The Old Man

9 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 14013
Reviews 280
Brutal Critiques welcome. Nit Picks encouraged.

The Old Man

This chink, my daughters fiancé was on his way for dinner and to spend the night. Kate had called my wife a week ago. She travelled Europe with him and he preposed in Paris. This afternoon they left Auckland in his car and would be here before dinner at seven. I killed a lamb last week, hung it up and Paula had put the first hind roast in the oven. I had nothing to do these days, not since I retired. Today I read the paper, the sport and business, then tore it up and lit the fire with it.

“They’re here.” Paula called from the Kitchen. I eyed the car through the blinds, a small, green, Jap model. There was a knock at the door. I placed my glasses on a low coffee table in the small lounge and walked to the entrance. Kate hugged Paula for a while; then she shuffled past and wrapped her arms around my neck. The chink hugged my wife, and then he stepped toward me, grinned and stretched out his hand. I took his hand and shook it. His thin eyes stared into mine and his grip was firm. He was smooth and shaven and across his forehead, his flat black fringe was swept. He said his name was Ung-So. I said mine was Tom. He smelt like a woman, perhaps it came from my daughter.

Kate put her notebook computer on the dinner table whilst I carved the meat. She was showing my wife photographs of her trip. The chink leaned over the back of my daughter’s seat licking his lips and laughing at his photos like a dope.

“All ready,” I called from the Kitchen, “You want to start serving up dear?”Paula loaded up four plates and placed them on the table. I sat down and reached for the gravy. Paula as swift as a lioness batted my hand away.
“You know you can’t have gravy not with your cholesterol.” I grimaced. The Chink gobbled down the entire meal as though he hadn’t eaten in weeks.
“You can eat boy.”
“Oh- ahh thanks.”Kate and Paula threw me looks. “This is a lovely house you have Mr Donald.”
“I built most of it myself.”
“Oh that’s interesting, Kate mentioned you’re a jack of all trades.”
“Well I wouldn’t go as far-“
“Don’t be modest Tom,” My wife interrupted “You know he did most of the electrical fittings and plumbing himself too.”
“Oh wow that’s amazing.” The chink exaggerated.
“So where are you from?”
“I moved over to New Zealand when I was nine and I grew up in Wellington.”
“OK, but where were you from?” The girls stopped eating for a moment, they both gave me sharp ‘drop – it’ looks.
“Originally, Taiwan.”
“Taiwan,” I thought a moment and continued, “And what brought you to our great country?” His gaze shifted to my daughter.
“Umm just work opportunities for my parents, plus better wages.”
“Oh well I haven’t been to Asia since the Vietnam War, so I wouldn’t know.”Kate dropped her knife and fork and stared at me.
“Who wants pudding?” my wife asked as she swiftly stood up, forcing her seat into a loud slide.

We sat in silence and when Paula returned from the kitchen, she carried bowls and spoons. She left again and this time returned with a large glass dish of steaming apple crumble. She served it up and everyone heaps on whipped cream except for me. Paula and the chink talked about his work and his trip with my daughter. Kate pushed me with questions about retired life and my brothers and sisters. Again he gobbled down the food much faster than anyone else.
“That was a delicious pudding Mrs Donald, and the Dinner was amazing. Kate mentioned you get a few lambs each season, was tonight’s roast home kill?”
“Yeah, killed it last week.”
“And most of the veges are from the garden” my wife added. She then dashed around collecting the plates and offered my daughter and the chink a glass of wine. Kate asked “Red or white?”
“Either dear”
“I’ll have a red, Merlot if you have it? Do you want a glass of water hun?”
“Yeah I will have a water if you don’t mind?”
“Not a problem Ung-so.” My wife answered and enter the kitchen.
Conversation continued at the dinner table for a short while longer. I added my thoughts occasionally but something seemed to irritate me about this guy. My wife threw back her head in a snort of laughter whenever he said a joke and each time I neglected to laugh my daughter stared at me as though a huge hideous slug was moving along the ridge of my nose. The conversation halted when my wife insisted it was time for her and Kate to clean up. They carried the plates into the Kitchen and my wife called “Why don’t you two make yourself more comfortable by the fire in the lounge or Tom perhaps you could show Ung-So around the house?”

