z

Young Writers Society


The Girl Has Been Silenced



User avatar
129 Reviews



Gender: None specified
Points: 2564
Reviews: 129
Mon Apr 04, 2011 12:57 am
Gracie says...



Spoiler! :
Please rip to shreds. As you'll notice I don't name the main character (or characters) and instead call them "The girl" and "The woman" It is just a new technique I'm trying and I'd really like to know what you think of it.


“I’m never getting married” Is what it said. Written feverishly on exercise book. The pen had pressed so hard it almost tore the paper. The handwriting so messy it was almost unreadable. They were words of passion, words of certainty, a one girl’s mind that would not be changed.
That very girl was now a women and leaning over the ragged notebook, in the corner of a room that was once her own. She couldn’t recognize this girl who wrote the words. A girl with her opinions and fire and flair. She was like a dream, something that the women could read but not understand.
The women stood up from the notebook and paced herself around the room. It was the first time she had visited it in 6 years and it had changed drastically. Most toxins of her adolescence had been scrubbed away. The closet of black had been given to charity and shelves painted back to white. The women touched the peeled wallpaper where all her posters had been ripped off.
Then she looked in the mirror. Her reflection has changed as much as the room itself. Though her skin was still pale and thin like crate paper. Her hair was dyed platinum blond and ironed into tight cowlick curls. She showed the beginning of aging, with creases forming around her eyes and mouth, that she chose to ignore. Her figure was slender and almost always fitted into breezy summer dresses. She was clean, easy and conventional. A productive member of society. A perfect wife, perfect daughter, perfect employer. A sweet and simple woman. The girl would have despised her.
There were not many pictures of the girl in the house. The last thing her parents had wanted. Her parents were like any couple on a small suburban street in the backblocks of Melbourne. The girl looked like she more belonged in Kings Cross or some other seedy suburb. She had fallen in love with dying her hair and changed it weekly. When she was 14 she shaved one half of it off and pushed the rest to the side. Her eyes were the colour of smoke, speckled with green and hazel and fuelled with anger. She wore plaid miniskirts, patterned tights and jumpers even in the boiling summer. Heavy army boots were her shoe of choice. She would stomp around her house in them just to feel heard.
The girl spent little time at her house, and she spent the time she was there wishing she wasn’t. It had never been her home, as far as she was concerned. Instead she took buses to the city, just to get away. She wandered the well-worn backstreet and narrow alleys, staring up at the sky, mind blank, running her fingers along the brick scorched by graffiti and tags. She had some friends, but few. Partly because she was not the type of person the suburb kids wanted to bring home and partly because she could zone out so far people thought she was sleeping with her eyes open. In fact she could so zone out so far people would think she wasn’t there at all. And maybe she wasn’t.

The woman’s parents called her down to lunch. It was a usual Sunday spread, of roast chicken and potatoes and white dough rolls. The woman’s husband, Clark was sitting opposite her in a mustard coloured shirt. Clark’s sharp Italian features had once been so handsome and enduring. With age and the stress of marriage he now just appeared cruel.
He was a strong man, in both mind and body. He was proud of his ability to withhold emotion, especially to his wife. Over the years their marriage had gone from joyful to sensible to miserable. Now he didn’t even look at her.
The woman’s parents, however, were oblivious. They were on the downhill side of 60 and had a hard time excepting it. They bought into the suburban dream, a pastel coloured house and a wardrobe full of beige.
“I saw you were looking through your old room, love” Said the women’s father
“Yeah just looking through some old photo’s” She said fidgeting in her seat
“Was it from that awful rebellious phase” Said the mother, laughing awkwardly.
“Oh I wasn’t just a phase, dear” Said the father “It was your whole adolescence. You were a silly girl, you were. A silly, silly girl.”
“Yeah I guess so” Said the woman, again looking down at her hands.
“Well you grew up” Clark said with his deep booming voice. “That’s what happens with everyone, they grow up.”

