Loving grandma

3 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 19189
Reviews 110
This is the beginning of a story I started writing. It's the story of the love between a grandmother and grandaughter. This is just the beginning, so it doesn't come yet... But it will :D Sorry about the length. Critiques are VERY welcome!

I never thought I’d love my grandmother as much as I did now. Staring at her half open eyes, unfocused and hollow, I felt guilt. Guilt for not helping her when I could have; guilt for ignoring her all my life. I tried to get her attention, to catch her blank eyes of which all colour had seeped out of long ago – but nothing I did would bring her back. Nothing I did could save her.

Her pale face, now spoilt with skin that no longer had any flesh to stretch it out evenly, looked tired and used. All the efforts she’d made when she was younger to make herself beautiful; for nothing. Every bit of makeup she’d ever applied now fought against her – the heavy mascara thinning her eyelashes until they were stiff, broken spider’s legs, the cherry red lipstick she always wore breaking her lips, cracking them like old soil.

She looked so small under the thin blankets, breakable, almost. I took her hand - an assortment of delicate bones, covered in thin paper-like flesh. She didn’t even flinch when I touched her. Her hand lay in mine, limp but warm. I glanced around the clean, white room, full of cables and monitors. The cleansing smell was making me feel sick. I closed my eyes, waiting for the spell of nausea to pass.

And while waiting for my grandmother’s last breath, I began to remember how, in the most impossible time of my life, I grew from hating her bitterly to not being able to live without her.

-----------------

It was a cold November day, the kind of weather that promised snow, but broke its promise every time. Instead, there was sleet in the air, falling against the hot classroom windows and clouding them with condensation. Everyone lucky enough to sit next to a radiator huddled close to them, for once not caring about the rumours about the disgusting things that hid on the walls behind them. Across the classroom I could see my friend, Jayne, drawing faces on the condensation, and snatching her hand away from the glass every few minutes to blow some warmth onto her chilled fingers. I wished I wasn’t seated in such a central place, where The Toad had a full view of me. Being forced to listen to his droning voice was awful; especially when I couldn’t distract myself from it like Jayne was without getting myself a detention.

The Toad was our maths teacher’s nickname. His real name was Mr Todd, but no one ever called him that. He wore really huge glasses, and was the type of person that would call them ‘spectacles’. He looked really old, and acted it too, but he must have been only middle aged because he had a daughter in year nine. If I were her I’d have died with embarrassment, but luckily, somehow, she gained respect, and no one teased her about her dad being the most boring person on this planet.

I looked at the whiteboard, and saw some complicated formulas that had no meaning whatsoever. Maths was never my strong point. I could never get much more than a C. It was okay though, I was alright at everything else. Especially drama. I loved drama.
I was snapped out of my thoughts when the bell rang. The scraping of chairs sounded almost immediately, angering The Toad until he was screaming at the top of his voice. No one listened, though. No one cared what he said. They wouldn’t let anyone spoil their relief that it was the end of yet another school day. Just one more day to go and it would be the weekend. I jumped out of my chair, snatching my maths book and walking brusquely out of the classroom.

I stepped out of the main entrance, pulling on my coat as I did so. It was good to breathe fresh air again, after being stuffed in the classroom for so long with the artificial heat and the smell of other people’s sweat rushing through the ventilation. The haggle of boys and girls outside the school started growing immensely, so I quickly walked down the steps and started off to the bus stop, where I usually met my friends before we headed off on our separate buses to get home. That was the problem with St Ash’s; it was in the middle of nowhere, and the only way to get home was by bus. Which wasn’t great, seeing as being in year 10 meant lots of homework, and how were we supposed to find time to do it when the buses always came so late?

‘Hi!’ I smiled, approaching Jayne, Hannah, Mike, Ryan and Sophie.
Jayne was in the same class as me for everything apart from French (where she was in a higher set than me, having a French grandma, who made sure she practised every evening). Hannah was only in one of my classes, but I’d known her since I was small. Sophie was my mum’s friend’s daughter, and, even though she was quite shy, she was really nice once you got to know her. Mike and Ryan hung around with sometimes at break times and after school, and when they weren’t acting stupid, they were actually quite good company. A chorus of ‘hello’s’ sounded, before Hannah started telling me all about someone fainting in her science class that morning, and how the teacher did nothing about it. Hannah was always full of stories, and usually wouldn’t stop talking unless forced on the pain of death.

