Swing Chapter 5

5 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 23443
Reviews 193
This is still a little rough around the edges but I hope that you will enjoy it. Thanks for your critiques :D

Chapter 5
My first mistakes





“Lila, wake up,” gentle hands shook me awake. “I know it’s early, but you’ll be in trouble if you don’t hurry.” I yawned and sat up. I rubbed my arms to try and warm myself up, and winced as I passed over bruises from falling by the carriage yesterday. James was leaning over me; he smiled and held out a hand. I took it and he pulled me to my feet.

“Thank you,” I said blushing.

He led me out of the cellar by the hand. We passed through the kitchen, where the cook was preparing breakfast on a tray. She was plump and friendly looking, I immediately warmed to her. She handed me and James a piece of bread each.

“You’re not supposed to have this, but your both as skinny as a bone. Don’t tell anyone where you got it and eat it quickly,” she said ushering us out of the kitchen, and into the hall. James grinned as he chewed the bread.

“She has always had a soft spot for me,” he mumbled through a mouthful of food. I couldn’t help smiling along with him, his mood was catchy.

I stared around the hall as I chewed my bread. Large tiles covered the floor. They were decorated with various grand patterns. A beautiful painting of Jesus and heaven covered the dome shaped ceiling, and a grand marble staircase led upwards to what I assumed was the master’s chambers.

James took me by the hand and led me up the stairs. We walked along a corridor and it struck me that the whole house was just as grand and ornate as the hall that we had just been through. We stopped outside another carved oak door.

“This is master’s office, he’ll be in there waiting for you,” James said dropping my hand. I chewed my bottom lip nervously. “Go on.”

I raised my hand and tentatively knocked on the door.

“Enter,” a gruff voice grunted from inside the office.

I took hold of the handle and glanced back at James. He smiled encouragingly and gently pushed me in the small of my back.

“Go on,” he repeated.

I twisted the handle and stepped into the room. The first thing I noticed about the office was that it was dark. The curtains were still drawn, and the only light came from a small oil lamp that hung in the corner of the room. There was a musty scent in the room, like light hadn’t touched it for a long time.

Bookcases lined the walls, they contained thick volumes. The closest I had ever come to a book was the fairytales Charlie and my Mother used to tell me. Those stories were always exciting, but these books looked thick and dull and I had no desire to read them. On top of the bookcase was an ornate vase, there were some flowers in it, but they were withering and dying. I wondered why the master didn’t change them.

A large oak desk dominated the room; it was covered in papers and files. Behind it sat the master in a high backed, plush chair; he was staring at me intently.

“Are you quite finished examining my room?”

“S...Sorry,” I stuttered staring at the floor to avoid his gaze. He grunted and leaned forward in his chair peering at the papers on his desk as if seeing them for the first time.

“Ah, here we are,” he said, pulling a sheet from under a pile of documents. “Your rota.”

He handed me the sheet of paper and I glanced at it curiously. It showed the chores that I was to complete each day, and the allotted times I had for lunch and dinner. I was stunned by the amount of work, but I was pleased that my last job of the day was feeding and mucking out the horses. I loved animals and I would at least get to see them, maybe even stroke them and feed them from my hand.

“I expect these tasks to be completed to an exceptional standard. Today, you will be shown how to do these tasks by one of my servants.”

I was pleased about this; I wasn’t sure how to make a bed to an “exceptional standard.” The master peered down his glasses at me.

“You realise that if you do not complete these tasks each day, to the standard that you will be shown, then you will be severely punished. You are somewhat of an experiment. I am tired of paying for my household to be run, I want to see whether threatening you and beating you will get the jobs done as well as they are done by those who I pay.”

I shuddered at the words ‘threatening’ and ‘beating’.

“The chimney sweep boy was the start of the experiment, and so far he seems to be doing the job well, so I expect you to do the same.”

I nodded, still looking at the rota. After what he had said the tasks suddenly seemed a lot more daunting. I had to get them all done, and they had to be done well, otherwise I guessed that I would taste his belt. I tried to imagine what a beating would feel like, but I couldn’t, and I didn’t want to find out.

The master pulled a cord and I heard a bell ring, somewhere outside in the hall. A moment later there was a knock on the door.

“Enter.”

A woman entered. She bowed her head in the direction of the master and gripped my upper arm.

“I trust you know of your instructions?” The master asked curtly. She nodded and steered me out of the room without a word. The oak door swung shut behind us and the woman turned to me.