The girl sat poised at the stranger’s window, looking down at the heads below her. She was at a house party, one that everyone was going to. She estimated she had about 7 minutes before the drugs kicked in. The girl had always fantasied about getting high. People had told her that it was like getting lost in a beautiful city. That you did not know where you were or what you were doing but that was okay. She heard the ugly of it to. That it could drive you crazy. That it could kill you. “I’m already dead” she thought. So here she was, seeing the lights of the party below her blur in her charcoal rimmed eyes. Three grams of coke was rushing through her body, it was only a matter of time till it set in.
The girl climbed back through her bedroom window at noon the next day. All the energy had been sapped from her body in the 12 block run from the party to her own miserable house. Her parents were out as she lay, exhausted in her bed, cotton sheets sticking to her bony, sweaty body. “I want to do that next weekend” she thought “And every weekend after that.”

“So how bad were you as a kid” asked Clark on the car ride back. Although he had made a silent pledge to ignore the woman (as punishment for not ironing his pants) he let his curiosity get the best of him.
“How do you mean” said the women
“Did you go to parties?”
“Yes” she said, voice clipped in fear for his reaction
“Drink alcohol?”
“Well yes”
He gripped the steering wheel tighter.
“Drugs”
The woman’s voice was now trembling.
“Yes”
Clark’s knuckles were now white around the steering wheel.
“Why”
“I – I was a angry kid, Clark. I really angry messed up kid.” She stumbled over her words.
He swerved violently to the side of the road.
“Do you know why I’m upset about this?” His voice was soft and dangerous
“Honey, please-“
“Do you?”
“It was a long time ago”
“It doesn’t change anything-“
I was a different person, I’ve changed”
“People don’t change”
“Honey please keep driving”
He looked at her, all sharp eyes and features, then slowly started the car motor.
“If you have been hiding that what else have you been hiding” said Clark
“Nothing”
“And how can I believe that”
“You just have to trust me”
“Trust you” his voice splintered in rage.
“I hate you” he said “and knows I mean it”


Clack didn’t mean it, of course. He forgave her a few days later and life went on as normal. The woman continued visiting her parents monthly. She continued to waste her money on things she did not need. She continued to despise her crow’s feet, die her hair, work her job, which was both unchallenging and boring. She continued to dodge questions about her youth, switching the topic and glossing over details.

It seemed that, at last, the girl had been silenced.
I can't explain myself, I'm afraid, Sir, because I'm not myself you see.

Alice in Wonderland
  





User avatar
403 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 23786
Reviews: 403
Mon Apr 04, 2011 3:55 am
SmylinG says...



Hey Gracie.. I don't think I've read any of your work in awhile. I shall review this for you. :) I'll start with edits.

Written feverishly on(an) exercise book (There's suppose to be an an there, am I right?)


The handwriting was so messy it was almost unreadable. They were words of passion, words of certainty, of one girl’s mind that would not be changed.


Her reflection had changed as much as the room itself.


that she chose to ignore. ("that" should be "which")


The last thing her parents had wanted. (What did you mean by this here? That they didn't want the daughter or that they didn't want pictures of her? It didn't seem very clear. I'd tweak it just a little.)


When she was 14(,) Comma she shaved one half of it off and pushed the rest to the side.


Her eyes were the colour of smoke, speckled with green and hazel and fuelled (Fueled is spelt with only one "l" with anger. She wore plaid miniskirts, patterned tights and jumpers even in the boiling summer. Heavy army boots were her shoe of choice. She would stomp around her house in them just to feel heard. (I love how you described this. It was perfect. :))


In fact(,) Comma she could so zone out so far people would think she wasn’t there at all.


The woman’s husband, Clark(,) Comma was sitting


“I saw you were looking through your old room, love(,) Commasaid the woman’s father(.) Period
“Yeah(,) Comma just looking through some old photos (it needs no apostrophe) (,)she said(,) fidgeting in her seat(.) Period
“Was it from that awful rebellious phase(?)said the mother, laughing awkwardly.
“Oh(,) it wasn’t just a phase, dear(,)said the father(,) “It was your whole adolescence. You were a silly girl, you were. A silly, silly girl.”
“Yeah(,) I guess so(,)said the woman, again looking down at her hands.
“Well you grew up(,)” Clark said with his deep booming voice. “That’s what happens with everyone, they grow up.”


she had about 7 minutes (I would just spell it as seven


The girl had always fantasized about getting high. (A misspelling.)


