Dancers in the Darkness

15 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6523
Reviews 657
Note: I am so disgustingly out of practice, it's been months since I've written anything longer than a page. Tear this to shreds for me-- be brutally honest.


Dancers in the Darkness


The dancer stumbles out the back door and into the alleyway. He leans against it, and as it closes the sounds of music and voices backstage die away. It’s dark outside, in the early hours of the morning, and the wind blowing through the alley is cold. It seems to go right through him, like there’s nothing there.

He fumbles in his bag for his pipe and lights it, cupping the little flame with his hand to protect it from the wind. He takes his thumb off the carb and inhales, doesn’t feel it. He tries again and sighs as the tangy smoke fills up his lungs.

He pulls one knee up to his chest and puts a chilly hand to his hot forehead. The tiredness is in his muscles and bones, between his ligaments, spread across his skin, it’s so heavy. He turns up his collar and takes another drag. It smolders red, then goes out again, leaving him in inky darkness except for the thin rectangle of light coming from under the door.

When he was fifteen he’d entered a dancing contest as a joke and won a six hundred dollar scholarship. This was with no practice, no instruction. After that his mom had rushed him into classes and lessons, and he’d excelled. He was lithe and flexible, and when he heard the music he had an intuitive sense of what would be beautiful. Ballet, tap, ballroom, tango, modern: nothing was beyond his grasp. By the time he reached adulthood he was supporting his mom almost entirely; they’d moved from living in a trailer park to a well-furnished apartment in the city.

“You should go to New York,” she said, a few weeks before his high school graduation. “You could be on Broadway.”

“I’m not sure,” he said. They sat at the kitchen counter, sorting his admission letters. Once again on a dance scholarship, he’d been accepted into various schools all over the country. Juliard, Harvard, Emerson, Chicago… “I might want to do something else.”

“What do you mean, something else?” she asked, opening yet another envelope. “You’re a dancer, Peter. It’s what you do.”

“Yeah, but maybe I wasn’t meant to be one. There are other things that sound really neat. Like architecture, or fashion. Some kind of design.”

“Of course you were meant to be one!” she said. “Look at you. You’re beautiful!”

“Tell me more about what Dad did.”

“Your father was a soldier for most of his life. Before that he just did odd jobs. He never went to college; never got the chance, though he always said he would’ve after he got discharged. Baby, he would have been so proud of you.”

Peter squirmed, uncomfortable. “I don’t know about that.”

“He would have. You got talent, Baby. You’d be a fool not to put it to good use.”


He'd done as she'd told him to. As she’d predicted he’d been accepted into Broadway starting the week he arrived in New York. He’d been Billy Flynn, Billy Elliot, The Phantom of the Opera, Simba, Prince Phillip, Prince Charming. And his mom had been there for each opening night, as long as she could. She’d take the train down from Connecticut and sit as close to the front row as she could. Even after all her hair fell out and the circles under her eyes grew so dark she looked like a skeleton.

“You don’t have to come to all of these,” he told her after another successful opening night—Wicked, this time. She’d fallen asleep in her seat, her breath choking and ragged. Janitorial had recognized her and instead of kicking her out had gone and found him. “I could come home and stay with you for a while.”

“Baby, you gotta stay right here, where you belong. This is your destiny, and of course I’m gonna come see you. You’re my star.”


She’d died a few weeks later in a hospital bed, hundreds of miles away, as the dancer bowed to a thousand hand’s applause. He’d gone on to star in many more shows, delighting strangers with his movement and grace. But he is older now, almost thirty which in show business was middle age, and thus less desirable. His knees creak when he stands up and his toes have a permanent curl from being tied up in ballet shoes. And he is so tired, and his whole body aches.

Something hits him from behind; the door to the backstage dressing room he is leaned against.

“Is that you, Peter? Move.”

Obediently he slides out of the way. Emily joins him in the alleyway. She is still in costume mostly, though she’s pulled on some leggings over her tutu. Her hair is down and oily from the gel, and she looks equally weary. Emily is his age, and has been in a few other productions with him. She does alright, though never quite makes the leading role. She sits down next to him, and cuddles up close. He is grateful for her warmth.

She sniffs the air. “Peter…”

He offers her the pipe.

“They’re gonna start testing for that soon. You could lose your job.”

“Good!” the dancer exclaims, lighting up again. He sucks in the smoke, ignoring Emily’s exasperated sigh. “Finally, a reason to leave this hell. I’ve been wanting to for years but I’m too much of a coward to do anything about it. Someone should make me.”

She puts her arm around him. “I know,” she says. With her fingers she traces circles on his bony shoulders, down the bumps of his spine. “They won’t really kick you out, I was just tryin’ to scare you. It’s fat soluble. That means it’s stored in your adipose tissue. Someone like you? You don’t have any. Goes right through.”

