Keeping The Green

21 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender Female
Points 5890
Reviews 504
Even one else seems to have arrived here before me, so I shall merely echo them in saying that thiw was brilliantly done. ^_^




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9692
Reviews 3900
smaur wrote:
Snoink wrote:I think this one sentence could be better so instead of this:

And so the queen touched their faces, and they fell to their knees and wept.

This:

And so she, the queen, touched their faces, and they fell to their knees and wept.

Or does that make sense? :P


If "she, the queen", is for emphasis, that makes perfect sense. The problem is that I think it sounds pretty awkward not only on its own, but when added to the previous sentence:

She must be strong for them, for it was she who carried their existences in the palms of her hands. And so she, the queen, touched their faces, and they fell to their knees and wept.


The additional "she" (plus commas) seems cumbersome; the sentence just doesn't flow. See?


Hehehe... I didn't say that you wouldn't have to change anything else. I just sounded what sounded better in that one sentence. :P

Writing a story is like playing sudoku. You find one blasted number that is in the wrong place, and it will give you absolute hell.
Ubi caritas est vera, Deus ibi est.

"The mark of your ignorance is the depth of your belief in injustice and tragedy. What the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the Master calls the butterfly." ~ Richard Bach

Moth and Myth <- My comic! :D




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 16552
Reviews 376
Wow, this is my first review and I was surprised to read such quality writing. This is very, very good. Quite humbling, in fact.

The transition from girl to queen is still a bit fuzzy for me. Sorry, I don't have any advice to fix that. Also, when you mention the saffron and scarlet twice, it seems a bit redundant, or rather repetitive. Maybe you could use some different descriptive words to emphasize the colors. I understand that sometimes repetition is used as a literary device, especially if it is meant to convey symbolism, but if that is the case, I would even add more instances of "saffron and scarlet" and make it an obvious symbol.

Once again, it was difficult to find much else to criticize. This was very well written. Hats off!
Perception is everything.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 2834
Reviews 131
You guys are lovely. Thanks for the feedback.

Snoink wrote:Hehehe... I didn't say that you wouldn't have to change anything else. I just sounded what sounded better in that one sentence.

Writing a story is like playing sudoku. You find one blasted number that is in the wrong place, and it will give you absolute hell.


Heh. I only did change that one sentence! I was just showing you what it looked like within the context of the surrounding story. :P If you take that into account, the sentence just doesn't work — instead of giving the story power, it undermines the narrative.

trident wrote:The transition from girl to queen is still a bit fuzzy for me. Sorry, I don't have any advice to fix that. Also, when you mention the saffron and scarlet twice, it seems a bit redundant, or rather repetitive. Maybe you could use some different descriptive words to emphasize the colors. I understand that sometimes repetition is used as a literary device, especially if it is meant to convey symbolism, but if that is the case, I would even add more instances of "saffron and scarlet" and make it an obvious symbol.


Hmm. In the case of "saffron and scarlet", I did purposely reuse the same phrase twice. The first time, it's in reference to the real sun, which Elanna loves and worships; the second time it was used, I wanted to carry the vague implication that she attributed the same value to the fake sun as she did the real sun. Given that, I'm not sure where else I could throw in the saffron/scarlet description without being superfluous — any ideas?

Also, by "fuzzy", do you mean that it's still too vague or too sudden? Or both?

Thanks again! :D
"He yanked himself free and fled to the kitchen where something huddled against the flooded windowpanes. It sighed and wept and tapped continually, and suddenly he was outside, staring in, the rain beating, the wind chilling him, and all the candle darkness inside lost."




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 16552
Reviews 376
I would say the transition is quite both actually. It took me a couple times of going back a few paragraphs to realize she had become queen. But that could just be me. :)

As to the saffron and scarlet, I would add some more words in front of the second case. Maybe the colors could be the "long forgotten" colors of the old sun, or to go the other way, it could be "the glow of the unforgettable saffron and scarlet". Just a suggestion, but I would try to add something to make it more symbolic.
Perception is everything.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 9692
Reviews 3900
smaur wrote:You guys are lovely. Thanks for the feedback.

Snoink wrote:Hehehe... I didn't say that you wouldn't have to change anything else. I just sounded what sounded better in that one sentence.

Writing a story is like playing sudoku. You find one blasted number that is in the wrong place, and it will give you absolute hell.


Heh. I only did change that one sentence! I was just showing you what it looked like within the context of the surrounding story. :P If you take that into account, the sentence just doesn't work — instead of giving the story power, it undermines the narrative.


Yeah, but the transition is a little stumbling, so it might be a good thing if you tweak (more) the surrounding sentences! :)
Ubi caritas est vera, Deus ibi est.

"The mark of your ignorance is the depth of your belief in injustice and tragedy. What the caterpillar calls the end of the world, the Master calls the butterfly." ~ Richard Bach

Moth and Myth <- My comic! :D



I'm not so good with the advice... Can I interest you in a sarcastic comment?
— Chandler Bing