Marriage, Who Needs It?

2 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1068
Reviews 39
This was a Companion Piece to Betty Rollin's Motherhood, Who Needs It? that I wrote for my English Final. Writing it was very entertaining, because Rollin writes in such a brisk, matter-of-fact tone. I sought to imitate her writing, and I apologize in advance for any content the reader may find controversial in any way. Oh, and don't be afraid to be harsh when reviewing! :]


Marriage: Who Needs It?

Needless to say, we are a strange species. Leave it to humans to take an act strictly for the purposes of love and procreation and mold it into the sanctimonious trend we believe to be necessary in the eyes of God and society. In reality, no other animal feels a need to remain coupled with another for reasons beyond reproduction. In fact, many kill and eat their mates, especially females. The Black Widow, being the more publicly-known example, devours her spouse immediately after she is impregnated. I suppose, like motherhood and fatherhood, the appeal lies with the outcomes of previous generations. An unhappy pair of parents is just as great a motivator as a happy pair, because children have strong desires to make work what their parents could not.
What really astounds me is how the act of marriage gained so much reverence over time and simultaneously countless negative stereotypes. I’m sure if there’s a God, he would not have wanted his invention, a union between two lovers, to become a common punch line including the word “shackle”. Little did he know he would be hoodwinked into having his beloved marriage, a once unbreakable bond necessary to gain entrance into Heaven, transform into an activity that may happen more than three times in one’s life. In addition, an equal slap to the face of God is probably how often divorce and adultery occur. It is estimated that now nearly 50% of marriages in America end through divorce. “’Till death do we part” has become an almost laughably inaccurate depiction of an actual marriage. I’m sure when our generation reaches the altar, it will prove difficult to resist rolling our eyes when that anecdote is uttered.
All-in-all, marriage has gone through some interesting changes throughout history. Today, it is not only used to legally validate love on paper, but also as a strategy to attain notoriety, property and, who could forget – money. All of these promote not some higher being’s original wishes. They promote the romanticized, sunlit, florally-smothered wedding every girl over age 2 dreams about. Then there is gay marriage, which I resent even referring to as an “issue”. Regardless of orientation, everyone has the right to cheat, divorce, re-marry and generally piss off God just the same as everyone else. I’ve never witnessed a better example of hypocrisy, the idea of straight couples claiming a certain marriage to be unnatural while 85% of all women involved in divorce claim it to be resultant of adultery. There is as well the matter of an “open marriage”. Has there ever been a more obvious oxymoron? One cannot marry another and have the disturbing freedom to be able to sleep with whomsoever they please; that’s not an open marriage, it’s dating! It baffles me. The so-called “rules” of marriage are broken at a faster rate than they are produced. This would be called “efficiency” in physics, but can only be called pathetic in what we refer to as real life.
Don’t get me wrong, I’m not suggesting the majority views marriage so naively, but I do believe it is getting out of control. I’m fairly certain we’ll reach a point at which it will be possible to unify happy couples via webcam. When this happens, I sincerely hope I’m lying peacefully in my coffin, within the same 5-foot radius as my lover, though perhaps not wife. To answer the question, “Marriage, who needs it?”…many people, I accept, do. However, countless individuals are wasting their time saying their vows right as I read this paper, some preparing to begin a life of regret, others confident in their abilities to cheat undetected. At any rate, marriage has become a habit of humans that has no correlation with how long they live, but has been ingrained in our minds as something influential on happiness. Perhaps in the distant future we will no longer be burdened by this sort of thinking, and will be able to view the act as not our divine duty, not what is presently stylish, but somewhere in between.
But for now, who needs it?
In me thou see'st the glowing of such fire,
That on the ashes of his youth doth lie,
As the deathbed whereon it must expire,
Consumed by that which it was nourished by.
(Exerpt from Shakespearean Sonnet Number 73)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1647
Reviews 57
Hey,

Obviously I've heard this piece before (Duhh), but I've never actually read it. Hmm. So, here we go...


Needless to say, we are a strange species.


Just wondering, is this how Rollins began her piece? If it is...then okay...I don't really have the right to criticize , but if not this seems like a really odd lead in. You haven't given us an example yet so the "needless to say" doesn't really make sense. I would strike out those first three words.

Leave it to humans to take an act strictly for the purposes of love and procreation and mold it into the sanctimonious trend we believe to be necessary in the eyes of God and society.


I'm not positive...but I thought that marriage was originally a religious act to prove a couple's love to their God. So technically wouldn't it be the reverse? We've molded marriage into something that is for the sake of procreation and a last name.

In reality, no other animal feels a need to remain coupled with another for reasons beyond reproduction.


There are lots of animals which mate for life...A lot of them form packs together to protect themselves. Wolves and vultures are a couple I can think of...

The Black Widow, being the more publicly-known example, devours her spouse immediately after she is impregnated.


Not always...Just sayin'... :P

Also, though it's comedic, this might not be the best example to use. I don't think a good solution to divorce and the lack of respect toward marriages would be to eat the husbands, do you?

An unhappy pair of parents is just as great a motivator as a happy pair, because children have strong desires to make work what their parents could not.


Good point.

What really astounds me

What is really astounding...

Little did he know he would be hoodwinked into having his beloved marriage, a once unbreakable bond necessary to gain entrance into Heaven,


This is just semantics, but technically that's not true.

“’Till death do we part”


Do *us* part. :D Otherwise you're promising to spend you're marriage away from your spouse. :)

All of these promote not some higher being’s original wishes.


Weirdly worded...Maybe "None of these promote what one would think a higher being's original wishes to be."

girl over age 2 dreams about.


Write out numbers. Especially ones under ten.


straight couples claiming a certain marriage to be


That comes off childish.

I’ve never witnessed a better example of hypocrisy, the idea of straight couples claiming a certain marriage to be unnatural while 85% of all women involved in divorce claim it to be resultant of adultery.


*scratches head* Unnatural=adultery? I'm not sure that's right. And adultery on their part? Or their partners? And when you say "claim" are you trying to imply that they might be lying?

This would be called “efficiency” in physics, but can only be called pathetic in what we refer to as real life.

Nice. :)

When this happens, I sincerely hope I’m lying peacefully in my coffin, within the same 5-foot radius as my lover, though perhaps not wife.


Maybe you could clarify this a little. When you read it to the class I thought at first that you were implying that it wasn't a woman.

Overall,

Well written and interesting. Though I agree with most of what you say, the tone used in this makes me want to punch you in the face and disagree just on principal. :) It's very bitter and know-it-all like. Also, if you do use this kind of tone, double check facts that you use because if they're not correct you sound like you're just making random assertions. Otherwise....very good! :) I liked the original piece a lot and this one was also good.

Nice job! :P

-Maggie
"Why kill time when you can kill yourself?"
-Voltaire



If you are tired remember it's a sign that you haven't expired
— fatherfig