“Lemme guess. You wanted to be a scientist.”

“Yeah. What did you want?”

“I wanted to be an architect.”

“You know, probably even if you did test positive they wouldn’t kick you out. They’d find some way to keep you. Some fluke or loophole. Anyone with talent like yours is in here for life. I’m not nearly as good as you and I know I couldn’t leave.”

“We could get fat.”

“I doubt it. I’m too nervous, can barely keep anything down. And you?”

“Yeah, it’s the same.”

“You look like you’re dying.”

“Thanks, Emily.” The dancer rubbs his eyes, creating a smear of black mascara on his palm. They sit in silence for a little while. He listens to her breathing, soft and shallow, and feels her hand make little circles on his back. She slides it down lower, until it was on his leg, then his thigh, then higher. The dancer coughs and moves away from her a little, disappointed. He’d hoped it wouldn’t come to this.

“You wanna go home with me?”

“No thanks, Emily. I’m so tired.”

“You a queer?”

“Does it matter? You’re my best friend.”

“It does a little bit," Emily said. "I don’t get turned down that often.”

“Then yes.”

“I’m really your best friend?”

“Baby,” the dancer says, “you’re my only friend.”


When he was twenty three he’d met Emily back stage for Les Miserables, curled up like a cat in the costume closet. He thinks back about the time: he’d seen her around, and was pretty sure she was a Cosette understudy, but they’d never spoken. But here she was, drooling all over his boots, looking so small and pitiful that he didn’t know what to do. Cautiously, he tried to pull them out from under her without waking her up, but she jerked and grabbed his shirt, pulling him to her.

“What—“ she stammered. “Where!”

The dancer leapt back. Emily looked around, her eyes big and terrified. Slowly, though, she calmed. She put her head in her hands.

“I think you were having a nightmare,” the dancer said.

“You can say that again. I was at my parents’ house and my sister and her baby were up on a ladder… never mind. Shit, did they call noises off?”

“Nah, we’ve got another twenty.”

“Alright. Sorry, Peter. These must be your boots.”

The dancer was taken aback, embarrassed that she knew his name and he didn’t know hers. He was Valjean and she was mostly backup unless Cosette had a problem, but it felt wrong to him anyway.

“You sleep here a lot?” he asked, sitting down next to her to lace up his boots.

“Only place I can. My apartment’s too cold and even if it weren’t I doubt I could.”

“You always have nightmares?”

“Always have. There’s a science behind it, I heard an article on NPR. Your unconsciousness talks to your consciousness while you’re asleep, and mine seems to only speak nightmare. Never two the same, either. People talk about their reoccurring nightmares and I get jealous.”

“You think that would be better?”

She shrugged. “I dunno. Maybe. We always want what we can’t have.”

And it’s true, the dancer thinks. Now, more than ever. He leans up against Emily in the alleyway, pulling her close to him. She is so warm. She smells like sweat and hairspray and chalk. Another gust of wind blows through him and he shivers.

“You know how many kids would kill to have our jobs?” he says. “To have our lives?”

She remains quiet, her hands still now. The light behind them shuts off, the theater is finally empty and closed for the night. It will be just a few hours, though, before it fills up once again with crowds of talking, dancing breathing people. The thought makes him feel sick.

He flicks the lighter on and off, watching the little blue flame dance. It’s so dim, and yet in the alleyway it’s the brightest thing there is. The shadows sway and flicker along with it. Click—light. Click—dark again. Click. Click. It’s out of fuel.

“We should run away,” he says to Emily. “Get a truck and just drive somewhere, just go and not ever come back.”

“You’re high.”

“Yeah, but I’m serious. You and me? We could find somewhere to stay and just sleep, sleep for like a year.”

“You know I can’t.”

“We gonna stay here ‘till we die?”

Emily thinks about it for a minute. “Probably,” she says.

The dancer closes his eyes, and wonders what it would be like to live somewhere peaceful, do something different. He imagines a body free of aches and pains, no more ballet shoes. He thinks about how nice it would be to get fat and sleep in and maybe even go to college for architecture. Eventually he dozes off, not waking up ‘till morning when the other dancers, stagehands and musicians begin to file in through the back door.

“Alright, baby,” Emily says, in his dream. “Let’s run away.”
Jennafina's Love Your Body Already Dammit Campaign

forum353.html

(To find out what it really is, just click.)




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 15698
Reviews 369
Hi there, Jennafina! It's me, and I'm here to review this.

So, I really like this. It's got a good balance between description, narrative, and dialogue, which I think is essential in good fiction writing. Your characterization is very strong, and I have to give you mad props for it.

The only thing I think you could improve here is when Peter and Emily first meet. It is out of chronological order, sort of, and that threw me off a bit. You might consider moving it to right before the older Peter and Emily start talking, just to alleviate that confusion.

