A Titleless Story (4)

26 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 174
** I am no longer using YWS but I'd like to say thank you to everyone who commented on my work and helped me to improve it - you guys are seriously amazing and I love you all. Thank you!! :D xx **
Last edited by lucyy on Thu Feb 04, 2010 9:21 pm, edited 8 times in total.
"Don't think, or judge. Just Listen."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 174
I would also love to know if my portrayal of America is correct or not. The only time that I've been to America was Disneyland at Florida when I was five, which I don't think quite counts, as I can hardly remember it anyway hehe. I have also not yet had the pleasure to visit New York (although it's one of my lifetime aspirations - to go there and shop :D ), so I would like to know whether or not my setting of New York is okay or not - although I didn't do much setting at the beginning, but I would love to know what I could improve on to properly describe the city etc.
Thank you all so much for your help and for reading this!!
Lucyy xx
"Don't think, or judge. Just Listen."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2384
Reviews 107
HI!

okay here we go.


leaving his six months pregnant wife behind. How tragic.

Well when we first start reading this, we're not exactly sure if this is in first person or third. If it's in third, that 'how tragic' either shouldn't be here or it should be in italics and following it should be ",____ thought".
Also, take the s off of months, so it's six-month pregnant wife. I'm not sure if it's correct, but it sounds right.


Rosaline Radley was one of those people, her bright blue eyes gazing upon the horrific headlines, shaking her head in disbelief. Sometimes life could be really unfair, but didn’t she know that already?

I read this, then I reread it saying this and I thought it sounded better:

Rosaline Radley was one of those people who scanned the headlines. Her bright blue eyes gazed upon the horrific headlines while shaking her head in disbelief. Sometimes life could be really unfair, but she already knew that.
It's okay if you don't agree.


Heidi the receptionist and made her way up the winding staircase

There should be a coma after Heidi and receptionist.


smart work jacket

Her what jacket?


“Okay, thanks,”

"Okay, thanks."


But she had always seemed detached whenever her sister or her home life in England was ever mentioned, which was slightly weird.

Take out that 'but'.


placing her handbag in the corner of the room. She sunk down into her high backed leather chair, placing the newspaper on the mahogany

'Placing' is used twice in this. It sounds strange when reading it aloud, try using something like 'setting'. Tip: When just finishing a paragraph, go back and read it over out loud to see if it sounds flowing.


Pull yourself together, she whispered to herself firmly, it’s no good wishing of what could be.

Put that in italics and ' ' except the "she whispered to herself firmly" part.


Rosetta Leah, 29, was informed in the early hours of yesterday morning that her husband had died on scene of a car crash on the M20 involving three cars.

Kenso Leah, 30, a leading journalist, was pronounced dead at the scene by Emergency Services, leaving his wife, Rosetta Leah, and twin brother, Jared Leah, in an agony of despair.

The occupants of one of the two other cars were a family of three: Jaydn and Austin Miller (28 and 31) and their nine year old daughter Ashlyn. The occupant of the third car, Roger Karr, 25, was reported to be the cause of the crash.

On Thursday 23rd October, at 11pm, following extended investigations, Roger Karr was arrested and charged on three counts of drunk driving, dangerous driving and the manslaughter of Kenso Leah. It has also been reported that the family of three involved in the car crash, who only suffered minor injuries, will be pressing charges on Roger Karr for ‘putting their nine year old daughter’s life in jeopardy’.

The court case for Roger Karr will be held on Wednesday 29th October, where the fate of Roger Karr will be decided whilst the grieving family of Kenso Leah will be hanging on the hope that justice will be served.

By Christian Lee. Reported on Friday 24th October


This should all be in italics. Also - we dont read about England here, maybe change this to looking at the news on her computer. Computer news is more international since it's used everywhere unlike newspapers that are used in cities.


on scene of a car crash on the M20 involving three cars.

It should be 'at the scene'.
Also, if you ever need help to 'write' a newspaper article, I'm in journalism so I can help you. I know all about the leads, the upside down triangle, all that.


23rd October
When writing dates in an article, you put the number of the date, of, and then the month. So: the 23rd of October.

