Pomegrante Seeds- i (his world)

13 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 53415
Reviews 1125
i
(his world)

His voice is low and pleading in her ear. It speaks of a thousand battles lost, generations destroyed, cities massacred by disease and famine. All the tragedy in the world, the awful, heartbreaking sadness that it is to be alive is layered in his words, three simple words that rip her soul and body apart.
“Please,” it begins. “Eat something.”
She buries her head deeper into the soft, downy cushions scattered on the couch. Her long hair, cascading in loops and tendrils, tickles scratchily against her cheeks. She ignores it and fights a sob, because she won’t let him know she’s crying, she won’t. Do you honestly think he doesn't know? says a voice in the back of her mind, but she ignores it.
“What about this?” he says, and she opens her eye a fraction. A pomegranate, soft and pink, seems out of place in his hard, stubby fingers.
He lays it down next to the fruit bowl sitting on the stone table and instead lays the hand on her back. It’s cold against her skin and she shies away from his touch, she doesn’t want anything to do with him. He lets a long miserable sigh out, whistling slightly as it passes his teeth, trembling in the cool, earthy air where it hangs between them. She frowns into the cushion. She would usually detest causing another being to be unhappy, but after what he’s done she can bear it. And yet the fact that he worries over her, barely leaves her side, watches over her and is only hurt by what she is doing to herself makes her feel uncomfortable.
So slowly she sits up, her hair swinging forward to over her face, blotchy and red from crying.
“What do you want?” she asks. Her voice is smaller than she remembers as if it is wasting away instead of her body.
“You know what I want,” he says simply. His beetle black eyes search her face and drop again. She looks away too, ashamed. How can she not help him? Her mother would. Then the memories of her mother come flooding back, the way she held her, sang to her, brushed her hair…
And now how her mother’s grief is destroying the world and how she has to get back.
“Persephone…”
He says her name like a man may whisper for water in the desert, desperate, begging and wishing. She doesn’t lift her head. She’s never known grief like that which she feels now. Her life has been of picking flowers and chasing butterflies. But his pleas, his sorrow, seem so huge that hers does not compare. For a moment she wants to put her arms around his cloaked back, stroke his iron grey hair and whisper back to him they everything will be alright. Just for a moment.
Then she remembers what he has done, stealing her away and bringing her here where nothing grows. She remembers where she is, in a room with a bare rock floor and earthen ceiling, with nothing in it but the couch and the table.
“Let me go,” she says with all the strength she can muster.
“I can’t,” he says and takes her hands. Her slender pink fingers seem oddly delicate in his.
“Why not?” she says, and she feels a salty tear run down her cheek. “Why not, Hades?” With a shock, she realises she’s never used his name before. It’s hard and blunt and suits this black aging figure before her perfectly.
He pauses and those shining black eyes bore into hers again. “You’re beautiful.”
“And so are a thousand other girls!” she says. “Please…” she adds softly. “Take one of them.” She feels selfish for saying it and is immediately ashamed.
“But I only want you,” he says, gripping her hands hard for a second. The atmosphere is oppressive, his words press in on her. She pulls her hands away, only now realising what a relief his cool fingers were against the heavy underground air. But she continues to turn away and collapse on the cushions.
She feels his weight being removed from the couch and his footsteps slowly, softly pad away.
He pauses at the door. “I don’t mean you any harm, Persephone,” he says and all of a sudden, tiredness is the chief emotion in his voice. “Please… just eat .”
And he’s gone.
