Annabelle's Box

9 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5120
Reviews 317
______________________

On the bottom of the small old wooden shelf up in my Grandma’s attic sat a small rusty metal box with a tiny lock on it. On the either side of the box, someone had written “Do Not Open”.

Ever since I was a child, I would go up in to the attic and sit in front of the box, taking it in my hand and pondering over its mysterious contents. I was not allowed to open the box--no one was-- and I only really got to see it over the summer holidays, when I visited my Grandmother.

She was quite sensitive about the box; I wasn’t to walk around with it or shake it (which I once tired to do to guess what was in it). The box was to be held with the utmost care. I asked her once when I was seven, about it's contents.

“Gran, what’s inside the metal box up in the attic?”

She had been reading a book. She peered at me from the top of her glasses. “What box?”

“You know the small one. The one with the lock and it says ‘do not open’?” I took a seat beside her on her bed. She took off her glasses and placed them gently on her side table. She fingered the book for a while, lost in thought.

“Well?” I said impatiently.

“It belonged to my sister. My little sister Annabelle.”

“She died when she was twelve right?”

“Yes her, Now don’t interrupt and I’ll tell you all about it.” She frowned at me. I nodded back. She continued, “We use to live in a cabin, away from town. We very poor and Father had just lost his job. He worked as a hired help for a farm uptown. Mother would go into town and sew for money. She earned money, but just barely enough to survive. Annabelle and I decided one day to sell all our belonging for a bit of money. We got it into our heads and told no one about our plan.”

Grandma chuckled softly. I did not see what was so funny. I wanted her to get to the part about the box.

“Well we got our all our things together. All our stockings, mittens and any toys that we had, all our clothes other than the ones we were wearing. Then we marched off to Town without telling anyone. But when we arrived, we did not know where to go, what to do, or where to sell our things. After a bit of looking around we saw beggars lined up on the street selling bits of odds and ends. We placed a sheet on the ground and sat right beside them. We were quite dusty and tired from our long walk to town, so we fit in right with the beggars.

“Annabelle starting calling out to people, just like the other vendors on the street. Now that I recall our prices were outrageously cheap. Every bit of thing we had was sold. With the small cash we had earned we headed back home, two very happy, bright-eyed girls. Oh we got scolded my Ma. But Papa took our hard earned cash and put it into his breast pocket. “Thank-you girls. It’ll really help”

“Is it a lot papa?” We asked. He smiled softly and nodded. Oh bless him. It was actually barely enough to buy bread and eggs. It wasn’t until the next day, we regretted our hasty decision. We never talked of it but we always felt it. We didn’t own a bit of thing. By and by we got a few clothes but not a toy we had other than our own home made twig dolls.
“Six months later, Papa came home with a small metal box with a key and lock.”

I perked up, suddenly attentive and very much interested. Grand-ma sighed.
“He handed it to Annabelle. He told her it was hers. Just for her. Her very own. He told us he had found it in the woods on his way home from Town. Dear Annabelle hugged it to her chest, her first possession in months.”

“What did she put in it?” I couldn’t contain myself and blurted my question out.

Grandma looked at carefully.

“I don’t know. She never told us what she kept in it. She was very secretive and possessive about her box. She opened it and closed all the time, she took it with her wherever she could. And not a single one of us was allowed to touch it or open it. Whatever she kept in it, she kept it a secret. It was always locked”

“But didn’t you ever try to open it?” I asked slowly.

“I tired but she always kept it with her. Especially when she caught the scarlet fever. It was always by her side. I never got the chance to open it. She died just soon after. Leaving me the key.”

“Did you open the box then?”

“No dear. Many times I wanted to. But I respected her wish. Her secrecy. I still have the key. And I can open it anytime I want. But I won’t.”

“Oh” I said, much disappointed. “Well Grandma if you change your mind…can you tell me what’s in it?”

Grandmother smiled slowly. “Go on now and let me finish my book.”


It wasn’t until I was married and had kids of my own, that I ever got to open the box. Grand-mother Died at the age of eighty-seven leaving me the key to the box of Annabelle.

