Stitching Candles

3 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6076
Reviews 134
If only the candles were real.

The quilt lies unfinished. Every week for the past year she has sewed a completed patch onto it. Every day she has sat by the fire, her tired eyes straining as her scarred fingers stitch the patterns. Some of them are accidental scars, where the pot burned her fingers or the sewing needle slipped and grazed her skin. Some are on-purpose scars when she burned or cut to numb the emotional pain. It helped her focus on the work, and the physical pain, and not have to think anymore.

Sometimes she listens to the radio while she works. Never the news, only the music. But the music, too, can be painful. When a Bob Dylan song comes on she turns off the radio with fumbling fingers. How she hates that son-of-a-bitch.

Tonight is his birthday. Tonight twenty years ago a small bluish child was born on the white hospital bed in Boston. And that night her blood stained the sheets and her cries of pain reverberated through the quiet hospital. No husband to hold her hand, only the doctors gathered round to deliver the child, cut the cord. Her blood staining the crisp white in blotches and swirls as ink stains a piece of paper when the bottle is knocked over.

Tonight his quilt patch takes keeps her up late. She is embroidering a birthday cake with orange and yellow candles and chocolate frosting. Chocolate was his favorite.

She considers baking a real cake and icing it with swirls and stars and writing Happy 20 Jack and cutting off a slice and pretending he is here while the good smells swirl through the house. Then she would bring it over to the neighbors. Eventually, she decides against it. That would hurt too much.

If only the candles were real.
Last edited by sarebear on Tue Sep 06, 2011 1:50 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Give a man a fish, he'll eat for a day. Teach a man to fish, he'll eat for a lifetime. Talk to a hungry man about fish, and you're a psychologist.




Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 962
Reviews 1
i think this is wonderful! i love the use of the imagery and how you build the tale around such a short structure. i don't feel like any of the sentences are wasted since each builds this womans tragedy. the writing has a very developed, mature style to it. i really enjoyed it, thank you!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 7459
Reviews 167
Every day she has sat by the fire, her tired eyes straining as her scarred fingers stitch the patterns.

It helped her focus on the work, and the physical pain, and not have to think anymore.

This sentence seems weak. I think it's the last bit of it that ruins it.
When a Bob Dylan song comes on she turns it off the radio with fumbling fingers.

Tonight, twenty years ago, a small bluish child was born on the white hospital bed in Boston.

No husband to hold her hand, only the doctors gathered round to deliver the child, and cut the cord.

Her blood staining stained the crisp white in blotches and swirls as ink stains a piece of paper when the bottle is knocked over.

She considers baking a real cake and icing it with swirls and stars and writing Happy 20 Jack and cutting off a slice and pretending he is here while the good smells swirl through the house.

I would italicize "Happy 20 Jack" or put it into quotations. Also, you should do something about this sentence. It could probably be split into more than one, that way you wouldn't be using so many ands. "... and ... and ... and ..." was pretty much the format for this sentence.


This was a very vague story, and I don't think I quite picked up on the concept. I realize that a mother is stitching a quilt, but the message isn't coming across as clearly as it should have.
This part confused me:
When a Bob Dylan song comes on she turns off the radio with fumbling fingers. How she hates that son-of-a-bitch.

Tonight is his birthday.

When you said 'his birthday', I thought you meant Bob Dylan. Then, when I realized that she was talking about her son (and for a bit I thought that Bob Dylan was her son.) Until you said "Happy 20 Jack". Tad confusing.
This story as a whole seems disjointed. It wasn't terrible, but it wasn't amazing either. I think you have a decent idea going here, but you didn't execute it as well as you could have. It needs an extra push to get it going in the right direction.
Anyways, I hope this helped! Chao.
"So the writer who breeds more words than he needs, is making a chore for the reader who reads."
— Dr. Seuss



akdsjfh you know that feeling where you start writing a scene but then you get bored with the scene so you move on and start writing a different scene and then you get bored with that scene so you move on to an entirely different WIP and then you get bored with that so you move on-
— AceassinOfTheMoon