Sureal

It's what he DIDN'T do that got him jail time. You think that not reporting a crime is enough to warrant a life sentance?

GryphonFledgling: An adult novel under 90,000 or over 120,000 words is unlikely to be published.

But you're still missing my argument: that the guy's action don't deserve the punishment he recieved, and so the law failed him.

But you're ignoring my entire argument: that the man didn't fail, the law did, and as such the law should be changed to accomodate how he reacted to the situation. ...

Now that is a little off topic. If you want to screw another gay guy or look at porn when you're 16 thats fine. This was a murder. It killed ...

Yes, it can. The law is constantly changing. Example: homosexual sex between two consenting men was illegal in England until 1967; by your reasoning, it should still be illegal and ...

The debate is whether or not he deserved this sentance, so no, it isn't pointless.

What if he was also a very close friend? Would you shoot him then? Are you asking us if a guy could kill a friend just after he’d killed his ...

His shows are always amazing to watch. I'd love to see him perform a live show.

Everyone is afraid of everyone else; we live in a constant state of paranoia, of distrust of our neighbours. And because of this we're not going to get rid of ...

So your argument is that he should be in jail because he failed to avoid being put in jail?

shotgun: your argument dies because the guy had no idea that they were going to commit the murder beforehand; he couldn't see into the future and they hadn't told him ...

Hello Wozzel - thanks for the timely reply (indeed: it appears you were so fast in reacting that you actually began work on this review in the twenty or so ...

And with a whimper only it can hear, the world ends. There are no cries of grief, nor any of triumph, there is only that omnipresent silence; the half-burnt corpse ...

YA novels tend to range from 40,000 to 80,000.