The first one is written by Nate! Click here] and read on how he thinks a good review should be formatted like.
The next one I thought would be helpful is the Book of YWS codes].
I think this article How to critique] will be good for all of us to read and follow.
And one more...If you like reviewing the fluff way and can't seem to get beyond that then go to here] and look at Tenyo's article.
If you have any more links that you think would be helpful for reviewing,post them here. Articles on reviewing short stories, poetry, essay's and whatever else you can find!