The Ghost Writer [Chapter one, part two]

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6235
Reviews 2631
Chocolate used to seem much too expensive and indulgent to me but (with a vaguely guilty pleasure) I can admit that's changed. The shopping bags slicing and dicing my fingers are evidence of that. Three of them, all filled with delightful treats: malteasers, mars bars, moments and every other chocolate beginning with m. It's like a drug. Even now, the minstrels I'm stuffing in my mouth are pumping energy through my veins, shooting me full of pleasant feelings. Yum. Additives.

Isn't human necessity an interesting thing? How the mind feels the need to compensate the body for its hard day of work, and seems to presume that the best way to do this is not in fact with carrots or a good, healthy jog, but with chocolate and drink and... cigarettes.

The walk home is tiresome but I haven't driven in such a long time that I almost think I may have forgotten how to. Besides, smoking works better when you're outside. Except when it's raining actually but today is one of those few British days with the absence of water, just a chilly, frosty bite to the air and a sprinkling of sugar on the ground.

The wind tries to prevent me from lighting my third cigarette, huffing and puffing... I'll blow your house down. But at last, it takes and I draw deeply, feeling that urge to cough and splutter but it's good. I started about three weeks ago, I'd say. About the same time that Mike and I broke up. To be more precise, the exact moment that Mike swore to never let another cigarette caress his lips, I decided to show him just what he'll be missing out on. I'm still not sure I see the attraction in it, I mean they're much too small for one thing, you just can't get a decent grip on them and I can think of much pleasanter things I could put in there. Like chocolate.

I'm standing at my door now, just finishing this cigarette and then I'll catch my breath before I go in. The air's a little old in there, a little musty and even this sharp, grating ice has to be better than breathing in the dust and grime. It's cold inside too, even though the heating dial's turned up. Must be broken. The hallway is rather cluttered, a lot of furniture from the living room's been pressed into here. A TV there, computer here. The mauve sofa's wedged up against the door to the kitchen – I wonder if it will fall on me as I pass but that would just be too easy and the world doesn't work like that. Never fear though, every narrative has its end and so will mine. So will... mine.

Passing through into the living room, I put my bag by the one piece of furniture remaining: a rather insignificant, inexpensive coffee table. It's a little cluttered by my laptop, coffee mugs, coasters and sheets of paper, all torn from A4 notebooks and covered in varying degrees of the same hand, from neat to scruffy to illegible, that being my particular favourite. I've always thought it represents one of those good days of writing, where the words are just spewed out across the page.

The rest of the room is cluttered. I never said it was empty. The furniture has been replaced with many inexpensive, priceless... books! There's piles of them, everywhere, some half open, some fully closed, some reading books, some research books, an abundance of notebooks, all colours and sizes. Come one, come all, come see the writer's work shop display! But seriously, this, this is everything.

See that fire-place at the far end of the room? I had that wood carved especially; it's mahogany, rich and red, almost the shade of blood. And the hearth, that marble slate before the cream carpet starts: that almost exhausted the funds from my latest masterpiece which, by the way, is one of those mauve, leather-bound books sitting on the mantel. The other three are mine as well.

The laptop on the table is relatively new. It's been in a writer's possession almost six months now, since the start of this novel. Lila liked to do that... she used to purchase a computer at the beginning of every book and then she'd use it, just for that novel, nothing else. That was her name, the woman who first set her fingers on these keys, carefully choosing every word she wrote down. She was a lot more particular than me but even so, even so... I sometimes forget. It somehow feels wrong that I wasn't the one to start this novel when it's going to end so perfectly.

Making a rough pile of the sheets and their varying degrees of scrawl, I begin typing up the extracts and scene ideas, filing each into a folder with its own heading or occasionally adding to one of the existing files. I'm not as precise as Lila was but I do try to remember to do this once a week. It helps me to see how the main frame is building and where another scene might be required or sometimes even a whole chapter. Pretty soon, there will just be the ending left to write.

Hours trundle by, mocking me with their snail's pace and I start to develop a pain in my neck and my fingers are aching, the callouses from years of typing not enough to prevent it. There's a knock at the door. I lose my place and a rush of anger grabs a-hold of me, causing me to slam the laptop lid into the table.

“Damn it!” I swear convulsively. I take deep breaths, I steel myself against the second knock and then stomp to the door, shoving hard against the sofa on the way. It's Mike.

“What the fuck do you want?” I demand, fumbling in my pocket for my cigarettes, just for the effect. I light one, my hands shaking a little as I do and his hand abruptly snatches it from my mouth. He holds it a moment, expertly twirling it between his fingers, practically drooling. “Go ahead and smoke it,” I snarl.

