Jack and Jill Went UP the Hill

4 posts
Random avatar
Gender Female
Points 300
Reviews 0
A long time ago, there was a village full of hills called Squill. In that village, lots of things were built on hills. They had McDonalds’ on hills, they had Targets on hills, they even had cart-washes on hills. Also, their wells were on hills. Nobody fell down the hills. That was just silly. They lived around them. They tottered on them since the age of two. They even went to the bathroom on them. Hills were a part of their life.

One day Jack’s mother said to him, “Now take your sister and get me some water, so we can have chicken soup.” Jack loved chicken soup. He laced up his boots, and ran outside to get Jill. Jill was sitting on the steps playing with her dolls. “Come on Jill, we have to get water, so we can have chicken soup!”
Jill’s mouth watered when she heard that. She got up, and said, “I love chicken soup,” and ran off behind Jack.
If you saw Jack and Jill together, you’d think they were twins. They both had blond hair, blue eyes, and a face full of freckles. On the outside, the only differences were that Jill had long hair, and that Jack was a little bit taller. On the inside, Jill was more timid, and shy. Jack was adventurous and bold. That was why Jack led the way to the well.
Halfway up the hill, on their quest for chicken soup, Jack paused and said, “That’s funny, it’s a little bit slippery up here.” Jill shrugged and they moved on. They got to the well.
“I think our soup will have to wait until tomorrow.”
Jack looked at Jill, obviously annoyed, and said “It won’t rain until we get home. Besides, I know these hills like the back of my hand. Remember, we live in Squill.”


Right after he said that, it started raining. Jill wanted to go home so much, she started crying.
“Get your bucket, and come on!” Jack said. And poor Jill was left to follow behind her scowling brother. Already soaked through, she sat down. When Jack didn’t notice that she wasn’t following him, she started laughing. The kind you couldn’t stop even if you got hit in the stomach with a block of wood.



Jack turned around and started shaking his fist. His hair was plastered down, and the rain was filling up his bucket faster than the well did. Suddenly, he toppled over backward. All those times when he said you couldn’t fall down a hill, were suddenly wrong.
Jill started laughing so hard, that she tumbled down after him, leaving the bucket on top of the hill.
“Boy, will Jack be mad at me,” Jill thought. Then remembering that mad look on his face made her laugh again.

That night at dinner, they didn’t have chicken soup. They had chicken and corn on the cob. When Jill told their dad what happened, he couldn’t help laughing, too. Their mother looked at him disapprovingly, and Jill looked at the scowl on Jack’s face. Then, their dad laughed so hard that he toppled over backward in his chair. He popped up so confused that they all laughed until they all toppled over backward. They looked at each other, and started laughing.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 792
Reviews 89
Hey Big sis! Welcome to the yws.
Before I review this piece, I would point out one or two rules you may not have been familiar with since you're new to the site.

All new members are asked to review two works before posting any of their own. When this is carried out, they may post as many stories/poems as they like, but that 2:1 ratio is asked to be kept (two reviews for every work posted.) Since you've already posted something, I would suggest getting right down to those two reviews! (Don't worry, I broke the first rule too when I first started out here.)

All stories/poem should be rated accordingly. If a piece has extremely vulgar language or mature scenes, they should be rated 'R'.

No chat speak! We are writers and must behave as so. ;)

For some other rules, go here:

rules.php


Okay, now on to the review!
Since this story is so short, I can't say much about it/
All in all, this was an okay piece. I enjoyed the story and the twists you gave to it. I particularly loved your description of squill, and think that was my favourite part of this.
The only thing I would like to point out is that it was a teency weency bit dull. You really have to describe things a bit more, so that your readers will be more interested in the story.
Another thing I noticed, is that in most of this, you told the reader the information you wanted to give them. You have to try and find a way to show the same information, without simply telling it to your readers. You do this by showing the main character's actions, and feelings in the story.
Here's an example:
Telling:
Becky had blonde hair and blue eyes.
Showing:
Becky's bright blue eyes shined as she brushed her lovely blonde hair.

See the difference?
Go here for more information about this:
viewarticlebody.php?t=41426

Go through this piece, describe things in more detail, work on showing and not telling, and it will make the entire story much better on the whole. :)
Keep up the great work!
PM me if you need any more reviews or have any questions!
xxmimixx
-mors aut honorabilis vita-


Forget the prince with a horse, I want a vampire with a volvo.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 8009
Reviews 93
Hey bigsis3! Welcome to YWS! You should head over to the "welcome" forum and introduce yourself!

Now for the review...

A long time ago, there was a village full of hills called Squill.


Love the village name! It wouldn't happen to be named after the YWS Squills, would it?

They had McDonalds’ on hills, they had Targets on hills,


You said that this was "A long time ago", so would they really have McDonalds and Target? Also, I know that you keep repeating "hills" for emphasis, but it seems very juvenile and dull. The repetition is more like something you'd see in a 5 year old's story.

On the inside, Jill was more timid, and shy. Jack was adventurous and bold.


It's all fine and dandy pointing this out, but it would be much better if you showed their personalities, not told. Also, I really don't see their personalities that well in this story. They seem kind of like cardboard cut outs.

Halfway up the hill, on their quest for chicken soup


I thought they were getting water, not chicken soup.


The Big Picture

Overall, this is a cute little story. It's decent for a fairy tale twist kind of story, but a bit predictable and childish. I would definetely suggest that you add a lot more description, and flesh out your characters a bit more. Your big "twist" really wasn't that big a deal at all. Perhaps you could make it more dramatic? Does Jack really just fall down the hill? There could be tons of more creative ways you could take this story than just a simple misstep. Attempted murder, perhaps?
“Don't tell me the moon is shining; show me the glint of light on broken glass.” Anton Chekhov




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1128
Reviews 5
Personaly I thought the intorduction was very weak, and needs some work. You could also use alot more detail.
*sigh*



Darkness cannot drive out darkness: only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate: only love can do that.
— Martin Luther King Jr.