Your article doesnt seem real. When I have more time tonight, I'll help you out with it.
A little less inhuman.
A little more brutal.
Let the blood be your drug.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 174
That sounds great daytripper - the article was the most thing that I struggled on so I would love for you to help me out on that :D And thanks for the tip on English news, I wasn't too sure if you could get English papers over there or not - so I just chanced it, hehe d:
& thank you for your crtiques - I shall get to changing them ASAP!!
Thank you again for reading this,
Lucyy xx
"Don't think, or judge. Just Listen."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 89
I've never been to America, although the bombardment of American influence on TV, in books and just about everywhere tells me that your portrayal is quite accurate, although it may seem like it's based just a little in the past (about 3, 5 years?). But take my opinion with a grain of salt, because I've never been to America, as I said.

I'll start with the newspaper, because you say that's what you had the most trouble with. Usually the headlines are in capitals to grab more attention. Also, I would shorten the headline. Instead of "A woman, six months pregnant, widowed by tragic car crash" (which is too many words to catch the eye of the busy readers of modern newspapers) I would write "PREGNANT WOMAN WIDOWED IN TRAGIC CAR CRASH". The details like that she was six month pregnant will come in the story.

By Christian Lee. Reported on Friday 24th October


The date normally goes at the beginning of the article, under the headline and is set out like this: "Friday 24th October". At the end you simly say "Christian Lee". No need for excessive words.

The three car thing is a bit confusing. You need to set it out so it is very obvious. Ie; "The first car, a blue 1970's beetle driven by Kenso Leah, the second car, a green Volvo containing a family of three, and the third car, a red Toyota driven by Roger Karr and the cause of the crash, smashed together on the turnoff to MadeUp Rd." After that you can go into more detail about their ages, their names in the case of the family, etc. You also need to state all the facts of the case first, interviews and heartbreaking pleas for justice come near the end, because that's what the readers will remember the most. I would have the 4th paragraph first, 3rd paragraph second, 5th paragraph third, 1st paragraph fourth and 2nd paragraph fifth. Obviously they will have to be slightly altered to fit this order, but that's the typical order for a newspaper report.

Kenso Leah, 30, a leading journalist, was pronounced dead at the scene by Emergency Services, leaving his wife, Rosetta Leah, and twin brother, Jared Leah, in an agony of despair.


An "agony" is not a unit of measurement for "despair". You need to pick one and stick to it.

The rest of the story is great! However, if you are going to name the secretary, you need to do it sooner. You call her "the secretary" twice before getting to her name, which is unnecessary. You can call her "the secretary" once, but if she's going to be named, you need to name her the next time you mention her.

But she had always seemed detached whenever her sister or her home life in England was ever mentioned, which was slightly weird.


Slightly weird? Nothing is slightly weird. It's weird or it's normal.

“Oh, Rosetta!”


This is weak for a final sentence. Try "hello? Rosetta?" or something along those lines. This sounds like you've picked the reader up and plopped them in the middle of the phone conversation. Not good.

This is a great effort! Keep writing!
Does anyone else smell books when they read them?




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 690
Reviews 1
It's like an english essay written in a rush. You need to try harder not to look like your trying to hard.... if you know what I mean.... still it's good for your age




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 174
Thank you new readers for reading this, I'm always happy to get advice from new people :D

chichi --
Thank you sooo much for your really helpful review (: it's so kind of you to take the effort to read this and do a detailed review, so thank you (: Also, thank you for helping out with the newspaper report (journalism writing is not my speciality :wink: ) and good point on the headline - I'll definitely be using that as a headline instead!! Thank you again for reading and reviewing this (:

noigexx --
Thank you for reading and reviewing this!! And I do totally get what you mean, although I have to say this isn't the best chapter I've ever written - the stuff that I needed to put in the chapter didn't want to cooperate with me d: hehe.

Thank you both again for reading this. Your critiques will come in very handy!!
Lucyy xx
"Don't think, or judge. Just Listen."




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1075
Reviews 842
Hey, luc! :D Here by request and ready to review!

Carefully, the people of New York scanned the headlines, shaking their heads in astonishment: one man killed, leaving his six months pregnant wife behind.


Should be just "month"

Wow, that is so sad...poor Kenso...:cry:

You say in there that his brother's name is Jared....I thought it was Jasper...right? Maybe I'm just being crazy so just ignore that if I am wrong :wink:

Otherwise, I only found that one thing above that was wrong. It was a fairly good chapter but you could have made the beginning more meaningful. I didn't really get interested until the car accident article. Really grab the reader, you know?