‘Where’s Lilly?’ I asked, finding a slight break in Hannah’s talking to ask where my closest friend was. She hadn’t arrived yet, and I was staring to wonder if she’d already left. I met Lilly when I started in secondary school, and apart from the occasional girly tiff, we’d never had a proper argument.
‘Oh, she’s gone out with Liam. She said to tell you ‘hi’, and ‘see you tomorrow’,’ Hannah replied. I nodded stiffly. Liam was her boyfriend, but, secretly, I didn’t like him at all. He was stupid, and was known to have gone out with at least five girls already, breaking up with each after a week or two. So far, Lilly had managed a week and a half. I wondered how much longer before he dumped her, too.
Just then, my bus came rushing round the corner, and, after saying bye to everyone, I got on, finding myself a window seat and starting on my everlasting homework.

As soon as I opened the door to my house, I knew something was wrong. The door wasn’t supposed to be open, for one. Mum and Dad owned a restaurant, and usually didn’t come home till late. My older sister, Cathy, was at her friend’s for the night. So, unless someone forgot to lock the door, someone was home early.
‘Hello?’ I asked, peering up the stairs, dumping my school bag in the dark corridor. There was something in the atmosphere that made me feel uneasy. Dread crawled up my throat, threatening my mouth with worst case scenarios.
‘Hello?’ I repeated, taking the stairs two at a time.
‘Isabel!’ Mum’s voice. She sounded… distressed. As if she’d been crying. Her voice was thick, almost forced. She didn’t want to speak, I could tell.
Worried, I ran in the direction of her bedroom. The door was slightly ajar, and on opening it, I found her sitting in the old wicker chair that stood in the corner of the bedroom, next to the bed. Just… sitting. Still in her work clothes; pencil skirt and grey jumper. Her dark hair, usually so immaculate, had fallen out of its bun, hanging in waves around her thin face. Her cheeks were wet, eyes red. The mascara was running down her face faster than the tears. I’d never seen her cry like this before, and it frightened me.

‘Mum…’ I whispered, flicking on the light switch. She jumped, as if only just now acknowledging my presence. Her eyes darted towards me, the distant look replaced with surprise.
‘Isabel!’ she cried, jumping out of the chair and rushing towards me, pulling me into a tight embrace. This wasn’t something she did often. The dread inside me grew even more, and for once I forgot about Lilly and Liam, forgot about all my homework, forgot about the double maths I’d have to endure the next morning. All I could feel was fear. I tore away from my mother’s arms, which were clinging so tightly around me.
‘What’s going on?’ I demanded.
Mum looked me in the eyes, her own dark brown eyes weak, for once powerless.
‘It’s just… It’s just that…’ She gulped. Forced a tiny smile.
‘What is it mum? Where’s Dad?’ A horrible thought came tiptoeing up to me, hounding my brain. ‘He’s not… he’s not hurt is he?’ I whispered.
‘No… no, Dad’s fine, sweetheart.’ Mum said, tucking a lock of hair behind her ear. ‘It’s… it’s grandma,’ Her voice broke.
I actually felt relieved.
Grandma was crabby and old and posh. She wasn’t as important as Mum, or Dad, or even Cathy. She was just there, in her neat little cottage that we visited every fortnight.

