You kept me alive

26 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7596
Reviews 287
I didn't read any of the previous comments before me, so if I repeat something I apologize. Also, I am not going to attempt to correct your grammar since I am not strong in that department. I got a couple nitpicks:

It only made [s]every part of[/s] her body hurt more.


Endless seconds of pain and agony of not being able to fight or defend herself.


Instead of telling us that she is enduring pain and has no way of defending herself, can you show us? You already talk about the ropes chafing her wrists and her body aching. But maybe you can be more specific, does her neck have a crick in it from being in the same position over time? Are her arms hurting from being tied to the bed? Does she have to pee? Is she thirsty? Hungry? I'd like all of this to be covered.

“Really? [s]You must be imagining things.[/s] Maybe it's [s]only[/s] the house. God knows, it's twice as old as I am.”


I think this dialouge flows better, and sounds more natural.

She couldn't remember how she had gotten here.


This seems weird to me, since you describe how the girl was abducted, which means she does remember, at least part of how she got there. She may not remember the drive there, but that's not really important.

It was the end of her practice and she packed her skates into her training bag.


I would reword this sentence to say something like: She had just finished her practice and was packing her ice skates into her training bag.

“See you tomorrow, guys!” she called to the others and [s]made her way to the[/s] exited [s]of[/s] the ice rink.


The changes I made to this sentence I think help it flow better.

The night was still young and fresh, so she decided to take the route to the park again, even though her father always scolded her, reminding her of how dangerous it was to be alone in the park as a girl.


Young and fresh sounds redundant. Why don't you say the night was still warm, that'd make more sense. Also, this is one extremely long run-on sentence. See if there isn't a place that you can break the sentence up into two sentences.

But she enjoyed walking through the park and the route to Peter was closer this way as well.


This is the second time you have used route in the same paragraph. I really don't like redundancies. Also I felt like the sentence was worded awkwardly. Maybe you could say: But she enjoyed walking through the park and it was a shortcut to Peter's.

she found peace just by sliding on the ice with her eyes closed.


Sliding doesn't seem like quite the right word. I think gliding would fit better.

Overall: I think this story has major potential. I really like the plot and your characters seem real enough. However, you do have a habit of telling us instead of showing. For instance, you give us a huge info dump about Ali and Peter's relationship. That's bad. Instead of giving us all that info all at once, break it up. Have Ali think about her relationship with Peter when she is being held captive. Have her go back in time and relive memories she had with him. That way you can show us their relationship in a way that isn't overwhelming. Plus I think that will help you beef up your characters and get them connecting with your audience. Hopefully that helped, and if you need any more reviewed you know where to find me!!
I am not addicted to reading, I can quit as soon as I finish one more chapter.




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 20
Evi
Thank you so much for your review :D I really appreciate it!

Well, my parents are both Korean, but I was born here in Germany, so I'm more fluent in German than I am in Korean ^^

A major thanks for the link! I do have lots of problems with punctuation - I confuse the German and the English one quite often, so I tend to use the German rules when I write in English and vice versa ...
I'll be sure to check that out whenever I write :D

Wow, you really did give a detailed review ;)
Thank you for pointing out all the unclear stuff - I'll try to rewrite them as best as I can!

*gives major hug*
Again, thanks a load for the review!!


asxz
No problem ^^ Thank you so much!

Sorry about all the confusing sentences; I'm working on another rewrite with the help of all the helpful reviews I got :D

Jeez, I notice now how many 'typos' I have *hides in a corner* Sorry about that again.
As for Parker ... I should have know that would happen, as I was kind of dumb and named a character in another story Parker -_-
I corrected that immediately!

Thanks :D Well, I was always interested in English, and spending a high school year in the States helped a lot, too.
It wasn't harsh at all, I think. Very thorough and helpful. I'll try to consider everything you said for following chapters!

Thanks again!


Moriah Leila
Thanks for the review :D

Thanks also for correcting all that - all my teachers tell me I have a problem with run-on sentences, and I don't know how to change that ^^"

Well, I was a little unsure about writing too much, because it's a prologue and I didn't want it to be too long. But I'll make sure to explain more, 'show' as you've said ;), when I rewrite it.

Thank you!
♥And if you go, I wanna go with you. And if you die, I wanna die with you♥




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 3
Wow, this was really good! I'm not so good at giving reviews, and now everyone has already "taken" everything there might have been to correct, so I really just wanted to say that I loved to read this. :D

The only thing I can think of is that the beginning is very confusing. But that only really made me more interested and stuff, and I'm guessing there will be more on this story?
If not then you should have explained the beginning better, and if you are planning to write more (Or already have?) then you should leave it confusing =)

Anyways; great work! *Thumbs up*
I never really needed you to love me back. You existed, and that was enough.
Please keep existing.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 794
Reviews 280
Hey!
You kept me alive. Every time I thought that this would be it, this time the pain ... everything would surely kill me, I heard your voice, and I knew you were with me. I knew, if I could hold on just a little longer, you would come and save me.