Hope this helps, luc! :D
"Woe to the man whose heart has not learned while young to hope, to love—and to put his trust in life."
~ Joseph Conrad


"Music washes away from the soul the dust of everyday life."
~ Red Auerbach




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 174
I will try and grab the reader at the start when I alter it .. I may just overdo this chapter as I'm not too pleased with it ... hmm ...
But anyway thank you for reading and reviewing this ashley. And nope, his name is Jared (: hehe :D
Thanks again :D
Lucyy xx
"Don't think, or judge. Just Listen."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 208
Lucy-

Taking a quick sip of her latte she picked up on her walk in to work,

Should be into.

That's the only mistake I found. Other than that, I felt like you left us at a cliff hanger. I really want to know what's going to happen.
Like what's going to happen to Rosetta? Oh, and is it a boy or girl? {I know. Kind of random}
In my opinion I would like it if Rosaline saw her sister and Jared. Maybe have them come to New York. Or bring her back to England.
It's just...somethings gonna happen. I know it. Besides what happened to Kenso.
Sorry, for my ramblings.
Remember to pm me for the next chapter. Thanks!
-Merry
Mary had a little lamb. Little lamb. Little lamb!

Ugh!! I really hate my name. >.<




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 174
Heyy Merry (:
Thank you for reviewing this and as for what's going to happen next .. you'll have to read on to find out :wink: & I haven't yet decided whether Rosetta's baby is a boy or a girl ... (:
& no, I like your ramblings (: I like to know what people think after they read my stuff :D
Anywho, thank you for reading this & I'll see you around (:
Lucyy xx
"Don't think, or judge. Just Listen."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1068
Reviews 582
WARNING to Luccy: I am going to be extremely nitpicky, considering I'm in the mood. So WATCH OUT!


Chapter One

Another tragic car crash was splashed across the headlines of every English newspaper [Eh. DOn't lime 'every English newspaper. It tells us in the next line that your setting is in New York, so that detail is unnecessary.]. Carefully, the people of New York scanned the headlines, shaking their heads in astonishment [Every single person in New York is reading a paper? And they all have the same reaction? Huh. Seems kind of unrealistic...]: one man killed, leaving his six months pregnant wife behind. How tragic. [Okay, I don't think newspapers would write about this; there are bad car crashes pretty much every day, and they're so common that NONE of the newspapers write about it.]

Rosaline Radley was one of those people, her bright blue eyes gazing upon the horrific headlines, shaking her head in disbelief [You said the people were shaking their heads. We don't need to know this again. Give us another detail about this character you're introducing.]. Sometimes life could be really unfair, but didn’t she know that already?

Rosaline [I don't thing you need to use her name here, because you've just told us what it is. Use 'she' here.] picked up one of the English newspapers that were being sold outside her office block, [Comma unnecessary here.] before tucking it securely under her arm, [Again, no need for comma.] and pushing open the heavy glass doors.

Taking a quick sip of her latte [Comma here] she [Okay, now you should use her name again.] picked up on her walk in to work, she waved a polite hello to Heidi [Do it like this: Heidi--the receptionist--and made... Get it?] the receptionist and made her way up the winding staircase, her black patent heels click-clacking on the marble surface.

“Rosaline, your sister left you an urgent message and wants you to ring back as soon as possible!” Rosaline’s secretary blurted out the moment she appeared at the top of the staircase.

Rosaline sighed inwardly and made her way over to her secretary’s wooden desk, which was [Cut the 'which was'.] placed conveniently outside her office door.

This was now [Don't need the 'now'.] getting beyond annoying. Her sister was forever pestering and ringing her, but for some obscure reason today more than anything else. She had left several messages on both her home and cell phones, which Rosaline had deleted before listening to. [If her sister was calling her so often, you'd think the MC would listen to at least ONE message just in case it was an emergency. Pretty cold if she doesn't even bother to listen, if you ask me.]

“Okay, thanks,” Rosaline said to Sienna, handing over her smart work jacket, [Cut the comma.] before heading into her office, without giving her a second glance.

