-
Re: Perlec
Despite its shortness, this is quite a good beggining, and yes, it's worth continuing. There are a few things that could be improved. Take this for example. He approached the ...
May 17, 2009 -
Re: The Quintessence of Randomness - Part 1
It isn't for everybody I guess. This was experimental. I started this with my mum when we were just being silly on holidays, but I decided to continue it. It ...
May 17, 2009 -
Re: Phantasm:Chapter One (Part Two)
To be honest, I think this wasn't quite as good as the previous part of the story. It was confusing at first, until I realised it was the ghosts of ...
May 17, 2009 -
Re: Phantasm:Prologue and Chapter one (Part one)
Overall I think this is a solid beggining to a story. Considering it's only halfway through the first chapter, the main character's personality is coming together nicely, and he doesn't ...
May 17, 2009 -
Re: The Quintessence of Randomness - Part 1
‘Twas raining hard on the caravan Nothing to do but sit That morning I’d eaten so much ham That I needed to do a shit I’d held it in all ...
May 15, 2009 -
Re: Oblivious Chapter One
This is unlike anything else I've ever read - but I loved it. The writing style is so engaging. I have read some other stories where it's as if the ...
May 15, 2009 -
Re: Assination Chapter 1 (incomplete)
Hi I won't bother telling you about paragraphing and grammar and all that fug. That's already been covered, and what you really need help with is character realism. At the ...
May 15, 2009 -
Re: The Accidental Rebellion, Ch. 3 - Exodus
This is updated - 3rd version now. There's a lot of new stuff, some old stuff chucked out and plenty of changes. Please review if you've got the time. Thanks ...
May 12, 2009 -
Re: The Accidental Rebellion, Prologue
I just updated this. The next chapter I'm posting (5) features Eric (who used to be called George) so I thought I'd put the latest version of the prologue up.
May 7, 2009 -
Re: Tales of a Kingdom
I was very impressed with the clarity of your writing. I only had to read this through once and feel like I have a perfect understanding of what's going on. ...
May 4, 2009 -
Re: A Brave Knight
Your writing style is a lot like the way someone would tell a story around a campfire. That is, it would work well told verbally. Unfortunately, when someone reads a ...
May 2, 2009 -
Re: Cold Blood
As my good friend Kyllorac said, You have an excellent base. In fact, all three of your stories on YWS have a good plot, if a little simple, but that ...
May 2, 2009 -
Re: My Fire (edited)
You've got a storyline, but it'll need a lot of work. The main problem is that so much of it is narrative summary. You need to break all of the ...
May 2, 2009 -
Re: Once Upon a Time
Yo, my latest YWS buddy! This is quite an interesting and unique peice of writing. You said it was just a character development excercise, but I think it's such a ...
May 1, 2009 -
Re: Hoofbeats Pound
This looks a lot like my fist drafts - that is, lots of dialogue, but not much else yet. Which is okay for a first draft, but something to work ...
May 1, 2009