I was a grown up woman by then, but my curiosity about the box was as fierce as ever. I deceived the trust of my Grand-mother. I opened the box soon after her death.


I knew I couldn’t live without ever knowing what was inside the box. I needed to know why Annabelle was so secretive. What did the box contain that she could show to no one, not even her closest friend, her sister.
A week after my Grand-Mother’s funeral, I climbed up to the attic, the key to the box in my hand. I knelt down towards the box. I opened it slowly, turning the key in the lock. The box was extremely old and rusty. It made an awful noise as I pulled the lid up.

It contained a small piece of folded paper in it. My heart thumping, I carefully unfolded the paper. This was it. Annabelle’s secret.

My heart fell as I read the paper. I was confused. In neat cursive writing, it read “Annabelle Rose Johnson.”

What so secretive about that? I didn’t understand. Maybe the real object had been taken out by Annabelle before she died. Maybe Annabelle had gone crazy. Was that a symptom of the scarlet fever? No I didn’t think so.

I left Pine Hollow, My Grand-Mother’s house two weeks later, ready for the long car ride home. I got myself and my kids in our van and started for home, my head still buzzing with questions about Annabelle’s box.

“Mommy tell Ben to stop bugging me.” My six year old complained from the back of the van.

“Ben, leave your little sister alone.”

“I just wanted to read her diary.” Replied Ben

“Jenny, dear will it hurt if you let you brother read it?” I groaned.

“ But Mom. It’s mine!”

“Is there a secret or something that you don’t want Ben to read?” I asked.

“No-oo” She replied slowly. “But it’s mine. All mine. I don’t have to share. It belongs to me and only me. Mommy I really like having it as just mine.”

I was about to say something back to my daughter about sharing, when suddenly I remembered Annabelle’s box. Suddenly it all made sense. My six year old daughter had answered all my questions.
Last edited by mizz-iceberg on Wed Apr 09, 2008 5:53 pm, edited 2 times in total.
I'm a godmother, that's a great thing to be, a godmother. She calls me god for short, that's cute, I taught her that.
--Ellen DeGeneres




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 4832
Reviews 199
This was well written, and not the normal fare.
Let me start with a couple small technical problems I saw:
+ In the first sentance you use the word "shelf" twice. I'd remove the "the bottom shelf of" Leaving: "On the old wooden...."
+ Beggers selling "odds and ends"
+ Regretted our "hasty" decision

I thought I had one more, but I can't find it...

Regardless, I enjoyed your story quite a bit. The only thing I didn't quite understand was the corrolation between the girls selling all their possesions and the box. I can guess at it, but it was perhaps a little too deliberately vague. And why did only Annabelle get the box? You want readers to have questions during the story, but maybe you're pulling "an Anabelle" by not giving us the answers.

Good work!
The woods are lovely, dark and deep.
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.
- Robert Frost

It cost $7 million to build the Titanic, and $200 million to make a film about it.
The plastic ties on the end of shoelaces are called aglets




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7241
Reviews 721
I really liked this. There were quite a few grammatical mistakes, but the plot was almost masterful. I will definitely not forget it in a pinch. I love stories that get you thinking and (unlike smorgishborg) I think the vagueness was one of the best parts of the story.

The main negative thing I noticed (besides the grammar mistakes I've already mentioned) is your really short, choppy sentences which don't work very well for a piece like this. I will try to point out both things in my critique.

I'll get onto the critique now... Please note that these are just suggestions and you needn't include any of them if you don't want to.

Firstly, I do agree with smogishborg that you need to eliminate the two "shelf"s in the first sentence, it didn't read smoothly at all.

The box had been the center of my curiosity for years.

Delete this. You go on in the next paragraph to explain HOW it had been the center of her curiosity for years, so why say it here?

I was not allowed to open the box. No one was. I really only got to see the box over the summer holidays, when I visited my Grand-mother.

I think it would read better as: "I was not allowed to open the box--no one was-- and I only really got to see it over the summer holidays, when I visited my Grand-mother."