Slowly and smoothly, different from her usual, skittish, sudden movements, she sits up and surveys the fruit bowl. Apples gleam and grapes drip lusciously over the edge. Perfectly ripe plums and peaches nestle nest to the huge, juicy, exotic oranges and lemons.
Her eyes settle on the pomegranate. Please… just eat. the words are still in the room. She picks it up, thinking that he only needs her to do this, to look after herself, to be peaceful at soul. She thinks that perhaps she can do this one simple thing as an apology. An apology because she can’t give him what he wants, no matter how hard he tries to make her, she won’t, she can’t love him, she tells herself, because he’s cruel and evil. Or is he? says a voice. Perhaps you’re just hiding from the truth.
She’s shocked that such a voice even exists and that it sounds as she used to, carefree and young. But pushing it aside, she takes the silver fruit knife and cuts the pomegranate in half. The bright red seeds spill out and with trembling fingers she places one in her mouth. It’s sweet and moist and wonderful after so long with nothing. She swallows it gratefully.
Her head is clearing and she thinks perhaps she should go and find him and tell him she’s eating. It may cheer him up.
She stands, her legs bravely taking the weight after so long. They’re spindly beneath the pink dress she’s wearing. He’s left her a pile of clothes, black and grey and brown and red, but she leaves them lying untouched where they are by the wall of the chamber and stumbles nervously away to try and find him.
The passage twists here and there, packed earth and cold stone the whole way. She pops seeds into her mouth, wiping her eyes, forming a plan. She intends to demand her release, to seem strong like her mother. And still she feels a pang for him, wishing that she could feel the way he does about her.
As she puts a fourth seed in her mouth, she hears voices.
“Your brother demands her release.” It is male, but light and tinkling. She immediately recognises it and puts a name to it. Hermes. She peeks round the next corner and sees the flutter of wings upon his heels.
“He needn’t.” Hades’ voice is gravelly, croaking as if he has been crying. She peers around again. He is sitting in one of the dark stone thrones at the top of the long hall, Hermes standing before him. The other throne is resolutely empty. He looks exhausted. “She is not happy here, I will not hold her.”
“I am glad. Demeter will restore the world to its former glory upon her daughter’s return.”
She is shocked, swallowing her fifth seed. He will let her go. She is elated and warmth spreads throughout her body at the thought of seeing her mother again.
Just as she is about to come from her hiding place to smile and thank them, the messenger begins to speak again. Joyful and buoyant, she settles another seed on her tongue.
“There is but one condition. Should she have eaten anything the old laws decree that she must remain forever.”
Her mouth turns to dust.
“I had forgotten. It is fortunate then, that she has been starving herself.”
The half fruit rolls out of her fingers and she falls to the floor. Both rush to see what the noise is. His black eyes settle upon the pomegranate and his brows knit together, his face pilled into the picture of regret.
She however, has spent all her tears.
“I did not know, I swear I did not know,” he says, gripping her shoulders.
“Forever?” is all she can manages, looking at the messenger.
“Forever,” he says, bowing his bronze head.
Her tears suddenly find their way back and they mix with his and he reaches forward to embrace her. “I did not know, I did not know…”
Hermes watches them. “I shall tell Zeus.”
“No!” His voice is fierce and he pulls apart from her arms that cling to him of their own accord. “How much did you eat?” he asks.
“Six… six seeds,” she manages to gulp. “But…” she looks up at him. “They’re only pomegranate seeds, aren’t they? They don’t count for anything do they?”
He shakes his head fervently. “Of course not.” He looks up at Hermes, who seems uneasy but does not speak.
“Only pomegranate seeds,” Hades agrees and despite all her resolutions, she loves him for it.

