Why not the Gentleman?

14 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1802
Reviews 261
Putang Ina! Move your car to the left!” I was seething mad at the idiot student driver blocking the gate out of Ateneo de Manila University. He had bumped the chain link fence with his shiny yellow Porsche and sat in the driver’s seat like a scared puppy. I got out of the car and into the rain and tore open the driver’s side of the Porsche. It slammed into the fence again. The kid gave a frightened squeal. I grabbed him by the collar and shook him. “Move your car—“ I let go abruptly as the guard put a hand on my shoulder and told me to go back to my car. He got into the driver’s seat himself and moved the stupid bee of a car to the side. I got into my Honda and amidst a chorus of car horns skidded into the traffic of Katipunan.
I stepped on the accelerator and pressed the horn several times. A thousand answering horns coupled with angry shouts roared in the air. I swerved past a tricycle. The driver cursed me loudly. I reached the U-Turn slot, ignored the Men in Blue flagging me down. I needed to get to Makati.
When she called me I was half-way through a make-up math class. It was 8:30 in the evening. She was slurring, sobbing, hiccupping, but then, that’s usually her language now. All I knew was that she was in Divino’s bar along Makati Avenue. The rest of the story I’ll hear from her later.
It wasn’t like I knew her for a long time. I met her just a few months ago at a party in the upper district of Metro Manila. I went out for a smoke in the parking lot. Her head was in the bushes, vomiting her guts out. Out of pity, I went to her. I recognized her as a girlfriend of a friend. I recognized her as one of the many pretty girls that walked around school. I asked if she was ok, she instantly put her hands on my chest and her face on my neck. She smelled like stale food and gin and her hair was wet from her own vomit. I put her arms around my neck and walked her back inside. I looked for Paolo, last time I knew they were together.
Paolo drew back visibly when I sat the girl down on the chair beside him.
“Shit. Is that Clara?”
“Your girlfriend.” I pointed out.
“Pare, she smells like shit.” He stood up and walked away. “You take her home. You’re a fucking gentleman right? She lives in Alabang. Ask around for Villavicencio.” Paolo laughed as he turned away.
A fucking gentleman.
So I drove her home, and so I met her. Drunk, vomiting, smelly Clara Villavicencio. All she ever seemed to do was party and drink, party and drink. Get high. Get screwed by one guy after another. Difficult as it may seem to imagine, she loved every single one of those guys. She gave out her heart bit by bit and threw up her soul little by little.
And I became the bestfriend. And like all the clichés I was the bestfriend who cared and was never cared for back. But in Paolo’s words, I’m a fucking gentleman.
Clara loved guys who treated her like shit. She craved for them hitting her a few months into the relationship. She loved it when they blew smoke down her throat or poured beer down her blouse. She loved it when she was left to open the car door for herself. It was part of the drama of love, she said. Love isn’t love when there is no pain. So I watched the pain of her love as night after night she sold her soul for an ounce of faux amore from the guys.
I tried to interfere countless times. I’ve broken the nose of so many guys that my own knuckle was permanently dislocated. It seemed like a metaphor for myself. That dislocated piece of bone that still kept hitting at Clara’s impenetrable wall. I tore away the cigarettes from her lips and the bottles from her hands. I’d have done it forever but then one day she informed me of my nothingness. Of me being the nobody.
Putang Ina. Who the hell do you think you are? You’re nobody, nothing in my life. What the fuck do you think you’re doing?” Then later that night, she’d call me up, and I’d pick her up, like always.
But I stopped interfering. I became a bystander to her ruin. Well, the bystander who picked up the pieces of the ruin and drove them home every night. Being Clara’s friend was like watching a figurine fall and break on the floor. I picked up the pieces, the sharp edges wounding my own hands, and I lay them all on the table gently—only to have some other guy sweep them off in a second and scatter them to the floor again.
I wiped the vomit off her face and washed it off her hair. I didn’t yell at her or hit her or even cared if she puked all over my car. I opened the doors for her. I picked her up in the middle of god-knows-where in the middle of god-knows-what-hour-of-the-night. I hit the bastards who hurt her. I listened when she talked about how all guys are jerks, except you of course, except you. You’re a gentleman.
Then why not the gentleman?
Why not the guy who actually did give a damn about her?
And as I drive Clara home, a bruise on her cheek, beer on her dress, sleeping soundly in the passenger’s seat, I ask her silently; Why not the gentleman? Why the fuck not the good guy?

