The Giver (film)

19 posts1, 2
User avatar
Gender None specified
Points 92255
Reviews 1748
1. I have never read the book, which is weird because you'd think I would have. Someday, probably.

2. Okay, so, not having read the book, I did go see the movie last night. There was a romance that I assume was not in the book (based on Lowry's other book that I have read, in which the MC was like ten), but other than that I thought it was fantastic.

3. There is not violence and insurrection. I mean, there's the whole "release to elsewhere" thing, but the only "violence" is the violence in the memories of war that Jonas receives from the Giver. There is not any mass insurrection or anything like that, so whoever had the impression of that from the previews, I can tell you that's not what happens in the movie.

4. I saw people online flipping out because "why is the movie going to be in color," but actually it starts off in black and white as it should. (I now understand why that was a concern, but I thought it was handled well.)

5. The only thing aside from the romance (which by the way is not toooooo overdone, like they aren't just like, "Omg, now I can feel things and I love you!!!" Thank goodness) that bothered me at all was the opening a little bit, because of the way the world is...I mean, like the three friends at very first seemed very generic, but considering all differences have been removed (as far as they can be), I guess that could just be a product of the world. Once it got to the ceremony where the kids got assigned their jobs and Jonas started receiving memories, it was fantastic.

I mean, I'm unbiased as far as book-movie differences go because as yet I haven't read it, so...if you've read the book, it's entirely possible it'll annoy you. I know I'm like that about books I love (not that it stops me from seeing the adaptations). But I enjoyed it, and that's not at all being a fan of dystopia. (HG did nothing for me and I'm not even planning on seeing or reading Divergent.)




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 1330
Reviews 900
@Eli if they have changed a bunch of other key parts of The Giver, you think it would kill them to throw in someone not white?
I like you as an enemy, but I love you as a friend.




User avatar
Gender Male
Points 11542
Reviews 426
But isn't one of the main points of the Giver that it is so white-washed; that is, everything and everyone is as similar as possible? From the reviews I've read, that idea of absolute overwhelming sameness is one of the themes that seems to have carried over into the film. It's meant to be a dystopian society where diversity of any type is squashed.




User avatar
Gender Female
Points 575
Reviews 11
Well, I read the book, and I don't think I'm going to see the movie. Apparently, I've heard the character's personalities aren't the same, and the plot isn't stuck to well. So, I definitely recommend reading the book, but I'm not so sure about the movie.
"If you find yourself with a desire that nothing in this world can satisfy, the most probably explanation is that you were made for another world." -C.S. Lewis



You're a hairy, wizard!
— EllieMae