quite a boring poem

4 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 20
sky: subtly blushed with crimson by way of
indefinable prophesy; and, soft as cotton,
purest of mists settled, obscuring all sight.
Such was the essence of magic. It lingered,
sweet scent, and drifted upon the icy breeze;
that the innocent traveller, alone in the night:
weary feet and frosted nose; would think
to stumble over a fairy or elf among
the grasses tall and green by way of shelter
a notion not at all fantastical.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6403
Reviews 312
Hi!

Not boring so much as incredibly pretty, and calm, and soft. I love that this poem paints a picture so that we can see exactly what you're talking about, and then you have the hypothetical traveller, which, in my mind, opens the poem up to a thousand possible stories.

Such was the essence of magic. I don't like this line, mostly because it seems such a big leap from subtly describing the sky to "...and that's because it's magic!" Don't tell me it's magic (the fairies and elves give that away, anyway) but let me read the poem and decide that it's magical in itself. Personally, in the 'sky:' lines, I was looking at it as one of nature's magic, but this line just ruins the whole thing. Also I dislike the past tense.

by way of shelter Do you mean here, that the elves and fairies are looking for the shelter in the grass, or that the traveller finds them while looking for shelter? I /think/ you mean the former, but it should be clearer, otherwise it's a little akward. I also think there should be some sort of punctuation - dash, semicolon, whatever - to separate this line from the next.

All in all, it was lovely. I envy people who can write short poems as you have to say so much in so little and I love this because it captures a moment, but it also suggests a story, as I rambled about above. Gold star!

-Mars
'life tastes sweeter when it's wrapped in poetry'
-the wombats


critiques // nano




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1090
Reviews 83
Megan you are going to make me cry xxx
I just hit my computer
Because it was being slow
I need my daily Smallville fix
And it will not load the video.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 8205
Reviews 62
Well done, love.
Although, I wish you would title the thing so people would look at it.

Your poem capture images as a fairy would running through tall grass.
Your use of language is pleasant, and sometimes even particularly clever.
I wish that this poem was at least three times as long, and the main reason for that is because I feel like I am being led up to something, which happens to be...just might be....
and we give you...
I now pronounce you....
you are the lucky...
I wish you...

It's as if it was leading up to the climax, and then, decides it'd rather just go curl up and go back to sleep.
While it's a unique effect, it left the poem wanting.

Please continue writing.
And I really think you deserve more credit then you are choosing to give yourself.

-M.
Where there is No Love, there is No Question.

A dream shared becomes reality, a dream alone is a nightmare.

"She tastes lyke raiyn
and sumtimes kiwi-fruit;
and wunce...
she tasted lyke a pen-ny." <3



Live your life how you want, but don't confuse drama with happiness.
— Ron, Parks & Rec