But looking at Mum’s tear stained face, I let the relief wash away in a big wave.
‘What happened to her? Is she okay?’ I asked. Despite not liking her, I didn’t want grandma dead. I didn’t want the grief that would follow, which I’d be forced to take a part in.
‘Course she’s not okay, silly,’ Mum sniffed, rubbing her eyes, making even more of a mess of her makeup. ‘She had a stroke…’ The serious face was back. Mum was on the verge of tears again.
‘Is she alright?’ I said, stupidly. Of course anyone who’d just had a stroke wouldn’t be alright. But what I really meant… was she going to survive, being so old? Did she survive at all?
‘Not really…’ mum replied, taking me seriously this time. ‘Luckily she was… found in time. And she’s going to live,’
This time I let my relief stay inside me. She was going to live. No grieving periods, no awkward funerals. It was going to be okay.
But there’s always a but. Always.
And that was why Mum was crying.
‘But… she’s not going to be the same, Izzy. Doctors don’t know if she’ll be able to speak again. She might not even be able to walk… She’s going to be like… be like a useless rag doll!’ Mum cried, breaking down in fresh tears.
I thought about it. Grandma, unable to walk and talk? She talked too much before, anyway. I wouldn’t miss her cocky comments, telling me how bad I looked. And she could hardly walk the last time I saw her anyway. So, even though it sounds mean, I didn’t feel much. Only sympathy, and that was for my mother. Grandma was her mother, after all. If something like that happened to my mother, I’d be absolutely devastated.
‘Oh God mum, that must be awful for you…’ I whispered, not quite finding the right words to say.
‘Awful for me?’ she cried, her eyes flashing with anger. ‘Don’t you think? Think about your grandma! She’s the one who’s the rag doll here! Not me!’
I backed away, put off.

‘Where’s Dad?’ I asked darkly. I didn’t want to think about my crabby grandmother anymore. Didn’t want to pretend I cared.
‘Coming home from the restaurant. Then we’re visiting her in hospital,’ Mum replied, sitting herself on the edge of her bed with a big sigh. I stood awkwardly, not quite sure what to say or do. ‘Cathy’s coming home too,’ Mum said, suddenly. This surprised me – even though Cathy and I didn’t get on, we did have one thing in common; and that was our dislike for grandma. Cathy was as stubborn as old boots; I was surprised she didn’t just tell Mum that she absolutely refused to see the miserable old cow. Obviously, she was in a nicer mood today.
‘Oh,’ I said.

The door slammed shut. Footsteps came pounding up he stairs. Dad came into the bedroom, his expression bleak.
‘Are we ready to go then?’ he said quietly. His hair was a mess, but that was normal. Dad was a very big man, and he never looked quite tidy. Today, he was wearing a crumpled shirt and jeans. It was what he wore almost every day.
‘We’re waiting for Cathy,’ Mum whispered.
A small look passed between them: the kind of look that said, ‘What on earth do we do now?’
‘I’m going to… going to…’ I said, not quite sure what excuse I could use to get out of this room. The worry in the atmosphere was starting to get me angry – why get so worked up about it all? At least grandma was sill alive.
Dad seemed to understand my need to escape, and nodded in permission. I wandered off to the kitchen, and got myself a snack.
All I could do was wait.
“Life itself is the most wonderful fairy tale.”

~Hans Christan Andersen




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1558
Reviews 13
Lilicia wrote:
I never thought I’d love my grandmother as much as I did now. Staring at her half open eyes, unfocused and hollow, I felt guilt. Guilt for not helping her when I could have; guilt for ignoring her all my life. I tried to get her attention, to catch her blank eyes of which all colour had seeped out of long ago – but nothing I did would bring her back. Nothing I did could save her.



Her pale face, now spoilt with skin that no longer had any flesh to stretch it out evenly, looked tired and used. All the efforts she’d made when she was younger to make herself beautiful; for nothing. Every bit of makeup she’d ever applied now fought against her – the heavy mascara thinning her eyelashes until they were stiff, broken spider’s legs, the cherry red lipstick she always wore breaking her lips, cracking them like old soil.

She looked so small under the thin blankets, breakable, almost. I took her hand - an assortment of delicate bones, covered in thin paper-like flesh. She didn’t even flinch when I touched her. Her hand lay in mine, limp but warm. I glanced around the clean, white room, full of cables and monitors. The cleansing smell was making me feel sick. I closed my eyes, waiting for the spell of nausea to pass.

And while waiting for my grandmother’s last breath, I began to remember how, in the most impossible time of my life, I grew from hating her bitterly to not being able to live without her.