I stood up. “Come on then.” He looked confused for a moment then stood and followed me. I went to the entrance and picked up my daughter’s suitcase, he picked up his own. He followed me through the lower level of the house. I showed him the small lounge, the lounge with the television, the guest bedroom, the guest ensuite, the games room (which was once Kate’s nursery), the down stairs bathroom, then we climbed the stairs. I showed him the door to our room but not inside. I showed him Kate’s room, the one she had from age three to 19. It still had pictures of shirtless men from magazines. Her bookshelf library so small yet so deep, with fiction intended for an audience well beyond her teenage years. Her vanity mirror. Photographs from her high school balls, being head girl she attended several. Tied together and strung up on a hook above her double bed were her ballet shoes. The most recent addition to her walls was a photo of me and my wife ten years ago with our little girl’s blonde head jammed beneath my shoulder holding in one arm a framed degree and in the other her mother.

I showed him the upstairs deck, looking out over the farm. I pointed out the pine trees tucked away in the corner of the farm barely visible on the moonless night. I lead him back down stairs and the girls were sipping tea at the dinner table. My wife eyed me for a moment then jerked her head toward the small lounge. I lead him through the dining room into the small lounge.
“Have a seat.” He fell into my chair and stared at the open fire. I slid the grill across and eased myself down on one knee to stoke it up. The grill squealed closed and I walked to the vintage side board and poured my self a neat whiskey.
“You want a whiskey boy?” He stiffly jerked his head toward me and smiled weakly.
“No thanks I don’t drink.”I resisted a wince before lowering myself onto the vacant Seat. The lights were out and the fire created tall dancing shadows on the walls. The boys face appeared ominous in the light.
“Can I ask you about the war?” He began. I swallowed a mouthful of whiskey and nodded. “Did you -” he paused and looked down a moment then continued, “Did you lose any friends?” before I could sip I lowered the drink from my lips. My heart picked up and the cool glass trembled softly in my hand. I sat it between my thighs.
“No.” I lied then inhaled a full chest of air. He unbuttoned the collar of his shirt and leaned forward pressing his palms onto his knees. Something small and silver slipped from his shirt and hung from a thin chain. He quickly placed it back in his shirt. “What was that?” I demanded.
He glanced at me for a second then back to the flames. He pulled the necklace back from his shirt and on it hung a crucifix.
“It was my mothers.”
“Was she a Christian?”
“Yeah, she died when I was young but before she did she instilled faith into me, one of my last memories of her was her asking me to pray everyday. She said if I do eventually good things will happen, she made me promise.”
I stared at the necklace. My own crucifix hung around my neck and one day it will hang from my daughter's neck. I sat and sipped my whiskey and together we stared into the flames.
"Did you keep it, the promise?"
"Yeah, I did."
“Do you love Kate?”
“Yeah, I do”
I blinked out a tear and stood up to pour myself another whiskey. I downed the entire thing in one gulp and walked behind the boy in my seat. The tears were building and sat ready to drip down my cheek. I placed one hand on his shoulder.
“ Good night son.”
Last edited by joshuapaul on Thu Oct 08, 2009 10:58 pm, edited 4 times in total.
Read my latest




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 883
Reviews 16
I enjoyed this despite it not being my normal genre. (As you know I expect :) )

The Chink is a nice addition as it gives the reader knowledge of Tom's character from the very beginning which you steadily and subtly expand upon.

I'm not very good at nitpicks, especially in anything other than fantasy so I'll just stick to the overall.

Your writing is well paced throughout the whole piece and filled, if one is attentive, with emotion. The emotion and characters are what make this piece great as-well as the little things like not being allowed the gravy, adding to an already pretty solid foundation and possibly giving readers something to relate to.

The shift of perspectives was quite subtle until it was swiftly brought to a finish at around the end. Normally the sudden change in pace would seem...wrong?, for lack of a better word, to me, but with
I stared at the necklace. My own crucifix hung around my neck and one day it will be my daughters.

it works well as it shows that he doesn't just have something in common with 'The chink' but also relates to him through it.

Only thing i noticed that i think needs changing is
Something small and silver slipped from his shirt and hung from a silver chain.

the double silver clutters things up a bit here. I would suggest changing it to something else.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 7650
Reviews 147
Very Funny story and touching at the end.

I read through your story again and didn't find anything to correct, well done. Well nothing that I should be correcting just remember to use apostrophes , punctuate etc.

