A deadly secret

7 posts
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 16930
Reviews 180
Hi!! This is a really small part of a three posts story I'm making, the story is really short and this is just the first part. So review, check, correct and please leave your comments.

Thanks for your time and help!!!!!
Pudin
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________

It was six thirty in the morning. Her alarm clock was ringing crazily in her ear. She was still covered by her pink and purple bed sheets but somehow managed to unwillingly open her eyes and get her hand out from under the sheets and turn the alarm clock off. She stretched lazily while letting out a huge yawn as she slowly got out of bed and looked around. She noticed that the curtains of her window were closed and even her window was closed. She didn’t remember why or when she closed but they now deserved to be opened, it was a brand new day and she had to enjoy it. She opened them slowly, smelling the sweet aroma of morning dew and wet soil as they hit her nose and she breathed them eagerly while listening to the soft chirping of a bird sitting in her window.

After viewing the splendor of the early morning she has always loved, she decided it was time to take a shower and get ready for school so she grabbed her towel and some clothes and headed to the bathroom. The mirror was the first thing she saw in the bathroom but refused to see herself in it for she already knew what she was going to see and even the thought of it made her sick so she took off her clothes and went straight to the shower. As she was taking a shower, quite unthinkingly, she began to run in the same place, lifting her knees to her hips. This now happened out of habit.

She finished quickly and went out of the bathroom. But before she got dressed and still wrapped in her towel, she took out her scale from under her bed and stepped on it. It read 77 pounds. She made the math in her head. She was 5’6, and weighed 77 pounds. Good, but still not perfect. She thought. She had been doing this for years now, weighing and waiting for the day in which she would finally be the perfect girl. With that on her mid, she slowly turned around to see herself in the mirror and what she saw almost made her cry.; over sized hips, huge belly, fat arms, fat thighs, all that was left of her were her green eyes and her sparkly red hair. She turned around and sat in her bed. After all these days of starvation and excessive exercise, there were no results and she was still the fat, rejected girl that once started high school. She looked at the scale and kicked it. That scale must be wrong. She thought.

“Christine” her mother called, interrupting her thoughts.

“Coming” she answered. She quickly got up and washed the tears out of her eyes. She dressed up fast, in a black skinny jean with a pink shirt fitted at the waist and loose on its way down, pretending she actually had some body fat to show off.

She finally decided to go downstairs and meet her mother at the kitchen. The house was beautiful and she admired it every time she walked into the beige colored living room with a nineteenth century style. It had a large hearth in the middle, decorated with fine carved pieces of wood and big windows with burgundy colored curtains hanging from them. It was interesting looking at the sun as its rays penetrated the windows. She has always liked it, so she went to sit on the leather sofa in the middle of the living room and rested her head in the sofa. Doing that really prevented her from her most torturing temptation, food. She heard her stomach growl, so she closed her eyes and wrapped her arms around her abdomen and pressed hard against it. She couldn’t just give in, when she had made it so far; she promised to herself she would be perfect, no matter what the cost of that might be.

And now hunger was attacking like a growling tiger, hitting her with its heavy paws and making her lightheaded, almost numb and the smell of recently backed pancakes was not helping. She gulped many times, trying to placate the unbearable hunger that seemed to fill her lungs making her breathing extremely hard. She was not doing it, she was not eating. So she quickly got up from the sofa and ran upstairs to her room, locking the door behind her when she got in. She looked in her many drawers and boxes and finally found what she was looking for, a razor-blade. She looked at its shiny blade and curled up the long sleeve of her shirt.

It felt cold and hard against her skin, but when it slowly and softly sliced her forearm, it felt like burning her white skin. The cut was not deep, but long, cutting through other scars that she already had. And the blood ran, not too much but it did, making her run to the bath room and grab gauze to wrap around her forearm. The bleeding did not continue when gauzed, but the burning was still there especially since she sliced through recent cuts and scars, but no one knew about it and this was not the day to come clean. So she arranged the sleeved of her shirt and headed out her room, taking a rubber band and putting g it in her damaged wrist.

She went downstairs again and as if on cue, the school bus’ horn beeped loudly from outside my house. I ran to get my stuff and say bye to my mother who was freaking out because I didn’t eat her recently cooked pancakes.

“Promise me you’ll eat at school” she had told her.

“Yes mother” Christine had told her, almost killing herself in that moment for lying to her mother.

She ran out the door and caught the bus that was already running. She got in and sat in one of the last rows of seats. She had her head in the clouds, she was numb, the pain and the hunger were attacking worse than ever, her eyes were becoming watery and the tears were now hard to control. But she had to, she couldn’t be weak, nor could let someone else know about her secret. It was hers and she was very jealous about it. She would fulfill it in whichever way and source she had. She was going to be perfect, admirable, and beautiful and above all, not one pound more.
Last edited by pudin.junidf on Sat Sep 12, 2009 2:41 am, edited 1 time in total.
Les sanglots longs
Des violons
De l'autonne
Blessent mon coeur
D'une langueur
Monotone.