Author's note: Putang Ina is a tagalog swear word. It seemed fitting because of the setting of the story.
All that I'm after is a life full of laughter, as long as I'm laughing with you.:)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 20503
Reviews 370
I know they always say that critiques that just gush aren't helpful, but wow. That was good.
The only thing I would say is to put paragraph one after paragraph three. I know you're supposed to start with the action; but I was a little confuddled as to when the first paragraph happened; and not a good kind of confuddled. It was rather off-putting, actually.
But the rest of the story was so brilliant I'll forgive you.
And one other thing; though I like the way the story is told; i feel like i need a few details on the girl; to help flesh her out; because right now she feels a bit like, i don't know, an object. She's more figurine than human. Just a little something--the color of her vomit-coated hair, the pattern on her dress.
But i really, really loved this story Kudos.
Naked I came from my mother's womb, and naked I will depart.
*Le Bible
Royal Reviews Here!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10262
Reviews 77
That was a pretty sweet story. You're gonna have a part two, right? Well, accually, this could stand alone, if you wanted it too...

I agree with Empress, you need to give a few more details. But I think the first paragraph gives a... suspense, or something, as to why he's so mad. You should keep it where it is.

Um, all I really have to say is that you skipped a comma...
And I became the bestfriend. And like all the clichés [comma] I was the bestfriend who cared and was never cared for back.


Besides that I didn't see any big nitpicks, so... I'll shut up now.
Courage doesn't always roar. Sometimes courage is the quiet voice at the end of the day saying, "I will try again tomorrow"
-mary anne radmacher




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 4804
Reviews 69
*Cue applause*

This was really good. The only thing I saw that could be improved was to maybe add a bit more description. But other than that, this was amazing. You did the cliched "guy in love with his best friend and she doesn't see him that way" without it sounding cliched. Bravo!

-youreit
I smile, because I'd rather have laugh lines than a perma frown. :)




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 15698
Reviews 369
Hi KnightlyAngel09. I'm Conrad Rice, and I shall be your reviewer for today.

So, this story is confusing. We have the entire first part devoted to the main character's morning drive. Why? There is no reason for us to be hanging out with him at that point. You could open the story with him taking his math test, and talking about his drive in, and it would be much better.

I'm not feeling any kind of connection to any of the characters, or even to the setting. In fact, if you hadn't said something about Tagalog, I would not have had a single clue to where this takes place. You need to throw in some better hints as to the location. To tell the truth, I am still not definitely sure.

But your characters are rather bland. The main character, though you say he's a gentleman, doesn't seem to behave like one aside from what he does for the girl. Does a gentlemen get out of his car and assault people, and then ignore cops? I doubt it. The girl also doesn't have any defining features other than her just making a series of bad relationship choices. Surely there is more to her than that.

This story also doesn't seem to go much of anywhere. If we found out a reason for why the girl doesn't like gentlemen, and it affected your main character, then I would say that it went somewhere. But she makes no such revelation, and her continued mistakes don't change your main character really, so the story really has no theme.

Also, I'm no prude, but I do find it hard to believe that people curse that much unless it's to provoke a reaction from someone.

There are good things in this story. Your word choices as far as description goes are rather good. Overall, what you have so far is a good plot line. The thing is, it doesn't really go anywhere. These other problems hold your story back, and you need to fix them before it can truly shine.

PM me if you have any questions, or simply wish to scream at me. Good job, and good luck.

-Conrad Rice
Garrus Vakarian is my homeboy.




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1474
Reviews 3
Hi, I'm Zephy and I'll be reviewing your piece! :D

Why not the gentleman?! I feel so sorry for him! I'd choose the gentleman!!!

CHARACTERS: I love them all! Clara is that girl who keeps going back for more crap in her life, not seeing that her best friend loves her and could make everything so much better! Though... He does need to grow some balls and tell her that... *cough >.>*

GRAMMAR/PUNCTUATION: No errors found! *though it's late and I'm tired*

Keep writing!
-Zeph




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 8198
Reviews 203
Hello
First off, I loved it. It was very good, extremely so. Actaully, I'm having a hard time critiqueing this piece. See, plot wise, it's a cliche, which came to life. Your MC's mind is original, he sounds like a guy, not too much on the emotional side, more describing. Oh, one thing I'd change is the begining with all the car things. I don't understand anything in that so it was a bit confusing and hard to relate to it. Other than that, it was wonderful. If you continue [please continue!~!!!!!] please PM me the link!
Ofir
"if you were waiting for the opportune moment... that was it." - Captain Jack Sparrow




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1742
Reviews 5
Hey, Levan here, and a review it is for your work! I see there's quite a number of Filipinos posting here as well. I don't feel so alone anymore! Yeah!