Wow- straight away you paint a great image in my mind. Your descriptions are beautiful, elegant and not over powering. Only thing is that I am assuming this is a prologue- and prologues are hated by everyone (well maybe not everyone but you know what i mean). I think you should use your creativity and weave in the backstory in a more clever way. Even though this was well written, it doesn't really tell me much other than her grandmother is dying. Nothing is actually happening. And as a reader, I cant feel sympathy for a character I don't really know. Plus you have given to much away by your last paragraph- I now know she is going to hate her grandmother, then grow to love her but then her grandmother becomes deathly ill and has to leave her. You have to leave something out for the story! When you do finally get to the part of her grandmother dying, it wont be as much of a shock. You want to keep the reader turning the pages constantly.
Lilicia wrote:It was a cold November day, the kind of weather that promised snow, but broke its promise every time. Instead, there was sleet in the air, falling against the hot classroom windows and clouding them with condensation.(Now this sentence didnt make sense, you desciribe a cold day- but the class room is hot?) Everyone who lucky enough to sit next to a radiator huddled close to them, for once not caring about the rumours about the disgusting things that hid on the walls behind them. Across the classroom I could see my friend, Jayne, drawing faces on the condensation, and snatching her hand away from the glass every few minutes to blow some warmth onto her chilled fingers. I wished I wasn’t seated in such a central place, where The Toad had a full view of me. Being forced to listen to his droning voice was awful; especially when I couldn’t distract myself from it like Jayne was without getting myself a detention.


Again you have great description but your sentences are too long. It drags on. You want to keep them as effective as possible. But I find that I lose myself in your long sentences. It ruins the flow/pace of the story. Here is a quick rewrite of the first paragraph:

It was a cold November day. Its was the kind of weather that promised snow, but broke its promise every time. Instead, there was sleet in the air, falling against the hot classroom windows. Everyone who was lucky enough to sit next to a radiator huddled close to them. The remained oblivious the disgusting things that hid on the walls behind them. Across the classroom I could see my friend, Jayne, drawing faces on the condensation. She snatched her hand away from the glass every few minutes to blow some warmth onto her chilled fingers. I wished I wasn’t seated in such a central place, where The Toad had a full view of me. Being forced to listen to his droning voice was awful.


Lilicia wrote:The Toad was our maths teacher’s nickname (we figured that out earlier, cut this it is redundant). His real name was Mr Todd, but no one ever called him that. He wore really huge glasses, and was the type of person that would call them ‘spectacles’. He looked really old, and acted it too, but he must have been only middle aged because he had a daughter in year nine. If I were her I’d have died with embarrassment, but luckily, somehow, she gained respect, and no one teased her about her dad being the most boring person on this planet.


How old did he look? How did he act old? Why isn't his daughter bullied for having such a boring teacher for a father. You only hint at these things but don't fully explain it.

Lilicia wrote:I looked at the whiteboard, and saw some complicated formulas that had no meaning whatsoever. Maths was never my strong point. I could never get much more than a C. It was okay though, I was alright at everything else. Especially drama. I loved drama.
I was snapped out of my thoughts when the bell rang. The scraping of chairs sounded almost immediately, angering The Toad until he was screaming at the top of his voice. No one listened, though. No one cared what he said. They wouldn’t let anyone spoil their relief that it was the end of yet another school day. Just one more day to go and it would be the weekend. I jumped out of my chair, snatching my maths book and walking brusquely out of the classroom.


I see some voice in this, but not enough. Why was the toad screaming if it was the end of school? does he prefer to dismiss you himself. If yes, then write that down!

Lilicia wrote:I stepped out of the main entrance, pulling on my coat as I did so. It was good to breathe fresh air again, after being stuffed in the classroom for so long(full stop) I couldn't stand that artificial heat and the smell of other people’s sweat rushing through the ventilation was nauseating. The haggle of boys and girls outside the school started growing immensely, so I quickly walked down the steps and started off to the bus stop, where I usually met my friends before we headed off on our separate buses to get home. That was the problem with St Ash’s; it was in the middle of nowhere, and the only way to get home was by bus. Which wasn’t great, seeing as being in year 10 meant lots of homework, and how were we supposed to find time to do it when the buses always came so late?

