting writers!!
All these comments are just suggestions from my own prefernce so ignore them if you want :) I'd love to hear more when you've posted it, I'm very interested in where this is going :D Hope I've helped!
"Your mother is a hamster and your father smells of elderberries"
-Monty Python and The Holy Grail




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 42
Reviews 368
Oh, you've helped and quite a bit.

Well, I noticed you seemed confused by Chapter Two. Perhaps (if you want too), read the Prologue, you might see that his speech has been this way all along - and you should get a conclusive vision of how Proctor is feeling and how his body is responding to the elements through some imangery. I should expand on the imangery part in the Prologue and I'll definitely play around at some point. Hehe. :twisted:

Many, many thanks for all the feedback! Does Proctor's thick dialect distract you as the reader?
The sadness drains through me rather than skating over my skin. It travels through every cell to reach the ground. I filter it yet strangely enough, I keep what was pure and it is the dirt that leaves.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 233
Just read the prologue properly and I'm liking that too! Things make more sense now - I half skimmed it when I first went to read chapter one because I was a bit impatient to read it so I don't think I took any of the information in :oops:

I think the dialect works well, it gives the character more personality and enables me to get a good grip of what they sound like- it makes me like the character even more as the story seems more personal :) The only word I had to read back to a couple of times was Gen'l but I understood it quite quickly once I saw the context it was written in.

Really glad I was of some help and looking forward to reading more :D
"Your mother is a hamster and your father smells of elderberries"
-Monty Python and The Holy Grail




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 233
Hi me again again :D I like how you have continued with this! Really good ending to this part too- although sad :( on with the review :) Like I said before, its a bit difficult to review the style of writing (although I really enjoy it) as I'm not sure if the way it is said is how the character is supposed to be talking or if it needs to be corrected- if that made sense :? So anyway, basically just ignore me if I say 'I think this should be this...' but it was all intentional :D I'll go ahead and say it anyway just in case!

Moments ago, I glanced at me right hand, just a peek, as the rest of it still tucked tightly in the coat. I was rather curious and as I hoped would not be, was.


it needs to be its and I'm a bit confused by the last sentence- do you mean what I hoped would not be?

Of course it bothered me so but such an assortment of colors were wretched – but accepted.


I think but before such an assortment needs to be that.

Had it been one year prior, May of ’76,’ when I was a fool to enlist, I say with absolute honesty, such extremes of limbs needing to be removed respectfully from thy body where were birthed too,


I'm not sure what you mean by the end of this sentence 'where were birthed too' :oops: -I'm not sure if that's just me not grasping it or if the meaning needs to be made clearer.

I heard marvelous stories of his Virginian Blues during the First War1


I don't think you need the 1 on the end here.

But, I know, we are not, just pawns to be moved and trifled with at any presumable way they see fit.


I think you need to add 'now' in after 'I know'. I'd get rid of 'But' as well as I think the sentence would work better without it.

We die, bleed our last drip of blood and breathe or last bit of air, but the cost is intangible.


or after breathe needs a u in it to be our :)

It was a rather unusual gesture, as gentlemen do not hug in the open but his own kin, his father, lied contorted on thy belly a few miles back there.


I'd add a dash between open and but his own kin. I'm not sure if thy makes sense used here- I think it should be his.

I remember I paid no attention but merely let the boy have his merry way with me.


I'm not sure if 'merry way' fits in here- I think it might be more effective to say something like 'let the boy ease his sorrow in any way he could' or 'I let the boy cling to me body in support'.

In doing so, I sort of cradled or the very least held on tight to the lad.


I think this sentence needs comma and an 'at' added to look like this- 'In doing so, I sort of cradled, or at the very least held on tight to the lad.'

I pulled myself to me feet and the lad occupied the gesture.


Instead of occupied I'd use the word copied or imitated.

He, I assumed fancied the tales of Gyle when I found a quiet moment and spoke of him.


There needs to be a comma after assumed.

Since then, I have often pondered why is it that I chose Zack.


Is and it need to swap places.


“Nay,” I repeated.


As it wasn't him that said nay before but Zack I wouldn't have 'I repeated' here.

“Go. I will catch up. I will rest a bit and then follow the tracks to the Fort. Be safe, Alex.”


I think you need to make clear it is Zack talking here and it would be a good point to add some description to how Zack speaks or looks here, maybe their eyes could meet or Alex could notice how sickly Zack looks?

Overall: I liked this part, the ending was great, really effective. I did get a little confused with the speech at the beginning but later on I found it a lot more easier to read. I'm still loving the way he talks though :D One thing I did notice was that at the beginning of the last part of the story (if you get what I mean) at first Zack seems to be a stranger to Alex- or at least that's how I gathered it, but later on they know each other well. I think you could make more clear that they are friends at the beginning. I think it would also be good to know how Zack looks- especially in the last moment as that image would be imprinted on Alex as the last time he ever saw his friend.

I hope this review makes sense and is of some help, I'm looking forward to the next part! :D
"Your mother is a hamster and your father smells of elderberries"
-Monty Python and The Holy Grail




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 42
Reviews 368
Thanks so much! You're very good with sentence structure and the usages of different words to make the sentence flow much better.

As soon as I finish this novella - or if I hit another Writer's Block - I'll get right onto the editing. Just thought I'd say something so you don't think I'm ignoring all your hard work. I just need to finish before editing can be done.

I heard marvelous stories of his Virginian Blues during the First War1


I don't think you need the 1 on the end here.
Hahaha! Oups. That "1" is from a footnote from Word. I meant to change it a bit and add the footnote here so it would be more concise. I'll fix that.

So, overall, how do you like Proctor so far as a person? Have you concluded where the setting is exactly? xD

I'm so glad you seem to be having fun reading this little story.
The sadness drains through me rather than skating over my skin. It travels through every cell to reach the ground. I filter it yet strangely enough, I keep what was pure and it is the dirt that leaves.



"Growing up isn't the problem... forgetting is."
— Antoine de Saint-Exupéry, The Little Prince