But, other than that, very nice. If you have any other questions, just drop me a PM.

Good job, and good luck.

-Conrad Rice
Garrus Vakarian is my homeboy.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 14013
Reviews 280
Jennafina wrote:Note: I am so disgustingly out of practice, it's been months since I've written anything longer than a page. Tear this to shreds for me-- be brutally honest.



Hey Jp here. For starters, this piece is pro, seriously.

I like the subtlety of they denouement, it was not what I wanted at all yet so satisfying and heartbreaking, I wanted the two to up and leave, but you wouldn't give me the happy ending...

I have no problem with balance, or flow, or order, I found it easy to read. I do however have one little issue. I felt the ending could have been a little more crisp. The last line needs to resound. I would suggest have Peter simply dose off, don't mention the returning crowds, or the next day, just have him slip away and perhaps - without mention the word 'dream' let alone the line 'and in his dream' - have him drinking a beer on his deck? or he and the girl waking on the back of his pick up under the stars?

I don't know, perhaps its just taste, I am a sucker for the sentiment.

all in all

9/10 - thoroughly enjoyable!
Read my latest




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 2702
Reviews 867
The story was done okay. It would have been more effective if you had written it from a first person viewpoint and had the character narrate it. "I leaned against the wall and lit a pipe" would have been easier to relate to than "The dancer leaned against the wall and lit a pipe."

It would have also lent it a kind of film noir aspect which is perfect for edgy stories, especially those that involve past regrets.

By switching to first person, the chronological error that Conrad noticed would be alleviated, since the character would be commenting on her after she got his attention.

The story as it stands more sounds more like a script, stage direction. This is a neat style twist, but I think it is a little distracting from the story itself.

I think this piece was well executed, in the sense that you did what you could with the format you chose. But to get more out of it, you should switch to first person. It allows for more characterization.
Moderator Emeritus (frozen in carbonite.)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6523
Reviews 657
Hey, Conrad! Thanks for the critique, and I'm really glad you like it. I'll see what I can do about when they first meet to make it less confusing!

JP, thank you so much! It's a major complement that you think my story is pro. I see what you're talking about with the ending, though. It is a bit too sudden/abrupt. I like your idea about having Peter and Emily having a beer in the truck bed, under the stars-- I think I'll use it.

Griff, I appreciate the review. I'll think about changing the character, especially if other reviewers think the same thing as you. I'm afraid if I did that, though, it would leave next to nothing the same-- I'd have to write a new story, which would be fine. I might just write my next story in first person instead.

I kind of like calling him the dancer.
Jennafina's Love Your Body Already Dammit Campaign

forum353.html

(To find out what it really is, just click.)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 3098
Reviews 196
Well first off, I would like to say that I think your imagery is very beautiful. It's not too extravagant but not plain either.

He pulls one knee up to his chest and puts a chilly hand to his hot forehead. The tiredness is in his muscles and bones, between his ligaments, spread across his skin, it’s so heavy. He turns up his collar and takes another drag. It smolders red, then goes out again, leaving him in almost pitch black darkness except for the thin rectangle of light coming from under the door.


This paragraph is a great example, not so chocked full of metaphor that you can hardly tell what's going on, but the idea behind it is clear. Isolationism etc. I like it very much.

One thing you might want to watch out for is past and present tense. I am fairly certain that in the beginning the switch was intentional, sort of reminiscing about the past from the present, but perhaps try to make the switch a bit more apparent? Even just a very small comment about "thinking back" after reading it a few times through I understood that he was sort of thinking back on times already passed. However the first read through it got a bit muddled.

The only other thing that I have to comment on is making sure that the dialogue feels natural. I think it's something that most of us deal with at some point or another. Specifically in the first conversation that takes place, bits of it feel sort of stiff and unrealistic? Maybe try to make it sound a little more casual? Even adding more of what is going on while the people are talking, what are they doing with their hands and how are their faces looking, that sort of thing. Your descriptions are so lovely that I feel like I must have more of them, it seems ^^

Those are the only things that I really had to comment on, dear, as the piece was overall quite lovely.

And I had no issue with the third person narrative, I think it works in this piece, the only thing that I ask for is that there be a bit more clarity in the transitions.

--OverEasy (Tiff)
Life is for living.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 5037
Reviews 29
Hey, requested review coming right up!

The dancer stumbles out the back door and into the alleyway. He leans against it, and as it closes the sounds of music and voices backstage die away. It’s dark outside, in the early hours of the morning, and the wind blowing through the alley is cold. It seems to go right through him, like there’s nothing there. -- Lovely openening.