That you did not know where you were or what you were doing(,) Comma but that was okay. She heard the ugly of it too.


“I’m already dead(,) Comma” she thought.


Three grams of coke was rushing through her body(.) It was only a matter of time till it set in.


“I want to do that next weekend(,)” she thought(,) “And every weekend after that.”


“So how bad were you as a kid(?)” asked Clark on the car ride back. Although he had made a silent pledge to ignore the woman(,) (as punishment for not ironing his pants) he let his curiosity get the best of him.
“How do you mean(?)” said the wom(a)n
“Did you go to parties?”
“Yes(,)” she said, voice clipped in fear for his reaction
“Drink alcohol?”
“Well(,) yes(.)
He gripped the steering wheel tighter.
“Drugs(?)
The woman’s voice was now trembling.
“Yes(.)
Clark’s knuckles were now white around the steering wheel.
“Why(?)
“I – I was a angry kid, Clark. A really angry messed up kid.” She stumbled over her words.
He swerved violently to the side of the road.
“Do you know why I’m upset about this?” His voice was soft and dangerous(.)
“Honey, please-“
“Do you?”
“It was a long time ago(.)
“It doesn’t change anything-“
(")I was a different person, I’ve changed”
“People don’t change(.)
“Honey(,) please keep driving(.)
He looked at her, all sharp eyes and features, then slowly started the car motor.
“If you have been hiding that(,) what else have you been hiding(?)” said Clark(.)
“Nothing(.)
“And how can I believe that(?)
“You just have to trust me(.)
“Trust you(.)His voice splintered in rage.
“I hate you(,)” he said(,) “and know I mean it”


Clack (Clark) didn’t mean it, of course. He forgave her a few days later(,) and life went on as normal.


Okay, so now that I've finished being all anal with grammar, I would just like to say that this was really beautifully written. Really, I loved it. It had it's own sort of gloominess that continued to soak in as I read on. I think you ended it beautifully. I couldn't possibly think of a better way your ending could have turned out. You tied up every loose end, and it was smooth and interesting all the way through. Great work here. :) With those corrections made, I think this will be pretty virtually flawless. At least in my opinion.
Paul is my little, evil, yellow bundle of joy.
  





User avatar
12 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 1141
Reviews: 12
Fri Apr 08, 2011 3:53 pm
pterascreams says...



I think SmylinG took care of all of the spelling and grammar mistakes that I saw, so on to my evaluation of the content. I really enjoyed it. It's interesting, and I actually like the use of 'the girl' and 'the woman' as opposed to a name. It really shows just how different the two are. They are pretty much polar opposites, and the difference in reference to them really helps point that out. I can really see people being able to relate to this. Overall, this was a great read. Feel free to request a review on your other works as well. Keep writing!

-Liz
Writing is a socially acceptable form of schizophrenia. ~E.L. Doctorow
  





User avatar
37 Reviews



Gender: Female
Points: 840
Reviews: 37
Fri Apr 08, 2011 10:22 pm
DeadEndsAreOptional says...



Hello, there! I'm here as requested. (:

This was an interesting piece, I can honestly say that I have never read anything like it (in a good way). I really like the way you narrated it - by not giving all the characters names. I tried - but can't - imagine The Girl Has Been Silenced with a name for the main character besides ' the woman'. I'm glad you did this story in that writing technique and I hope you continue to write with that technique for awhile. Simply, because you're good at it. (:

Though I enjoyed this story, I'm sad that 'the woman' continued on her life like this:

She continued to waste her money on things she did not need. She continued to despise her crow%u2019s feet, die her hair, work her job, which was both unchallenging and boring.


But I do like the ending:

It seemed that, at last, the girl had been silenced.


That is my favorite part. (:
So, that's the end of my review, I'm sorry if it wasn't very much help. When I review stories it's hard for me to say something negative about it. Just because the stories I choose (or requested) to review are always my favorites, and I *like* your story. (:

Keep Writing!
~DeadEnds
"If there's a book you really want to read, but it hasn't been written yet, then you must write it." ~Toni Morrison
  








I'm against picketing, but I don't know how to show it.
— Mitch Hedberg