[/quote]
joshuapaul wrote:I downed the entire thing in one gulp and walked behind the boy in my seat.


How do you do that?

I think if I'm going to review this thing I'd just have to recommend one thing: If you're going to talk about being a christian maybe actually use the name Jesus, Christ or God at elast once. If you were trying to hint that he was christian then you didn't need to add it but you made it plain so he should use his name. Also maybe you should re-do your ending, really strike the iron while it's hot. Something like this:

[quote="joshuapaul"]“What was that?” I demanded.
He glanced at me for a second then back to the flames. He pulled the necklace back from his shirt and on it hung a crucifix. “It was my mother's.”
“Was she a Christian?”
“Yeah, she died when I was young but before she did, she instilled faith into me and taught me about God, one of my last memories of her was her asking me to pray everyday. She said if I do eventually good things will happen.”I stared at the necklace. My own crucifix hung around my neck and one day I'll pass it on to my daughter. I sat and sipped my whiskey and together we stared into the flames."Have you kept to that boy?"
"Yes,"
“And do you love Kate?” I asked
“Yeah, I do”
I blinked out a tear and stood up to pour myself another whiskey. I downed it all in one gulp and walked behind the boy. Tears perched on my eyelids, ready to drip down my cheek. I placed one hand on his shoulder.“ Good night son.”




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 14013
Reviews 280
Thanks for your replys. Hero, theres a few themes I'm really tryin to push her, one being ' Any religious faith can unite people.' Tom overcomes his racist and stubborn atitude when he realises the common ground between he and Ung-So. The fact they both wear crucifixes presses the point enough because it is a motif, it symbolises all forms of religion. I am not affixed to any religion but I can see the benefits of religion and its unparralelled ability to unite people of differant ethnicities etc. Another theme I'm trying to strike into the reader stems from the nature of 'the veteren.' Perhaps I am too subtle but Tom is a racist. He became racist in the war and still loathes anyone from Asia. He realises at the end that this boy is much like himself and therefore opens his eyes a little. So I guess the theme I'm pushing here is (at risk of sounding hackeneyed and cliche) 'Don't judge a book by its cover.' I almost wince when I confess that was a theme but its universal and applies here. Anyway small changes made enjoy!
Read my latest




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 15394
Reviews 1464
Hey there Joshua :),

I generally don't do nitpicks, but there are a few places I'd like to 'pick' at here. Overall, I think the story is impressive. As I first read it, I have to admit that it didn't grasp me as much as it could have, but the more I thought about it, the more I appreciated it, and the more I wanted to review it.


I don't think that your opening line does your story justice, dear. I'm not really fond of stories that open with a large amount of commotion or a banal description of setting. It was satisfactory to not see that here, but in another way, I don't think that starting with "This chink" suits. Perhaps if you had forshadowed his mention with other grey thoughts of the narrator, or something else, this would have seemed a bit more in place. It seems a bit on the strange side for reasons I can't exactly pinpoint, but it might have something to do with the not having Ung-so in his presence when he uses "this" to refer to him.


Small nitpick here:
She travelled Europe with him and he preposed in Paris.


To ask to marry is to propose, dear, so this should be proposed.

Throughout the story, there are quite a few places where punctuation should be in order. There's a lack of commas and semi-colons that make reading this somewhat difficult in a sense, because we can't actually distinguish between pauses and continued phrases, especially in dialogue. If you'd like me to point out where I'm talking about, I'd be more than glad to do so. :)

I like your dialogue. It's natural, something that few writers can achieve. It really displays the old man's tension clearly, and from his manners, we do see that he is a racist. Good job for not grinding that in our faces. :)


Also! Pay attention to word choice. For the most part, it's good, but in places like where you say "something seemed to irritate me about him" it's not necessary to use words like "seemed" that make your message unclear. Because this is the narrator, he either feels irritated or he doesn't. If it was Kate, then he could say that she seemed irritated, because he couldn't know for sure. Little things like this detract from the quality of writing. ;)

I do like your closing. I do think that it could have been stronger if we were able to see a little bit more of the old man's thoughts here, but otherwise, you made it clear that he softens up to Ung-so. Because we don't get much of his thoughts at that point, it kind of does make his change towards him slightly abrupt.