The second part is written, just not typed up, and the third isn't written quite yet. But what do you think? Horribly overwritten? Waffling? Repetitive? Tell all! Stel x
Last edited by StellaThomas on Fri Oct 31, 2008 2:58 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"Stella. You were in my dream the other night. And everyone called you Princess." -Lauren2010




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1767
Reviews 40
Wow. I found this amazing. I really really enjoyed it. Last year, I had to do an English project on Persephone and she interested me. It was very interesting reading this Greek myth retold. You did a wonderful job with it.

A few things you should fix, a few errors. There are a few unnecessary spaces between words if you can find them. I don't think I can now, but they're there.

I really loved how you described everything, but if you wanted to make it more descriptive, you could make her describe the room she's in, make her describe the Underworld with more detail. All the reader gathers from this is it's dark and there's a couch, a table, and a bowl of bright fruits. Try to let the reader explore the room. Make Persephone avoid Hades' eyes and explore the room instead, or make her pace across the cold, black floor. Show the reader where she's being held, how terrible it is and why she hates it so much. This would greatly add to the story.

Hope I could help.

StarDuster
"With every joy that passes
Something beautiful remains."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 21
I found this to be a great piece of work! It had wonderful descriptions and the way you described the characters was very vivid. I could almost feel Hades' voice whispering in MY ear! Though, I agree with StarDuster- you could have described the room, just to make the reader see where Persephone is being held. I also love the last line of the story.

“Only pomegranate seeds,” Hades agrees and despite all her resolutions, she loves him for it.


Overall, it was a beautiful story. Nice work!
topic43954.html

Click it! You know you want to!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 89
StarDuster is right, there is room for much more description. This is from Persephone and the Four Seasons, right? Beautifully retold!

The description of the people is fantastic. I can almost hear Hades murmuring. The feeling and thoughts are perfectly expressed. But you need to describe the non-living things much better.

Her head is clearing and she thinks perhaps she should fo and find him and t ell him she’s eating.


I think these are just typos, but "fo" is "go", right? And "t ell" is "tell". In a few other places you have unnecessary spaces inside words.

You certainly paint Hades in a better light than I've seen him! I never knew he actually had feelings and could appear anything but loathsome.

This is fantastic work! You are an amazing writer. Don't ever stop!
Does anyone else smell books when they read them?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 53415
Reviews 1125
Edited 28/10/08. Thought I'd give it this little bump, since I'm about to post part ii...

Thanks for reading all!

-Stel x
"Stella. You were in my dream the other night. And everyone called you Princess." -Lauren2010




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 273
His voice is low and pleading in her ear. It speaks of a thousand battles lost, generations destroyed, cities massacred by disease and famine. All the tragedy in the world, the awful, heartbreaking sadness that it is to be alive is layered in his words, three simple words that rip her soul and body apart.
Great way to start; it's so intriguing :)
“Please,” it begins. “Eat something.”

She buries her head deeper into the soft, downy cushions scattered on the couch. Her long hair, cascading in loops and tendrils, tickles scratchily against her cheeks.Wow, your description is amazing! She ignores it and fights a sob, because she won’t let him know she’s crying, she won’t, (although he probably knows already but she ignores that thought).

“What about this?” he says, and she opens her eye a fraction. A pomegranate, soft and pink, seems out of place in his hard, stubby fingers.I really like that sentence. Something about the description in the pomegranate - it just works

He lays it down next to the fruit bowl sitting on the stone table and instead lays the hand on her back. It’s cold against her skin and she shies away from his touch, she doesn’t want anything to do with him. He lets a long miserable sigh out, whistling slightly as it passes his teeth, trembling in the cool, earthy air where it hangs between them. She frowns into the cushion. She would usually detest causing another being to be unhappy, Maybe she would detest causing another being unhappiness would be more effective here, something about the last bit appears a little awkward. but after what he’s done she can bear it. And yet the fact that he worries over her, barely leaves her side, watches over her and is only hurt by what she is doing to herself makes her feel uncomfortable.

So slowly she sits up, her hair swinging forward to over her face, blotchy and red from crying.

“What do you want?” she asks. Her voice is smaller than she remembers as if it is wasting away instead of her body.

“You know what I want,” he says simply. His beetle black eyes search her face and drop again. She looks away too, ashamed. How can she not help him? Her mother would. Then the memories of her mother come flooding back, the way she held her, sang to her, brushed her hair… The bit at the end there is absolutely amazing! I love it. :)

And now how her mother’s grief is destroying the world and how she has to get back.

