The Elbe is Filled With Prayers

6 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 27175
Reviews 387
- and the basement smelled of old cigarette smoke and chipped paint.
It smelled like sweat and urine – infecting the air like musky perfume – and the walls seemed to whisper quiet prayers along with the huddled Germans on the basement floor. They were soot-smeared with fear – both the walls and the Germans – and their prayers tumbled to the ground and shattered against concrete like Christmas tree baubles. The concrete was cold. Dieter thought that it felt like the skin of a corpse as he crouched on it with his arm around Ada. The floor was a dead body and the walls and the ceiling of the basement were coffin planks, nailed shut by the phlegmy coughs of the American and British bombs.
Falling on Dresden like the footsteps of drunken giants dancing on rubbled ballroom floors.
Gutting buildings.
Causing the ground to sigh and exhale ash that boiled in the air like ticker-tape parades.
In the darkness, someone groped for his hand and held it tightly and Dieter suddenly imagined that they were all gathered in the basement that night for a séance. For a communion with the dead. Holding hands, bowing heads, as candles were lit outside. As trees withered like wicks and fire bearded buildings like wax.
Ada curled even further into his chest so that his nose was nestled in her hair, which smelled and tasted like burnt books and roses. She felt so delicate in his arms. Her bones were drinking straws, hollow and brittle. Each time a bomb laughed outside – complimenting the opera-house alto of the air raid alarms with a trombone bass – she contracted. She flickered like the flame of a cigarette lighter.
Whoever was holding his hand had practically oiled their hands with sweat.

ADA [whispering]: Is it ever going to stop?
DIETER: Just think of it like a symphony.
ADA: I've never heard something less musical in my life.
DIETER: Snare drum, bass drum, oboes, clarinets, trumpets...
ADA: It's not working.
DIETER: Everything's going to be fine.
ADA: Should we pray?
DIETER [pausing]: To who?
ADA: To God.
DIETER: I think praying to Roosevelt or Herr Hitler would work faster. Heaven is pretty far away and our voices are so soft.
ADA: You're a terrible Christian, Dieter.
DIETER: Who said I was a Christian?
ADA: How else can someone survive through a war like this?
DIETER: War is too distracting, darling. I don't have the patience for faith. I just can't concentrate on salvation and repentance with all these dead bodies lying around and all this beautiful music in the air.
ADA: You must be tone deaf.
DIETER: No, you're just not listening closely enough.

The floor trembled and outside it sounded like a hundred buildings were falling to their knees, beaten and penitent. Little sprinkles of dust fell from the ceiling like mustard gas. It hung the air like a curtain before an opening act. Dieter was closing his eyes. He was trying to capture the musical elements of the scene taking place outside. The bombs descending on the city like bocce balls. The air raid alarms lilting grainy screams through gramophone mouths. The grunts torn from the ground and spattered in the air like quarter notes on sheet music. It wasn't pretty, but there was a pattern. There was order in the chaos. Dresden had been transformed into an orchestral hall and filled with the applause of airplanes making bombing runs. There was no doubt about.
Ada just needed to listen.
Another nearby explosion. Violent enough to make the ceiling cough more dust. Whoever had been holding his hand slipped away and someone began weeping softly. Their tears joined the shattered prayers on the ground and Dieter imagined that the basement floor looked something like the Jewish neighborhoods on Krystallnacht.
Dieter desperately needed a cigarette. But he was out of tobacco and his rolling paper was sitting in his house on his table like crumpled origami frogs. He could only savor the air. He could only find comfort in Ada at his side and the music of the bombing of Dresden.
His ears popped like popcorn as the third explosion blistered the basement; closer this time.
And Dieter wondered how God could possibly hear the prayers over these giant incendiary hail stones –

– felt like a stork swaddling newborn babies and dropping them down chimneys baptized in soot. Max could see the bombs as they pulverized the city; red-orange corsages on tuxedo shirts. They looked like desert roses or miniature suns or overflowing beer glasses and as he watched them blossom his hands buttered themselves with sweat.
Either that or blood.
Bombing Dresden seemed a little too much like slaughtering a lamb.
The fires below laughed cheerfully.

