Doll

15 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 89
You hang your head—how did you get here?

There’s no past, no future, and hardly any now. The darkness surrounds, but there is an up, and a down. There’s all around you as well.

A stage light shines on you from somewhere above. You squint into the brightness and see a ring of white with little specks of grey. There are dead moths and june bugs in the light.

“Dance,” They whisper.

Your head jerks in the direction of the voices. Who are They, some kind of authority? If you focus on the darkness outside your ring of light, you can see where the illumination reaches their pant legs. They must be slouched over in their chairs.

You can also see the light cast a reflection off their teeth. They’re pointed teeth—ready to eat you, your dreams, your love, your soul, your eyes.

“Dance,” They whisper again. The voice is commanding, and menacing, but you shake your head anyway.

“I don’t want to dance,” you manage to choke out. Your voice hasn’t ever been used, and it hurts when you speak. You’ve never been able to speak back, you realize, but now you can.

“We want you to dance,” They command again; their tone doesn’t grow louder.

“Why am I here?” It hurts to speak. There’s a fire in your throat that tells you to stop, that no good will come of this.

“We’ll make you dance then,” they say.

A mechanism churns somewhere. It creaks and groans as it starts up, and you feel a tug against your back, shoulders, legs, arms. You try and resist, but your muscles are no good against the authority—they are too weak.

“Dance,” They say again, for the satisfaction of you having followed their orders. Their grins widen. They look hungry. They’ll come for your life soon.

Then your legs rise, and your arms sway side to side. The tugging hurts; the strings are sharp needles that burn into your flesh. You scream but the flames in your throat force you to close your mouth.

And you dance. You twirl and jig and skip and hop and caper and leap. They snicker in their snake-like voices and you sob. The tears don’t burn like the screaming or strings do—they’re your only relief.

Slowly, your arms fall to your side, limp. Your legs begin to dangle and you are lowered to the ground. The stage light flickers off, leaving you with the darkness and the invisible smiles.

And They come in for the kill.
Last edited by Talking_Pinata on Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:12 am, edited 2 times in total.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 6070
Reviews 277
If you focus on the darkness outside your definite ring of light,


Your trying to makes something surreal with this piece. By adding a technical term like the word definite, you jerk the reader from that mood. Find a different description.

They look hungrier.


Hungrier? When did you describe them as just hungry?

they’re your only relief from this desperate reality.


Again, you're stepping outside the surrealness with this phrase. Desperate reality defines the situation. Don't define it. It stands better undefined.

Can't say much about the last line. It was a pretty good ending.

Overall, this was very well done! The right amount of creepiness, vivid description. Really, it's good work.

Hope that helps! :D

[s]BlackGhost[/s]




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 4
A very abstract piece. Quite interesting, different from usual take on short stories, I like the sense of mystery around the people who are commanding the main character
You use the word 'suddenly' twice in one sentence. It is one of the most common writing mistakes to use the same words over and over in your work, so it would be useful to always keep a thesaurus nearby
It's such an unusual piece of writing I'm not really too sure about what else to say! It certainly grabs the reader's attention, and lingers in the reader's mind. Overall, pretty good!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 89
Thank you for the reviews! I've made edits that I hope are sufficient!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1090
Reviews 5
Now, I feel stupid for sting this but I'm utterly confused. I get that the girl is a doll but who eats a doll? So all I have established is that the owners aren't human. Are they bugs. You said someyging about bugs earlier. But what big can make a doll's throat burn in flames? Even though your trying to show and not tell, I still think you have to be a little more obvious! Unless ofcourse it is a couple of witches who capture a girl. If not though, take my above advice.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 89
It's a metaphor. It's not SUPPOSED to make complete sense. And its not that the girl is a doll. It's that the doll is a girl. Its a person. Metaphorically battling her superiors who have chosen her future for her.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 7
Whoa, baby that's deep.

But deep is good. And I totally understood your metaphor. I wrote a report on succumbing to the demands of authority last year, and this has that kind of vibe.

So, I'm really liking this. I'm not up to critiquing at the moment. Mild migraines and low blood sugar and that. :wink:

Kudos. I'm loving your rebellious streak.

~Noah~
"The man who smiles when things go wrong has thought of someone to blame it on."
- Robert Bloch -

Team Jacob: Because REAL men don't sparkle.
Team Switzerland: Because I like Edward, too.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 203
[quote="Talking_Pinata"]You hang your head—how did you get here?

There’s no past, no future, and hardly any now. The darkness surrounds, but there is an up, and a down. There’s all around you as well. >>> PERFECT TO START I LOVED IT!!!

Suddenly, a stage light shines on you from somewhere above. You squint into the light and see a blinding circle. There are dead moths and june bugs in the light.

“Dance,” They whisper.>>>OOH WHO'S THEY???

Your head jerks in the direction the voices originated. Who are they? Some kind of authority? If you focus on the darkness outside your ring of light, you can see where the illumination reaches their pant legs. They must be slouched over in their chairs.

You can also see the light cast a reflection off their teeth. They’re pointed teeth—ready to eat you, your dreams, your love, your soul, your eyes.

“Dance,” They whisper again. The voice is commanding, and menacing, but you shake your head anyway.

“I don’t want to dance,” you manage to choke out. Your voice hasn’t ever been used, and it hurts when you speak. You’ve never been able to speak back, you realize, but now you can.

“We want you to dance,” They command again; their tone doesn’t grow louder.