“No thank you,” he says firmly. He stubs it out against the wall and I try not to cringe as the singed end touches my delicate paper, leaving a blackened ring. He nods to himself. Smart arse. Arse hole. How dare he come over here, dressed in his snazzy grey suit with his shiny, leather shoes and that ridiculous polka dot tie as if, as if... as if he still lived here.

“What do you want?” I ask sulkily, standing in the doorway with my arms crossed against my chest, trying to resist the need to set my fist against his big, tanned nose and black out those two green balls. He seems to really think about this, pausing long enough for me to consider closing the door on him. Then he swallows, his big adam's apple convulsing and he speaks:

“Do you want to go running tomorrow?” he asks. I stare at his lips, marveling at how they could have known what words to form but then, they always were very talented.

“Why not Wednesday?” I ask, subdued and confused.

“Sounds good,” he replies. “See you then.” Mike waves, walking backwards down the path and I raise my hand in a half wave before making a fist and setting it against my face. I can feel the long nails etching crescent moons into my flesh but I stand there a long time, just looking out, everything forgotten.

Back inside, the room feels different somehow and I can't seem to settle back down to typing so instead I just sit, ruffling absently through the piles of books, soon searching for one in particular. It's small and leather-bound with a duck-egg blue cover and on the inside page is Lila's signature. I make a terrible mess, my ruffling changing to frantic searching as the panic wells in my chest and I shove books back and forth, toppling piles, crying heavily. If I don't find it... but of course I do. It's on the table; half covered by the multitude of paper but even so, it is clearly visible and evidentially safe from harm.

I hold it a while, just pressing the book against my chest, crying for the girl who filled it with such careful words. In that moment, I feel more connected to Lila than ever before but it doesn't prevent me from relishing the snorting that will come, the prolonged laughter and ridicule at her expense that has become an almost routine for me. When I'm down. I open the book eagerly and let my eyes rest upon the words, absolving my predecessor; all her thoughts, her feelings. Her ideas.


I had a lovely day. We went down to the park as planned and sat on the bench, throwing bread for the ducks. They all waddled over on their strange, webbed feet, hooting and flapping at us. I laughed so hard when he started impersonating them that I thought it might bring my period on early. Seriously! And then he took me out for a meal, all expenses on him! He dressed up real nice in a dark suit with his favourite tie (that made me smile) and I took his arm and didn't we look a pair.

It was a little restaurant, a nice, quiet place. Very cosy. The table cloth was white, the chairs nicely padded and the lighting was lovely. Turned down just low enough to be romantic but at the same time, we could see what we were eating and I could see his beautiful eyes and that shock of rust coloured hair combed back and slick with gel. He pressed his strong, firm hand against my leg and I thought: this is how Briar has to feel about Eric. Her pulse needs to beat faster when he passes, her flesh needs to burn when he takes a bucket from her hand and their fingers touch, her mouth needs to throb every time he speaks, every time she sees his tongue rolling over words.

Is it wrong of me to find myself so connected with her? Especially when I plan for her to be the victim of this romance?

But oh, this is the way it must be! Sophie enchants me, there's something so warm and soft about her, I don't think I've ever loved any of my characters as much as I do her. This book, this will be my greatest masterpiece. No longer will I stand in the shadow of others, no longer will my books be placed on the bottom of the shelf. This is the beginning of perfection.


______________________
It's a much weaker second half and one of my least favourite sections but hopefully I'll be able to bring it up to scratch with a little help.
Last edited by Rydia on Tue Dec 16, 2008 2:21 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Writing Gooder

~Previously KittyKatSparklesExplosion15~

The light shines brightest in the darkest places.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1117
Reviews 80
I just finished reading the first part to this a few minutes ago and loved it, so I was glad that you had posted this one today. Grammatically and punctuation-wise, it was perfect. Content: 10/10. It was extremely well-written and leaves the reader wanting more. I apologise for not being able to nitpick, as the only things I saw were comma differences that, in my opinion, are too minor to worry about. Glad to see that there are still some people who use complete sentences and care about their grammar :) I look forward to more.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 7061
Reviews 277
Hi Kitty15

Firstly, I want to compliment you on your writing, as it is in fact, in my humble opinion spectacular. Here are a series of nitpicks. Hopefully they will help with the editing.
Kitty15 wrote:Chocolate used to seem much too expensive and indulgent to me

Perhaps this would be better as "indulgent for me".
slicing and dicing my fingers are evidence of that.

Maybe "this"would be better than "that"
malteasers, mars bars, moments and every other chocolate beginning with m.

What is the significance of the chocolates beginning with an "m"?
in my mouth are pumping energy through my veins

perhaps "into my mouth"?
frosty bite to the air and a sprinkling of sugar on the ground.