She was quite sensitive about the box. I wasn’t to walk around with it. I wasn’t allowed to shake it (which I once tired to do to guess what was in it). The box was to be held with the utmost care. I asked her once when I was seven, about the box.

Would read better as "She was quite sensitive about the box; I wasn’t to walk around with it or shake it (which I once tired to do to guess what was in it). The box was to be held with the utmost care. I asked her once when I was seven, about it's contents."

“She died when she was twelve right?”

This is COMPLETELY a matter of opinion, but I think this wouldn't be a very polite thing to say... And also, isn't she seven when she's asking these questions? How then would she be referring in past tense to something that happened when she was twelve?

She earned. But just barely enough.

Make the period in the middle into a comma.

Well we marched off to Town without telling anyone. And when we arrived, we did not know where to go. What to do. Where to sell our things.

First sentence: I think it should be "Then we marched off..."
The rest of it: Should be "But when we arrived, we did not know where to go, what to do, or where to sell our things."

“Annabelle starting calling out to people, just like the other vendors on the street. Now that I recall our prices were outrageously cheap. Every bit of thing we had was sold. With the small cash we had earned we headed back home, two very happy, bright-eyed girls. Oh we got scolded my Ma. But Papa took our hard earned cash and put it into his breast pocket. “Thank-you girls. It’ll really help”
“Is it a lot papa?” We asked. He smiled softly and nodded. Oh bless him. It was actually barely enough to buy bread and eggs. It wasn’t until the next day, we regretted our haste decision. We never talked of it but we always felt it. We didn’t own a bit of thing. By and by we got a few clothes but not a toy we had other than our own home made twig dolls.
“Six months later, Papa came home with a small metal box with a key and lock.”

You need to break this whole section up a bit, make it spaced out like the rest of the story. And about the part in bold... do you mean "It really helped"? Or maybe "It really helps"?

“What did she put in it” I couldn’t contain myself and blurted my question out. Grand-ma looked at carefully.
“I don’t know. She never...

Firstly, there should be a question mark after "...put in it" And secondly, fix the spacing here as well.

“Well Grand-ma if you change your mind…can you tell me what’s in it.”

Put a question mark at the end of this. And also, the spelling of Grandma is inconsistent... sometimes you say "grand-ma" or "grand-mother" but other times you say "grandmother"... just something to think about.

“Jenny, dear will it hurt if you let you brother read it.” I groaned.

Make what she says into a question by putting a question mark after "read it"
------------------

...and that's about it. :D I suggest tat you read through it to yourself (out loud or under your breath). That really helps to diminish the rough spots and make it read smoother.

Overall, I really liked the feeling this piece gave me... good job!

PM me if you have questions!
~Azlia~




Random avatar
Gender Male
Points 1823
Reviews 665
I liked this and the vagueness was good. It was a nice short peice and left people wanting to know more. Where is this set though, what country. I think of some European place for some reason. Like Romania or something. The Grandmother thing too no dash to seperate it. Tis was a good story and I believe Azila caught worse problem :). Just read it over carefully like other two have said. Kudos for an enjoyable read.

Good luck VSN
We get off to the rhythm of the trigger and destruction. Fallujah to New Orleans with impunity to kill. We are the hidden fist of the free market.
We are the ink, we are the quill.
[The Ink And The Quill (Be Afraid) - Anti-Flag]




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1121
Reviews 57
This is a really awesome piece. I was so curious to know what was in the box! You did an awesome job reeling and hooking your audience. You've got a promising career ahead of you. One thing though, I didn't realize it was a little girl 'till somewhere near the end. Maybe you could make that clearer? Anyway, keep writing.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 514
Azila seemed to catch the mistakes I found, so I really don't have much to say.

I think that the secrecy of it all was done well, and I loved that the six year old was able to answer the question. What I didn't like so much was that there was so little emotion when it came to the deaths of characters, Grandmother to Annabelle, MC to Grandmother.

I think you did a very good job, and congradulations on finishing a story, it's an awesome feeling isn't it?

