Tales of the Blacksmith

6 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 10
Hello all! :) This is my first piece of work, and is also coincidentally the prologue and first chapter in the first story of a series I am thinking of doing. Please critique and don’t be put off by the length!

Prologue: Seclusion

The Dwarves were not known for being an aggressive race; they just pursued their love for wealth, immense wealth and gold. The most skilled craftsmen belong to their race, whether it be smithing, mining or sculpting, none surpass the Dwarves in craft, and some may argue in battle. War raged across Heiligtum but the Dwarves, in their mountainous halls, had little contact with the outside world. In their homeland Khaz’ar-Tal the Dwarves lived in peace, their leader a strong and fair man kept happiness in the hearts of all. The ale was strong, the gold was plentiful and all Dwarves found themselves content.

Fall of Khaz’Mort

On the eighteenth of Mar the twenty third mining division of Kal-Rok clan went missing. Fifteen strong the group marched out of Khaz’ar-Tal at Moonrise. The usual routine went as follows, Moonrise the division leaves Khaz’ar-Tal, and taking the mine-carts they precede to the town of Khaz’Mort where they continue the cultivation and mining of the power stone.

***

This huge stone is located in the centre of Khaz’Moram, a great crater around which Khaz’Mort is situated. The stone has been speculated and praised by the Dwarves for centuries, and even before the populace divided into clans. Its sleek blue surface set a sharp contrast with the red surroundings of the hot crater. When the power stone was first discovered its seemingly moving density struck fear into the hearts of Dwarves, but upon striking the stone with a pick it was found that the stone was extremely light, so light in fact that it floated when not securely anchored. The stone its self was thought to travel acres below the Dwarves’ tunnelling system, providing enough anchorage for it to remain. Another feature the rock possessed was the power to repair. When the Dwarves mined the sacred stone it would heal and re-grow, providing an endless supply, however the Dwarves did not discover its healing abilities until after the division of the populace.

The division of the populace was seen as a great milestone in Dwarf history; it showed that they not only had desire for gold, but desire for peace. When the populace began to fall into civil war, the Dwarf council gathered at the heart of Khaz’ar-Tal and proposed the idea of division. At first there was uproar, but in time the populace began to see it as the best option in order to keep the peace.

***

Thar, the leader of the mining division led the group down the connecting passage from Khaz’ar-Tal to the underground network. The network spread an unimaginable distance under the Khaz mountain range. Dwarves trundled past on carts acknowledging the group.
“You know the drill lads, let’s get moving.” Came the gruff voice of Thar, years of dust from living underground had made his voice low and rumbling. One by one the Dwarves piled into the large travel cart. The cart was about ten foot wide and twenty long, a thick rope ran through a hole at each end, the wheels were large, finely crafted and rusting. Grunts and pants echoed around the tunnel as each Dwarf tugged on the rope. The comforting sound of metal on metal shimmered in each Dwarf’s head as the cart began to move.
“So Thar, how much stone must we mine today? It is said in the city that power usage is increasing, is it true?” Wheezed Bhar, one of the younger Dwarves.
Thar contemplated the question as he continued to pull the rope, his strong tanned arms glistening with sweat like dew on a spider’s web.
“I have heard similar Bhar and it seems true, our demand has been increased.” Was his reply.
“Gah, how much this week, it must be that blasted Gajh-Rok clan, I was always suspicious about them…” Retorted the oldest Dwarf.
“Now we’ll have none of that,” Stated Thar, “But I was told we must return to the depot with four carts worth. For that I am deeply sorry”
Moans and grumbles erupted from the group as a speck of moonlight in the distance began to grow; each Dwarf’s pupils began to dilate, adjusting from the extremely dim light from which they emerged.
“We approach Khaz’Mort,” said Thar after a while, “And,” He continued, “I must tell you all, I plan to resign…”
Not one of the Dwarves was shocked, as they had all planned to do the same.
“This will be my final mining voyage; it is no job for a blacksmith I wish to return to the forge, for that is where I am most efficient.”
“Aye! Ale all round on return to Khaz’ar-Tal!” Cheered the elderly Dwarf.
“Aye!”

