-
Re: A Christmas Parable (Removed)
This play has been removed because it was terrible. Sorry if you were unfortunate enough to read it. ~ smorg
Dec 24, 2007 -
Re: A Day's Diamond
I'm sorry, but this one does nothing for me. I don't have any questions about your effort, you seemed to be trying, but I felt the effects of a lack ...
Dec 24, 2007 -
Re: The Sweet Smell Of Success
Well, it's nice. I enjoyed the roundabout way you approached a rather simple story. couldn 't’t Why did that keep happening? What [s]I[/s] must rank as my greatest success did ...
Dec 23, 2007 -
Re: Trickster
Interesting... Certainly unique, it all depends on where you go with this. She leaned her head back as she heard someone open the door to the jail. A weird line. ...
Dec 22, 2007 -
Re: Honor
I like critiquing your work Kylan, I always have very little to do... EDIT: There you go! Three cheers for my 100th post!
Dec 22, 2007 -
Re: The flower fields
Nah, didn't cut it. Disjointed and rambling. The random bits of actual plot description were kinda useless, better cut them and let the dialogue speak (pun!) for itself. Better yet, ...
Dec 21, 2007 -
Re: Something Exciting that Happens to Be Untitled
Supurb work. I like the complex rhyming, I almost missed it! What I liked the most was the use of toast as a metaphor for the rising oil prices worldwide.. ...
Dec 21, 2007 -
Re: Critique the Person Above You!
Führer Kylan, I apologize, I've been to busy to tackle the second "Honor" portion. Bear with me, I should get it done no later then Friday. ... URL CODE IS ...
Dec 20, 2007 -
Re: Führer
Ever read Harry Turtledove? :D Well, I really enjoy your ideas, and your writing, and your story. But On first read, you lost me utterly and totally. What you need ...
Dec 20, 2007 -
Re: Lucky Number Seven
Indeed! Significantly improved!But not perfect. First, I saw two instances of you not capitalizing the name of a character when they deliver a line. Worst case of this was in ...
Dec 20, 2007 -
Re: o.o eh i dunno
This is not lyric, nor is it poetry. In fact, I'd shudder to call it literature, the punctuation, spelling, and grammar is awful. Which leads me to ask... what are ...
Dec 19, 2007 -
Re: The Heart of the Heavens
The main problem wiith this is that I think it's too obscure, too nonsenical, too all-over-the place Yes. Nail/head. It holds some allure, I think, because of it's unconventional treatment ...
Dec 18, 2007 -
Re: A young girls suicide
This poem displays a fundamental ignorance (possibly disinterest) in what makes a poem engaging to a reader. On some level, the reader must relate to the work. Because of this, ...
Dec 18, 2007 -
Re: All Poets Should Read This
First, take a deep breath. In. Out. Now, by joining a writing forum, you ought to be aware that your work will be critiqued, criticized, and misinterpreted. This is not ...
Dec 16, 2007 -
Re: Lucky Number Seven
My feelings here are mixed. This is partially the case because this is way to little to work on. If you really want a full critique with full understanding, then ...
Dec 16, 2007