MAX: They don't even have any anti-aircraft guns, Sunshine.
SUNSHINE: That's their problem, isn't it?
MAX: It's like killing little kids though, don't you think?
SUNSHINE: Nah. The Jerrys had it coming. Besides, little Jerrys grow up to be big Jerrys. Kinda like rats or cockroaches. They all start out small and nice-lookin'.
MAX: They're people.
SUNSHINE: They're cockroaches.
MAX: We're all out of packages.
SUNSHINE: I'm telling you, kid, we're just carrying out science here. Good, proven genetics. That's what this whole God-awful war's about anyway. This is just spring-cleaning, kid. We're just burning the compost pile.
MAX: We're all out.

The bomber buzzed mosquito soliloquies into Max's ears as Sunshine nodded and wheeled the throbbing airplane around. No matter what Sunshine or anybody else said, he couldn't shake the image of a trillion people – civilians – combusting like witches burning at telephone pole stakes. He couldn't shake the image of pyramids of putty-skinned corpses or hollow, serrated buildings with windows that were charred and blackened; bleeding mascara.
As the plane headed back to the airbase, Max heard little prayers knocking on his plexiglass windows as they floated up to heaven like ash.
"I am beginning to despair
and can see only two choices:
either go crazy or turn holy."

- Serenade, Adélia Prado




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2242
Reviews 695
Experimental hmmm? *thinks for a second*

I thought this was weird in a good sense. As always, I find myself pulled into your writing. The script-formation you used was different and it was refreshing to see something out of the norm for historical fiction. Your characters Dieter and Ada were very believable. The descriptions you used were crazy good and the way Dieter kept saying to think of the bombs as symphonies was very unique. The contrast between the two characters was great because it just set the tone for the story. This was amazing and I'm not surprised.
As always, when I read your work I point out a line that I really liked. This line was powerful and I feel that it was birthed by the surroundings of the war that devoured Dresden.

As the plane headed back to the airbase, Max heard little prayers knocking on his plexiglass windows as they floated up to heaven like ash.


Max and Sunshine. The contrast between these two characters is believable as well and I almost felt that they were essential to the story and I'm glad you added them in.

Question: Sunshine is a guy right? If so, is that his last name? Just curious.

All in all, I loved this piece and I hope you continue your experiments because this was great.
Good Job and Keep writing,
Angel :D :D :D

P.S. I think plexiglass has one s
True love, in all it’s celestial charm, and
star-crossed ways, only exist in a writer’s
mind, for humans have not yet learned
how to manifest it.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 10087
Reviews 701
Whoa. I love this. Just the right blend of the lyrical and the concrete. Well done!

As the plane headed back to the airbase, Max heard little prayers knocking on his plexiglass windows as they floated up to heaven like ash.

Beautiful.

I'll definitely keep an eye out for some more of your work.
Got a poem or short story you want me to critique?

There is only one success: to be able to spend your life in your own way, and not to give others absurd maddening claims upon it. (C D Morley)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6090
Reviews 1258
*thwaps* Kylan. You didn't tell me you posted this! At any rate, you're my fourth red star, so be proud, though I don't think you deserve it for being secretive. *sniff*

Anyway. My main reaction to this piece was: OH MY GOD SOMEONE ACTUALLY HAD FUN WRITING SOMETHING. Because that's what it felt like. You like to take English and slap it silly, which is a lot of fun to watch, especially when inundated with Stephanie Meyer clones.

I actually really liked the script format; it sloughed a way a lot of the "baggage" that comes along with writing traditional dialogue/tags. It read a lot faster, a lot more desperate than it would have felt otherwise. Perfectly appropriate for the bombing of Dresden, I think. ^_~

WENN SIE SIND IN ROM, TUN SIE WIE DIE RÖMER TUN

When you're writing about people who talk in a foreign language, it's important to find someone who speaks that language if you're even going to attempt to use any of it. Why? Translators pwn, but real people pwn more. Because very few of my stories take place in Germany or Japan, it helps to keep a few foreigners about to check facts. (The most fun was having to use Persian--I had to ask a friend's mom and she didn't quite understand what it was I wanted or why, but was nice about it nonetheless.)

I think praying to Roosevelt or Herr Hitler would work faster


I think at this point in the war they'd probably use 'Führer', instead of Herr Hitler. "Mr. Hitler" sounds a bit weird--Chancellor is probably a bit better. Also, a lot of your slang is very Anglicized (darling, etc.) My dictionary says you can use "der Schatz" or "der Liebling"-- 'du bist einen Schatz', 'mein Liebling', etc. It sounds a lot cooler than English, anyway. :wink:

I have kind of a pet peeve of people italicizing foreign words, just because I use them randomly in everyday conversation and don't have the patience to BBCode them all when I transcribe them. Krystallnacht is a word universally used, so don't italicize it.