Good job, Joshua. Really enjoyed this. :) If I'm unclear at any point, or if you have any additional questions, feel free to send a PM my way.


- June
"I'd steal somebody's purse if I could google it and then download it." -- Firestarter




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 14013
Reviews 280
Thanks June will PM regarding punctuation!
Read my latest




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 15394
Reviews 1464
Hey Again, Joshua, :)

My punctuation corrections will be in bold.


----
This chink, my daughters fiancé, was on his way for dinner and to spend the night. Kate had called my wife a week ago. She travelled Europe with him and he preposed in Paris. This afternoon they left Auckland in his car and would be here before dinner at seven. I killed a lamb last week, hung it up and Paula had put the first hind roast in the oven. I had nothing to do these days, not since I retired. Today I read the paper, the sport and business, then tore it up and lit the fire with it.

“They’re here,” Paula called from the Kitchen. I eyed the car through the blinds; a small, green, Jap model. There was a knock at the door. I placed my glasses on a low coffee table in the small lounge and walked to the entrance. Kate hugged Paula for a while; then she shuffled past and wrapped her arms around my neck. The chink hugged my wife, and then he stepped toward me, grinned and stretched out his hand. I took his hand and shook it. His thin eyes stared into mine and his grip was firm. He was smooth, shaven and across his forehead, his flat black fringe was swept. He said his name was Ung-So. I said mine was Tom. He smelt like a woman; perhaps it came from my daughter.

Kate put her notebook computer on the dinner table whilst I carved the meat. She was showing my wife photographs of her trip. The chink leaned over the back of my daughter’s seat licking his lips and laughing at his photos like a dope.

“All ready,” I called from the Kitchen.“You want to start serving up dear?”

Paula loaded up four plates and placed them on the table. I sat down and reached for the gravy. Paula, as swift as a lioness, batted my hand away.

“You know you can’t have gravy, not with your cholesterol.”

I grimaced. The Chink gobbled down the entire meal as though he hadn’t eaten in weeks.

“You can eat boy.”

“Oh- ahh thanks.” Kate and Paula threw me looks. “This is a lovely house you have Mr Donald.”

“I built most of it myself.”
“Oh, that’s interesting, Kate mentioned you’re a jack of all trades.”

“Well I wouldn’t go as far-“

“Don’t be modest Tom,” My wife interrupted, “You know he did most of the electrical fittings and plumbing himself too.”

“Oh wow, that’s amazing,” The chink exaggerated.

“So where are you from?”

“I moved over to New Zealand when I was nine and I grew up in Wellington.”

“OK, but where were you from?” The girls stopped eating for a moment, they both gave me sharp ‘drop – it’ looks.

“Originally, Taiwan.”

“Taiwan,” I thought a moment and continued, “And what brought you to our great country?” His gaze shifted to my daughter.

“Umm, just work opportunities for my parents, plus better wages.”

“Oh well I haven’t been to Asia since the Vietnam War, so I wouldn’t know.” Kate dropped her knife and fork and stared at me.

“Who wants pudding?” my wife asked as she swiftly stood up, forcing her seat into a loud slide.

We sat in silence and when Paula returned from the kitchen, she carried bowls and spoons. She left again and this time returned with a large glass dish of steaming apple crumble. She served it up and everyone heaped on whipped cream except for me. Paula and the chink talked about his work and his trip with my daughter. Kate pushed me with questions about retired life and my brothers and sisters. Again he gobbled down the food much faster than anyone else.

“That was a delicious pudding Mrs. Donald, and the Dinner was amazing. Kate mentioned you get a few lambs each season, was tonight’s roast home kill?”

“Yeah, killed it last week.”

“And most of the veges are from the garden,” my wife added. She then dashed around collecting the plates and offered my daughter and the chink a glass of wine.

Kate asked “Red or white?”

“Either dear”

“I’ll have a red, Merlot if you have it? Do you want a glass of water, hun?”

“Yeah I will have a water, if you don’t mind?”

“Not a problem, Ung-so,” My wife answered and enter the kitchen.

Conversation continued at the dinner table for a short while longer. I added my thoughts occasionally but something seemed to irritate me about this guy. My wife threw back her head in a snort of laughter whenever he said a joke and each time I neglected to laugh my daughter stared at me as though a huge hideous slug was moving along the ridge of my nose. The conversation halted when my wife insisted it was time for her and Kate to clean up. They carried the plates into the Kitchen and my wife called, “Why don’t you two make yourself more comfortable by the fire in the lounge or Tom perhaps you could show Ung-So around the house?”