“Why am I here?” It hurts to speak. There’s a fire in your throat that tells you to stop, that no good will come of this. >>> THIS IS KINDA LIKE POETRY BUT I STILL ENJOYED THIS PART

“We’ll make you dance then,” they say.

Suddenly, a mechanism churns somewhere. It creaks and groans as it starts up, and you feel a tug against your back, shoulders, legs, and arms. You try and resist, but your muscles are no good against the authority—they are too weak.

“Dance,” They say again, for the satisfaction of you having followed their orders. Their grins widen. They look hungrier. They’ll come for your life soon.

Then your legs rise, and your arms sway side to side. The tugging hurts; the strings are sharp needles that burn into your flesh. You scream but the flames in your throat force you to close your mouth.

And you dance. You twirl and jig and skip and hop and caper and leap. They snicker in their snake-like voices and you sob. The tears don’t burn like the screaming or strings do; they’re your only relief.

Slowly, your arms fall to your side, limp. Your legs begin to dangle and you are lowered to the ground. Then, the stage light flickers off, leaving you with the darkness and the now invisible smiles.

And They come in for the kill.[/quote] >>> LOVE THE ENDING!!!!


Ok I just demolished your work, so sorry about that it was just begging me :) anywho I liked this piece but it sounds more like poetry than a story, like it has a hidden side. I dunno maybe it's just me? I like this piece I think that the title is a bit dull but it kind of brang me in at the same time. I don't think it's other Fiction like I said it's more dramatic poetry I don't mean to tear your work apart or anything but I think that the story was well not so much on the title. Anyways I hope you don't find this too harsh I'm only trying to help PM me if you have any questions or comments. Good luck, have fun, and keep writing :)

as always
-Max
We're meant to be one
I know we are...
If I am the Sky
Then you are my star... ™




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 89
I'm sorry. I couldn't rewrite this as poetry, for I'm not a very good poet. ;)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 21
Beautiful, beautiful work.I really can't see anything that requires editing.
An absolutely perfect piece!!
Amazing imagery, chilling description.
I wasn't even consciously reading it, it just seemed to be happening before my eyes!
I'm utterly in awe of this... Good Job!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 99
I. NITPICKS
You hang your head—how did you get here?


“You hang your head” that doesn’t make sense to me. When I hang my head it usually means I’m frustrated or bored or ashamed or something, not trying to figure out where I am. Just a suggestion.

[s]Suddenly[/s] [take that out], a stage light shines on you from somewhere above. You squint into the light and see a blinding circle [When you say that do you mean the light or the circle of “They”] . There are dead moths and june bugs in the light.


Also, there’s a bit of repetition of “light” here. Change it up.

“Dance,” They whisper.
Your head jerks in the direction [s] the voices originated[/s] [“of the voices” sounds better to me] . Who are they? Some kind of authority? If you focus on the darkness outside your ring of light, you can see where the illumination reaches their pant legs. They must be slouched over in their chairs.


[s]Suddenly[/s], a mechanism churns somewhere. It creaks and groans as it starts up, and you feel a tug against your back, shoulders, legs, and arms [A bit too wordy, take out one of the items in the series or take out “and” because it sounds better] . You try and resist, but your muscles are no good against the authority—they are too weak.


“Dance,” They say again, for the satisfaction of you having followed their orders. Their grins widen. They look hungrier [I don‘t remember you saying they were hungry..]. They’ll come for your life soon.


And you dance. You twirl and jig and skip and hop and caper and leap. They snicker in their snake-like voices and you sob. The tears don’t burn like the screaming or strings do; [I think a dash would be better] they’re your only relief.


Slowly, your arms fall to your side, limp. Your legs begin to dangle and you are lowered to the ground. [s]Then[/s], the stage light flickers off, leaving you with the darkness and the [s]now[/s] invisible smiles.


II. EXPERIMENTING IS FUN

Reading your other pieces I can tell you are experimenting with your writing, which is always fun. I liked this - I usually don’t like second-person pieces but I think it doesn’t the job here.

I agree that the title is a bit too boring for this piece, but I can’t find any more problems. I hope this helps. PM me/text me if you have any questions.
Maybe you should kiss someone nice or lick a rock, or both - Regina Spektor




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 192
Did I ever tell you I love your writing?

Your metaphors and descriptions are supurb. I felt like I was the Doll... very good, Pinata. I'm at a loss for words.

Judging by previous comments, you've improved this to make it even greater than it already was.

No crit here, just a star! :D




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 89
AHHH! Thank you! I appreciate the completment so much!




Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 4
This work is one of the more abstract ones I've read, and it did a great job on keeping my attention. A rather sinister and daunting story about how one cannot escape authority, though it did feel a bit lacking. Perhaps it is too short to be a considered a short story. It seemed more like a prose to me.

Either way, well done. I'll be reading more of your work, that I will.
Strong is he who tames his anger




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 890
Reviews 10
Much has already been pointed out, and it seems that you have edited the story two times already. Nevertheless I will throw in my own opinion too.

I liked the oddity of the story very much, and I don't think it was too short at all. I kept imagining the doll as a marionette, though I may be wrong about that (?). You can almost feel the doll's despair grow.

Talking_Pinata wrote:“Dance,” They whisper. [As October Girl pointed out, who are "they"? it sounds as if the dead bugs are talking]


I don't think there's much else that I can point out. Maybe I should read some of your other stories if they resemble this one in style :). Bravo! *applauds*
In omnibus requiem quaesivi, et nusquam inveni nisi in angulo cum libro.
Character in avatar belongs to Sarah Ellerton.



Those are my principles. If you don't like them I have others.
— Groucho Marx