Sienna stood up, [Cut this comma.] with Rosaline’s jacket on her arm and shook her head disbelievingly at her boss’s lack of response to her sister’s distress. But she [Getting a little confusing. I know who 'she' is, but you need to specify here.] had always seemed detached whenever her sister or her home life in England was ever mentioned, which was slightly weird.

Rosaline closed the office door behind her and made her way over to her desk, placing her handbag in the corner of the room. She sunk [Should be sank.] down into her high backed leather chair, placing the newspaper on the mahogany desktop and buried her face in her hands. [Awkward sentence. Reword.]

Moving over here to New York was every day proving to be harder than she ever thought it would have been. Even ten years on, she couldn’t get rid of the constant longing she had to see both her sister and Jared’s faces and to be back in England, where she undoubtedly really belonged.

Rosaline sat up and took a deep breath, blinking back the tears that had glazed over her eyes. Pull yourself together, she whispered to herself firmly, it’s no good wishing of what could be. It’s the here and now that matters. Thinking this, Rosaline turned on her computer monitor and opened up the newspaper in front of her and started to read the short article about the car crash that had happened in England.

A woman, six months pregnant, widowed by tragic car crash

Rosetta Leah, 29, was informed in the early hours of yesterday morning that her husband had died on scene of a car crash on the M20 involving three cars.

Kenso Leah, 30, a leading journalist, was pronounced dead at the scene by Emergency Services, leaving his wife, Rosetta Leah, and twin brother, Jared Leah, in an agony of despair.

The occupants of one of the two other cars were a family of three: Jaydn and Austin Miller (28 and 31) and their nine year old daughter Ashlyn. The occupant of the third car, Roger Karr, 25, was reported to be the cause of the crash.

On Thursday 23rd October, at 11pm, following extended investigations, Roger Karr was arrested and charged on three counts of drunk driving, dangerous driving and the manslaughter of Kenso Leah. It has also been reported that the family of three involved in the car crash, who only suffered minor injuries, will be pressing charges on Roger Karr for ‘putting their nine year old daughter’s life in jeopardy’.

The court case for Roger Karr will be held on Wednesday 29th October, where the fate of Roger Karr will be decided whilst the grieving family of Kenso Leah will be hanging on the hope that justice will be served.

By Christian Lee. Reported on Friday 24th October

“Oh … my … god …” Rosaline gasped, as her shaky hands dropped the newspaper onto the desktop.

As though in a trance, Rosaline picked up her office phone and dialled Rosetta’s cell phone number.

“Oh, Rosetta!”

[Whoa. Names are just too similar, and make it too confusing. Please - even if it's a key to the story or something - change that. I just won't be able to keep up and will mix up the two characters f their names are so close.]




Well, Luc, I've been seeing definite improvement in your writing. While this wasn't a superb beginning - it is a bit bland, to be honest - it is not horrible. You have some good character development, and you've given yourself a lot of room to keep going with this.

Therefore, keep going :)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 174
Thank you KJ for reading and reviewing this. I'm glad you think my writing's improving (:
& I totally agree with you, I don't like this chapter at all, so I'm going to redo it. And as for the names, I just chose them to make them seem similar, but to show the contrast of their personalities, if you get what I mean? I've also grown too attatched to the names now to change them hehe oops d:
Thanks again for reading this, your review was very helpful :D
Lucyy xx
"Don't think, or judge. Just Listen."




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2209
Reviews 106
Lucyy, I loved this chapter. What a great way to start off the story. Your writing has improved so much since I last read your prologue. Very well done. Right when I saw Rosetta and Kelso's name I knew something bad must've happened. Although I do think you should've decribed more what Rosaline was feeling when she first saw her sister's name in the paper. Awesomeness (is that a word?). Hurry up with more!

A-

-Moony

P.S. More description would've been nice.
If I can impact one person, just one, with my writing before I die, then I've lived a great life




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1040
Reviews 174
Thank you so much In_the_Moonlight for reading this & I'm soo glad you think my writing's improved :D thank you also for following this story & I totally agree with you, more description is definately needed :wink:

Thank you so much again everyone for taking your time to read and review this, I appreciate it soo much :D

Lucyy xx
"Don't think, or judge. Just Listen."



I do not use my siblings as the cleaning equipment.
— Atticus