I stood up. “Come on then.”

He looked confused for a moment, then stood and followed me. I went to the entrance and picked up my daughter’s suitcase; he picked up his own. He followed me through the lower level of the house. I showed him the small lounge, the lounge with the television, the guest bedroom, the guest ensuite, the games room (which was once Kate’s nursery), the down stairs bathroom, then we climbed the stairs. I showed him the door to our room but not inside. I showed him Kate’s room, the one she had from age three to 19. It still had pictures of shirtless men from magazines. Her bookshelf library so small yet so deep, with fiction intended for an audience well beyond her teenage years. Her vanity mirror. Photographs from her high school balls, being head girl she attended several. Tied together and strung up on a hook above her double bed were her ballet shoes. The most recent addition to her walls was a photo of me and my wife ten years ago with our little girl’s blonde head jammed beneath my shoulder, holding in one arm a framed degree and in the other her mother.

I showed him the upstairs deck, looking out over the farm. I pointed out the pine trees tucked away in the corner of the farm barely visible on the moonless night. I lead him back down stairs and the girls were sipping tea at the dinner table. My wife eyed me for a moment then jerked her head toward the small lounge. I lead him through the dining room into the small lounge.

“Have a seat.” He fell into my chair and stared at the open fire. I slid the grill across and eased myself down on one knee to stoke it up. The grill squealed closed and I walked to the vintage side board and poured my self a neat whiskey.

“You want a whiskey, boy?” He stiffly jerked his head toward me and smiled weakly.
“No thanks, I don’t drink.” I resisted a wince before lowering myself onto the vacant Seat.

The lights were out and the fire created tall dancing shadows on the walls. The boy's face appeared ominous in the light.

“Can I ask you about the war?” he began. I swallowed a mouthful of whiskey and nodded.

“Did you -” he paused and looked down a moment then continued, “Did you lose any friends?”

Before I could sip I lowered the drink from my lips. My heart picked up and the cool glass trembled softly in my hand. I sat it between my thighs.

“No.” I lied, then inhaled a full chest of air.

He unbuttoned the collar of his shirt and leaned forward, pressing his palms onto his knees. Something small and silver slipped from his shirt and hung from a thin chain. He quickly placed it back in his shirt.

“What was that?” I demanded.

He glanced at me for a second then back to the flames. He pulled the necklace back from his shirt and on it hung a crucifix.

“It was my mothers.”

“Was she a Christian?”

“Yeah, she died when I was young but before she did she instilled faith into me, one of my last memories of her was her asking me to pray everyday. She said if I do eventually good things will happen, she made me promise.”

I stared at the necklace. My own crucifix hung around my neck and one day it will hang from my daughter's neck. I sat and sipped my whiskey and together we stared into the flames.

"Did you keep it, the promise?"

"Yeah, I did."

“Do you love Kate?”

“Yeah, I do.

I blinked out a tear and stood up to pour myself another whiskey. I downed the entire thing in one gulp and walked behind the boy in my seat. The tears were building and sat ready to drip down my cheek. I placed one hand on his shoulder.

“Good night son.”


-----

Okay, that's pretty much it! But some tips:

Use a comma to replace 'and' at times. It helps eliminate runons and repeated words.

In dialogue, use a comma when ending a tag that is followed by a narrating action:

EX: "I don't remember," she sighed and pushed her hair back. "It was long ago."

And also! Vary your sentence length! Some long, some short is always good. Be sure to not have any 'stray caps' in your work; words that start with capital letters where it's not necessary. Kitchen doesn't need to be capitalized in the middle of a sentence. Only proper nouns do. :)

- June
"I'd steal somebody's purse if I could google it and then download it." -- Firestarter




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 14013
Reviews 280
Thanks June, will impliment changes soon!
Read my latest




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 13816
Reviews 563
Hello joshuapaul! This is WD and I'm glad I finally got around to this. I apologize for it taking so long. When I get requests, I like to read the piece a good number of times through. :wink:

This was very well-written; despite the conciseness of the story, the characters were well-developed. Of course, you can always do more character development, but I feel that you have a very good grasp of what matters about your characters in this story and you have emphasized it effectively. The characters are well-crafted, and I am impressed by your appropriate concept of where emphasis should lie. The story contained no blatantly needless information, but I did not find it vague or empty either. Well done. My favorite part was, without a doubt, the end. You built up to the ending very well and the end was fundamentally, earnestly moving. A very impressive finale.