The cart shuddered to a halt and fifteen relieved Dwarves stepped off, grabbed the picks and other gear from the storage underneath the cart, and marched towards Khaz’Mort. The usual hearty welcome at the exit of the great network was not received, but went unnoticed by the group. Great and white the moon hung amongst the stars, a great crescent in the sky illuminating the path towards the town. An eerie silence hung over the place. Usually filled with laughter, merriment and ale the town was the furthest southerly outpost from Khaz’ar-Tal. A great blue radiance could be seen from the tip of the power stone, however red light could be seen at the furthest end of the town.
“Maybe we should go and check that everyone is okay?” Suggested Bhar.
“Hmm, I received no news of an evacuation, and the mountains surround this settlement, the only landmark is the crater.” Replied Thar.
“Aye, the only way to leave here is back into the network.” Added the elderly Dwarf.
“We didn’t pass anyone…” Bhar mumbled.
“Thar I don’t like this.” Added another Dwarf.
“Keep your guard up and your eyes open boys…” Warned Thar as he proceeded up the rise into the town.

As the group proceeded further into the town the noise of a cracking fire could be heard, and upon reaching the town square the source of the red light was found. The inn. The only building positioned away from the others was ablaze, and with only mining gear there was no means of extinguishing it. Thar dropped his gear and ran forwards, the full intensity of the heat meeting him.
“Is anyone in there!?” He cried, his voice quivering. No reply came.
“There is nothing we can do, Thar…” Bhar stated bluntly.
“Correct, however the mystery still stands, where is everyone? It is clear that there are no survivors in the inn and it would be impossible to fit the entire population of Khaz’Mort inside it.”
“True, it is-,” Bhar started, before being cut off by a tremendous screeching noise. Fourteen of the Dwarves stood pale with fear, shivering at the noise, one remained totally calm.
“I have heard that sound before…” Came the voice of the elderly Dwarf. “We are in danger of the worst kind; we must leave this place, although I fear it is already too late.”
The screeching sounded again, closer this time. Twelve Dwarves hastened back through the town, towards the cart. Only Bhar, Thar and the elderly Dwarf remained.
The elderly Dwarf began to yell warnings. A third screech sounded, and a horrific beast grounded in front of the fleeing Dwarves.
“May the Gods help them.” Mumbled the elderly Dwarf.

The beast wielded the most beauty the Dwarves had ever set eyes on. A giant relative to the Dwarves, this female, slim and beautiful, beckoned the fleeing group with a fine hand. Fine, but deadly. Talons emerged in the place of nails, though the radiance her beauty shone through the weapons. Dead in their tracks the twelve stared in astonishment. Two foul black wings protruded from the shoulder blades of the woman. One of the twelve stepped forward, followed by the other eleven. Swiftly and smoothly, the tall beast swooped forward grabbing the twelve with grubby talons and flew away in a chorus of wails.
Balian of Ibelin: You go to certain death.
Hospitaller: All death is certain.
My friend flickers~
My photography galery:
http://embraceunreality.deviantart.com/gallery/




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 3925
Reviews 160
You know, rarely do I read about dwarves being written as main characters. I find this a cool notion, because it is so rare and fun. I actually would take a dwarf over and elf any day of the week...

but that's beside the point. This reminds me very much of the Silmarillon work that Tolkien did. I don't know why, but it does. This seems a bit vague, thoug; I think the action at the ending needs to be described a bit more, because there's no real tension here; there's no setup for the suspense. That's the only real problem I see here. Try to increase the drama and fear that the dwarves are feeling, and make it something that the reader can experience, so that the reader can feel like he's right in the middle of it all.

Otherwise, I'm happy with what I've read so far. Keep it up.
I'm advertising here: Rosetta...A Determinism of Morality...out May 25th...2010 album of the year, without question.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10554
Reviews 272
I quite enjoyed this actually. I had the sense that you the author knew a lot more about the world and the characters than I the reader did. I like that in books.

The only problems I had were, some of the dialogue. I don't know just some of it didn't seem realistic but maybe it is a character thing that they talk like that.

For example I liked this :-
“Keep your guard up and your eyes open boys…” Warned Thar as he proceeded up the rise into the town.
It seemed like something a dwarf would say lol

Although these lines, to me, just seemed kind of odd. It sort of pulled me out of the tension because they were being all proper and English :P
“Correct, however the mystery still stands, where is everyone? It is clear that there are no survivors in the inn and it would be impossible to fit the entire population of Khaz’Mort inside it.”
“True, it is-,” Bhar started, before being cut off by a tremendous screeching noise. Fourteen of the


Also this line :-
“Gah, how much this week, it must be that blasted Gajh-Rok clan, I was always suspicious about them…” Retorted the oldest Dwarf.
For some reason I thought Gah was another dwarf for a while lol

I agree with Krupp, the ending wasn't as suspenseful as it could have been. It was getting there I was worried about the dwarves but it was a bit confusing and a bit too fast. Before I knew it, it was over.