Keep up the good work!
-JC
But that is not the question. Why we are here, that is the question. And we are blessed in this, that we happen to know the answer. Yes, in this immense confusion one thing alone is clear. We are waiting for Godot to come. -Beckett




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 516
On the bottom shelf of the small old wooden shelf up in my Grand-ma’s attic sat a small rusty metal box with a tiny lock on it. On the either side of the box, someone had written “Do Not Open”. The box had been the center of my curiosity for years.


I like your beginning it drew me in right away, although I don't know why you spelt Grandma as Grand-ma. I'd fix that up, unless theyre's a reason for it?

Ever since I was a child, I would go up in to the attic and sit in front of the box, taking it in my hand and pondering over its mysterious contents. I was not allowed to open the box. No one was. I really only got to see the box over the summer holidays, when I visited my Grand-mother.


I don't know if she'd be mor or less curious if she hardly saw the box. At the moment, I'm thinking less. Again with the Grandmother thing.

“Yes her. Now don’t interrupt and I’ll tell you all about it.” She frowned at me. I nodded back. She continued, “We use to live in a cabin, away from town. We very poor and Father had just lost his job. He worked as a hired help for a farm uptown. Mother would go into town and sew for money. She earned. But just barely enough. Annabelle and I decided one day to sell all our belonging for a bit of money. We got it into our heads and told no one about our plan.”


I don't really think she'd be telling this to a seven-year old. It seems a bit heavy.

“Oh” I said, much disappointed. “Well Grand-ma if you change your mind…can you tell me what’s in it.”


what's in it?"

Grandmother smiled slowly “Go on now and let me finish my book.”


Grandmother smiled slowly. "Go on now and let me finish my book."

“I just wanted to read her diary.” Replied Ben

“Jenny, dear will it hurt if you let you brother read it.” I groaned.

“ But Mom. It’s mine!”

“Is there a secret or something that you don’t want Ben to read?” I asked.

“No-oo” She replied slowly. “But it’s mine. All mine. I don’t have to share. It belongs to me and only me. Mommy I really like having it as just mine.”


This bit was really cute and funny. You captured a little girl's personality perfectly. But, a six year old with a diary? I don't know about that.

Overall, I liked this piece. It was sweet. I'd put in a little bit more description, and it was really annoyig how you kept writing Grand-ma. Apart from that, it was good.
*Don't expect to see me around much in the next couple of weeks. School has started again, and it'll be a couple of weeks before I've settled in. If you've asked me for a critique, you will get it, but not for a little while. Sorry*




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1068
Reviews 582
Hello. Everyone pretty much has all the editing covered, but there were a couple things that I thought needed adjusting:

“Well?” I said impatiently.

It would seem that, after asking a question that may provoke anger from her grandmother, and that the girl really wants to know the answer, I don't think she would take the risk of being demanding and impatient.


The only other thing was this: Why didn't the girl at least attempt to open the box? I realize that there was a lock, but any normal child would usually attempt to. Locks never stopped me when I was small. I would try to find a key, or just bust the thing.

Otherwise, very creative and pretty well-written. Oh, and you don't really need a dash between Grand and ma. Saw that a couple times.

Keep writing.




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1075
Reviews 842
I only noticed a few things:

She fingered for a while with her book, lost in thought.


This should be worded differently. She fingered the book for a while, lost in thought.

“Yes her. Now don’t interrupt and I’ll tell you all about it.”


There should be a comma between Yes and her.

She earned. But just barely enough.


This should be two sentences. Like: She earned money, but just barely enough to survive.

Otherwise, it was good. You definitely need a more gripping hook though. I won't lie when I say that I was losing interest until the grandma started the story.

That's really all you need to work on.

Keep Working :)
"Woe to the man whose heart has not learned while young to hope, to love—and to put his trust in life."
~ Joseph Conrad


"Music washes away from the soul the dust of everyday life."
~ Red Auerbach



Blessed is the man who, having nothing to say, abstains from giving us wordy evidence of the fact.
— George Eliot