You, the Arsonist

4 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 4832
Reviews 199
You, the Arsonist
The writing exercise in front of the class
concerns a pile of leaves
depressed and repressed
stricken from nature and laid to rest
under a great fluorescent ceiling
this is a mausoleum –
no – museum
to the endless application of imagination.

Our pens set off fireworks
until the pile of leaves has caught on fire.
and the fire department has to be called
because the smoke’s alarming people in the hallway
and then, of course,
the police get involved
because they don’t like the firemen
stealing all their thunder
so they haul you,
the arsonist,
to court, and then into the slammer,
where all that grows
is wet moss
that starts fire about as well
as Jack London,
indeed he would be the first to tell you
this is dangerous stuff.
The woods are lovely, dark and deep.
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.
- Robert Frost

It cost $7 million to build the Titanic, and $200 million to make a film about it.
The plastic ties on the end of shoelaces are called aglets




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 33318
Reviews 382
Hi smorgishborg,

smorgishborg wrote:You, the Arsonist
The writing exercise in front of the class
concerns a pile of leaves
depressed and repressed
stricken from nature and laid to rest


Not sure why you have such a change of tone within the "sticken...rest" line itself. The "stricken from nature" is obviously not a pleasant thought because of the word usage and the mood it entails, while the "laid to rest" has a sort of tranquil about it - a funeral, an honor to the removed. Both these conflict with each other; it might have worked had you incorporated this perpendicular structure in the previous lines or somewhere, at least. As it stands, you don't, and that conceals a great potential that could be had with this line.

under a great fluorescent ceiling
this is a mausoleum –
no – museum


I don't like this self-reflective "no". Don't overdo it when trying to make an inverse of the thought process so the reader can read the ponderings.

to the endless application of imagination.


Sappy and painfully obvious, but it'll fly. It's not bad enough to warrant a deletion.

Our pens set off fireworks
until the pile of leaves has caught on fire.
and the fire department has to be called
because the smoke’s alarming people in the hallway


Check your tenses. "Has caught" vs "smoke [is] alarming people" , etc.

and then, of course,
the police get involved
because they don’t like the firemen
stealing all their thunder
so they haul you,
the arsonist,
to court, and then into the slammer,
where all that grows
is wet moss
that starts fire about as well
as Jack London,
indeed he would be the first to tell you
this is dangerous stuff.


I'm pretty sure that this is a reference to "To Build a Fire" - Jack London, moss, not being able to build a fire in the first place, etc. But there's no dignity in scrounging such a large part of your piece from another piece. It's good that you incorporated some of the ideas from the other story, but do you have to make it so obvious and let it eat away at half of your poem? A reference should only be a reference, nothing more.

In general, this was decent. The simplistic language is a double-edged sword; it either can provide a sense of passionate innocence (on the arsonist's part) or a detached mood. It doesn't work to have it go both ways (well, it does, but in this case that would not fit well with what the poem is trying to convey) and so the reader is forced to stop at the fork in the road and choose a path, risking going down a completely different interpretation. Keep that in mind.

Hope that helped,
Galerius




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1564
Reviews 16
smorgishborg wrote:You, the Arsonist
The writing exercise in front of the class
concerns a pile of leaves
depressed and repressed I like your choice of words!
stricken from nature and laid to rest
under a great fluorescent ceiling
this is a mausoleum –
no – museum I really love poems that have interruptions.
to the endless application of imagination.

Our pens set off fireworks
until the pile of leaves has caught on fire.
and the fire department has to be called
because the smoke’s alarming people in the hallway This line seems out of place, or maybe a bit too long?
and then, of course,
the police get involved
because they don’t like the firemen
stealing all their thunder This part is definitely my favourite!
so they haul you,
the arsonist,
to court, and then into the slammer,
where all that grows
is wet moss
that starts fire about as well
as Jack London, Maybe this would only make sense if you knew who he was?
indeed he would be the first to tell you
this is dangerous stuff.


Really good poem. The only thing I would really consider changing would be the reference to Jack London, as the audience (like myself) may not know who he is and what validity he has to this poem.
We're living in a den of theives, and it's contageous.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 8205
Reviews 62
in a header: thought, "this was perfect"
never said that before
-M
never left this sad of a reply
hope it means as much to you
as for me
I'll never say it again

It simply communicated perfectly my own heart behind the soul of writing.
Where there is No Love, there is No Question.

A dream shared becomes reality, a dream alone is a nightmare.

"She tastes lyke raiyn
and sumtimes kiwi-fruit;
and wunce...
she tasted lyke a pen-ny." <3



With great power... comes great need to take a nap. Wake me up later.
— Rick Riordan, The Heroes of Olympus