Young Writers Society


Kate v. Zane

9 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10262
Reviews 77
“Stay,” she whispers, but he pretends not to hear. “Please stay?” She pulls her thin and stringy brown hair out of her eyes, her bright blue eyes trying to see if he would show some remorse, or even a single sad look, but his back is already turned.

“Don’t you ever think, Kate?” His words are sharp, strange, as his voice once would flow as easily as a river. “I don’t have the time for your games anymore!”

“Don’t just leave again, that's not fair. Please Zane?” Kate’s voice is even softer, but she doesn’t stop him as he opens the passenger door.

He steps out, but before he closes the silver car door, he bends over and talks sweetly again. "Kate, you know i love you, don't you? Eventually I'll prove it to you again, i swear." But then he pulls himself away from the car and slams the door, hard, taking all the meaning out of his words.

She puts her car into gear and drives off, the few stray tears left in her falling down her too-pale cheeks. It even surprises her, as she hadn't cried since the night he turned so sharp. She passes the turn to her job, then skips the turn into her neighborhood. But she doesn’t even see that. All she can see is the road ahead of her, the gas pedal under her foot.

"No!" Kate yelled again, laughing. "You can't read that!" She sat on her knees, feeling the grass beneath her fingers. The small hill just past their high school had a slight breeze, ruffling her hair but keeping his perfectly gelled black do in its exact spot. She pulled her bag away from him, but he grabbed the envelope that poked out of her bag. "No!" She giggled again, hoping that he would not open the mortifying note.

Zane held the filched envelope in his hand, smiling at her. "What's in it?" He shakes it a bit, and then he broke the seal. Her face turned somehow even paler, and then it blushed at the cheeks a fiery red. He pulled the notebook paper out, unfolded it softly, and then smoothed out the creases. "Sara," he read in a regal voice. "I think th-"

She made a grab for the note. "I put it in a sealed envelope for a reason," she cried, reaching for the paper.

Zane pulled the note away. "I think that I'm in love, how am I supposed to know? I'm only seventeen, after all. I'm just the girl who wears t-shirts of bands and things that nobody's heard of before, the girl who is average height and weight and intelligence and general being." Kate kept reaching for the paper, but he kept pulling it away. "His name is Zane."

This time when she reached for it, he didn't pull the note away, but stood as if in a trance. "Are you for real?" He whispered, but didn't wait for the response. He pulled a paper from his bag, and wrote something on the back of a math worksheet, then passed it to her.

Her name is Kate.

Kate looked up at him, his head just a few inches above hers. Then she threw her arms around his neck.

She drives past the city limits, underneath the curtain of rain, through the tears, and into the night.
Last edited by EmiAnne on Mon Jun 07, 2010 1:43 pm, edited 5 times in total.
Courage doesn't always roar. Sometimes courage is the quiet voice at the end of the day saying, "I will try again tomorrow"
-mary anne radmacher




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 12298
Reviews 124
Hey there! I'm Trish, and I'll be reviewing your story this evening! Just beware that I like to nit-pick. So let's get started! :D

Nit-Picks

“Stay,” she whispers but he pretends not to hear.


You should probably have a comma between 'whispers' and 'but'.

“Please stay?”She pulls her bangs out of her eyes, her bright blue eyes piercing him, but his back is already turned.


Needs a space between the end of the dialogue and the start of description.

“Don’t just leave, please stay,” Kate’s voice is even softer, but she doesn’t stop Ray as he unlocks the passenger door.


This is a bit awkward, and you can change the comma at the end of the dialogue to a period so it won't be so run-on-ish.

“You know, I kind of do want to stay. But you know, I’ve got to go. I do want to stay forever, I promise you. Someday, I… I will.”


A bit of an odd thing for him to say. *shrugs*

It even surprises her, for she thought she was empty since he started being so sharp. She passes the turn to her job, then the turn to her neighborhood. But she doesn’t even see that- all she sees is the road ahead of her, the gas pedal under her foot.


This is also a bit awkward. Maybe reword it as well. Also, the dash in the last sentence is unnecessary, and can easily be changed to a period.

She drives and drives.


A bit of an odd way to end it. Maybe reword it a bit.

And that's it for the nit-picks.

Overall

This is a bit short, and it doesn't really have much of a plot. But that will porbably change once you continue it.

Also, I noticed that you lack description and character development, and as a result, it's not that interesting. You should add that so that it's more interesting, and a bit longer.

