By Sun, By Moon - Prologue

35 posts1, 2, 3
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 6
KJ wrote: I met his stare, hating and defying his silent condescension. But, after a long moment, I was the one to drop my gaze.


is it correct to start a sentence with 'But'? I don't think it is however I could be wrong.

However putting that aside that was amazing. It introduced you to the story very well however did not give too much away and burden the reader with information, it had the exact right amount of information and progression through the story. I will definitely make an effort the read through the rest of it after I have caught up on some sleep after handing in my college project.

A very enjoyable read




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1068
Reviews 582
*EDITED* Wow, it's been a long time since I've worked on this! I've only just now starte dto get a passion for it again. Weird, huh?




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 12900
Reviews 110
Hi KJ,

This was readable. You picked a good dramatic scene to start with, and I liked the fact that the worst possible outcome is the one that actually happened. I'm getting the strong impression that the Mark character will save the narrator from being killed, in which case the plot is a little predictable and maybe too heavily foreshadowed in this prologue. If not, ignore that.

My key problem with this piece was not being engaged with any of the characters. It felt like a lot of characters were introduced in a short space, and many of them were just throwaways: Derrick is just a name, Cornelia feels like a generic antagonist to me, the father was weak. Mark and Richard came across to me as puffed-up cockerels comparing the size of their, uh, whatever cockerels compare the size of. I wanted to tell them to get a ruler out already and end the argument once and for all.

Conversely, I quite liked the narrator's jaded thoughts about how her father wasn't a hero, least of all hers, and her courage in facing her own death. But I think her characterisation still needs another layer. Here are examples of places you could still work on:

* You don't need to explain directly to the reader that the narrator is fooling herself about not needing Mark. It'd be just as obvious and, imo, more elegant if she just turned her back on him telling herself she didn't need him.

* Ditto for her reaction to the family's eyes boring into her in the first sentence. Her family are hating on her, she hunches her shoulders. End of sentence. Emotion shown, not told. (A rule of thumb I learned from a smart person is RUE - Resist the Urge to Explain.)

* Her emotional reaction to her father not helping her is delayed, to the point where I couldn't quite follow the emotional journey that she went through. Remember to keep cause and effect together and flowing logically. She looks to her dad to protect her, but because he cops out, now she knows he's not a hero. It's these because-s that need to be in place.

I don't want to knock on her characterisation too much, because I enjoyed the edge that she has, but you can still take her up another level.

Not knowing what she actually did is hurting the story for me, I think. I can't tell whether the narrator is a moron who screwed up and is getting her just desserts, or a freedom-fighting iconoclast who's about to die for flouting tradition, or ... something else. This would really help me understand her. Nor can I tell whether the other characters are all as generically evil as they seem, or whether they actually have a reason for sentencing the narrator to death.

The pack voting ritual with the howling was interesting and atmospheric. The only part that bugged me is that I can't understand how a werewolf pack, which is apparently led by whoever is biggest and scariest and most heavily muscled, has democratic voting rituals. Especially since a few lines earlier the Mark and Richard characters settled a dispute with a Dark Ages-esque physical dominance challenge. These elements of the world-building aren't matching up very well for me. I'm struggling to understand the culture here.

Story has good bones, potentially going somewhere interesting, still needs a little smoothing over.

Karsten




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 7
great job, i was feeling really sorry for her and was pretty much like "no why! give her a chance" and such which is really good. i felt like i was there, with the way you described everything, and i felt like i was actually the one being put to death.

well done
christine (slightly weird, but normal otherwise)




Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 1040
Reviews 8
Hi KJ,


i really enjoyed your prologue it gave me a sense of the love hate relationship between both Pack mate towards Pack mate and human towards wolf.



You told us the setting emphasizing on the date which is a modern date, yet the humans are surrounding the pack with torches..... seems a little old school


All in all it was great writing and I am looking forward to reading all your work and hopefully some gruesome fight scenes
LIVE, LOVE, AND WRITE
to express your self is not weird its natural and, in my opinion, AWESOME!!!!



No great thing is created suddenly. There must be time. Give your best and always be kind.
— Epictetus