To my Beloved,
Remember the old days by the creek bed? We would splash in the water and slosh through the mud, desperately looking for toads and salamanders. You always had that incredible way of persuading me to do things I knew were bad ideas. And then there was that one time when my mom had me dressed up for Easter, and you coaxed me into a game of hide-and-seek with those charming eyes of yours. After the game I had dirt all down the front of my dress. Do you remember? My mother looked like she wanted to murder us. But it didn’t matter much to me; after all I despised that dress.
Then there was my thirteenth birthday. You came knocking at my door first thing in the morning with a bouquet of roses and a wide smile on your face. Now I think about then and laugh when I recall your bewildered expression when I kissed you on the cheek, but you tried to hide your puckered lips. That day holds a special place in my mind, simply because I knew I had you. Which is why writing this letter pains me so.
When you asked me to prom and I told you I needed to think about it, I lied. I knew the second you asked me what my answer would be. In a cruel way, I wanted you to think I might have said no. I suppose it’s just one of those uncontrollable, horrible traits in a person. And when I finally let you kiss me that night - after almost a decade of waiting- it was the most magical moment of my life.
But my love, there’s more to our story than I’ve told you. Shortly after prom night, when I disappeared for three days, do you remember? I said to you that I’d just been camping, on a trip with my family. But there is something you and everyone else seemed to overlook. The weekend I was gone was the same time your brother, Maxwell, had gone missing. I came back to you, panicking, but I attempted to seem calm. Here, six months later, it is time for you to know the truth.
I murdered Maxwell.
Impossible, don’t you think? Yet incredibly believable. He came to me on that Friday night, looking for consolation. He’d not told me the reason, only that I was the only one he knew to come to. He begged me for comfort. And so I gave it to him.
The next morning when I awoke, realizing the entirety of my actions, I couldn’t live with the emotions swirling through me. I knew every time we’d be in the same room with him it would only have uncomfortable silences and knowing glances. And I knew eventually you’d realize the truth of what we’d done together.
I could not let him ruin what we had together- no, of course not! I’d finally had you all to myself with no girls swooning all over you. Yet, ironically, it seems it was me you’d wanted all along. Wasn’t it?
Though I’d always loved you, not Maxwell. And I knew deep in the contours of my heart that once you knew the truth you could never forgive me for the deception I’d caused you. I’d betrayed you! After all those years of you being so kind to me, loving me, in spite of me being the disgusting monster I am.
So I eliminated the problem the only way I knew how. I had to kill Maxwell, otherwise he would have ruined me. I’d forever be marked down as a revolting slut in every sense of the word imaginable.
Maxwell was a heavy sleeper; it was simple to bash in his skull with one of my father’s work hammers. I acted quickly, not giving him enough time to utter a sound before his life came to a gruesome end.
Yet, as I recall my life and our life together, I do not have any regrets. Yes, Maxwell is dead, and once you know this it will be impossible for you to forgive me. Which is exactly why, my love, I would never ask for your forgiveness to a demon such as I. For a demon is what defines me.
No, I will not apologize. I will not accept any reconciliation. I do not deserve it.
Once you receive this letter, dear, I know you will hate me. I could never imagine a world without your arms wrapped around me; for our shadows merge as one when we’re together and it is nearly unmanageable to tell it is two.
I can’t live in a world without you, I won’t live in a world where you loathe me. By the time you learn of this note, I will be as gone as Maxwell is. I owe at least this to you it is the only way I can think of to rid you of your pain.
So, my love, accept my final goodbye.
Yours forever.