He fumbles in his bag for his pipe and lights it, cupping the little flame with his hand to protect it from the wind. He takes his thumb off the carb and inhales, doesn’t feel it. He tries again and sighs as the tangy smoke fills up his lungs.

He pulls one knee up to his chest and puts a chilly hand to his hot forehead. The tiredness is in his muscles and bones, between his ligaments, spread across his skin, it’s so heavy. He turns up his collar and takes another drag. It smolders red, then goes out again, leaving him in almost pitch black darkness except for the thin rectangle of light coming from under the door. -- This is a wonderful introduction! Good imagery as well.


When he was fifteen he’d entered a dancing contest as a joke and won a six hundred dollar scholarship. This was with no practice, no instruction. After that his mom had rushed him into classes and lessons, and he’d excelled. He was lithe and flexible, and when the music entered him (Odd choice of verb here?) he had an intuitive sense of what would be beautiful. Ballet, tap, ballroom, tango, modern, (Colon instead of a comma might go better.) nothing was beyond his grasp. By the time he reached adulthood he was supporting his mom almost entirely; they’d moved from living in a trailer park to a well-furnished apartment in the city.

“You should go to New York,” she said, a few weeks before his high school graduation. “You could be on Broadway.”

“I’m not sure,” he said. They sat at the kitchen counter, sorting his admission letters. Once again on a dance scholarship, he’d been accepted into various schools all over the country. Juliard, Harvard, Emerson, Chicago… “I might want to do something else.”


“What do you mean, something else?” she asked, opening yet another envelope. “You’re a dancer, Peter. It’s what you do.”

“Yeah, but maybe I wasn’t meant to be one. There are other things that sound really neat. Like architecture, or fashion. Some kind of design (How about: "Something creative?).”

“Of course you were meant to be one!” she said. “Look at you. You’re beautiful!”

“Tell me more about what Dad did.”

“Your father was a soldier for most of his life. Before that he just did odd jobs. He never went to college; never got the chance, though he always said he would’ve after he got discharged. Baby, he would have been so proud of you.”

Peter squirmed, uncomfortable. “I don’t know about that.”

“He would have. You got talent, Baby. (The use of "Baby" throughout the piece seems a bit out of place to me.) You’d be a fool not to put it to good use.”


-- Be careful with the dialog. It's easy to make it seem unreal or false. Especially the mother's in this case.

And so he had. (A bit of a bland opening to be honest) As she’d predicted he’d been accepted into Broadway shows from the first week he arrived in New York (The original sentence seemed a bit clunky, but just a suggestion). He’d been Billy Flynn, Billy Elliot, The Phantom of the Opera, Simba, Prince Phillip, Prince Charming. And his mom had been there for each opening night, as long as she could. She’d take the train down from Connecticut and sit as close to the front row as she could, even after all her hair fell out and the circles under her eyes grew so dark she looked like a skeleton. (Wonderfully done, although of course very sad. Although I suggest a semi-colon after "could" and before "even". Or even start a new sentence, just to make the sentence have more impact)

“You don’t have to come to all of these,” he told her after another successful opening night—Wicked, this time. She’d fallen asleep in her seat, her breath choking and ragged. Janitorial had recognized her and instead of kicking her out had gone and found him. “I could come home and stay with you for a while.”

“Baby, (Again, this feels out of place) you gotta stay right here, where you belong. This is your destiny, and of course I’m gonna come see you. You’re my star.”


She’d died a few weeks later in a hospital bed, hundreds of miles away, as the dancer bowed to a thousand hand’s applause. And (Cut the 'and') he’d gone on to star in many more shows, delighting strangers with his movement and grace. But he is older now, almost thirty which in show business was middle age, and thus less desirable. His knees creak when he stands up and his toes have a permanent curl from being tied up in ballet shoes. And he is so tired, and his whole body aches.


Something hits him from behind— (Use a colon instead of a dash)the door to the backstage dressing room he is leaned against.

“Is that you, Peter? Move.”

Obediently he slides out of the way. Emily joins him in the alleyway. She is still in costume mostly, though she’s pulled on some leggings over her tutu. Her hair is down and oily from the gel, and she looks equally weary. Emily is his age, and has been in a few other productions with him. She does alright, though never quite makes the leading role. She sits down next to him, and cuddles up close. He is grateful for her warmth.

She sniffs the air. “Peter…”

He offers her the pipe.

“They’re gonna start testing ("for that") soon. You could lose your job.”

“Good!” the dancer exclaims, lighting up again. He sucks in the smoke, ignoring Emily’s exasperated sigh. “Finally, a reason to leave this hell. I’ve been wanting to for years but I’m too much of a coward to do anything about it. Someone should make me.”

She puts her arm around him. “I know,” she says. With her fingers she traces circles on his bony shoulders, down the bumps of his spine. “They won’t really kick you out, I was just tryin’ to scare you. It’s fat soluble. That means it’s stored in your adipose tissue. Someone like you? You don’t have any. Goes right through.”

