The Kirja (Chapter One)

18 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4206
Reviews 362
So, I'm gonna confess, that I have read nearly every Warrior book out there.
you're gonna have to work super hard tp make your work original.

Your grammar was a bit iffy.
Her sister were called True, nearly all black but she had a maroon speckle under her left eye and her right ear looked like it was dipped in maroon paint, True was closer to Lakea’s size but still bigger than the undersized pup.

You had sentences like these.

Her sister were called True, who was nearly all black except for the few maroon speckles making her look like she was dipped in maroon paint. True was closer to Lakea’s size but still bigger than the undersized pup.

Thats a simple edit that makes it easier for the reader.
Keep Writing
~WickedWonder
'We will never believe again, kick drum beating in my chest again, oh, we will never believe in anything again, preach electric to a microphone stand.'

*Formerly wickedwonder*




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 323
Reviews 83
Thank you for your review Shubhi, it was really informative. (: I have been working my way through this chapter and it is almost fully 'de-longsentanceised'. I will certainly take your suggestions into account when I'm editing and writing the future chapters.
Avatar (c) to Thalia - A great friend of mine




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 30338
Reviews 560
Hey Crimson! I've here to review your novel! The glitch monster ate my review the first time I typed it out, so if anything here doesn't click together, feel free to ask me about it.

First things first - corrections
It doesn't look very good when someone reviews your work and you don't edit it accordingly - it seems a bit like you're ignoring your reviewers. I made this mistake too when I first started posting chapters of my own novel. Even if you edit it on your computer, post the updated copy. That way other reviewers won't waste time picking out the same mistakes or repeating the same things, and they'll be able to check back on your progress.

The opening;
The opening is a turn off. Your first chapter, first paragraph, first line, have to catch your readers attention, so having an info dump (that bit in bold) right at the start isn't going to do that. Instead, your reader will look for another story that does. If there is crucial information that your reader needs to know, incorperate it into the story.

The characters:
I think what this chapter is lacking is that initial bond that your reader needs to make with the main characters. This chapter seems to be told from a very strict third person perspective. You need to bring your characters to life a bit more. Chose one of them, and give your reader a reason to be interested in them, or to want to follow them. Here you mentioned Lakea as being the runt of the litter, which is a great start - everybody loves the underdog. Emphesising this and creating a rivalry between her and her siblings would be an easy way to get your reader to follow her.

She became known as...
How? There are different ways people inherit their name. Some people 'come to be named' something by their parents, or 'end up being called' something by those who have no other name for them. They 'come to be known as' something if they have a different name, but (usually in a story of a famous hero) people or the public call them something else because it's easier to remember.
Lakea would 'be named' something rather than 'be known' as something, because it's her parents who would give her this name.

Overall:
I like it. This is an interesting plot and perspective to take on. You should take advantage of that. Use the opportunity to really get inside the head of a wolf, explore their nature and use this to spice up your writing. As a first chapter you need to start on something a bit more exciting though, maybe following one of the wolf parents hunting for food. Don't be scared to use animal stereotypes to characterise the wolves too.

On to part two.
We were born to be amazing.



Writing is my soul made tangible on paper.
— bluewaterlily