Verlaine




User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 5448
Reviews 56
Whoah. This reminds me a lot of Jaqueline Wilson's 'Girls Under Pressure'; the thing on anorexia and the constant belief that the MC is an obese monstrosity.
Some parts that I thought could use some checking:
She was still covered by her pink and purple bed sheets but somehow managed to unwillingly open her eyes and get her hand out from under the sheets and turn the alarm clock off.

This sentence is kinda long. Also, 'still covered by her pink and purple bed sheets' is kind of unnecessary; its 6 AM! Why wouldn't she be covered by blankets? I know I am at that time.
She didn’t remember why or when she closed but they now deserved to be opened

Uh, shouldn't it be 'why or when she closed them'.
The mirror was the first thing she saw in the bathroom but refused to see herself in it for she already knew what she was going to see and even the thought of it made her sick so she took off her clothes and went straight to the shower.

Again, sort of long. It could easily be broken down.
It read 77 pounds. She made the math in her head. She was 5’6, and weighed 79 pounds.

Hang on, it reads 77 pounds, and then she's 79 pounds? Did you mean 77 pounds?
That scale must be wrong. She thought.

Shouldn't that be: 'That scale must be wrong,' she thought.

Also, near the end, I thought; Whoah, she's hungry, so she tries to commit suicide? That's a new one.

All in all, haunting, something that teaches the lesson 'Courage' (a song by Superchick), 'Girls Under Pressure' teach, that the overall image of a skeleton with skin is not something beautiful. That its deadly, especially if you keep it a secret.

'These secrets are walls that keep us alone.'
Courage, Superchick
This guy is so evil you could put him in between two slices of bread and call him an evil sandwich.

Coming at you like a jetpack Shakespeare.

Hero's Reviews
http://www.youngwriterssociety.com/topic53905.html




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1475
Reviews 58
Hey, pudin'! I'm Lily, your reviewer for the evening (or morning, depending on where you are). Pleased to meet you.

Firstly, it's a relief to see that you practise proper grammar and spelling. You won't believe how many people don't, which is heartbreaking when their ideas and expressions are perfectly fine.

However, you do need to trim your sentences a little. Break them down. For example:
She opened them slowly, smelling the sweet aroma of morning dew and wet soil as they hit her nose and she breathed them eagerly while listening to the soft chirping of a bird sitting in her window.
could sound a lot more palatable as
As she opened them, the sweet aroma of morning dew and wet soil hit her nose. She breathed them eagerly while listening to the soft chirping of a bird sitting in her window.

Make it short and sweet, since over-long sentences sometimes bore readers, no matter how good their description. It's like eating sausages - good as they are, they'd be a lot easier to eat when cut up into smaller bits, right?

I've highlighted most of these sentences in the quote box below:
pudin.junidf wrote:It was six thirty in the morning. Her alarm clock was ringing crazily in her ear. She was still covered by her pink and purple bed sheets but somehow managed to unwillingly open her eyes and get her hand out from under the sheets and turn the alarm clock off. She stretched lazily while letting out a huge yawn as she slowly got out of bed and looked around. She noticed that the curtains of her window were closed and even her window was closed. She didn’t remember why or when she closed but they now deserved to be opened, it was a brand new day and she had to enjoy it. She opened them slowly, smelling the sweet aroma of morning dew and wet soil as they hit her nose and she breathed them eagerly while listening to the soft chirping of a bird sitting in her window.
After viewing the splendor of the early morning she has always loved, she decided it was time to take a shower and get ready for school so she grabbed her towel and some clothes and headed to the bathroom. The mirror was the first thing she saw in the bathroom but refused to see herself in it for she already knew what she was going to see and even the thought of it made her sick so she took off her clothes and went straight to the shower. As she was taking a shower, quite unthinkingly, she began to run in the same place, lifting her knees to her hips. This now happened out of habit.


Also, your dialogues lack a wee bit of punctuation.
Example:
"Promise me you'll eat at school"
should be
"Promise me you'll eat at school," or "Promise me you'll eat at school!"
Aside from that, your grammar is great, which is a big relief. It's so much easier to read.
And some of your sentences start with a "She" too often, so it sounds kind of repetitive. Maybe you should use the MC's given name a bit more.

A few more nitpicks:
- Near the end of the piece, when she's running out, you used "I" instead of "She".
- The use of "had" sounds a tad out of place.
- There's a second "g" after your "putting" at the bleeding part.
- At the part where she's sitting on the leather couch, you used "has" instead of "had".