“Lemme guess. You wanted to be a scientist.”

“Yeah. What did you want?”

“I wanted to be an architect.”

“You know, probably even if you did test positive they wouldn’t kick you out. They’d find some way to keep you. Some fluke or loophole. Anyone with talent like yours is in here for life. I’m not nearly as good as you and I know I couldn’t leave.”

“We could get fat.”

“I doubt it. I’m too nervous, can barely keep anything down. And you?”

“Yeah, it’s the same.”

“You look like you’re dying.”

“Thanks, Emily.” The dancer rubbs his eyes, creating a smear of black mascara on his palm. They sit in silence for a little while. He listens to her breathing, soft and shallow, and feels her hand make little circles on his back. She slides it down lower, until it was on his leg, then his thigh, then higher. The dancer coughed and moved away from her a little, disappointed. He’d hoped it wouldn’t come to this.

“You wanna go home with me?”

“No thanks, Emily. I’m so tired.”

“You a queer?”

“Does it matter? You’re my best friend.”

“It does a little bit. I don’t get turned down that often.” (The flow of this dialog confused me a bit. Especially about who was saying what. Could just be me though)

“Then yes.”

“I’m really your best friend?”

“Baby,” (No! Not from a boy's mouth please! :lol:) the dancer says, “you’re my only friend.”


When he was twenty three he’d met Emily back stage for Les Miserables, curled up like a cat in the costume closet. He’d seen her around, and was pretty sure she was a Cosette understudy, but they’d never spoken. But here she was, drooling all over his boots, looking so small and pitiful that he didn’t know what to do. Cautiously, he tried to pull them out from under her without waking her up, but she jerked and grabbed his shirt, pulling him to her.

“What—“ she stammered. “Where!”

The dancer leapt back. Emily looked around, her eyes big and terrified. Slowly, though, she calmed. She put her head in her hands.

“I think you were having a nightmare,” the dancer said.

“You can say that again. I was at my parents’ house and my sister and her baby were up on a ladder… never mind. Shit, did they call noises off?”

“Nah, we’ve got another twenty.”

“Alright. Sorry, Peter. These must be your boots.”

The dancer was taken aback, embarrassed that she knew his name and he didn’t know hers. He was Valjean and she was mostly backup unless Cosette had a problem, but it felt wrong to him anyway.

“You sleep here a lot?” he asked, sitting down next to her to lace up his boots.

“Only place I can. My apartment’s too cold and even if it weren’t I doubt I could.”

“You always have nightmares?”

“Always have. There’s a science behind it, I heard an article on NPR. Your unconsciousness talks to your consciousness while you’re asleep, and mine seems to only speak nightmare. Never two the same, either. People talk about their reoccurring nightmares and I get jealous.”

“You think that would be better?”

She shrugged. “I dunno. Maybe. We always want what we can’t have.”

And it’s true, the dancer thinks. Now, more than ever. He leans up against Emily in the alleyway, pulling her close to him. She is so warm. She smells like sweat and hairspray and chalk. Another gust of wind blows through him and he shivers.

“You know how many kids would kill to have our jobs?” he says. “To have our lives?”

She remains quiet, her hands still now. The light behind them shuts off, the theater is finally empty and closed for the night. It will be just a few hours, though, before it fills up once again with crowds of talking, dancing breathing people. The thought makes him feel sick.

He flicks the lighter on and off, watching the little blue flame dance. It’s so dim, and yet in the alleyway it’s the brightest thing there is. The shadows sway and flicker along with it. Click—light. Click—dark again. Click. Click. It’s out of fuel.

“We should run away,” he says to Emily. “Get a truck and just drive somewhere, just go and not ever come back.”

“You’re high.”

“Yeah, but I’m serious. You and me? We could find somewhere to stay and just sleep, sleep for like a year.”

“You know I can’t.”

“We gonna stay here ‘till we die?”

Emily thinks about it for a minute. “Probably,” she says.

The dancer closes his eyes, and wonders what it would be like to live somewhere peaceful, do something different. He imagines a body free of aches and pains, no more ballet shoes. He thinks about how nice it would be to get fat and sleep in and maybe even go to college for architecture. Eventually he dozes off, not waking up ‘till morning when the other dancers, stagehands and musicians begin to file in through the back door.

“Alright, baby,” Emily says, in his dream. “Let’s run away.”





This is wonderful! You have certainly have a talent for keeping the reader hooked 'till the end. You created great imagery, and had a wonderful idea in this story. The one thing that did let you down a bit though was the dialog, but it isn't really a big gripe, and I'm just being picky because I can't find anything else wrong with it! :D

If you were going to carry this on though I wouldn't suggest starting with this. It reads more like an extract from a bigger picture, if you know what I mean.