“I want to help you, but if you fail at the tasks then I will also be punished, so I will have to be hard on you at times. Please don’t think too unkindly of me,” she said in a lilting Irish accent. I smiled to show her that I would be a good student and her expression softened.

“I’m Susan.”

“Lila,” I said smiling up at her.

“That’s a pretty name.”

I nodded in thanks and she took the rota from me. She read it through quickly and her face fell.

“That’s a lot to have to do in a day,” she whispered and I could see her mentally counting the hours. I bit my bottom lip with worry. How was I going to manage to do all of the work if a grown adult thought it was a lot?

“What will the Master do to me if I don’t get it done?” I asked before I could stop myself. Susan looked up from the rota, she had a shocked expression on her face and she didn’t answer for a long time.

“I don’t know sweet, I really don’t know.”
Thinking about what you COULD achieve will get you no where. You've got to chase your dreams.
http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/viewtopic.php?f=188&t=92400 - Need a review?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 44360
Reviews 1087
Hey Lydia!
You haven't got any reviews on this so far, so I thought I'd help you out.
I haven't read the first few chapters so I'll probably fail epically. :roll:

Red = Corrections/negatives
Blue = Thing I like
Bold = My comments/suggestions

Chapter 5
My first mistakes

“Lila, wake up,” gentle hands shook me awake. “I know it’s early, You don't really need this comma. but you’ll be in trouble if you don’t hurry.” I yawned and sat up. I rubbed my arms to try and warm myself up, and winced as I passed over bruises from falling by the carriage yesterday. James was leaning over me; he smiled and held out a hand. I took it and he pulled me to my feet.

“Thank you,” I said blushing.

He led me out of the cellar by the hand. We passed through the kitchen, where the cook was preparing breakfast on a tray. She was plump and friendly looking, I immediately warmed to her. It's good that you said this, but I want to know how she's friendly looking. She handed me and James a piece of bread each.

“You’re not supposed to have this, but your both as skinny as a bone. Don’t tell anyone where you got it and eat it quickly,” she said ushering us out of the kitchen, and into the hall. James grinned as he chewed the bread.

“She has always had a soft spot for me,” he mumbled through a mouthful of food. I couldn’t help smiling along with him, his mood was catchy.

I stared around the hall as I chewed my bread. Large tiles covered the floor. They were decorated with various grand patterns. A beautiful painting of Jesus and heaven covered the dome shaped ceiling, and a grand marble staircase led upwards to what I assumed was the master’s chambers. I liked this description!

James took me by the hand and led me up the stairs. We walked along a corridor and it struck me that the whole house was just as grand and ornate as the hall that we had just been through. This sentence sounded a bit awkward and a bit long. Try rephrasing it maybe? Something like ~ As we walked along the corridor, something struck me. The whole house was as grand and ornate as the hall we'd just been through. We stopped outside another carved oak door.

“This is master’s office, he’ll be in there waiting for you,” James said, dropping my hand. I chewed my bottom lip nervously. “Go on.”

I raised my hand and tentatively knocked on the door.

“Enter,” a gruff voice grunted from inside the office.

I took hold of the handle and glanced back at James. He smiled encouragingly and gently pushed me in the small of my back.

“Go on,” he repeated.

I twisted the handle and stepped into the room. The first thing I noticed about the office was that it was dark. The curtains were still drawn, and the only light came from a small oil lamp that hung in the corner of the room. There was a musty scent in the room, like light hadn’t touched it for a long time.

Bookcases lined the walls, they contained thick volumes. The closest I had ever come to a book was the fairytales Charlie and my Mother used to tell me. Those stories were always exciting, but these books looked thick and dull and I had no desire to read them. On top of the bookcase was an ornate vase, there were some flowers in it, but they were withering and dying. I wondered why the master didn’t change them.
I loved this description as well. :wink:

A large oak desk dominated the room; it was covered in papers and files. Behind it sat the master in a high backed, plush chair; he was staring at me intently.

“Are you quite finished examining my room?”

“S...Sorry,” I stuttered staring at the floor to avoid his gaze. He grunted and leaned forward in his chair, peering at the papers on his desk as if seeing them for the first time.

“Ah, here we are,” he said, pulling a sheet from under a pile of documents. “Your rota.”