It looks like June has already brought up the grammar issues, and I would just like to stress her points. I know grammar is sometimes the least of our worries as writers while we seek to pour our stories out onto the page, but grammar really does provide clarity, and there were times when the grammar distracted me from what was being said. Work on that, and listen to what June has mentioned.

First, I'm just going to nitpick a few things and then give some overall suggestions and hopefully address some of your thematical elements, all right?

The Nitpicks

This chink, my daughter(')s fiancé was on his way for dinner and to spend the night. Kate had called my wife a week ago. She travelled Europe with him and he preposed in Paris. This afternoon they left Auckland in his car and would be here before dinner at seven. I killed a lamb last week, hung it up and Paula had put the first hind roast in the oven. I had nothing to do these days, not since I retired. Today I read the paper, the sport and business, then tore it up and lit the fire with it.


Okay, 'daughters' needs that apostrophe as it is possessive. But that's not why I pulled out this section. Normally, I do not like this kind of beginning, with the narrator telling us a bit of backstory. However, you did a very nice job with this and it was not boring. It effectively drew the reader in, mainly because your main character is intriguing because of his narration, I think. A lovely beginning. As for the sentences in red, they sound awkward. You switch verb tenses and it sounds very strange. "This afternoon they left Auckland" is strange because 'this' suggests present tense and 'left' is past tense. Additionally, in the sentence "I had nothing to do these days, not since I retired", you suggest different tenses as well. "Had nothing" is extremely past tense, "these days" has a present-feel and "since I retired" also suggests present tense. Really watch out for tenses and read your sentences aloud. It will help mitigate the awkwardness.

I took his hand and shook it. His thin eyes stared into mine and his grip was firm. He was smooth and shaven and across his forehead, his flat black fringe was swept.


The phrase 'black fringe was swept' is a great image, but it sounds a little awkward so mess with the wording. Also, is there a better word than 'thin' to describe his eyes?

We sat in silence and when Paula returned from the kitchen, she carried bowls and spoons. She left again and this time returned with a large glass dish of steaming apple crumble. She served it up and everyone heaps on whipped cream except for me. Paula and the chink talked about his work and his trip with my daughter. Kate pushed me with questions about retired life and my brothers and sisters. Again he gobbled down the food much faster than anyone else.


Again, watch verb tenses. "Served" is past tense. "Heaps" is present tense.

Conversation continued at the dinner table for a short while longer. I added my thoughts occasionally but something seemed to irritate me about this guy.


I think this has been mentioned, but the phrase 'seemed to irritate' also bothered me. Think about how to convey this a bit more vividly. Right now it seems a weak phrase for what your narrator is feeling.

I stood up. “Come on then.” He looked confused for a moment then stood and followed me. I went to the entrance and picked up my daughter’s suitcase, he picked up his own. He followed me through the lower level of the house. I showed him the small lounge, the lounge with the television, the guest bedroom, the guest ensuite, the games room (which was once Kate’s nursery), the down stairs bathroom, then we climbed the stairs.


I like the tour. My only issue here is Kate's nursery. I understand how this might be important to Kate's father, but I think if you're going to mention it, especially in parentheses, it warrants a reaction from your narrator. This could be conveyed by tone or by just a brief insert of his reaction. Just adding an "I remembered" would make this more meaningful. "...the games room (which was once Kate's nursery, I remembered)" It's up to you how you want to go about this, but I think the setting off by parentheses designates this as important enough for a reaction.

“No thanks I don’t drink.”I resisted a wince before lowering myself onto the vacant Seat. The lights were out and the fire created tall dancing shadows on the walls. The boys face appeared ominous in the light.


So maybe this is just me, but I would like to get a better image of the 'ominous light'. The phrase is effective, but very vague right now, and 'appeared' is an extremely general verb. I think this part is important as it is the narrator's perception of this kid, so making this image more vivid would further develop his initial view.

Again, I love the ending.