*Clears throat.* Ehrm... Now for some serious matters. The review.

It's actually pretty convenient that some of the Filipino terms (and locations) are familiar and understandable to me. The mix of Filipino and English in a story is one thing I have adored for quite some time now.

Secondly, I'm not exactly the guy who likes PoV's (Point of Perspective stories). I have found your story quite interesting though, reflecting a whole lot on a current dilemma usually seen throughout almost any state-community, and is completely realistic.

I think most parts of the current story are just perfect. You fully emphasized the ideal attribute of the main character here, and you produced a very interesting plot line for a romantic story.

That's it. I have a difficult time finding negative things for a story with such an interesting plot line. :shock:




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1543
Reviews 5
Evening, KnightlyAngel09. :)

If I didn't have a good number of Filipino friends, I wouldn't know where they were and what the heck they were saying. Also, how come you didn't italic the word 'pare' (Isn't it tagalog?)

Also, I had a tough time believing that this guy was a gentleman. Picking up your 'best friend' after another bad relationship or night but then get into a huge fit and not giving sympathy to a new student driver? It contradicts each other. Maybe you could put how he didn't want to make a fit cause he felt bad, so he just hopped out of the car and ran. Or maybe he hitched a ride from someone.

How are they best friends? Just because he picks her up all the time after shit relationships, doesn't make them great chums. She might as well call him ' my designated driver'. It doesn't sound like they hang out besides during Clara's bad bets. And why does Clara think love isn't love without pain? What is the 'gentleman's' name? (Do you want to keep it us without knowing on purpose?"

The only other thing else I have is I think using Putang Ina has less...punch when it's used the second time. But that's just my preference.




Random avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1175
Reviews 3
Hello
First off, I loved it. the car stuff was a little confusing but i loved the descriptive ability to describe everything. i read the story twice becuase i though it was so good. the plot is very good and i like the writeing. please tell my when you write more.
-adam




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1590
Reviews 6
:smt038 I absolutely loved it, and there isn't much to critique on it. One thing I would do, though, is put a little bit more description in your story. It would make the story better and more understandable.

Being Clara’s friend was like watching a figurine fall and break on the floor. I picked up the pieces, the sharp edges wounding my own hands, and I lay them all on the table gently—only to have some other guy sweep them off in a second and scatter them to the floor again.


I listened when she talked about how all guys are jerks, except you of course, except you. You’re a gentleman.

Then why not the gentleman?

Why not the guy who actually did give a damn about her?

And as I drive Clara home, a bruise on her cheek, beer on her dress, sleeping soundly in the passenger’s seat, I ask her silently; Why not the gentleman? Why the fuck not the good guy?


Those were my two favorite parts. Comparing Clara to the figurine was a very good idea. :smt038

This definitely deserves two thumbs way up! :smt023
Here comes the Sun
And I say,
It's alright~~~




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1390
Reviews 6
As everyone else has mentioned, that was amazingly written. Your writing style is very, very good.
The only concerns I have with this, and yes they have been mentioned, is your paragraphing and use of descriptive detail.
I think you broke the story down into one too many paragraphs, which is common and very easy to fix, as well as using a little more description to make your writing better than it already is. Detail was something that was lacked, very slightly but still noticeably.
All in all, great piece. I'm a little bit Pinay myself. (:




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 1776
Reviews 10
This piece is so amazing! I did find it a bit hard to understand in the beginning but that may be because I am a fast reader. The writing was very well written and I enjoyed feeling what the characters were feeling. You made the feelings come alive in your piece and that is simply amazing to do!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2548
Reviews 15
First off, I really really really reallyyyy liked this! It's really true too. There are a lot of girls like Clara and a lot of guys like... what was the main characters name? That's one of the things that bothered me about this. I appreciated the fact that you jumped right into the story, but it was kind of confusing the way you did it. The beginning was especially confusing. And seriously, I do that all the time in my own writing. I'll jump right in and then be like "Uhh... that will make no sense to a reader..." so just really try and make things clear from the beginning because it will really make a difference. Other than that, I really enjoyed this. It is very much realistic and it definitely makes a point. Great job :D

~Time8keeper
"And in that moment I swear we were infinite." -The Perks of Being a Wallflower, Stephen Chbosky



I do all of the training for Walgreen’s cashiers.
— The Devil