rise over run

4 posts
Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 2608
Reviews 37
this ice, dislodged, falls togetherly and sharp
the aching break, the sweet slide
the sounds secretly greening within the bough as it
slowbuoyed, these are as nothing

to the fall
once the fall;

a slump and a depth where was dome
in the second ground that lies pale here
and the bough springs up like birds
have taken flight.
Last edited by Helpful McHelpfulpants on Mon Feb 21, 2011 5:00 am, edited 2 times in total.
Nunc lac est bibendum.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 28282
Reviews 884
I think what really makes this poem work is how well it reads aloud, and it just rolls perfectly off of your tongue. You use really good alliteration and rhythm, giving it a nice flow. I'm not completely sure how much I like the last line, though; I think it could've ended on a better note. All the same, I liked this.
Keep writing,
StoryWeaver
Reading is one form of escape. Running for your life is another. ~Lemony Snicket




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 789
Reviews 44
Hey,

Okay, so maybe you need to add a bit of punctuation in there, commas at the ends of lines maybe?
But I like this, it's a bit short but flows nicley.

Gerry :)
"Winner, winner, chicken dinner" Wise words said by the one and only, Dean Winchester.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 26101
Reviews 1335
HELPPANTS.

I saw this tree covered with ice bending from the pressure, bending, bending, bowed, and then! Released. But I felt like I skipped over these lines:

to the fall
once the fall;

a slump and a depth where was dome
in the second ground that lies pale here


They didn't seem to hold as much imagery as the others did, and I feel like I felt this whole image, this motion, and this feeling without them. Unless there's something in those four lines that I missed, you might consider cutting them or replacing them with something of a little more substance.

I am going back and re-reading it as well, and though I love the ice imagery in the first, it seems disconnected when working through it -- actually more like watching ice dislodge over a new spring stream, not connected to the tree at all.

I am so sorry if I am missing some deeper meaning, but I am enjoying so much this simple, beautiful described moment, and remembering how much I've always envied your talent for describing things that are in daily life. It's spot on, it's clear to me.

One other suggestion:

as nothing


I think this should just be 'nothing'. That's how I consistently read it, and I don't think it changes the meaning to take out "nothing", because we read that you're describing a physical object so it can't actually be nothing.

Might want to bring the ice back in at the end somehow, if the ice is meant to connect to the bough. C: Thank you, Helppants. I missed you!

- Hannah -
you can message me with anything: questions, review requests, rants
are you a green room knight yet?
have you read this week's Squills?



Who, being loved, is poor?
— Oscar Wilde