I really liked this prologue/chapter though and gave it a star :D (the first star I have given). Keep writing this please I want to know who the winged woman is and where the heck are the dwarves eek! I also want to know if Thar sruvives :)




Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 1990
Reviews 254
War raged across Heiligtum but the Dwarves, in their mountainous halls,

Comma after "Heiligtum".

In their homeland Khaz’ar-Tal the Dwarves lived in peace, their leader a strong and fair man kept happiness in the hearts of all.

Put commas before and after Khaz'ar-Tal. Also put a comma after "leader" and after "man". Also change "kept" to "keeping".

On the eighteenth of Mar the twenty third mining division of Kal-Rok clan went missing.

You mean "the Kal-Rok clan".

Fifteen strong the group marched out of Khaz’ar-Tal at Moonrise.

Comma after "strong".
Its sleek blue surface set a sharp contrast with the red surroundings of the hot crater.

Comma after "sleek". Whenever you have two words describing the same noun, you need a comma between them.

Thar, the leader of the mining division led the group down the

Comma after "division".

Dwarves trundled past on carts acknowledging the group.

Comma after "carts".

Came the gruff voice of Thar, years of dust from living underground had made his voice low and rumbling.

You do this multiple times, so I'm going to explain it once and leave you to find the wrest like it. You need to change "had made" to "having made". You need to keep it present tense when you use a comma in such a way. Otherwise you need to start a new sentence instead.

The cart was about ten foot wide and twenty long,

"Feet" not "foot".

The comforting sound of metal on metal shimmered in each Dwarf’s head as the cart began to move.

I'm not sure I like "shimmered" in this situation. Maybe "rang" or something associated with sound.

Thar contemplated the question as he continued to pull the rope, his strong tanned arms glistening with sweat like dew on a spider’s web.

This is a great description, but it's just not for this situation. A good few people would let this slide and not think much of it... But I am nitpick, hear me roar. So, describing his strong, tanned arms that glistened with sweat by comparing them to the dew on a spider's web just doesn't work. Let's break it down. Dew is a concept of clarity. How refreshing does it sound like it would be to drink a glass of morning dew? Now how about a glass of sweat...? Also, a spider web is a dainty thing that nearly falls apart in a strong wind. Now think about a strong, tanned arm.
Okay, what I'm basically saying is that you need to convey a warm, hardy feeling in such a situation. Maybe you could say the sweat glistened red from the hot coals in the crater or something.
“I have heard similar Bhar and it seems true, our demand has been increased.”

You did this a few other times, but I think one example is enough. You need to surround "Bhar" with commas. You need to do this whenever you have someone saying a name in such a way.

“Gah, how much this week, it must be that blasted Gajh-Rok clan,

You should probably try and make these clans easier to pronounce. I know you're trying to make them sound dwarfish, but you've also got to be sure that it's still not a challenge to say. This one right here is right on the borderline. So, as a warning, be careful with them.

“But I was told we must return to the depot with four carts worth. For that I am deeply sorry”
Period after "sorry".

“This will be my final mining voyage; it is no job for a blacksmith I wish to return to the forge, for that is where I am most efficient.”
Period after "blacksmith".
Great and white the moon hung amongst the stars, a great crescent in the sky illuminating the path towards the town.

Comma after "sky".

Thar dropped his gear and ran forwards, the full intensity of the heat meeting him.

"forward" not "forwards".

“Is anyone in there!?” He cried, his voice quivering. No reply came.
“There is nothing we can do, Thar…” Bhar stated bluntly.
“Correct, however the mystery still stands, where is everyone? It is clear that there are no survivors in the inn and it would be impossible to fit the entire population of Khaz’Mort inside it.”

Wow... He got over that pretty quickly... Anyway, maybe show some concern in his dialogue, and I'd ditch the word "correct". It sounds like a British professor telling his student he had the right answer.

Overall this was pretty good. The main problem was at the end how you never took the time to build up suspense or make any successful attempts at making me feel sad about all the dead dwarfs (mainly of those in the fire). So suspense is definitely something you need to brush up on, and you should try to describe what the dwarfs look like more, whether it be what clothes they wear, their hair color, defining features, etc.

Well, that's everything. Good luck with this!
Trying to get to heaven without Jesus is like climbing to the summit of Mount Everest naked. You die before it happens.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2154
Reviews 119
I think this is fantastic, your imagination makes us run wild alongside it!