“Persephone…” Did you choose that name? - I love it :)

He says her name like a man may whisper for water in the desert, desperate, begging and wishing. She doesn’t lift her head. She’s never known grief like that which she feels now. Her life has been of picking flowers and chasing butterflies. Your description is mind blowing! But his pleas, his sorrow, seem so huge that hers does not compare. For a moment she wants to put her arms around his cloaked back, stroke his iron grey hair and whisper back to him they everything will be alright. Just for a moment.

Then she remembers what he has done, stealing her away and bringing her here where nothing grows. She remembers where she is, in a room with a bare rock floor and earthen ceiling, with nothing in it but the couch and the table.

“Let me go,” she says with all the strength she can muster.

“I can’t,” he says and takes her hands. Her slender pink fingers seem oddly delicate in his. :)

“Why not?” she says, and she feels a salty tear run down her cheek. “Why not, Hades?” With a shock, she realises she’s never used his name before. It’s hard and blunt and suits this black aging figure before her perfectly. Amazing!

He pauses and those shining black eyes bore into hers again. “You’re beautiful.”

“And so are a thousand other girls!” she says. “Please…” she adds softly. “Take one of them.” She feels selfish for saying it and is immediately ashamed.

“But I only want you,” he says, gripping her hands hard for a second. The atmosphere is oppressive, his words press in on her. She pulls her hands away, only now realising what a relief his cool fingers were against the heavy underground air. But she continues to turn away and collapse on the cushions.

She feels his weight being removed from the couch and his footsteps slowly, softly pad away.

He pauses at the door. “I don’t mean you any harm, Persephone,” he says and all of a sudden, tiredness is the chief emotion in his voice. “Please… just eat .”

And he’s gone. That single sentence is so effective.

Slowly and smoothly, different from her usual, skittish, sudden movements, she sits up and surveys the fruit bowl. Apples gleam and grapes drip lusciously over the edge. Perfectly ripe plums and peaches nestle nest to the huge, juicy, exotic oranges and lemons. Yum:)

Her eyes settle on the pomegranate. Please… just eat. the words are still in the room. She picks it up, thinking that he only needs her to do this, to look after herself, to be peaceful at soul. She thinks that perhaps she can do this one simple thing as an apology. An apology because she can’t give him what he wants, no matter how hard he tries to make her, she won’t, she can’t love him, she tells herself, because he’s cruel and evil. Or is he? says a voice. Perhaps you’re just hiding from the truth. The truth hurts - the way you've portrayed it is perfect

She’s shocked that such a voice even exists and that it sounds as she used to, carefree and young. But pushing it aside, she takes the silver fruit knife and cuts the pomegranate in half. The bright red seeds spill out and with trembling fingers she places one in her mouth. It’s sweet and moist and wonderful after so long with nothing. She swallows it gratefully.

Her head is clearing and she thinks perhaps she should go and find him and tell him she’s eating. It may cheer him up.

She stands, her legs bravely taking the weight after so long. They’re spindly beneath the pink dress she’s wearing. He’s left her a pile of clothes, black and grey and brown and red, but she leaves them lying untouched where they are by the wall of the chamber and stumbles nervously away to try and find him.

The passage twists here and there, packed earth and cold stone the whole way. She pops seeds into her mouth, wiping her eyes, forming a plan. She intends to demand her release, to seem strong like her mother. And still she feels a pang for him, wishing that she could feel the way he does about her.

As she puts a fourth seed in her mouth, she hears voices.

“Your brother demands her release.” It is male, but light and tinkling. She immediately recognises it and puts a name to it. Hermes. She peeks round the next corner and sees the flutter of wings upon his heels.

“He needn’t.” Hades’ voice is gravelly, croaking as if he has been crying. She peers around again. He is sitting in one of the dark stone thrones at the top of the long hall, Hermes standing before him. The other throne is resolutely empty. He looks exhausted. “She is not happy here, I will not hold her.”