Anyway, great work, I loved the read. :)

Keep up the good work!
Recognizing and rewarding writing talent: RW Competitions

Request reviews here: Requests

" All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing "
-- Edmund Burke




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6235
Reviews 2631
Sorry about the delay hun! You've got a good piece here, not much to nit pick but there's a few suggestions I can make:

The dancer stumbles out the back door and into the alleyway. He leans against it, and as it closes the sounds of music and voices backstage die away. It’s dark outside, in the early hours of the morning, and the wind blowing through the alley is cold. It seems to go right through him, like there’s nothing there.
[I think you could improve a few lines here by making them shorter and more dramatic. Maybe, 'It's dark outside. It's quiet outside. The early morning wind blowing through the alley is cold.']

He pulls one knee up to his chest and puts a chilly hand to his hot forehead. The tiredness is in his muscles and bones, between his ligaments, spread across his skin, it’s so heavy. He turns up his collar and takes another drag. It smolders red, then goes out again, leaving him in almost pitch black darkness [This is a little awkward. Maybe '...leaving him in inky darkness' or smothering darkness. You don't need the almost because you have except for...] except for the thin rectangle of light coming from under the door.


Love your dialogue. Excellent characterization of the mother. However I'm not feeling the dancer very strongly. I can feel that life is heavy for him and how tired he is toward the end but what about before that? Why was he uncertain even then? Didn't he feel some excitment, some lust for fame and duty to his mother of course. I'd like a stronger starting personality to compare his later one with so that the reader can actually see what the wrong choices do to a person.

“Thanks, Emily.” The dancer rubbs his eyes, creating a smear of black mascara on his palm. They sit in silence for a little while. He listens to her breathing, soft and shallow, and feels her hand make little circles on his back. She slides it down lower, until it was on his leg, then his thigh, then higher. The dancer coughed and moved away from her a little, disappointed. He’d hoped it wouldn’t come to this.
[Try to stick with one tense. You slip into present for a little while here and then back to past but should really choose just one.]

He flicks the lighter on and off, watching the little blue flame dance. It’s so dim, and yet in the alleyway it’s the brightest thing there is. The shadows sway and flicker along with it. Click—light. Click—dark again. Click. Click. It’s out of fuel.
[Love the use of the lighter and a very powerful few sentences here.]

Like I said, in general I like it. There was perhaps a little too much telling in places which split the atmosphere of your piece but short of a completely different style I don't know how you'd work that differently. The dancer's vocab could be better explored, like I didn't feel that he was the type who'd use baby, it seemed too much of an echo of his mum.

Other than that I'd have maybe liked a few more scenes in there to bring out the chaarcters and their story more but great work, thanks for the read.
Writing Gooder

~Previously KittyKatSparklesExplosion15~

The light shines brightest in the darkest places.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 33318
Reviews 382
Watch this space (a post to remind myself to review this).




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6523
Reviews 657
I just made a ton of changes! Thank you so much, guys. I kept the 'baby' thing, but only until I can think of a better word.

Gal, I look forward to seeing your review. :)
Jennafina's Love Your Body Already Dammit Campaign

forum353.html

(To find out what it really is, just click.)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 35199
Reviews 878
Hey Jenna! So I'm finally here -- sorry you've had to wait!

- Overall, your style of writing is very balanced and pleasant to read.
- The paragraph in the beginning that is all about the background of the story seems rushed, or makes the general feeling rushed. For me it was too much information squeezed in too tight.
- I'm not a big fan of the present tense, but then again, it somehow seemed to fit the whole dancer theme?
- This is probably nothing, but don't you also have to be a good singer to be on Broadway? For example, The Phantom of the Opera doesn't really dance at all. I think you could bring the singing up a bit as well.


Juliard, Harvard, Emerson, Chicago…


A small nitpick -- if you mean the dance school, it's spelled Juilliard, I believe. =)


“Thanks, Emily.” The dancer rubbs his eyes


Should be "rubs."


The dialogue in the end seems realistic and adds a nice touch to the story. I liked the ending! For now, I have nothing else to say, sorry about that... but congrats on getting this into a featured work!


Demeter
x
"Your jokes are scarier than your earrings." -Twit

"14. Pretend like you would want him even if he wasn't a prince. (Yeah, right.)" -How to Make a Guy Like You - Disney Princess Style

Got YWS?