‘Hi!’ I smiled, approaching Jayne, Hannah, Mike, Ryan and Sophie.
Jayne was in the same class as me for everything apart from French (where she was in a higher set than me, having a French grandma, who made sure she practised every evening). Hannah was only in one of my classes, but I’d known her since I was small. Sophie was my mum’s friend’s daughter, and, even though she was quite shy, she was really nice once you got to know her. Mike and Ryan hung around with sometimes at break times and after school, and when they weren’t acting stupid, they were actually quite good company. A chorus of ‘hello’s’ sounded, before Hannah started telling me all about someone fainting in her science class that morning, and how the teacher did nothing about it. Hannah was always full of stories, and usually wouldn’t stop talking unless forced on the pain of death.

You introduced to many characters at one. It is disorienting and as a reader I can take them all in. Instead, I end just brushing them aside- something you don't want a reader to do if those characters are important. Only have the characters you need at the moment, shoving them all in right now is too much.
Lilicia wrote:‘Where’s Lilly?’ I asked, finding a slight break in Hannah’s talking to ask where my closest friend was. She hadn’t arrived yet, and I was staring to wonder if she’d already left. I met Lilly when I started in secondary school, and apart from the occasional girly tiff, we’d never had a proper argument.
‘Oh, she’s gone out with Liam. She said to tell you ‘hi’, and ‘see you tomorrow’,’ Hannah replied. I nodded stiffly. Liam was her boyfriend, but, secretly, I didn’t like him at all. He was stupid, and was known to have gone out with at least five girls already, breaking up with each after a week or two. So far, Lilly had managed a week and a half. I wondered how much longer before he dumped her, too.
Just then, my bus came rushing round the corner, and, after saying bye to everyone, I got on, finding myself a window seat and starting on my everlasting homework.

As soon as I opened the door to my house, I knew something was wrong. The door wasn’t supposed to be open, for one. Mum and Dad owned a restaurant, and usually didn’t come home till late. My older sister, Cathy, was at her friend’s for the night. So, unless someone forgot to lock the door, someone was home early.
‘Hello?’ I asked, peering up the stairs, dumping my school bag in the dark corridor. There was something in the atmosphere that made me feel uneasy. Dread crawled up my throat, threatening my mouth with worst case scenarios.
‘Hello?’ I repeated, taking the stairs two at a time.
‘Isabel!’ Mum’s voice. She sounded… distressed. As if she’d been crying. Her voice was thick, almost forced. She didn’t want to speak, I could tell.
Worried, I ran in the direction of her bedroom. The door was slightly ajar, and on opening it, I found her sitting in the old wicker chair that stood in the corner of the bedroom, next to the bed. Just… sitting. Still in her work clothes; pencil skirt and grey jumper. Her dark hair, usually so immaculate, had fallen out of its bun, hanging in waves around her thin face. Her cheeks were wet, eyes red. The mascara was running down her face faster than the tears. I’d never seen her cry like this before, and it frightened me.

‘Mum…’ I whispered, flicking on the light switch. She jumped, as if only just now acknowledging my presence. Her eyes darted towards me, the distant look replaced with surprise.
‘Isabel!’ she cried, jumping out of the chair and rushing towards me, pulling me into a tight embrace. This wasn’t something she did often. The dread inside me grew even more, and for once I forgot about Lilly and Liam, forgot about all my homework, forgot about the double maths I’d have to endure the next morning. All I could feel was fear. I tore away from my mother’s arms, which were clinging so tightly around me.
‘What’s going on?’ I demanded.
Mum looked me in the eyes, her own dark brown eyes weak, for once powerless.
‘It’s just… It’s just that…’ She gulped. Forced a tiny smile.
‘What is it mum? Where’s Dad?’ A horrible thought came tiptoeing up to me, hounding my brain. ‘He’s not… he’s not hurt is he?’ I whispered.
‘No… no, Dad’s fine, sweetheart.’ Mum said, tucking a lock of hair behind her ear. ‘It’s… it’s grandma,’ Her voice broke.
I actually felt relieved.
Grandma was crabby and old and posh. She wasn’t as important as Mum, or Dad, or even Cathy. She was just there, in her neat little cottage that we visited every fortnight.