* Before I forget: genetics seems like an odd term to use for a bomber, considering it would have been a relatively new science then and was about a decade before Watson and Crick. New term?

PERSONIFICATION

I know this is stylistic, but you tend to personify everything you come into contact, with, or make it into origami animals. :wink: It gets a bit repetitive--it's shocking the first time round, but after several things being made into living, breathing creatures, it's a bit weird, as with:

Max heard little prayers knocking on his plexiglass windows as they floated up to heaven like ash.


It feels a bit odd. It falls a bit flat, actually, considering that you characterize them as heartless lamb-slaughterers, and here they feel very sympathetic and Hallmark card. In order to enhance characters like this, your narration has to take on the psyche of the people it's describing.

WASH YOUR HANDS TO GET RID OF GERMANS

Referring to people by ethnicity is often a little jarring and can sometimes sound like the punchline to a joke.

It smelled like sweat and urine – infecting the air like musky perfume – and the walls seemed to whisper quiet prayers along with the huddled Germans on the basement floor. They were soot-smeared with fear – both the walls and the Germans


Unless you're making a race joke or something of the like, try to avoid lumping people together like that. Why? When you label people like that, it feels as though no further explanation is needed, even though--as we see with Dieter and Ana--they're more than just a breathing mass of strudel.

__

Kylan! You're amazing, as usual. PM me if you have any questions or want me to look at something else.
Graffiti is the most passionate form of literature there is.

- Demetri Martin




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 516
This was really good. I'm very interested in WW2, and I beleve this was the bombing of Dresden, when the English got back at the Germans for the Blitz? Correct me if I'm wrong, I'm no expert.

I liked how you formated the dialouge. It was really cool to see it like that, and it probably made it easier to read, because the rest was pretty heavy.

You introduced Max and Sunshine very abruptly. I had no idea who they were, because you had said nothing about them. I'd put something in, because it was very annoying.

I liked how Dieter compared the bombs to music, it was kind of creppy in a way.

Overall, great job. Got anything else on WW2? Because I'd love to read it!
*Don't expect to see me around much in the next couple of weeks. School has started again, and it'll be a couple of weeks before I've settled in. If you've asked me for a critique, you will get it, but not for a little while. Sorry*




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 890
Reviews 26
Refreshing. I guess that's my first impression on this short story. The very first line with the continuation of the title was creative. Generally speaking, the entire piece seemed to want to evoke an image rather than convey a message. Which is actually not a bad thing, it's unique and fresh.

~~

Good for you for alluding Dresden to music! Ode to Joy the poem was written in Dresden by Friedrich Schiller, and this poem soon became the famous chorale of Beethoven's 9th. Seeing how the music is now the European anthem and was played during the reunification of Germany, you get the connection... Therefore, excellent symbolism!

~~

Each time a bomb laughed outside – complimenting the opera-house alto of the air raid alarms with a trombone bass – she contracted.


I'm being picky in your allusion to music here: I'm confused about your alto and bass comment. Alto what of the air raid alarms? Alto singer? Alto trombone? Alto tessitura? If you're talking about an alto opera singer, then I'd suggest you to change it to something else. Alto voices are rare in solo opera settings. And secondly, trombone bass what? Trombone ground bass? Trombone bass line? Or do you mean bass trombone? Then again, I'm just being extremely nit picky, seeing how not many people would notice these minor details.

~~

The way you chose to the write dialogues was interesting. I didn't really like it, but it worked well with what you were trying to convey.

~~

There was no doubt about.


No doubt about what?

~~

Hmm... Asides from those small details, I don't think there are much I have to say. It's a very satisfying and complete piece itself. Symbolism was well used here and there... Perhaps the only thing I would ask for in this story is to give the reader something more for him or her to ponder about after reading.

Overall, it was a very structured and artistic piece of writing.
It is only when dissonance plays one will find pleasure in consonance.
topic34094.html <-- Free Reviews



cron
It’s not unorthodox, I thought it was beautiful.
— Jimi Hendrix