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 368
Reviews 456
Sorry for such a wait but here I am to review your piece. I see you've had multiple reviews and lots of nitpicky things thrown at you, so for the fear of being redundant I just want to say that this was a pleasent read, and that I really liked the dialogue at the end. It seems so realistic, and and i can just see it forming from somes mouth... or thoughts. I really like the idea of this piece and creativity shown. The ending was fantastic :) Happy writings,
Tiffany
There is nothing to writing; all you do is sit down at a typewriter and open a vein~ Red Smith

Who needs a review? :) http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/topic38078.html




User avatar
Gender Other
Points 89625
Reviews 1272
Hello Jenna! I read this awhile back but never had the chance to review it. Reviewing Sunday is the perfect opportunity. ;) (Note- I haven't read any other reviews so pardon if I repeat anything)

I found this basically well-written. My main issue I had was here:

The dancer was taken aback, embarrassed that she knew his name and he didn’t know hers. He was Valjean and she was mostly backup unless Cosette had a problem, but it felt wrong to him anyway.


All around this paragraph, he calls her by name. It really messed up flow for me for the rest of the work. I wasn't sure exactly what was going on after that.

I also found you reached a point where you lost the theme of the story; at the beginning, there was living another's dream. At one point, the paragraph I quoted above, everything felt lost. I've been in such a situation before, where the teacher/parent wanted their student to become a professional. I've also seen girls who've dedicated their life to dance. They don't do anything else because they know nothing else. Their whole life is focused on dance, maybe because they want to do it, maybe because they're being forced to. Either way, they can't imagine any other path for their lives to take. You had some of that at the beginning, but I find the story would be a lot more realistic if you added that dimension to the story.

PM me if you have any questions.

~Rosey
A writer is a world trapped in a person— Victor Hugo

Ink is blood. Paper is bandages. The wounded press books to their heart to know they're not alone.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1368
Reviews 40
Oh wow! I thought the title would be something a little bit different, something more light and elegant. But then I realized it was. The desires of someone tossed out into the world and thrown into something else just because the person does well at it. It's what someone loves that matters, but also matters on how to survive.

I don't know how this was before you edited it, but this is really good! I didn't really see many mistakes, the spacing between lines made it seem a bit longer than normal, but otherwise it was just fine.

I enjoy reading you works!

Thief
By the Gods... Please let inspiration strike me! (Just in a non-violent way O.o)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 33318
Reviews 382
Hi Jennafina,

Jennafina wrote:The dancer stumbles out the back door and into the alleyway. He leans against it, and as it closes the sounds of music and voices backstage die away. It’s dark outside, in the early hours of the morning, and the wind blowing through the alley is cold. It seems to go right through him, like there’s nothing there.

He fumbles in his bag for his pipe and lights it, cupping the little flame with his hand to protect it from the wind. He takes his thumb off the carb and inhales, doesn’t feel it. He tries again and sighs as the tangy smoke fills up his lungs.


You're trying really hard to be gritty-noir, aren't you? "It seems to go right through him, like there's nothing there". There's a difference between minimalism in description and flat rejection of fluidity (yes, a certain perverse fluidity can even exist in works that are supposed to reflect the tone of the hardened streets), and this is crossing it like a Christian. Take a page from your next paragraph:

He pulls one knee up to his chest and puts a chilly hand to his hot forehead. The tiredness is in his muscles and bones, between his ligaments, spread across his skin, it’s so heavy. He turns up his collar and takes another drag. It smolders red, then goes out again, leaving him in inky darkness except for the thin rectangle of light coming from under the door.


With the exception of the abysmal little side-note "it's so heavy", this is decent quality writing. The reader can actually picture this, make it part of his own visceral being. Not so for the opening paragraphs, which were a great disappointment and subconsciously set the stage for the reader's expectations. Never set low expectations.

In addition, three paragraphs dedicated to showing him sullenly standing and smoking in the street is more than enough. You've already convinced us of the setting, don't go overboard.

When he was fifteen he’d entered a dancing contest as a joke and won a six hundred dollar scholarship. This was with no practice, no instruction. After that his mom had rushed him into classes and lessons, and he’d excelled. He was lithe and flexible, and when he heard the music he had an intuitive sense of what would be beautiful. Ballet, tap, ballroom, tango, modern: nothing was beyond his grasp. By the time he reached adulthood he was supporting his mom almost entirely; they’d moved from living in a trailer park to a well-furnished apartment in the city.

“You should go to New York,” she said, a few weeks before his high school graduation. “You could be on Broadway.”

“I’m not sure,” he said. They sat at the kitchen counter, sorting his admission letters. Once again on a dance scholarship, he’d been accepted into various schools all over the country. Juliard, Harvard, Emerson, Chicago… “I might want to do something else.”

“What do you mean, something else?” she asked, opening yet another envelope. “You’re a dancer, Peter. It’s what you do.”

“Yeah, but maybe I wasn’t meant to be one. There are other things that sound really neat. Like architecture, or fashion. Some kind of design.”

“Of course you were meant to be one!” she said. “Look at you. You’re beautiful!”