He handed me the sheet of paper and I glanced at it curiously. It showed the chores that I was to complete each day, and the allotted times I had for lunch and dinner. I was stunned by the amount of work, but I was pleased that my last job of the day was feeding and mucking out the horses. I loved animals and I would at least get to see them, maybe even stroke them and feed them from my hand. You don't necessarily need this.

“I expect these tasks to be completed to an exceptional standard. Today, you will be shown how to do these tasks by one of my servants.”

I was pleased about this; I wasn’t sure how to make a bed to an “exceptional standard.” The master peered down his glasses at me.

“You realise that if you do not complete these tasks each day, You don't need this comma. to the standard that you will be shown, then you will be severely punished. You are somewhat of an experiment. I am tired of paying for my household to be run, This should be a period. I want to see whether threatening you and beating you will get the jobs done as well as they are done by those who I pay.” Oooo... harsh :xd:

I shuddered at the words ‘threatening’ and ‘beating’.

“The chimney sweep boy was the start of the experiment, and so far, he seems to be doing the job well, This comma would be better as a period. soso I expect you to do the same.”

I nodded, still looking at the rota. After what he had said, the tasks suddenly seemed a lot more daunting. I had to get them all done, and they had to be done well, otherwise I guessed that I would taste his belt. I tried to imagine what a beating would feel like, but I couldn’t; and I didn’t want to find out.

The master pulled a cord and I heard a bell ring, Don't need this here. somewhere outside in the hall. A moment later there was a knock on the door.

“Enter.”

A woman entered. She bowed her head in the direction of the master and gripped my upper arm.

“I trust you know of your instructions?” The master asked curtly. She nodded and steered me out of the room without a word. The oak door swung shut behind us and the woman turned to me.

“I want to help you, but if you fail at the tasks then I will also be punished, so I will have to be hard on you at times. Please don’t think too unkindly of me,” she said in a lilting Irish accent. I smiled to show her that I would be a good student and her expression softened.

“I’m Susan.”

“Lila,” I said smiling up at her.

“That’s a pretty name.” I agree :wink:

I nodded in thanks and she took the rota from me. She read it through quickly and her face fell.

“That’s a lot to have to do in a day,” she whispered and I could see her mentally counting the hours. I bit my bottom lip with worry. How was I going to manage to do all of the work if a grown adult thought it was a lot?

“What will the Master do to me if I don’t get it done?” I asked before I could stop myself. Susan looked up from the rota, she had a shocked expression on her face and she didn’t answer for a long time.

“I don’t know sweet, I really don’t know.”


Overall

Wow! I really liked this. It's gotten me very interested in it and I definitely want to read more! I haven't really got much to critique about this, mainly because I haven't read the first few chapters. Therefore, I can't really comment on character progression or anything like that.

When it comes to the nit-picks, your grammar isn't perfect. You sometimes put commas where they shouldn't be or not put commas where they should be. :wink: I've highlighted the areas where you do this and included some suggestions. Although your grammar isn't perfect, it definitely isn't the worst case I've ever seen; not by far. I'm pretty sure that there are a few thread's about commas around YWS. Maybe you could take a look at one of them and hopefully get some good advice? I have a feeling that Demeter wrote a good one... If I find a link, I'll post it here!

I feel useless now... :lol: I can't think of anything else to critique. I adored some of your descriptions. I mostly liked your description of the Master's room. I especially liked it when you mentioned the old books that reminded your MC of her family. That was a nice little touch. You're really good at descriptions as a whole, actually! As well as describing scenery, you're also very good at describing actions.

My only small critique about your descriptions is that you tend to only describe using one sense. You did describe the scent of the Master's room and the Master's voice, but you could have done a bit more. Outside the Master's room, for example. Were the hallways silent or were they bustling with the noise of other people? You described the Master's room well but you could have described the things outside the room a bit more, as well.

You also didn't really describe what anyone looked like. You might have done this in other chapters though, so I'm sorry if you have! If you haven't, what does the Master actually look like? I can tell that he is a vicious, angry man. I'm not too sure what he looks like though. You didn't describe what the woman on the end looked like either. Was she skinny and mouse-like? Or was she short and plump? The same goes for the cook at the beginning; you said that she was plump but I'd like to know more.