But looking at Mum’s tear stained face, I let the relief wash away in a big wave.
‘What happened to her? Is she okay?’ I asked. Despite not liking her, I didn’t want grandma dead. I didn’t want the grief that would follow, which I’d be forced to take a part in.
‘Course she’s not okay, silly,’ Mum sniffed, rubbing her eyes, making even more of a mess of her makeup. ‘She had a stroke…’ The serious face was back. Mum was on the verge of tears again.
‘Is she alright?’ I said, stupidly. Of course anyone who’d just had a stroke wouldn’t be alright. But what I really meant… was she going to survive, being so old? Did she survive at all?
‘Not really…’ mum replied, taking me seriously this time. ‘Luckily she was… found in time. And she’s going to live,’
This time I let my relief stay inside me. She was going to live. No grieving periods, no awkward funerals. It was going to be okay.
But there’s always a but. Always.
And that was why Mum was crying.
‘But… she’s not going to be the same, Izzy. Doctors don’t know if she’ll be able to speak again. She might not even be able to walk… She’s going to be like… be like a useless rag doll!’ Mum cried, breaking down in fresh tears.
I thought about it. Grandma, unable to walk and talk? She talked too much before, anyway. I wouldn’t miss her cocky comments, telling me how bad I looked. And she could hardly walk the last time I saw her anyway. So, even though it sounds mean, I didn’t feel much. Only sympathy, and that was for my mother. Grandma was her mother, after all. If something like that happened to my mother, I’d be absolutely devastated.
‘Oh God mum, that must be awful for you…’ I whispered, not quite finding the right words to say.
‘Awful for me?’ she cried, her eyes flashing with anger. ‘Don’t you think? Think about your grandma! She’s the one who’s the rag doll here! Not me!’
I backed away, put off.

‘Where’s Dad?’ I asked darkly. I didn’t want to think about my crabby grandmother anymore. Didn’t want to pretend I cared.
‘Coming home from the restaurant. Then we’re visiting her in hospital,’ Mum replied, sitting herself on the edge of her bed with a big sigh. I stood awkwardly, not quite sure what to say or do. ‘Cathy’s coming home too,’ Mum said, suddenly. This surprised me – even though Cathy and I didn’t get on, we did have one thing in common; and that was our dislike for grandma. Cathy was as stubborn as old boots; I was surprised she didn’t just tell Mum that she absolutely refused to see the miserable old cow. Obviously, she was in a nicer mood today.
‘Oh,’ I said.

The door slammed shut. Footsteps came pounding up he stairs. Dad came into the bedroom, his expression bleak.
‘Are we ready to go then?’ he said quietly. His hair was a mess, but that was normal. Dad was a very big man, and he never looked quite tidy. Today, he was wearing a crumpled shirt and jeans. It was what he wore almost every day.
‘We’re waiting for Cathy,’ Mum whispered.
A small look passed between them: the kind of look that said, ‘What on earth do we do now?’
‘I’m going to… going to…’ I said, not quite sure what excuse I could use to get out of this room. The worry in the atmosphere was starting to get me angry – why get so worked up about it all? At least grandma was sill alive.
Dad seemed to understand my need to escape, and nodded in permission. I wandered off to the kitchen, and got myself a snack.
All I could do was wait.


You have great dialogue which is good. It was realistic and also easy to read. The story starts of slow, really slow. Nothing actually happens until your MC gets home. So I would start it there. I can see real conflict in the last scene and it was the most gripping. Your MC sounds very passive- she doesn't really do much. She just describes things and doesn't really give her opinion on things until the last scene. Why wait until then to give your MC a good voice?

This is really good and I hope you found my suggestions useful. they are only my opinion so do with them as you please!

Good luck!
If I'm trying to sleep, the ideas won't stop. If I'm trying to write, there appears a barren nothingness.

