The best I can give is 2%

4 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 316
I really don't expect crits on this, since I've neglected critting for so long.

So why am I posting this?
I don't know.

Anyway, crits will be returned if you give a link/name the piece

The best I can give is 2%


embraced each other like defeat,
in the wee hours, we
sunk bourbon down thirsty throats
burned the chill, swallowed the choke, and
swapped healthy for sane. We may
have flooded out our love, but at
least we drowned the pain.

don’t cry over

We ordered out and
ate with sticks.
I swallowed words
and a paper slip, that read
like an obituary.
You told a joke like a secret,
stretched a crooked smile,
and between blushing cheeks whispered:
We’re like books. When we’re opened,
We’re red.


That one just killed me.
Still showing teeth stained read,
you mop me up like
spilled milk.
__________________
Last edited by whence on Sat Aug 30, 2008 6:30 am, edited 1 time in total.
The good parts of a book may be only something a writer is lucky enough to overhear or it may be the wreck of his whole damn life — and one is as good as the other.
Ernest Hemingway




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 253
I really liked this. It's very different, and you can really feel the emotion. I just have a few nitpick things to say. 1) the lines that you wanted to be colored red aren't showing up that way; you might just want to show them black.
2 ) In the second verse, when you say we "ate with sticks" it sounds really weird. It'd be better if you put chopsticks.
3 ) In the second line, I think the "we" should be moved down a line.
Other than that, this was very interesting and did not seem to drag on like some poetry does; instead it moved at a nice speed and let the reader keep up without being confused about what was going on.

If you could do this it'd be great, but you don't have to. Feel free to rip it to shreds if you do.
topic30187.html
"Just saying none of us want to conquer the world won't stop some other idiot from trying."
~Liberty and Justice, by Paul Dini

www.batmanworldblog.blogspot.com




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 23425
Reviews 566
Great, you've made me jealous of how you write, are you happy now? :P I just love your tone, it sounds so good. I like how you swapped red and read around, assuming you did that on purpose. Also, the kind of subliminal message in red, I was about to say that "don't cry over" seemed rather random and superfluous, until I put those two lines together. Nothing really to criticize, sorry. :( All I can say is keep up the good work, and I love how much thought you've put into this piece and its meaning.
Matt.




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 335
Ooh, it confused me initially, but I love the words in bold and the swap of "red" and "read". Very e. e. cummings.

I'm afraid this is going to be an utterly useless critique, because this is so brilliant. Let's see... I was thrown off a bit by the part about eating with sticks and swallowing a paper slip (btw, the obituary simile is gorgeous)- you could make it a bit more obvious that you're talking about Chinese food, unless it is obvious and I'm just dense. The title seemed a bit irrelevant- I suppose the "2%" part ties into the "spilled milk" line, but it still doesn't seem to quite fit the poem as a whole.

Otherwise, this was lovely- the wording, the imagery, the overall flow. I get the impression that you considered the connotations of every word, every phrase, yet it doesn't feel like you were trying too hard. Excellent work.

Don't feel obligated since this is a pretty weak crit, but I'd really appreciate your feedback on my poem "chrysalis," which is in my featured works.
"I myself am composed entirely of flaws, stitched together with good intentions."- Augusten Burroughs



how insane i exist in rooms i'm not in at the moment
— fatherfig