His voice penetrated the fog in her head. She tried to shake it off completely, but that didn't help. It only made every part of her body hurt more.

Hrmm, something is off here. As I was reading, I came to 'come and save me.' and thought that was the end, only to look down and see the next line may or may not be linked to the former one. Is the line in italics the voice? If so, it shouldn't be a new paragraph, as the first line of a paragraph should be able to stand on its own. If it's not, and another voice entirely, then clarify. State what she could hear, to avoid confusion.

Endless seconds of pain and agony of not being able to fight or defend herself.

Okay, I can read this two ways. It could be either:

Endless seconds of pain, and agony of not being able to fight or defend herself.
This is saying that there is pain, and not being to fight is causing agony.

The other way is

Endless seconds of pain and agony; of not being able to fight or defend herself.
This is saying there is endless seconds pain and agony, and endless seconds of not being able to fight or defend herself.

The night was still young and fresh, so she decided to take the route to the park again, even though her father always scolded her, reminding her of how dangerous it was to be alone in the park as a girl.


This sentence is a little long, what you want to do is keep one idea to a sentence. Here you have that the night was young and fresh, that she decided to take the park route home, that her father scolded her and reminded her it was dangerous. You could have three sentences, but two would suffice:

The night was still young and fresh, so she decided to take the route through the park again. Her father always scolded her for walking that way, reminding her that it was dangerous for a girl to be alone in the park.

But she enjoyed walking through the park and the route to Peter was closer this way [s]as well[/s].

The 'as well' isn't needed. Unnecessary words slow down your plot and distract the reader, taking away from the effectiveness of the sentence.

Overall, this is actually quite interesting. I enjoyed it.

What I suggest you do is show her emotional reactions more clearly. Think about what happens when you are scared, your palms sweat, you tremble, you breathe shallow and fast. Inserting descriptions like this can really portray an emotion without you having to state what the emotion is.

An example:

Tremors ran through my flesh, my muscles tensing. I could feel my heart shuddering within my chest, trying to escape the confines of bone and flesh. My tongue flicked out to run across my dry lips, which ached from being pressed together tight against the emotion threatening to escape. I took a shuddering breath, my nerves alight, and stepped out into the light.

Is better then saying "I was so nervous I was shaking", right?

Other then that, you have a really interesting little prologue here. Well done.

-Nutty
It's not easy having a good time. Even smiling makes my face ache.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 4125
Reviews 194
AHAHAH, I'm back! -gigglesevilly-

A noise like a tree branch snapping under someone's shoes disrupted the peaceful silence of the park, and she whirled around and saw a tall figure standing a few feet behind her in the shadows. Judging by the build, it had to be a man. He was dressed exclusively in black, and his hair seemed to be a dark color also. She couldn't see his face clearly, as the shadows mostly concealed it, but she did see the glint in his eyes. He was looking at her as if she were his prey.

She wanted to flee. To run towards the street, run towards Peter who was on his way, but she couldn't move. He came to her, slowly, seeming to taunt her, daring her to run.

He towered over her when he finally stopped right in front of her. A slow smile curved his lips, and he lifted a hand.

She opened her mouth to scream for help, but his hand covered her mouth and nose with blinding speed. Just as she had realized that he had a cloth in his hand that was soaked in a sweet-smelling liquid, everything went dark.


Well, I don't have much to say. It gets better every time, and the only none-nitpicking thing that really bugged me was the fact that he didn't speak. If it were my story, I'd have him chatting away with her as if they were old friends - but maybe that's not his character, I wouldn't know. It's just that, well, the whole "I'M TOTALLY SILENT AND I'M GONNA KNOCK YOU OUT WITHOUT A WORD JUST BY BEING BIG AND TALL AND DARK AND STUFFING SOME WEIRD-SMELLING CLOTH INTO YOUR FACE," seems cliche, expected. I'd make him drag it out a bit, maybe even make him act 'nice' to get her off her guard, and then when she like, turns to check the road and see if Peter's coming yet, he knocks her over the head from behind or something. That would be a little more exciting, I think.

Anyways, good job! This was much better. Can't wait to see the third revised edition! ^_^

-SELA
Well, I can't eat muffins in an agitated manner. The butter would probably get on my cuffs. One should always eat muffins quite calmly. It is the only way to eat them.

--Algernon, The Importance of Being Earnest




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6403
Reviews 312
Hi, MySunshine. I'm (finally) here as requested, and really sorry that it took so long!

So, I must be honest - I really only have a couple of things to point out here, and I haven't read the other reviews, so perhaps I'm repeating them. I'll get to those right after I tell you that it was creepy (in a good way) and well-written and I loved it.

There.

Now, the first thing I noticed is that you have a lot of pronouns, and lots of pronouns can get confusing. I love that you don't tell us their names right away, especially since she wouldn't know her kidnapper's, but it would be better if you could describe him - say, he has dark hair or something. And then in her head, she could call him by that feature. EG, Dark Hair said, blah blah blah! Mustache nodded. You know? Just as a way of clarifying, without giving up their actual names. Otherwise you end up with He was talking to him and it doesn't sound good.