“I am glad. Demeter will restore the world to its former glory upon her daughter’s return.”

She is shocked, swallowing her fifth seed. He will let her go. She is elated and Don't use the and here warmth spreads throughout her body at the thought of seeing her mother again.

Just as she is about to come from her hiding place to smile and thank them, the messenger begins to speak again. Joyful and buoyant, she settles another seed on her tongue.

“There is but one condition. Should she have eaten anything the old laws decree that she must remain forever.”I love this description :)

Her mouth turns to dust.

“I had forgotten. It is fortunate then, that she has been starving herself.”

The half fruit rolls out of her fingers and she falls to the floor. Both rush to see what the noise is. His black eyes settle upon the pomegranate and his brows knit together, his face pilled into the picture of regret.

She however, has spent all her tears. That sentence is ... for lack of a better word ... perfect :)

“I did not know, I swear I did not know,” he says, gripping her shoulders.

“Forever?” is all she can manages, looking at the messenger.

“Forever,” he says, bowing his bronze head.

Her tears suddenly find their way back and they mix with his and he reaches forward to embrace her. “I did not know, I did not know…”

Hermes watches them. “I shall tell Zeus.”

“No!” His voice is fierce and he pulls apart from her arms that cling to him of their own accord. “How much did you eat?” he asks.

“Six… six seeds,” she manages to gulp. “But…” she looks up at him. “They’re only pomegranate seeds, aren’t they? They don’t count for anything do they?”

He shakes his head fervently. “Of course not.” He looks up at Hermes, who seems uneasy but does not speak.

“Only pomegranate seeds,” Hades agrees and despite all her resolutions, she loves him for it.


The second part is written, just not typed up, and the third isn't written quite yet. But what do you think? Horribly overwritten? Waffling? Repetitive? Tell all! Stelx

Wow! That was so intriguing. I want to know more. Your description is mindblowing. Moreover I couldn't find a single mistake. Yours is one of the best pieces I've seen on here for ages :) Thanks for posting it, 'twas amazing!
for what are we without words and stories?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 42011
Reviews 922
Ooh! Hades and Persephone! Only one of my favorite Greek myths evah! Must read... *zombie stare*

*ahem* Anyway, quite the lovely piece of work, I must say. I've always loved Hades in this tale and imagined him almost exactly as you write him. Although, I did think that he purposely made her eat the pomegranate, but your Hades is a bit more sympathetic than mine. Very, very nice.

She ignores it and fights a sob, because she won’t let him know she’s crying, she won’t, (although he probably knows already but she ignores that thought).


I really don't like the parentheses here. You don't have them anywhere else in the piece that I can find and the one instance isn't doing much for you. Parentheses really have to be either a constant presence or not there at all. Better would be to somehow work the stuff in the parentheses into the prose.

ex. She ignores it and fights a sob, because she won't let him know she's crying. She won't.

He probably knows already, her mind whispers, but she ignores it.

Or do something to that effect.

Or is he? says a voice. Perhaps you’re just hiding from the truth.


I would put the voice's comments into italics to set them off from the prose. As is, they kind of get lost in the rest of the prose and thus lose some of their impact. In italics, they will be distinct, but not be mistaken for actual out-loud dialogue. Italics are a good way to go for internal thoughts and wonky stuff like not-real voices.

Other than that, I found nothing worth critiquing. The entire thing was magnificently done and I really liked your use of the present tense. I'm not a big fan of it ordinarily, but the way it flowed in a stream of consciousness-type way was great. It felt as though it were happening and I felt anxious as the story unfolded just from the way it was written. You had fantastic descriptions and language. Great, great job.

*thumbs up* Seriously, epic win.

~GryphonFledgling
I am reminded of the babe by you.




User avatar
Gender Other
Points 89625
Reviews 1272
Thought I'd drag this back up, since part 3 is up.

Characters- It's short, so we don't get much, but the despair for Persephone is clear, so is the possessiveness of Hades.

