It only made [s]every part of[/s] her body hurt more.
Endless seconds of pain and agony of not being able to fight or defend herself.
Instead of telling us that she is enduring pain and has no way of defending herself, can you show us? You already talk about the ropes chafing her wrists and her body aching. But maybe you can be more specific, does her neck have a crick in it from being in the same position over time? Are her arms hurting from being tied to the bed? Does she have to pee? Is she thirsty? Hungry? I'd like all of this to be covered.
“Really? [s]You must be imagining things.[/s] Maybe it's [s]only[/s] the house. God knows, it's twice as old as I am.”
I think this dialouge flows better, and sounds more natural.
She couldn't remember how she had gotten here.
This seems weird to me, since you describe how the girl was abducted, which means she does remember, at least part of how she got there. She may not remember the drive there, but that's not really important.
It was the end of her practice and she packed her skates into her training bag.
I would reword this sentence to say something like: She had just finished her practice and was packing her ice skates into her training bag.
“See you tomorrow, guys!” she called to the others and [s]made her way to the[/s] exited [s]of[/s] the ice rink.
The changes I made to this sentence I think help it flow better.
The night was still young and fresh, so she decided to take the route to the park again, even though her father always scolded her, reminding her of how dangerous it was to be alone in the park as a girl.
Young and fresh sounds redundant. Why don't you say the night was still warm, that'd make more sense. Also, this is one extremely long run-on sentence. See if there isn't a place that you can break the sentence up into two sentences.
But she enjoyed walking through the park and the route to Peter was closer this way as well.
This is the second time you have used route in the same paragraph. I really don't like redundancies. Also I felt like the sentence was worded awkwardly. Maybe you could say: But she enjoyed walking through the park and it was a shortcut to Peter's.
she found peace just by sliding on the ice with her eyes closed.
Sliding doesn't seem like quite the right word. I think gliding would fit better.
Overall: I think this story has major potential. I really like the plot and your characters seem real enough. However, you do have a habit of telling us instead of showing. For instance, you give us a huge info dump about Ali and Peter's relationship. That's bad. Instead of giving us all that info all at once, break it up. Have Ali think about her relationship with Peter when she is being held captive. Have her go back in time and relive memories she had with him. That way you can show us their relationship in a way that isn't overwhelming. Plus I think that will help you beef up your characters and get them connecting with your audience. Hopefully that helped, and if you need any more reviewed you know where to find me!!