The only minor flaws that I can see, which some may disagree with are the use of
the most beauty the Dwarves had ever set eyes on
and later in the paragraph
though the radiance her beauty shone through
The use of beauty twice so close together is not something I would advise, but it doesn‘t really matter, however I think you may mean the radiance of her beauty. Also
The stone its self
Which I believe should be the stone itself. However these are minor changes which you may not wish to make.

I think this is a well crafted and interesting read, and it leaves you longing for more! It is quite like the World of Warcraft novels in style. The vocabulary used is excellent and it suits the mood of this piece. There is a professional edge to the writing style that is refreshing and a valuable tool to be able to wield, I look forward to future instalments!




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 7
Good evening, Mind! I hope what I found can be of use to you tonight.

I'll tell you straight out that writing any fantasy using Tolkienian races makes the job of distinguishing your story from the rest an uphill battle, but as someone said above, it's interesting to read something from the dwarves' point of view.

Others have remarked enough on grammatical issues; for these, I would suggest taking this manuscript to a parent, a teacher, or anyone else you trust to be excellent at English to proofread it before posting. I noticed one thing that kept popping up:

“You know the drill lads, let’s get moving.” Came the gruff voice of Thar, years of dust from living underground had made his voice low and rumbling.


Quotations are never closed with periods unless you have reached the end of the sentence. Since "Came the gruff voice of Thar..." followed immediately after, close the quotation with a comma and keep the first word after the quotation in lower-case (unless that word is a proper noun, of course). Corrected, you would have

“You know the drill lads, let’s get moving,” came the gruff voice of Thar. Years of dust from living underground had made his voice low and rumbling.


(Also fixed part of the tag)

Moving on, my view on prologues is taken from Orson Scott Card, who has never encountered an interesting or relevant prologue in any story he's read. Prologues are too easily Chapters One in disguise (by actually starting the story) or an exposition dump (you know the phrase, "Show, don't tell"), and your story begins with the latter. I appreciate the information, and yeah, I can buy a stone that floats, heals, and regenerates itself, 'cause this is fantasy, but that kind of information serves the reader better when it's integrated into the story proper, where he has context to put that information to use. Take the hard route and deliver the information when it's relevant through characters and scenes connected with that information -- readers are more than happy to piece things together themselves, and find it more rewarding than having a neutral voice spoon-feed it to them.

A strange part occurs near the end, with the elderly Dwarf going,

“I have heard that sound before…” Came the voice of the elderly Dwarf. “We are in danger of the worst kind; we must leave this place, although I fear it is already too late.”


If he fears it's already too late, why doesn't he offer another solution, say, hiding? Maybe hiding is futile in the end, but 1) he has encountered the temptress before, and 2) as an elderly Dwarf, he shouldn't be so defeatist, since he's had longer to deal with crises before.

A final suggestion on my part has to do with names. Thar and Bhar doesn't do it for me unless its mentioned somewhere in there that they're related -- then I could understand the similarity in name. Names are a very important part of a character, and, done correctly, can inform the reader of the character's nature. That said, maybe you're attached to these names, so make sure their personalities are developed distinctly to avoid casting doubts on your promising creativity.

On a very positive note, I loved this paragraph:

The cart was about ten foot wide and twenty long, a thick rope ran through a hole at each end, the wheels were large, finely crafted and rusting. Grunts and pants echoed around the tunnel as each Dwarf tugged on the rope. The comforting sound of metal on metal shimmered in each Dwarf’s head as the cart began to move.


1) I think that's a novel method of transporting themselves; I could imagine the rope extending from the pits of the network all the way out to the cave entrances, unless I'm mistaken. And 2) The detail of what sounds pleasing to Dwarven ears is a solid way of describing the temperaments of the race. I argue against using the word "shimmered" there, as that's more a visual verb than "quavered" or "wavered."

Last thought: There needs to be something very compelling to the story for it to have such a nondescript title as Tales of the Blacksmith. Actually, I would try and come up with a different title altogether; that Thar wishes to retire to blacksmithing doesn't seem a strong enough force to merit naming the story.

Write on! I feel this story has the potential to go somewhere. :)
Stop thinking pessimistic thoughts. You will run out.



i think once every new ywser realizes they can manifest themselves into the quote gen by making a post about the quote gen, they make a very inconspicuous post about the quote gen, but deep in their hearts, they know they’ll see that post at the bottom of the page one day. (yeah, i see you mods. you brought this upon us)
— Avian