Plot- I know the myth, so I know where this is going. You have done a pretty good job of fleshing this out, however.

One little nit-pick about your history: I thought Pomegranates were the only things Persephone couldn't eat, because it was the food of the dead. Had she eaten something else, she might have been allowed to stay.

Overall- For a minute, I thought this was Beauty and the Beast, since the first lines have an allusion to the scenes in the Disney version, but I was pleasantly surprised. You've done a pretty good job of fleshing out the myth, and their is just enough description to see what's going on.
Last edited by Rosendorn on Sun Dec 20, 2009 10:21 pm, edited 1 time in total.
A writer is a world trapped in a person— Victor Hugo

Ink is blood. Paper is bandages. The wounded press books to their heart to know they're not alone.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 250
oh,

I love Persephone and Hades story. and your story just give the me the behind the scenes stuff.

I love this part. I kind of feel thought because she was kind of trick into eating the fruit. and of course the laws.

Poor Persephone and her naive. Of course the pomegranate seed mean something, why wouldn't they.

I look forward to reading the other parts.
"I love you," she whispered in his ear, before taking his mouth with her own.

~Elizzabeth Grey of Addicting Posion




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 5
I'm about to go read the other parts, but I wanted to leave you a quick note here.

The characterization is done quite well - this is one of my favorite stories of Greek mythology, and it's great to see a fleshed out version done so nicely.

My only complaint is the description of the Underworld. Why does Persephone want to leave so badly? What waits for her? What makes the Underworld so hellish (forgive me, I had to) that she wants to leave? It needs more description and character within itself, so the reader who may not be completely familiar with the myth has a chance to really get why she hates being there.

Otherwise, wonderful job. Off to part 2!
"I wonder, what are people most afraid of? A new step, their own new word, that's what they're most afraid of." [Crime & Punishment]




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 440
instead lays the hand on her back. It’s cold against her skin and she shies away from his touch,


Should we assume then that her back is bare?

and how she has to get back


Did you mean “now she has to get back”? If not, tis a bit confusing.

like a man may whisper for water in the desert, desperate, begging and wishing.


You probably only need one of those adjectives at the end—I think desperate would be the best to keep.

whisper back to him they everything will be alright


I think you mean “that” instead of “they”

She picks it up


It’s a bit fuzzy what you mean by “it”—of course I know it’s the pomegranate, but the last noun you’ve used is “room” so you can see how that would be confusing.

“I did not know, I swear I did not know,” he says, gripping her shoulders.

“Forever?” is all she can manages, looking at the messenger.

“Forever,” he says, bowing his bronze head.

Her tears suddenly find their way back and they mix with his and he reaches forward to embrace her. “I did not know, I did not know…”


The “he”s in this part get confusing—perhaps replace a few of them with the names?

Overall

Well, I intended to drop by and review this as a return on the favor you gave me in reviewing "Out of a Grey Day" but I find that once again I am the one who profits! I've always loved the story of Persephone and Hades, and you tell it masterfully. I hope you don't mind that I chose such an old piece to critique; I notice no one's done a nit-pick of it yet so I thought I might be useful. Truly a delightful read. Many, many thanks.
"In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function...We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful." ~C.S. Lewis




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1459
Reviews 22
WOW!! I really liked it! I love this kind of thing anyway, but you write it really well. I would like to know how they look though, but keep it up!!
We're all a bit mad...




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 465
Reviews 81
OH MY GOSH! I LOVE greek mythology, and you retold the story of the season's BEAUTIFULY. I like the way you don't portray Hades as the bad guy, like people usually do. Well, not yet any way, I havn't read the rest. but this is amazing. I love hearing myths be retold.
Cats are like characters. You may say they're yours, but in reality, they own you. ~Me

You can take away all the arts you want, but soon, the children won't have anything to read or write about. ~Glen Holland



A day without sunshine is like, you know, night.
— Steve Martin