It was quite good in spite of that, though - I think if you wrote another chapter I'd only be too glad to read it. If you have any questions or problems with my review, feel free to PM me!

Hope I helped!
Lily.
Got YWS?




User avatar
Gender Other
Points 89625
Reviews 1272
Hiya!

Your sentence organization here is rather repetitive. Almost every single sentence starts starts with "she." If you read published works, they don't start every sentence like that. They change their word order around, make it so that readers aren't looking at the same sentence organization each and every time. Look at your sentence lengths as well, and don't have them all be the same lengths. Fiction is one case where fragments are acceptable.

PM me with questions!

~Rosey
A writer is a world trapped in a person— Victor Hugo

Ink is blood. Paper is bandages. The wounded press books to their heart to know they're not alone.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10701
Reviews 356
Hello Juni, my dear beloved student~ :mrgreen: I'm here, as promised. Let's see what I can grab...

I. Punctuation
AS Lily has mentioned, not only your dialogue vocabulary could use some commas or any other kind if punctuation, but once in a while I get the feeling that there should be a comma in a certain place. I will only point out one or two, since you've got to be able to identify those places by yourself ;)

After viewing the splendor of the early morning she has always loved,

Comma before 'she', because the you start what it's call an additional information, and those are the ones that either should be between parentheses or commas.

“Christine” her mother called, interrupting her thoughts.

“Coming” she answered

Dialogue punctuation. Mwahahaha! So, when the person finishes speaking, and in the end of the sentence you add 'she replied', 'she said' or anything like that, there should be a comma. Example: here, there should be commas after 'Christine' and 'Coming'.

Also, almost always before 'but' there should be a comma.

II. Tone
I wasn't sure on how to name this part xD Anyway, what I want to explain to you is something you should take light heartedly and do not feel sad about it. Honestly, for the end of the first paragraph I wanted to stop reading. This is because of the lines. As Lily, and Rosey said almost every line starts with 'She' something, something. You are normally just naming your character's actions. I have done that, in a first chapter, but it can seem to drag on and on.
About your lines, example A:
She stretched lazily while letting out a huge yawn as she slowly got out of bed and looked around

Here you have four actions in one sentence. (Also, there should be a comma before 'while' xD) This type of sentence gives the reader a story kind of feeling, like those the parents used to read to the child before sleep time. But the development of the actions, is what cut me off, since the first three paragraphs it's all about her waking up and taking a shower, without any other interesting thought or so.

Example B:
“Christine” her mother called, interrupting her thoughts.

“Coming” she answered. She quickly got up and washed the tears out of her eyes. She dressed up fast, in a black skinny jean with a pink shirt fitted at the waist and loose on its way down, pretending she actually had some body fat to show off.

She finally decided to go downstairs and meet her mother at the kitchen. The house was beautiful and she admired it every time she walked into the beige colored living room with a nineteenth century style.

Here, since you've already revealed her name, you should start using it instead of always 'she'. It would help the reader.

Typo here:
She went downstairs again and as if on cue, the school bus’ horn beeped loudly from outside my house. I ran to get my stuff and say bye to my mother who was freaking out because I didn’t eat her recently cooked pancakes.

You switched to first person; I do that a lot, specially in storybooks :D


III. Overall
I really liked this. It has so much emotion, even thought it was just describing tasks, it still did feel like that kind of morning: the pains he was going through and all. Good job!

Hope I've helped,
- Kat
Piglet: How do you spell love?
Pooh: You don't spell it. You feel it.

The Buddy System Check us out!




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 20503
Reviews 370
This was really good. I'm kind of sad to say I liked it more than I did Red Vendetta... but I hope you continue this story. Reading made my throat clench and my fingers shake. Anorexia is sad, very sad. I've never before understood what it felt like; I'm more of a "fat and proud of it" mindset; like that jolly serbian grandma who tells you to eat more schklooshquanesh.
Anyways, great, great, great job. You switched to "I" in one part and you may need some more commas here and there, but for the most part a fantastic story.
Naked I came from my mother's womb, and naked I will depart.
*Le Bible
Royal Reviews Here!




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 7979
Reviews 111
HEY...PUDIN...here's the review



overall, the story is good. I like it. It introduces not only the personality of thereader but also of her bodily features particularly the one at the mirror scene. 'good job on that.

furtehrmore..you were able to state the plot clearly along with the description of the setting as well as the tone of the story by putting in what the girl was thinking...

as for the subject matter, it is a little sad but the story is well done
John McClane: Drop it. It's the police.
Tony: You won't hurt me.
John McClane: Oh, yeah? Why not?
Tony: Because you're a policeman. There are rules for policemen.
John McClane: Yeah. That's what my captain keeps telling me



"would you still love me if i was a worm" yeah babe i would AND id get you your own compost bin so we could enter gardening competitions together
— Corvid