Secondly, when you go into the flashback - I think you did this at the end, but not the beginning - you change the tense of the first couple verbs. Instead of It was the end of her practice and she packed her skates into her training bag. it should be It had been the end of her practice and she'd packed her skates into her training bag. I know you're not a native English speaker, but you have to change the tense so that it's clear that it's a flashback - then you leave the rest of it as it is, then at the end you do the tense thing again with the last verb. It can be confusing >.< but otherwise, the reader is left going, huh? She was just being kidnapped! So yeah.

Okay, that's the actual critiquing done. But (and maybe this is just my preference) I would love to see more atmosphere, more description, more...more! Not necessarily the people - although, like I mentioned above, you could name them that way - but what does her torture room look like? Smell like? How do the voices sound? Gravelly, soft, barking? Is her bed hard or lumpy or squishy or...you get the idea. It's just that, since she's been in here, she'd have time to notice everything, and I think it would really help the mood of the piece if you could give us a little more of that.

To sum up:
:arrow: Pronouns.
:arrow: Tenses.
:arrow: Mood.

So, as I said already, I think is a great start, it definitely has enough intrigue to keep me reading! Hope this helped, PM me if you have any questions (and again, I'm sorry it took so long).
-Mars
'life tastes sweeter when it's wrapped in poetry'
-the wombats


critiques // nano




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 20
IdunnSofie
Thank you so much for your review :D
I'm really glad you liked this!

Yes, there will definitely be more to this ;)
It's just the prologue now, and I've already written a few chapters, but right now, I'm trying to make the prologue as perfect as possible, so there won't be anything new yet. Sorry about that!

Hope you come back for the next chapter - or the revised prologue, maybe? ;)


Nutty
Thanks for reviewing!

I'm rewriting the prologue right now, and I hope it'll be done soon ;)


Sela Locke
Thank you for the review ^^
I'm glad it's getting better :D Hopefully, after a few more rewrites, it'll be as close to perfect as possible ;)


Mars
Thanks a load for taking the time for reviewing :D
I'm glad it was creepy, because that's the way I wanted it to be (although I guess I have to work on that a little more ;))

Yes, I'm trying to make more clearer who of the guy is who. I have to admit even I did get confused, which is a really bad thing ...
I'm also working on the descriptions and I hope it'll be better then ;)
It would be awesome if you came back to check out the revised prologue and the chapters that'll follow ;)


Thank you guys, you're so awesome! :D
MySunshine
♥And if you go, I wanna go with you. And if you die, I wanna die with you♥




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 21
I think this was an interesting piece- plot is definitely your strong point. I was like 'Oh my gosh!' when she actually got kidnapped like Peter and her father said.

Though, you could do a bit of work on details. I liked Evi's suggestions about setting, but I also wanted to know about the emotions that your MC was feeling. I wanted to know how your MC went through content (at the park) to annoyance (with Peter) to fear (with being kidnapped). You might want to get into some detail about how she was feeling throughout this whole thing, and what the setting looked like. It could come alive a lot more if you could describe things better.

But overall, I love your ideas! I think that this could turn out to be an awesome piece of writing! :D

Message me when you have the next installment!

-Ember
topic43954.html

Click it! You know you want to!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3129
Reviews 108
I absolutely loved this. It was creepy but really well written! Great job. I don't have anything you should improve on except in the beginning all the "he" and "him" things got confusing. I would try to make that a little more clear. Fantastic, though. Especially for someone who doesn't speak english as their first language. I'm really impressed.
... :D ...
[url]spottedturtle.tumblr.com[/url]




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 4
English isn't your first language? Wow! You put my writing to shame and It is my native language!

Well...as every1 else seems to have done a grammer check...I won't bore you with another one! Though I will say I'm a little confused at what's going on...I does jump about a little and I had to read it twice before I got it...prehaps you need to do something about that?

You might want to do just slightly more description of the park...scare us slightly more....not that I wasn't scared anyhow but a bit more would have been nice!




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 20
Ember
Thank you so much for the review!
I know it's been ages, but I finally got around to upload the newest version ;)


KailaMarie
Thanks for the review!
I'm so glad you thought it was creepy :D I didn't know if it was enough (though I wrote that whole kidnapping scene a little more detailed now), because I've never written a creepy scene before.

I tried to change that, too, so no one gets the two men confused. I hope I did that a little better.
Thanks again ;)


kestralspace
Haha, thanks :D
Yeah, I think it's kind of weird, because my English writing skills are even better than my German ones, although I technically grew up with German :lol:

I hope it's not as confusing before and it got a little more scary ^^
Let me know?


Thanks again to all who reviewed on this :D
MySunshine
♥And if you go, I wanna go with you. And if you die, I wanna die with you♥



The poetry of the earth is never dead.
— John Keats