I think the sugar metaphor is overdoing it a little.
I'm standing at my door now, just finishing this cigarette and then I'll catch my breath before I go in.

Although this is probably grammatically correct, I would suggest sticking to a single tense, as this sentence does throw the reader.
It's a little cluttered by my laptop, coffee mugs, coasters and sheets of paper

It's a little cluttered with your laptop...
The rest of the room is cluttered.

You just used the word cluttered in the previous paragraph.
But seriously, this, this is everything.

Ironically, I think that the word "seriously" in this context, undermines the seriousness of the sentence.
And the hearth, that marble slate before the cream carpet starts: that almost exhausted the funds from my latest masterpiece which, by the way, is one of those mauve, leather-bound books sitting on the mantel.

I can't help feel that this sentence is clumsy.
The laptop on the table is relatively new. It's been in a writer's possession almost six months now, since the start of this novel. Lila liked to do that... she used to purchase a computer at the beginning of every book and then she'd use it, just for that novel, nothing else. That was her name, the woman who first set her fingers on these keys, carefully choosing every word she wrote down. She was a lot more particular than me but even so, even so... I sometimes forget. It somehow feels wrong that I wasn't the one to start this novel when it's going to end so perfectly.
I'm confused, I thought you said above that the laptop was yours. If Lila is no longer around, and the laptop has passed onto you, I think you should make this clear.
it is clearly visible and evidentially safe from harm.

"Evidently", not "evidentially".

I had a lovely day. We went down to the park as planned and sat on the bench, throwing bread for the ducks. They all waddled over on their strange, webbed feet, hooting and flapping at us. I laughed so hard when he started impersonating them that I thought it might bring my period on early. Seriously! And then he took me out for a meal, all expenses on him! He dressed up real nice in a dark suit with his favourite tie (that made me smile) and I took his arm and didn't we look a pair.

I found this paragraph a remarkable contrast to the rest of the story. Yet, I still found it immature, as it does not seem realistic at all. Also, ditch the "all expenses on him, as if he took you out, its fairly obvious that all expenses were on him. If you want to finish the paragraph on a question, which I don't find to be particularly effective in this context, than I suggest you use a question mark.
The table cloth was white, the chairs nicely padded and the lighting was lovely.
You used "lovely" in the previous paragraph, it seems overused. try "sparkly" or something of the sort.
But oh, this is the way it must be! Sophie enchants me, there's something so warm and soft about her, I don't think I've ever loved any of my characters as much as I do her. This book, this will be my greatest masterpiece. No longer will I stand in the shadow of others, no longer will my books be placed on the bottom of the shelf. This is the beginning of perfection.
This seems a little random.

In a nutshell:
I would be lying if I said that this story really drew me in. In fact to be perfectly honest I found it quite a chore to read. And while there were several beautiful parts, I don't really think that this story has a particularly strong plot to it, and there are several pieces that can be confusing to a reader. I don't think that clarifying them would compromise the beauty at all. I would also suggest grabbing the reader's attention as soon as possible.

Have a good one! :)




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 5577
Reviews 672
Hey there Heather, I am back :D

The shopping bags slicing and dicing my fingers are evidence of that.


A little nit-pick, but how is the narrator carrying those bags?

The wind tries to prevent me from lighting my third cigarette, huffing and puffing... I'll blow your house down.


I like your use of allusion here. It really adds to the child-like aspect of the narrator.

The air's a little old in there, a little musty and even this sharp, grating ice has to be better than breathing in the dust and grime.


What's wrong with the sharp grating ice though?

“What the fuck do you want?” I demand, fumbling in my pocket for my cigarettes, just for the effect.


What effect? I also find it strange that she would have a cigarette in a moment like that. Crossing arms, smiling, leaning by the wall etc that I would find realistic, but not this.

I can feel the long nails etching crescent moons into my flesh but I stand there a long time, just looking out, everything forgotten.


I do not get this at all nor do I see the reason for it.

Overall impressions:

Not much I can actually say about this part. You are quite right, it isn't as good as the last part for reasons that I'm trying to grasp.

The most obvious flaw that I've noticed in this piece is the interaction between the narrator of this part and Mike. The interactions between them here doesn't really say much about Mike or on how their relationships work. Instead of focusing on the mundane, have them talk about something that actually holds more meaning and depth to it and that will allow them both to be able to express their thoughts and feelings. Seriously, if Mike made that effort to walk all the way to confront the narrator face to face, it's bound to be for something important. But what you have here right now, it seems as though it would be suited for a phone call instead. I also think that if you have made the conflict between them more active instead of being passive, then it would have been quite an engaging part.