Overall

The one thing that jarred me most about this story was the way the dialogue was arranged. The problem with your dialogue is not that it is unnatural. It's that it is hard to follow. Part of this is due to grammar issues, but I think it's something to pay close attention to.


“That was a delicious pudding Mrs Donald, and the Dinner was amazing. Kate mentioned you get a few lambs each season, was tonight’s roast home kill?”
“Yeah, killed it last week.”
“And most of the veges are from the garden” my wife added. She then dashed around collecting the plates and offered my daughter and the chink a glass of wine. Kate asked “Red or white?”
“Either dear”
“I’ll have a red, Merlot if you have it? Do you want a glass of water hun?”
“Yeah I will have a water if you don’t mind?”
“Not a problem Ung-so.” My wife answered and enter the kitchen.


Here, for instance. At first, the conversation is between Ung-so and Mr. Donald. Then it is between Mr. Donald and Mrs. Donald and then you bring Ung-so back in. The lack of dialogue tags confuses me here and I had to read it a few times to realize that Ung-so had re-entered the conversation. I like that you don't overdo dialogue tags, but watch out for clarity.

Also, I would have liked to see a little bit of elaboration on the war. It's nice and subtle right now, but it's almost too subtle. Part of this is due to the confusion with the dialogue, I think, but I would suggest going back and clearing up a few things to make the war a bit more of an emphasized issue. Then, when Ung-so brings it up at the end, the reader won't have to pause and think back for a minute to remember the bit about the war.

The way you express these characters through dialogue and narration is brilliant, and I really enjoyed the looks that mannerisms of Kate and Mrs. Donald. They are coming across clear and strong. I think your characterization is well-developed as it is; however, I, personally, would have liked more body language with Mr. Donald and Ung-so. Their dialogue and the narrator was most effective in characterizing them, but more body langauge could only improve your story right now, I think.

To address your comments about theme:

Thanks for your replys. Hero, theres a few themes I'm really tryin to push her, one being ' Any religious faith can unite people.' Tom overcomes his racist and stubborn atitude when he realises the common ground between he and Ung-So. The fact they both wear crucifixes presses the point enough because it is a motif, it symbolises all forms of religion. I am not affixed to any religion but I can see the benefits of religion and its unparralelled ability to unite people of differant ethnicities etc. Another theme I'm trying to strike into the reader stems from the nature of 'the veteren.' Perhaps I am too subtle but Tom is a racist. He became racist in the war and still loathes anyone from Asia. He realises at the end that this boy is much like himself and therefore opens his eyes a little. So I guess the theme I'm pushing here is (at risk of sounding hackeneyed and cliche) 'Don't judge a book by its cover.' I almost wince when I confess that was a theme but its universal and applies here. Anyway small changes made enjoy!


I understood that Tom was a racist; it was subtle, yes, but I think your bits about the war and his attitude towards Ung-so make it clear enough. Clarifying those bits about the war will help this out, but I think it is good as is. The religion theme came across, yes, but I felt that the fact Ung-so had kept his promise was more important than the crucifix in the narrator's eyes. The way you cut off dialogue tags around there emphasizes the promise point, and that echoed louder than your religion theme in my mind. Personally, I find that promise point more powerful than your religion point in this story. The religion point is a brilliant one to make, but I feel this story lends itself more to the narrator's acceptance of Ung-so due to his keeping his promise, if that makes sense. I also got that he had become a racist in the war, but again, I feel like clarifying the war could emphasize this and lend more power to the 'epiphany' at the end.

A very good story. I really enjoyed reading this and your ending was extremely well-done. Just remember to keep an eye on your grammar and be careful about awkward verb tense shifts and hard-to-follow dialogue. Clarifying the war and more narrator body language would pack some more power into this piece, in my opinion, but I think your story is standing firmly as it is (after some grammar revision, that is). Nice job and keep writing! If you have any questions, feel free to PM me. :wink:
~ WD
If you desire a review from WD, post here

"All I know, all I'm saying, is that a story finds a storyteller. Not the other way around." ~Neverwas



I always knew that deep down in every human heart, there is mercy and generosity. No one is born hating another person because of the color of his skin, or his background, or his religion. People must learn to hate, and if they can learn to hate, they can be taught to love, for love comes more naturally to the human heart than its opposite.
— Nelson Mandela, Long Walk to Freedom