Why yes, I Blog.
http://amnawrites.blogspot.com




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1779
Reviews 121
It's me again, here to review as requested.



Her pale face, now spoilt with skin that no longer had any flesh to stretch it out evenly, looked tired and used.


This sounds off I think it's the word spoilt

All the efforts she’d made when she was younger to make herself beautiful; for nothing. Every bit of makeup she’d ever applied now fought against her – the heavy mascara thinning her eyelashes until they were stiff, broken spider’s legs, the cherry red lipstick she always wore breaking her lips, cracking them like old soil.



Nice description but it doesn't flow together. I suggest something like this. Her heavy mascara thinned her eyelashes until they were stiff, like broken spider legs; he cherry red lipstick cracked her lips like dry soil.

Or something like that. I'm not good with grammar so my punctuation in my example is probably wrong but you get the point. You need to add transitions.



And while waiting for my grandmother’s last breath, I began to remember how, in the most impossible time of my life, I grew from hating her bitterly to not being able to live without her.


"I've noticed a pattern with you. You like to use flashbacks. I'm sure you no that this is very dangerous. Dreams and flashbacks tend to annoy people. I myself usually skip them. I just wonder if you could present this information without using one. After all who really sits and thinks about every little detail of an event. (Note this is my opinion, I'm not saying you have to get id of it, just giving my opinion.)

I suggest if you're going to start this. Start with the flashback and have the reader believe this is the story, then when necessary reveal what is really happening.


I was snapped out of my thoughts when the bell rang. The scraping of chairs sounded almost immediately, angering The Toad until he was screaming at the top of his voice. No one listened, though. No one cared what he said. They wouldn’t let anyone spoil their relief that it was the end of yet another school day. Just one more day to go and it would be the weekend.


I'm not sure what kind of teachers you have, but the ones I've had would force us to stay if we showed them such disrespect.


The haggle of boys and girls outside the school started growing immensely, so I quickly walked down the steps and started off to the bus stop, where I usually met my friends before we headed off on our separate buses to get home. That was the problem with St Ash’s; it was in the middle of nowhere, and the only way to get home was by bus. Which wasn’t great, seeing as being in year 10 meant lots of homework, and how were we supposed to find time to do it when the buses always came so late?


I don't want to be mean but this is my point. I want to know about the character and her grandmother, because of this I'm board of this and don't really care. Again sorry :(





The mascara was running down her face faster than the tears.


how is that possible don't tears make the mascara run.

‘What’s going on?’ I demanded.


This is a pet peeve of mine. I hate tags when used uselessly. Demand implies anger. When I here this I picture a drill Sargent. I don't think this is what you're going for. Just have her ask. Demand is to strong of a word, especially if the person is crying. Unless your character is a direct tactless kind of person, I suggest you change it.


‘But… she’s not going to be the same, Izzy. Doctors don’t know if she’ll be able to speak again. She might not even be able to walk… She’s going to be like… be like a useless rag doll!’ Mum cried, breaking down in fresh tears.
I thought about it. Grandma, unable to walk and talk? She talked too much before, anyway. I wouldn’t miss her cocky comments, telling me how bad I looked. And she could hardly walk the last time I saw her anyway. So, even though it sounds mean, I didn’t feel much. Only sympathy, and that was for my mother. Grandma was her mother, after all. If something like that happened to my mother, I’d be absolutely devastated.
‘Oh God mum, that must be awful for you…’ I whispered, not quite finding the right words to say.


Really good characterization




Ok overall it's good, I just think you have it in the wrong order put the flashback first and then move into the scene with her and her grandmother. Besides that it's really good. Your character has a unique personality and your description is great. Although it occasionally it comes off choppy. I usually have the same problem with description. I hope I wasn't too mean, but I wanted to make these reviews different from my regular and make them more detailed. I should start doing this with all my reviews. Well sorry again, and I hoped I helped.
This is one little planet in one tiny solar system in a galaxy that’s barely out of its diapers. I’m old, Dean. Very old. So I invite you to contemplate how insignificant I find you.

Death~



All hail the mighty Glow Cloud.
— Welcome to Night Vale