Personal Essay (!!Need critiques!!)

6 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1871
Reviews 46
I had to write a Personal Essay (for an English assignment, but possible university submission) and I really, really need critiques. All of the other people I know say it's great, but I need more opinions before I submit it! All critiques are welcome!
By the way, the point of the essay was to be unique. I think I followed that prompt pretty well.

The Definition of “Real”

As I sit here at my kitchen table, pen in hand, I glance up at the antique clock ticking monotonously on my wall. Eleven thirty-eight. I turn my attention back to the pile of notebook paper in front of me. The crisp white of the blank paper has an inviting vibe about it, but without ideas, the sheets are useless.

I gnaw on the end of my already chewed-up pen, trying to think of the best way to write my personal essay. My dictionary lays opened up to a random page, in the hope that some word would leap out at me and strike me with inspiration. My thesaurus, on the opposite side of the paper, sits untouched.

I try to think of a subject to write about. Something that would glorify my achievements, make me sound as brilliant as a rocket-scientist, or as talented as a contortionist in Cirque de Soleil.

Strangely enough, my mind is as blank as the paper waiting on the table. Sure, I have my talents, I’m reasonably intelligent, and I’ve had experiences that changed my life, both for better and worse. Sadly, none of these seem worthy of such an influential essay.

I think about times I was discriminated against. For about an hour, I write about the discrimination I faced being a teen mother. As I review what I’ve written, it sounds informational; I used a lot of big words, and it accurately shows how I dealt with the awkward questions and cold glances. I still shove the paper down the shredder. I’m not impressed.

Then, I write about my experiences being homeless from age sixteen. I weave a heartbreaking tale about freezing under a bridge in the middle of January, or living in substandard conditions in a teen shelter. After another hour and a half, I evaluate the finished essay. Once more, the paper goes through the shredder. Still not impressed.

I glare up at the ticking contraption up on my wall again, as if it were the clock’s fault I couldn’t write the perfect college essay. I drag my feet over to the espresso maker to pour myself another cup of the strongest coffee possible. Sipping the bitter liquid, I slump back into my chair. This has to be the hardest thing I’ve ever had to write.

I grab my dictionary, about to give up and just go to bed. Before I could slam it shut, the hope I once thought futile roared back into my brain. One word sent an electric tingling sensation through my body. Real: genuine; not counterfeit, artificial, or imitation; authentic.

Words fly onto the last sheet of paper on the table. They flow from the deepest level of my soul, branding the paper with my flaws, but stamping the bright white with my unique seal of authenticity. Holding up my final attempt, a warm feeling spreads through my fingertips. Finally: my personal essay.

Mod: No all-caps in title, please. :)
♥~*Emalee*~♥




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 8414
Reviews 151
Hi EmmaLee! Its my turn to review yours now!

word would leap
I think you should put "will" instead of would, since your story is present tense...well essay.

That was the only mistake I saw! Mwahaha! Anyways, I really did like it, and I'm not just saying that. You put personal stuff in, and it lets us know about your personality quite a bit, even though you maybe didn't notice it. It tells us about your personal life, but not too much, like not super descriptive. I think its great EmmaLee!!! Good luck!

~Forest
(your fellow Emily! Haha I have friend who's name is spelled like yours!)
Sorrow lasts through this night
I'll take this piece of you,
and hold for all eternity
For just one second I felt whole... as you flew right through me.


~Sorrow by Flyleaf




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 1780
Reviews 9
I really, really like this. No joke, it is one of my most favorites. There is only one eeensy weensy thing that is bugging me (but a lot of random things bug me, so dont worry about it). But just in case, here it is:
I weave a heartbreaking tale about freezing under a bridge in the middle of January, or living in substandard conditions in a teen shelter.

I like how the sentence is worded, but where is says "or" I think it needs to be replaced with "and", since you are talking about one topic, not many.
But all in all, I really, really love this! :)
"By the time you are 25 years old, you will be great at writing begginings, ok at writing middles, and suckish at writing endings. What does this teach us? FINISH YOUR STORIES."
--Unknown




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1030
Reviews 1260
Hey!
I really liked this. You're a very talented writer, and I especially love the comparisons to popular culture that you use, as well as the similes. You completely convey the message that you're trying to get across in a not too long essay, which is good. I also didn't find many grammatical errors.

However, I felt that it was a little slow-paced. I get that it's supposed to be theme of the essay, but there are sections where you simply drone on and on, especially at the beginning. You could probably eliminate a few of the paragraphs, as you go on for a few too many about how you can't think of anything to write.

Great essay otherwise. PM if you have questions.

All our dreams can come true — if we have the courage to pursue them.

-- Walt Disney




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1871
Reviews 46
Thanks everybody! I really needed the critiques, just because this is a huge 100 point assignment and I really want a good score. So I shall fix those errors and submit! Once more, thank you! :smt054
♥~*Emalee*~♥




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 42428
Reviews 411
I thought that was fantastic, I particularly like how it was unique :). I was thoroughly interested until the end! I personally thought the beginning was the most captivating! The only tip I can really come up with is Keep it up and best of luck with getting the score you need :)



Obsessing over what you regret won't get you anywhere.
— Steggy