Also, as I said earlier, there were a few awkward sentences that should be fixed, but there's not much else because it's so short.

And lastly, I noticed that Kate's dialogue was a bit repetitive. Maybe reword her dialogue so it isn't like that.

I hope that you continue it, and I'm interested to see what you do next with it. This is a good idea that you have here. Good luck with your continuation!

I better go though. Hopefully, I'll see you around the site sometime, and I'll keep a look out for future chapters. Good luck, and bye bye for now!

~ Trish :smt006
~ Patricia Tina :smt006

Don't look in the spoiler.

Spoiler
I lost the game.

"I always hear punch me in the face when you're speaking, but it's usually subtext."
~ Dr. John Watson




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7036
Reviews 53
Hello, my name is Kate. This was pretty well written! Although, I have a few comments:

EmiAnne wrote:“Please stay?”she pulls her bangs out of her eyes


'she' would not be capitalized because it's still apart of the dialogue.

Again, here:

EmiAnne wrote:“Can’t you ever think, Kate?” his words are sharp


EmiAnne wrote:“Don’t just leave, please stay.”


You would end this sentence with a period because this sentence ends there.

EmiAnne wrote:Someday, I… I will.” but then


This is the same as above. A simple grammar mistake.

EmiAnne wrote:It even surprises her, for she thought she was empty since he started being so sharp.


This sentence is confusing. What surprises her? Why is she empty? When did he start being sharp?

Overall

I thought this was a touching story, but it needs some history! Also, work on the clarity too. There were sentences that were not very easily understood. I hope I pointed out the major sentences I had trouble with, but read back through and you should catch them.
By the way, I love your protagonist's name! ;) Good Job! Keep writing and I'll be looking forward to the continuation!

-Kate
"Sometimes it is said that man cannot be trusted with the government of himself. Can he, then, be trusted with the government of others?"

-Thomas Jefferson




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 44887
Reviews 816
Hello EmiAnne

I'm not going to nitpick, since that's already been done.
I'm just here to give you a few tips that might help out next time.
Firstly, this is short. Maybe make a bit longer?
I can see this is probably an emotional piece so add some depth so us readers can understand the characters and their feelings.
Also, add some descriptions, it seems sort of bland right now.
Other than that, this was interesting.
Keep it up!

~Pink.
There are three rules for writing a novel. Unfortunately, no one knows what they are.
-W. Somerset Maugham




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5407
Reviews 75
Aw, wow, so sad! I really felt what Kate was feeling, good name by the way. She's on the verge of getting on her knees and begging for him to say, but his words are so cold, it really wouldn't have made a difference if she had.
Why do guys have to be so cold? Why can't they just click like we girls click when we're dating a guy, it's so unfair!
But, anyways, loved it!
The heart wants, the body needs, and the mind suffers. - me




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10262
Reviews 77
Thanks for all these responses! I can't believe I got so many of them at one time... and so fast! Thanks for my nitpicks and general plot suggestions, it really helped. I had no idea what my story was going to be so thanks for the help, it was really... helpful. I sound really repetitive now. But, really, thanks so much. I'd love any help ever, it helps... this sounds really pathetic now. :pirate1:
Courage doesn't always roar. Sometimes courage is the quiet voice at the end of the day saying, "I will try again tomorrow"
-mary anne radmacher




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5567
Reviews 98
this is really really nice, leaving out the few confusing sentences. well the people above have already said everything that needs to be looked at. overall it was a really nice story perhaps you can use this as a preface instead of the first chapter because of its length, also as others have mentioned its needs to be longer and characters more descriptive, still it was really nice

i really like the way you wrote it so please if your writing another chapter please please let me know, id love to read it.

budding-
## My thoughts are stars I cannot fathom into constellations ##




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 4804
Reviews 69
Hey there! It's Dink!

I loved the flashback, and this is pretty intriguing. I think everybody else got the nitpicks, so I'm going to just give you a few suggestions. i think it would be better if you sort of explained why he's leaving. You show us them as they are happy, and them as they are sad, but not how they changed. That has a major impact on the story, and I think it would be a little less confusing if you did that. Although, the mystery is what intrigues me about the story, so depending on your storyline, you might just disregaurd that suggestion.

Well, that's all I've got for now. PM me if you post another chapter!
-youreit
I smile, because I'd rather have laugh lines than a perma frown. :)




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 300
Reviews 0
That was an awesome story. Maybe tell a little more about the characters. I love the flashback part.



First you broke my moustache, now you break my heart.
— MaybeAndrew