A Devout Death

4 posts
User avatar
Gender Male
Points 1108
Reviews 404
I unearthed this story from the beginning of eighth grade. With a little tweaking... maybe it's good?

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

The old man was sitting unresponsive in his old armchair, snoring severely with a cylinder in his mouth. The smoke was swirling mutely, almost calmly, when the man heard a knock on the back window.

The old man stirred, his fat chin wiggling like hospital jelly. “Who, who?” he grunted, when an unfamiliar face of a young woman grinned from the window. “Oh!” the man yelled gladly, “Oh! And who is this young beautiful lady?” he asked, rapidly rising from the lounger, as if he recognized her.

He let her in through the front door. Her eyes focused on the man’s face with a slim smile slithering across her lips.

“Hello!” she said, holding out her hand. “My name is Debbie Abrams. Nice to meet you.”

“Debbie?” the old man croaked. “Debbie? Did you change your name? I always though your name was Jackie!” and before Debbie could answer, the man started: “But you obviously modified it, didn’t you, such a lovely gal with the name of Jackie, oh no, obviously not. Why, now that you remind me, your mother, (she was a wonderful woman), she herself abhorred the name Jack! I never understood why she gave it to you, but still.” He unfolded a dotted handkerchief and coughed into it.

“Yes, well,” she said, “I was never called Jackie. I am…well, I am actually a religious consultant and I came here to discuss with you the terms of your sister’s unfortunate death.”

The man’s face abruptly turned grave. He walked over to his arm chair and leaned on it, and then he took the cigar from the coffee table uneasily and puffed once. The trail of smoke gathered in his face, which was turned away from Debbie. “Which one? I’ve had three dead sisters so far, and I feel like I have… I have already dealt with them, you know, nothing more to worry about.”

“Sir,” Debbie said, standing straight like an old, pine tree, “We worry. It is our job to worry. Some people kill themselves because they have no one to talk to, and this is why we are here, to talk to you, to see what troubles you. Do you understand?”

The man gazed at her reflection in the glass window: her ginger hair, her emaciated eyebrows, her ruby lips. Her skin was nearly ideal, with only a hint of microscopic blemishes.

“And it is our honor, too, to respect you and your ideas. We don’t want to burden you. We just want to aid you with the misery of Naomi’s loss. You understand?”

The man nodded. He dropped into the fluffy pillows on the lounger, taking another whiff from the cigar, closing his eyes as he did so. The creases on his hands were not at all vague, covering every inch of his body. “It’s just that…” he started, his eyes still closed. “It’s just that I can’t understand how she died, why she died, what made her so. I don’t have anyone anymore, and anything that feels significant for once just disappears.”

As he said that, Debbie smiled gradually. “Don’t worry about it, sir. It was her time.” She didn’t say it spitefully, but she did it coldly, like an android.

“Religious consultant, you say?” he asked. “But what is so religious about you, Debbie? That’s what…”

“You’ll understand soon, sir. I will take you to my church,” she said, and hastened again at the surprise on his face, “But of course, only if you want to come.”

“I think I do, Debbie.” He rose.
Last edited by Gadi. on Sun Dec 09, 2007 7:41 am, edited 2 times in total.
my world isn't only beautiful
it is so far away




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 516
Okay, this was quite good. Not the greatest, but quite good. I didn't really understand the end. Isn't she who she says she is? I didn't get it.

Your description were quite good, and your main characters was different. It's not everyday I see a piece with an old man as the MC.

The old man was sitting unresponsive in his old armchair, snoring severely with a cylinder in his mouth. The smoke was swirling mutely, almost calmly, when the man heard a knock on the back window.

The old man stirred, his fat chin wiggling like hospital jelly.


The repitition of 'the old man' annoyed me. I think you could change the second one to something like 'he'. I liked the comparison to hospital jelly.

Your formatting was a little weird. Like, it wasn't always double-spaced, and then you would have three lines blank.

APart from those things, I enjoyed it.
*Don't expect to see me around much in the next couple of weeks. School has started again, and it'll be a couple of weeks before I've settled in. If you've asked me for a critique, you will get it, but not for a little while. Sorry*




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 890
Reviews 140
Scientology, eh?
I liked the way you made Debbie seem really nice and everything and then in the end she turned out to be ice-cold.
The story describes a very typical "scientology visit" (talking about the old man being potentially endangered by comitting suicide...).
That's exactly, how it works.
You're from the US I take it? In some countries scientology is not allowed to call itself a "religion", that's why.

He let her in through the front door. Her eyes focused on the man’s face with a slim smile slithering across her lips.


I liked this part, because it gives the reader the impression, that something is wrong with Debbie, without being too obvious.

I also liked the way you described the old man. He wasn't the steriotype old man, who is completly sweet and helpless. He has a couple edges.

The only thing you might want to do, is add on. Add a little more, before the old man spills, that he feels so alone. It seems he tells her what she wants to hear too fast. Maybe she should have to ask a little more. But maybe that's just me.

Otherwise this was really neat!

Keep it up :wink:

~Kalli




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 6400
Reviews 497
Hey Gadi! *waves*

The old man was sitting unresponsive in his old armchair, snoring severely with a cylinder in his mouth.

For some reason, I pictured him with a Coke can or something stuffed into his mouth. You can use cigar or cigarette, whichever it's supposed to be. ;)

(she was a wonderful woman),

This doesn't need to be in parenthesis.

taking another whiff from the cigar,

A whiff? He smelled it? I think you mean he took a drag from it. ;)

Hmm... I have two major problems with this. I never really connect with the main character, and he isn't consistent. At first I was getting the idea that maybe he was a bit crazy, but all the sudden he turns from a borderline lunatic into a perfectly sensible human being ready to share his heart with a semi-complete stranger. It doesn't keep with the idea of the character. Also, both he and Debbie are kind of flat. I don't really feel a connection to them. I don't really care about them, to be honest.

I think the biggest thing that's impacting this is the length. A bit longer, a bit more detail, some chopped tomatoes, and boil should make this better. ;)

Still, the writing is good! I just feel like the length of this is hindering your true skill as a writer. If that makes sense at all.

I never know how to end critiques. xD
-Saint Razorblade
The Official YWS Pirate :pirate3:
"2-4-6-8! I like to delegate!" -Meshugenah
"Teague: Stomping on your dreams since 1992." -Sachiko
"So I'm looking at FLT and am reminded of a sandwich." -Jabber



We are dreamers, you and I.
— Leya