I do have to say though, I really liked the characters themselves. I also like their names, especially your MC's name. I think that her name seems to suit her, or at least what I know of her so far! All that you need to do now is put some faces to those names. :wink: Like I said before, your descriptions were very, very good! I wish I could describe like you can. What I love mostly about your descriptions is the fact that they're not in annoying clumps. I hate it when there are very good descriptions in a piece of writing but they are in horrible clumps. Thankfully, you don't do this at all. You have little sprinkles of descriptions here and there; perfect! Plus, there aren't any spelling mistakes in this. :wink:

Sorry if I haven't been much help! If you post the next part of this, be sure to ask me for a review in my WRFF thread. I'd happily check it out. :)

Keep writing and good luck,

xoxo Skins
I didn't know what to put here so I put this.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 58538
Reviews 553
Hi Lydia1995. Here on request.
Shall we get to the nit-picks first?

“Lila, wake up,” gentle hands shook me awake. “I know it’s early, but you’ll be in trouble if you don’t hurry.” I yawned and sat up.

The red part seems as if Lila is saying this(due to the presentation. try to start the dialogue in the next line and after its complete add- she/he said, if possible.

He led me out of the cellar by the hand. We passed through the kitchen, where the cook was preparing breakfast on a tray.
LOL we don't prepare breakfast or for that fact anything on a tray. You should either try- setting up the breakfast on the tray.

She was plump and friendly looking, I immediately warmed to her.
I am not sure of warmed should be here. Thry- She was a plump woman with friendly nature adn this made me pass her a warm smile to her.

"Don’t tell anyone where you got it from and eat it quickly,” she said ushering I liked the word here. us out of the kitchen, and into the hall.


“She has always had a soft spotcorner for me,” he mumbled through a mouthful of food.I couldn’t help smiling along with him, his mood was catchy infectiousThis sounds more cool.


A beautiful painting of Jesus and heaven covered the dome shaped ceiling, and a grand marble staircase led upwards to what I assumed was the master’s chambers.
Shubhi likes it! :)

He smiled encouragingly and gently pushed me in the small of my back. The bold part is a bit awkward.


There was a musty scent in the room, like light hadn’t touched it for a long time.
What is light to do with musty smell? I probably don't know.

I am tired of paying for my household to be run, I want to see whether threatening you and beating you will get the jobs done as well as they are done by those
whom I pay.”


After what he had said, the tasks suddenly seemed a lot more daunting.


She bowed her head in the direction of the master and gripped my upper arm.
I think the bold part very messy, I didn't like it reading. Try: She bowed her head in respect to the master and then held me tight by my upper arm.

“That’s a lot to have to do in a day,” she whispered and I could see her mentally counting the hours.
If Susan is counting the hours mentally then how can Lila see. :lol: This was funny, Lydia.


Now I just gave you a review from grammar point of view but I'll read your other parts and return later to comment on the story. :D I think this was an average piece, maybe because I didn't know the story. I am not in a state to comment more.
I would need more emotions here if possible and more description of the people. Like you could've described the cook and Susan more and guessing by the atmosphere, i think the story is based in England so let me get that feel.

Would definitely come back! :)

Signing off till then! :superman:
"Next time you point a finger
I might have to bend it back
Or break it, break it off
Next time you point a finger
I'll point you to the mirror"

— Paramore




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 23443
Reviews 193
Thanks to the both of you, these were really helpful comments :D
Thanks for the suggestion about finding a thread on commas, I never really know where to put them! :lol:

Shubi I hope you enjoy the other chapters. Thanks for reading them.

If you two have anything that you would like me to review then drop me a PM and I will see what I can do.

~Lydia
Thinking about what you COULD achieve will get you no where. You've got to chase your dreams.
http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/viewtopic.php?f=188&t=92400 - Need a review?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 15421
Reviews 158
Hi ledge
I like this. I love the way that you are gradually going through Lila's life.
The bit I like most in this chapter is when Lila meets the master and he says she will not be paid if she does well but she will be punished if she does badly, I think that it really does show how some people acted towards their servants.
Can you pm me when you post more?
midnightread :elephant:
P.S Good luck at Sterts over the summer.
The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing.
A wise man does not need advice and a fool won't take it.


Growing old is mandatory,
Growing up is optional.


Rugby is a thugs game played by gentle men,
Football is a gentleman's game played by thugs.



In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit. Not a nasty, dirty, wet hole, filled with the ends of worms and an oozy smell, nor yet a dry, bare, sandy hole with nothing in it to sit down on or to eat: it was a hobbit-hole, and that means comfort.
— JRR Tolkien