“Tell me more about what Dad did.”

“Your father was a soldier for most of his life. Before that he just did odd jobs. He never went to college; never got the chance, though he always said he would’ve after he got discharged. Baby, he would have been so proud of you.”

Peter squirmed, uncomfortable. “I don’t know about that.”

“He would have. You got talent, Baby. You’d be a fool not to put it to good use.”


No.

This entire above chunk was a deal-breaker. The mom wants him to do something, the kid doesn't, and you oh-so-perfectly set the background like roses floating in a pool, no petals untouched, the stem glistening. It's sickeningly in place, all of it. You're basically reading to us an outline, a script as Griffinkeeper has said, a collection of bullet points that we're supposed to invest in our memories and bring up whenever The Big Point Of The Story, or The Meaningful Climax occurs. You don't need to emphasize the Harvard and Yale and whatever, nor do you need to make their conversation so wooden.

Take this example: "Yeah, but maybe I wasn’t meant to be one. There are other things that sound really neat. Like architecture, or fashion. Some kind of design."

Who speaks like that? "Yeah, but maybe I wasn't meant to be one," blah blah. He wraps up about five major ideas, some subtle and some not, in the span of two-and-a-half sentences. He's sappy and this screams out the fact that you're trying to deliver some kind of message to the reader and doing an extremely poor job of gift-wrapping it. You give strangers a shoddily-bound present and they'll make note of it negatively. You give the readers a shoddily bound character building exercise, and they'll do the same. Cut down on the entire... cookie-cutter banter of the whole ordeal. This is a kid talking to his mom, not two strangers trying to be as polite to each other and possible and so exchanging pleasantaries the whole time.

He'd done as she'd told him to. As she’d predicted he’d been accepted into Broadway starting the week he arrived in New York. He’d been Billy Flynn, Billy Elliot, The Phantom of the Opera, Simba, Prince Phillip, Prince Charming. And his mom had been there for each opening night, as long as she could. She’d take the train down from Connecticut and sit as close to the front row as she could. Even after all her hair fell out and the circles under her eyes grew so dark she looked like a skeleton.

“You don’t have to come to all of these,” he told her after another successful opening night—Wicked, this time. She’d fallen asleep in her seat, her breath choking and ragged. Janitorial had recognized her and instead of kicking her out had gone and found him. “I could come home and stay with you for a while.”

“Baby, you gotta stay right here, where you belong. This is your destiny, and of course I’m gonna come see you. You’re my star.”


This part is pretty good, no comment.

She’d died a few weeks later in a hospital bed, hundreds of miles away, as the dancer bowed to a thousand hand’s applause. He’d gone on to star in many more shows, delighting strangers with his movement and grace. But he is older now, almost thirty which in show business was middle age, and thus less desirable. His knees creak when he stands up and his toes have a permanent curl from being tied up in ballet shoes. And he is so tired, and his whole body aches.


He didn't go to see his own mother's last days? Why?

And is there any good reason you keep on italicizing words? It's a gimmick, get rid of it. You do it a few times through the story, and it fails to achieve its purpose each time.

The rest of this is decent. The main drawback of the story is because of the way you describe everything so objectively, as if the author doesn't really care about the information presented but knows that it needs to be told anyway. This in turn forces the reader to loses interest. Important scene #1, important scene #2, tear-inducing scene #1, important scene #3, end credits. It's like watching a military procession; all looking very clean, crisp, and professional on the outside but with no real creativity once you get past the uniform.

This applies especially to the story itself, not only the devices used to carry it to its close. So a man doesn't really want to be a dancer, but becomes a dancer, meets a girl, runs away. The storyline is also hitched and ensnared on the Big Ideas which just never seem to have the decency to make themselves subtle. I give you,

The dancer closes his eyes, and wonders what it would be like to live somewhere peaceful, do something different. He imagines a body free of aches and pains, no more ballet shoes. He thinks about how nice it would be to get fat and sleep in and maybe even go to college for architecture. Eventually he dozes off, not waking up ‘till morning when the other dancers, stagehands and musicians begin to file in through the back door.


Don't do this. We get it. We get that he wants to do architecture and doesn't really like ballet. Why must you keep force-feeding the reader until his gums bleed? Get rid of that entire paragraph, it reeks of pretentiousness.

Overall, a digestable story but not nearly an enjoyable one. It's not that it was particularly disturbing to read, it's just that there was nothing in it to enjoy. No substance, just vapors, people talking tough, and stereotypical 50s descriptions that sounded more like something from a comedy than anything else.

If you were simply going for something to get your fingers free again, though, then this worked to propel you to write what will hopefully be a better piece of prose.

Hope that helped,
Galerius



I like anchovies~ but nobody calls me that.
— alliyah