This piece also seems sort of fragmented as I was reading this. I think this was why yrclever thought that there was no hook in this piece (when actually there was). Conceptually, it flows quite logically (except the end but I'll discuss that a bit later on in the critique) since the descriptions of what's inside the narrator's house and the narrator's taste for chocolate draw on the idea of how addictive writing can be (to the point that one doesn't take much value in their welfare). But in the ways of how it's written, it's not because of the actual flow of the sentences. It's not exactly smooth, it's somewhat jumpy in places. I'm not exactly sure as to how to exactly fix it, but I noticed that when the narrator's describing the house, she tends to describe it in parts (like a shopping list). That could be one of the reasons as to why I felt this piece seemed fragmented in a few places. I think having more action during that section would help make it seem less like a shopping list.

Still on the fragment issue, after Mike left, it seems kind of random that she would then decide to look for her book. There's no actual motivation nor trigger to it. I think it would help if you had established more of the codes of being a writer (eg: where their inspiration comes from, having to sit behind a computer screen/ staring at paper for ages, writer's block etc etc). Doing that will not only help make that bit more convincing, but it will also help the audience understand the life of being an author better. I don't think many can comprehend the hardships of being one so it's good to establish that more.

The story of Lila seems kind of weak; it doesn't really seem like a memento to the narrator. It's quite tailored to descriptions rather than the actual emotion and thoughts that one would get from such a scene. I personally would like more insight as to why Lila decided to choose a restaurant and what she thought/felt about it. There's actually quite a lot of thoughts/feelings that one would get from eating at a restaurant. One time, I invited my friends along to my birthday party at this Chinese restaurant at night. One of the reasons as to why I love that day was because I felt as though my friends were part of my family (not to mention that I was sitting next to the girl that I had a crush on haha). This is because in Chinese tradition, family members would often gather together during dinner time as a sign of respect or tribute to their family relationship. So yeah, I would really love to see more insight on that through Lila's dictation to really make that day feel special.

Overall though Heather, I like this piece. It's interesting and fairy good on the whole. Well done. I hope this critique has helped.

Good luck editing this Nano Heather, and I'll stay tuned for the next part.

Andy.
"To the edge of the universe and back. Endure and survive."




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 2816
Reviews 252
Hey, Heather. :) I thought I'd get your crit done tonight. I'll get straight into it, and give my general impressions later.

Chocolate used to seem much too expensive and indulgent to me but (with a vaguely guilty pleasure) I can admit that's changed.


I really don't like brackets in a story. They're jarring and they detract from it, because they usually have telling in them.

The walk home is tiresome but I haven't driven in such a long time that I almost think I may have forgotten how to.


I think the sentence would be better if you removed either "almost" or "may." At the moment, the two combine to make it even more uncertain, and it seems to make it almost not worth mentioning.

I'm standing at my door now, just finishing this cigarette and then I'll catch my breath before I go in.


Your sentences tend to be very long in this part. They jar a little, because most would be better if they were made into two sentences.

So will... mine.


It would read better if you cut this. It's a bit awkward.

“Damn it!” I swear convulsively.

“What the fuck do you want?” I demand,

“No thank you,” he says firmly.

“What do you want?” I ask sulkily,


The dialogue here is a big problem. Well, not so much the dialogue as what follows it. Remember, "said" is your friend. ;) Also, kill the adverbs. It can be forgiven for now, because you wrote it for NaNo, so telling is almost impossible to avoid. Now that it's over, though, you should get rid of them.

“Sounds good,” he replies. “See you then.”


This entire conversation happens very fast. It would be good if you drew it out. Like Andy said, it'd give us a better idea of the relationship between them, which I'd like to see explored more.

I won't comment on any more specifics, as Andy and Joseph seem to have covered them all. I will give you my impressions, though.

There was a massive change in style in between Part 1 and Part 2. Part 2 had a different sentence structure, which put me off a little. To be honest, it took me a while to get into it. When I did, it was enjoyable, but the long sentences drag out the story and make it seem longer than it is.

Your characters don't have very much depth to them yet. We know a little about them, but this is just the beginning. I won't comment on them in this part, because I'm confident that you'll flesh them out more in the coming chapters.

The only other big problem you have in this is telling. You do it a lot, probably more than you show. Most of it is through adverbs, but some of it is in narrative statements. Try to show these things in your description and the dialogue itself, and the story will be a lot better. Sorry I couldn't be of much help.

That said, I really enjoyed reading it. I'll be waiting for the next part. Nice job. ;)

-Mat



I wondered why we put villains in our stories when we have plenty of them in real life; then I realized that maybe we wanted stories where the good guy wins.
— nogutsnoglory